DB FPX 8710 Assessment 1 Competitive Position Analysis example

Reviewed by Blythe Cavendish, PhD Strategy and Innovation: Theorizing, Crafting, Executing Capella University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This DB FPX 8710 Assessment 1 sample paper is a competitive position analysis of where a premium ice cream maker actually stands in a crowded freezer aisle. It was written for Capella DB FPX 8710, Strategy and Innovation: Theorizing, Crafting, Executing, a course in the Doctor of Business Administration (DBA) listed as DB-FPX8710. The paper sets out the category's economics first, including slotting fees and retailer margins, then states a test for what would count as a competitive advantage. It applies the test with evidence from outside the firm, such as retail scanner data and competitor pricing, and faces the uncomfortable point where the firm's strengths meet its weakest channels.

CourseDB FPX 8710 Strategy and Innovation: Theorizing, Crafting, Executing
AssessmentAssessment 1
Paper typeCompetitive position analysis
LengthAbout 1,100 words, 5 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolCapella University
ProgramDoctor of Business Administration (DBA)
UpdatedSeptember 2026

Free sample paper for DB FPX 8710 Assessment 1

1

Where a Premium Ice Cream Maker Actually Stands: A Competitive Position Analysis With Category Economics First, a Stated Test for Advantage, Evidence From Outside the Firm, and the Uncomfortable Intersection Faced

Student Name

Capella University

DB FPX 8710: Strategy and Innovation: Theorizing, Crafting, Executing

Instructor Name

Month Day, Year

What this part is doingThe title names the firm and the analysis's order. Position analyses in this course are judged on starting with industry economics, so the category comes first.
2

Industry Economics Before Firm Description

Premium packaged ice cream is a difficult category for a small producer, and its economics shape everything a regional firm can do. Porter (2008) argues that the strength of five forces, rivalry, the threat of entry, the power of buyers and suppliers, and the threat of substitutes, determines how much of an industry's value its firms can keep. In this category, three of the forces are strong. Buyers are powerful. Grocery chains control scarce freezer space, charge slotting fees for new items, and remove products whose sales per store fall below internal thresholds. A handful of chains account for most grocery volume in any region. Rivalry is intense: national brands in the super-premium tier spend heavily on promotion and hold the best freezer positions, and grocery chains' own private-label premium lines compete on price. Supplier power is moderate but volatile, because cream and butterfat prices swing with dairy markets, and cream is the largest ingredient cost in a high-butterfat product. Distribution is costly because every unit must stay frozen from plant to freezer case, which favors producers large enough to fill trucks. The threat of substitutes is real as well: frozen novelties, gelato, and nondairy desserts compete for the same freezer space and the same shopper's dessert budget. Entry into grocery is hard because of slotting fees and buyer power, but entry into small-scale production is easy, which is why many small creameries exist and few reach grocery at scale. Taken together, the forces suggest that a small producer's profits in packaged grocery ice cream will be squeezed from several sides at once. The foodservice side of the category, selling bulk tubs to independent scoop shops and restaurants, has different economics. Buyers are small and numerous, switching costs are higher because shops build menus around flavors, and freezer space belongs to the shop rather than to a chain.

The Firm

Northwoods Creamery is a composite family-owned producer in central Minnesota, founded 22 years ago, with 64 employees and annual sales of about 14.5 million dollars. It sells pints to grocery chains in five states, which account for 61% of revenue, and three-gallon tubs to about 140 scoop shops and restaurants across Minnesota and Wisconsin, which account for 39%.

A Stated Test for What Counts as Advantage

A claimed strength counts as a competitive advantage in this analysis only if it passes a test drawn from Barney (1991): it must be valuable, meaning customers pay more for it or it lowers the firm's costs relative to rivals; it must be rare among competitors; and it must be costly for competitors to imitate within a few years. A strength that fails any part is described as a capability, not an advantage.

