| Course | BUS FPX 3121 Healthcare Management Ethics |
|---|---|
| Assessment | Assessment 1 |
| Paper type | Management ethics dilemma analysis |
| Length | About 1,070 words, 5 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Capella University |
| Program | BS in Business |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for BUS FPX 3121 Assessment 1
An Ethical Dilemma at the Management Level: Closing a Money-Losing Outpatient Psychiatric Clinic or Keeping It Open
Student Name
Capella University
BUS FPX 3121: Healthcare Management Ethics
Instructor Name
Month Day, Year
The Situation
The setting is Riverview, a composite nonprofit hospital with 180 beds, the only hospital in its county. Its outpatient psychiatric clinic cares for roughly 1,100 people, many living with serious mental illness, and runs a deficit near 900,000 dollars each year, largely because Medicaid, which covers most of the clinic's patients, reimburses less than the care costs. The hospital's operating margin has fallen to 0.5%, and its board has asked the chief operating officer to recommend actions to restore a 2% margin. Closing the clinic would eliminate the largest single loss. The nearest other outpatient psychiatric provider accepting Medicaid is a community mental health center 30 miles away with a four-month waiting list.
Two Obligations, Both Defensible
The chief operating officer faces two obligations, and both are defensible. The obligation to the hospital's long-term survival. A hospital that loses money year after year risks cutting services across the board, delaying equipment replacement, and eventually closing or being sold. The board and executives have a duty of stewardship: to use the hospital's resources so that it can continue serving the whole community. Closing a clinic that loses 900,000 dollars a year could protect services that thousands of other patients depend on. The obligation to the clinic's patients and the community. The hospital's mission includes caring for the community's most vulnerable people. The clinic's patients have serious conditions, few alternatives, and limited means. Closing the clinic could lead to missed medications, psychiatric crises, emergency department visits, and hospitalizations, and in some cases to harm. Neither obligation is clearly wrong. That is what makes this a genuine dilemma rather than a choice between right and wrong. Presenting both obligations as defensible prevents the analysis from becoming a justification for a decision already made.
The Constraint Stated Plainly
The constraint is money. The hospital cannot continue losing 900,000 dollars a year on the clinic and also meet the board's margin target without cutting elsewhere. Every dollar spent sustaining the clinic is a dollar not available for other services, staff, or equipment. Stating the constraint plainly matters because ethical discussions sometimes avoid the financial reality, making the dilemma seem easier than it is.
Management, Not Bedside
The dilemma is at the management level, not the bedside. A psychiatrist caring for an individual patient faces clinical ethical questions, such as how to balance a patient's autonomy with safety. The chief operating officer faces a different question: how to allocate limited resources among services and populations. The ethical principles are the same, but they apply to groups and systems rather than to one patient. Keeping the analysis at the management level prevents it from drifting into individual clinical cases, which are not the decision at hand.
Principles Applied to Facts
Beauchamp and Childress (2019) describe four principles widely used in health care ethics: respect for autonomy, nonmaleficence, beneficence, and justice. Each is applied to the facts. Nonmaleficence, avoiding harm: closing the clinic would likely cause harm to its patients, some of whom would lose access to psychiatric medication management with no alternative for four months. The foreseeable harm is significant. Beneficence, doing good: keeping the clinic open benefits its patients; but the hospital's resources used elsewhere also benefit patients. Beneficence does not settle the question alone, because it applies to both options. Justice, fair distribution of resources: patients with serious mental illness and Medicaid coverage are already underserved. Closing their clinic would concentrate the burden of the hospital's financial problems on one of its most vulnerable groups, which raises a strong justice concern. On the other hand, justice also requires considering other patients whose services might be cut instead. Respect for autonomy: the clinic's patients have little say in the decision; involving them and their advocates in considering alternatives would respect their autonomy more than a decision made without them. Applied to the facts, the principles weigh against simple closure, particularly because of the harm and the concentration of burden on a vulnerable group, but they do not require keeping the clinic unchanged regardless of cost.
Why the Decision Belongs to Management
Some might argue that clinical leaders, not executives, should decide whether a psychiatric clinic stays open. Clinicians' views are essential, and they should be consulted. But the decision involves trade-offs among services, budgets, and the hospital's future that only management and the board can weigh across the whole organization. Recognizing that the decision belongs to management also places responsibility clearly: whoever decides must answer for the harm the decision causes, which is why the analysis must name that harm honestly.
Alternatives Between the Extremes
The dilemma is often presented as close or keep, but options exist between them. The hospital could seek a partnership with the community mental health center to transfer the clinic with funding support, ask the state for enhanced Medicaid rates or grants for behavioral health, integrate psychiatric care into primary care clinics with telepsychiatry, or reduce the clinic's losses through changes in staffing and scheduling. These options do not remove the dilemma, but they may reduce its severity.
Somebody Named as Bearing the Cost
Every option imposes costs on someone, and naming who bears them is essential. If the clinic closes, the 1,100 patients bear the cost, along with their families, the community mental health center, which would receive more referrals than it can handle, and the hospital's own emergency department, which would likely see more psychiatric crises. If the clinic stays open unchanged, the cost falls on other patients and staff through cuts elsewhere, or on the hospital's long-term stability. If a partnership is pursued, the cost falls partly on the hospital's budget for transition support and partly on patients who must change providers. Naming who bears the cost keeps the decision honest about its consequences for real people.
