| Course | BUS FPX 4993 Business Capstone Project |
|---|---|
| Assessment | Assessment 3 |
| Paper type | Options priced and compared |
| Length | About 1,080 words, 6 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Capella University |
| Program | BS in Business |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for BUS FPX 4993 Assessment 3
Pricing and Comparing Options for a Bakery's Late Deliveries: Criteria Fixed Before Scoring, Doing Nothing Priced, Every Option Costed to Implement, Weak Options Kept In, and the Runner-Up Named
Student Name
Capella University
BUS FPX 4993: Business Capstone Project
Instructor Name
Month Day, Year
The Decision
Ridgeline Bread Company must raise on-time wholesale delivery from 81% to at least 93% within 16 weeks, under a capital ceiling of 50,000 dollars. The cross-functional analysis found that production finishes later because the product count grew from 38 to 61 and changeovers rose from 26 to 44 a night, with no process for deciding which products to add. Five options are compared, including doing nothing.
Criteria Fixed Before Scoring
Criteria and weights were fixed before any option was scored, to prevent choosing weights that favor a preferred answer. Hammond et al. (1999) recommend specifying objectives before evaluating alternatives, because objectives chosen afterward tend to justify a decision already made. The criteria, agreed with the owner, Tom Hughes, are: effect on on-time delivery, 35%; annual net cost, 25%; time until the effect is felt, 20%, because of Harvest Fresh's 90-day deadline; and risk to wholesale revenue, 20%. Each option is scored from 1, worst, to 5, best, on each criterion.
Doing Nothing Priced
Doing nothing has a cost, and it is priced like any other option. If Ridgeline changes nothing, Harvest Fresh is likely to leave; the owner and sales manager estimate a 60% probability. Its 780,000 dollars of annual sales at a 35% contribution margin is 273,000 dollars, and at 60% probability the expected loss is about 164,000 dollars a year. Continued attrition of smaller accounts at last year's pace would cost another 108,500 dollars of contribution. Late credits of about 41,000 dollars and courier runs of about 18,700 dollars continue. The expected annual cost of doing nothing is about 332,000 dollars. Doing nothing is the most expensive option on the list.
Every Option Costed to Implement
Option A, start production one hour earlier: 22 production employees for one extra hour, 312 nights a year, at an average of 27 dollars an hour with night differential, about 185,000 dollars a year. Expected on-time rate: about 89%, based on the relationship between finish time and on-time delivery. Effect within two weeks. Option B, reduce products and move the order cutoff: drop the 15 lowest-volume products, move the order cutoff from 6:00 p.m. to 2:00 p.m. the day before, and require the owner's approval for new products. Changeovers would fall from 44 to about 30 a night. Goldratt and Cox (1984) show that time recovered at the bottleneck raises the output of the entire operation, and the roughly two hours of changeover time recovered each night fall exactly on the ovens between 1:00 and 5:00 a.m. Lost sales, net of customers switching to other products, are estimated at 60,000 dollars, or 21,000 dollars of contribution; retraining sales staff and updating the order system cost about 5,000 dollars. Total first-year cost: about 26,000 dollars. Expected on-time rate: about 92%. Effect within six weeks, as customers are notified. Option C, add a second deck oven: about 180,000 dollars installed, which exceeds the capital limit and would need owner approval, plus a baker at about 55,000 dollars a year. Annualized over ten years at 7.5%, the oven costs about 26,000 dollars a year, for a total of about 81,000 dollars a year. Expected on-time rate: about 95%. Effect in about five months, because of equipment lead time. Option D, routing software: about 24,000 dollars a year plus 10,000 dollars of setup. Expected on-time rate: about 85%, since routes are a minor cause. Effect within eight weeks.
Weak Options Kept In
Weak options are kept in the comparison rather than dropped before scoring. Option D, routing software, addresses a minor cause, and doing nothing clearly fails, but scoring them shows how far behind they are and protects against the objection that they were never considered. Option C also looks weak because of its timeline, but it has the strongest long-run effect and remains relevant if volume grows. Keeping all five in the table lets the owner see the whole field at once and challenge any score he disagrees with.
The Scoring
Doing nothing: on-time 1, cost 1, time 1, revenue risk 1; weighted score 1.00. Option A: on-time 3, cost 2, time 5, revenue risk 4; weighted score 1.05 plus 0.50 plus 1.00 plus 0.80, or 3.35. Option B: on-time 4, cost 5, time 4, revenue risk 3; weighted score 1.40 plus 1.25 plus 0.80 plus 0.60, or 4.05. Option C: on-time 5, cost 3, time 1, revenue risk 2; weighted score 1.75 plus 0.75 plus 0.20 plus 0.40, or 3.10. Option D: on-time 2, cost 4, time 3, revenue risk 4; weighted score 0.70 plus 1.00 plus 0.60 plus 0.80, or 3.10. Option B scores highest. It addresses the cause identified in the cross-functional analysis, the growing product list, and costs the least.
Sensitivity of the Ranking
The ranking was tested by shifting weights. If the weight on on-time effect rises to 45% and cost falls to 15%, Option B still leads with 3.95 against A's 3.45 and C's 3.30. Option B loses first place only if revenue risk carries more than about half of the total weight, with the other criteria scaled down in proportion, which would reflect a belief that dropping products will drive away many customers; the customer interviews do not support that belief. The recommendation survives any reasonable change in weights, which is the test that matters.