Conclusion
The chief operating officer faces a genuine dilemma between stewardship of the hospital and obligations to the clinic's vulnerable patients, under a clear financial constraint. Applied at the management level, ethical principles weigh against simple closure because of foreseeable harm and injustice, but they do not demand ignoring the constraint. Options between closing and keeping the clinic unchanged should be explored, and every option's costs should be assigned to those who would bear them.
References
Beauchamp, T. L., & Childress, J. F. (2019). Principles of biomedical ethics (8th ed.). Oxford University Press.
What the BUS FPX 3121 Assessment 1 instructions ask for
The first assessment in BUS FPX 3121 asks you to analyze an ethical dilemma faced by health care managers. You describe the situation, identify the competing obligations, explain the constraint that makes the choice hard, apply ethical principles or frameworks to the facts, consider options, including middle paths, and state who bears the cost of each. The dilemma should be at the organizational level, such as service closures, staffing, pricing or resource allocation, rather than an individual clinical decision. Ethics frameworks such as principlism, utilitarianism and the ACHE Code of Ethics support the analysis. A decision is not always required in this first assessment, but the options should be clear. The situation carries into the stakeholder and policy papers that follow.
How the BUS-FPX3121 Assessment 1 example is put together
Situation, obligations, conflict, decision, cost. The opening establishes the management situation and the constraint that makes it hard, since a dilemma with unlimited resources resolves itself. The obligations block names what the organization owes and to whom, with each grounded in a principle or a code provision rather than in general fairness. The conflict block shows precisely where the two cannot both be met, which is narrower than it first appears and is the heart of the analysis. The decision block commits, working the principles through the facts until one obligation yields. A cost block names who absorbs the loss. The closing states what fact would have made the decision come out differently. Section headings follow the prompt, and the whole paper stays in an administrative register rather than drifting toward the bedside.
Where the marks sit in the BUS FPX 3121 Assessment 1 scoring guide
Faculty grade the situation, the obligations, the constraint, the application of principles and the alternatives. The situation reaches Distinguished when described with the facts a manager would have, such as the clinic's annual loss and the number of patients served. Obligations score higher when both are defensible, rather than one being set up as obviously wrong. The constraint earns credit when stated plainly, since a dilemma with unlimited money is not a dilemma. Principles should be applied to the facts, not defined in the abstract. Keeping the analysis at the management level shows the right perspective for this course. Alternatives between closing and keeping the clinic, such as partnering with a community mental health center, show creative judgment.
BUS FPX 3121 Assessment 1 help from the desk
Students often choose a clinical dilemma, such as a patient's treatment decision, when the course asks for management ethics. Another common mistake is presenting one obligation as clearly correct, which removes the dilemma. The financial constraint is vague, such as the clinic loses money, without figures. Principles are defined in a paragraph and never used. Alternatives are limited to the two extremes. The people who bear the cost of each option, such as patients who would travel farther, are not named. The ACHE Code of Ethics is overlooked, though it speaks directly to managers. Grounding each principle in a fact from the case keeps the analysis concrete and sets up the stakeholder paper.
Get a BUS FPX 3121 Assessment 1 example written to your instructions
Send the Assessment 1 instructions and the scoring guide from your BUS FPX 3121 courseroom, plus the scenario your version supplies. We write a custom example against those exact criteria and return it in 24 to 48 hours. The first custom sample is free, and finding a conflict that is genuinely hard is the part worth studying. The paper above is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Capella University document.
More BUS FPX 3121 papers and BS in Business samples
- BUS FPX 3121 Assessment 2: Stakeholder Impact Paper
- BUS FPX 3121 Assessment 3: Organizational Policy Proposal
- BUS FPX 4011 Assessment 1: Virtual Team Charter
- BUS FPX 3050 Assessment 1: Audience and Message Analysis
- BUS FPX 4012 Assessment 1: Organizational Leadership Analysis
- BUS FPX 3040 Assessment 1: Job Analysis and Description
BUS FPX 3121 Assessment 1 questions, answered
How do I know my dilemma is a real one?
Try arguing the other side and see whether it holds up. If the opposing position is indefensible, you have a compliance question rather than an ethical one. A genuine dilemma leaves a thoughtful reader uncomfortable with whichever answer you reach, and that discomfort is the test the criteria effectively apply.
Can the scenario be clinical?
It should be administrative, because this is a management ethics course. A clinical decision at the bedside belongs elsewhere. Where a clinical matter is involved, come at it from the administrator's chair: the policy, the staffing level, the resource allocation that shapes what clinicians are able to do.
Do I have to reach a decision?
Yes, and the criteria treat avoidance as an incomplete answer. Concluding that both obligations must somehow be balanced restates the problem rather than resolving it. Decide, explain which principle you weighted more heavily and why, and name what is lost, because that combination is what the assessment is testing.
Where can I find a free BUS FPX 3121 Assessment 1 sample paper?
This page contains the full dilemma analysis on closing or keeping a money-losing psychiatric clinic, with both obligations, the constraint, principles applied, alternatives and who bears the cost. It is written from a manager's point of view.
What counts as a management ethics dilemma in BUS FPX 3121 Assessment 1?
A choice at the organizational level where legitimate obligations conflict, such as closing a service, cutting staff, pricing care or allocating scarce resources, rather than a decision about one patient's treatment.