The Runner-Up Named
The runner-up is Option A, starting one hour earlier. It acts fastest and carries little revenue risk, but it costs about 185,000 dollars a year and treats the symptom, leaving the product list to keep growing. It is named so the owner knows the alternative if Option B falls short, and it can serve as a short-term bridge: a half-hour earlier start for the six weeks it takes Option B to take effect would help meet the Harvest Fresh deadline.
Conclusion
With criteria fixed in advance and doing nothing priced at about 332,000 dollars a year in expected losses, Option B, reducing products, moving the order cutoff, and requiring approval for new products, scores 4.05 and costs about 26,000 dollars in the first year. Option A is the runner-up and a possible bridge, Option C remains a long-run choice if volume grows, and Option D and doing nothing were scored and fall behind.
References
Goldratt, E. M., & Cox, J. (1984). The goal: A process of ongoing improvement. North River Press.
Hammond, J. S., Keeney, R. L., & Raiffa, H. (1999). Smart choices: A practical guide to making better decisions. Harvard Business School Press.
The Capella BUS FPX 4993 Assessment 3 instructions
The third capstone assessment asks you to develop and compare solutions to the problem you defined and analyzed. You set the criteria and their weights from the problem definition, describe each realistic option, including doing nothing, price each one, covering implementation as well as running costs, score the options against the criteria, test whether the ranking changes if the weights change, and choose a preferred option while naming the runner-up. Options that score poorly should stay in the comparison, since removing them hides the reasoning. Business research, supplier quotes and the earlier assessments supply the figures.
How this BUS FPX 4993 Assessment 3 example is built
Criteria, options, costs, comparison. The opening states the criteria the options will be judged on and where they came from, drawn from the problem definition rather than invented here. An options block describes each realistic alternative in enough detail to price, including the status quo. A costing block prices each: implementation, ongoing effect, and the period over which any return appears, with assumptions labeled. A comparison block scores them against the stated criteria and shows the working rather than asserting a ranking. A risk block covers what could go wrong with each and how likely that is. The closing identifies the preferred option and names the circumstances that would have handed it to the runner up. Figures carry bases and nothing is scored on a criterion invented afterward.
Reading the BUS FPX 4993 Assessment 3 scoring guide
Marks go to the criteria, the options, the pricing, the scoring, the sensitivity and the choice. Criteria reach Distinguished when drawn from the problem definition and weighted before scoring. Options score higher when doing nothing is priced, showing the cost of the late deliveries continuing. Pricing earns credit when implementation costs, such as training and transition time, are included. Scoring is judged on whether it is shown for every option. Sensitivity should show whether the ranking holds when weights change. The runner-up should be named with the conditions under which it would win. Proficient comparisons pick a sensible option; Distinguished ones show the choice survives reasonable disagreement.
BUS FPX 4993 Assessment 3 help from the desk
Option comparisons commonly present one favored solution and two weak ones added to make it look good. Another weakness is setting the criteria after scoring, which lets the preferred option win by design. Doing nothing is not priced, so the cost of inaction is invisible. Implementation costs are left out, so an option looks cheaper than it is. Sensitivity is skipped, so a small change in one weight could reverse the ranking without anyone noticing. The runner-up is ignored, leaving the owner with no fallback if the preferred option stalls. A scoring table with each option, each criterion, the weights and the totals, followed by a second version with different weights, makes the comparison transparent and hands the implementation plan a choice that has already been tested.
Get a BUS FPX 4993 Assessment 3 example written to your instructions
Send the Assessment 3 instructions and the BUS FPX 4993 scoring guide from your courseroom, with the analysis your earlier assessments produced. We write a custom example against those exact criteria and return it in 24 to 48 hours. The first custom sample is free, and pricing the status quo is the move that makes an options comparison honest. The paper above is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Capella University document.
More BUS FPX 4993 papers and BS in Business samples
- BUS FPX 4993 Assessment 1: Problem Definition and Scope
- BUS FPX 4993 Assessment 2: Cross Functional Analysis
- BUS FPX 4993 Assessment 4: Implementation and Presentation
- ECO FPX 1150 Assessment 3: Personal Financial Plan
- BUS FPX 4802 Assessment 3: Adoption Measurement Plan
- BUS FPX 1011 Assessment 3: Control and Evaluation Report
- BUS FPX 4801 Assessment 3: Ethics Recommendation and Disclosure
BUS FPX 4993 Assessment 3 questions, answered
How many options should I compare?
Three or four, all of them genuinely available. Fewer and there is no comparison; more and none gets costed properly. The test the criteria effectively apply is whether a reasonable manager could have chosen any of them, and straw alternatives fail it at once. Fewer, better options is the rule.
Why price doing nothing?
Because it is what happens if nobody decides, and it is rarely free. The margin keeps eroding, the turnover keeps costing, the customers keep leaving. Putting a number on that is often the strongest argument the recommendation has, and it is the option students most reliably forget.
What if I cannot cost an option precisely?
Bound it and say how. An implementation cost stated as a range with its basis is entirely defensible, and comparing ranges is often enough to separate the options. What weakens the section is one option costed carefully and another waved through as broadly similar. Uneven costing is what a marker notices first.
Where can I find a free BUS FPX 4993 Assessment 3 sample paper?
The complete option comparison for the late deliveries is here, with criteria fixed first, doing nothing priced, every option costed to implement, weak options kept in and the runner-up named.
Why price doing nothing in BUS FPX 4993 Assessment 3?
Every option costs money, but so does leaving the problem alone, through lost customers, penalties and waste. Pricing inaction shows what the solutions are really competing against.