What this part is doingThe test is written before any strength is judged. Scorers reward analyses that say in advance what would count.
3

Claims Not Taken From the Firm

The owners describe the firm's quality as its advantage, pointing to its 16% butterfat and local cream. That claim is tested with evidence from outside the firm. Grocery scan data supplied by the two largest chains show that Northwoods pints sell at an average shelf price of 6.49 dollars, about 8% below the leading national super-premium brands and 45% above private-label premium. Sales per store per week average 3.1 units in Minnesota stores and 1.2 units in stores in the other four states. One chain's category manager said in an interview that items selling under 1.5 units per store per week are reviewed for removal at the annual reset. Scoop shop data tell a different story. Of the 140 accounts active three years ago, 128 remain, and 31 of those added Northwoods as their only ice cream supplier during that time. In a survey of 60 shop owners conducted for this analysis, 44 named flavor consistency and the firm's willingness to produce custom flavors in small batches as their main reasons for buying, and only nine named price. The survey was conducted by a graduate student hired for the purpose rather than by the firm's sales staff, to reduce the chance that owners would give the answers they thought the firm wanted. Applied to the test, quality in grocery does not appear to be an advantage outside Minnesota: shoppers there do not pay a premium above national brands and do not buy at a rate that secures freezer space. In the scoop shop channel, custom small-batch production passes the test: shop owners value it, national brands do not offer it at this scale, and it would be costly for a large producer to imitate because its plants are built for long runs. That is a capability built over two decades of small orders, not a claim about taste. The owners' strength is real, but it is being sold hardest in the channel that rewards it least.

The Uncomfortable Intersection

The evidence meets at an uncomfortable point. The channel that produces most of the firm's revenue, out-of-state grocery in particular, is the one where the firm has no demonstrated advantage and where its velocity is below the level at which one chain reviews items for removal. The channel where the firm has a clear advantage is the smaller one. The owners' attention and marketing budget, by their own account, go mostly to grocery, where buyer meetings and promotions are frequent.

Position Stated, Strategy Withheld

Northwoods Creamery's competitive position can be stated as follows: in grocery outside Minnesota, it is a small premium brand without a price premium or velocity advantage in a category controlled by powerful buyers; in Minnesota grocery, it holds a modest home-market position; and in the scoop shop channel, it holds a genuine advantage in custom small-batch production that customers value and large rivals are poorly placed to copy. This analysis does not recommend what the firm should do about that position. Strategy requires choices about which channels to pursue and what to give up, and those choices belong to the next stage, where the beliefs behind each option can be examined.

What this part is doingThe analysis ends with position and holds back recommendation. Scorers reward restraint that separates diagnosis from strategy.
4

Conclusion

Industry economics make packaged ice cream a hard category for a regional producer, with powerful buyers and heavy rivalry. Tested against a stated standard and evidence from retailers and customers, Northwoods Creamery's claimed quality advantage does not hold in most of its grocery business but does hold, in the form of custom small-batch production, in its scoop shop channel.

5

References

Barney, J. (1991). Firm resources and sustained competitive advantage. Journal of Management, 17(1), 99-120. https://doi.org/10.1177/014920639101700108

Porter, M. E. (2008). The five competitive forces that shape strategy. Harvard Business Review, 86(1), 78-93.

DB FPX 8710 Assessment 1 instructions, in plain terms

The first assessment in DB FPX 8710 asks you to analyze a firm's competitive position with doctoral rigor. You describe the economics of the industry or category, state the criteria you will use to judge whether the firm has an advantage, such as the resource-based view's tests of value, rarity and difficulty of imitation, apply those criteria using evidence from sources outside the firm's own claims and identify where the firm's position is weaker than it appears. The analysis should rest on theory and evidence rather than marketing language. Strategy research, including Porter and Barney, and industry data support the analysis.

How the DB-FPX8710 Assessment 1 example is put together

Two inventories, then their intersection. The opening establishes the industry's economics, using published financial data and the structural features that explain where returns concentrate rather than a general description of the sector. The second block inventories the firm's resources and capabilities against a stated test of inimitability, and applies the test visibly, striking out what fails it. The third block sets the two against each other, asking which of the firm's genuine holdings the industry actually rewards, which is frequently an uncomfortable comparison. The fourth states the resulting position, including where the firm is competing on things the market does not pay for. Headings follow the prompt, financial claims carry sources with periods, and no capability is credited on the firm's own description of itself.

DB FPX 8710 Assessment 1 scoring guide: what Distinguished looks like

Capella's scoring guide rates the account of category economics, the test for advantage, the evidence, the honesty about weaknesses and the use of theory. Economics reach Distinguished when the structure of the category is set out before the firm, including who captures margin along the chain from dairy supplier to grocer. The test scores higher when stated in advance, so the firm's resources are measured against criteria rather than described. Evidence earns credit when drawn from outside the firm, such as syndicated sales data, retailer pricing and trade press, since company statements are not proof of advantage. Weaknesses are judged on whether the paper faces the intersection where strengths fail, like a premium brand losing shelf space in conventional grocery. Theory should shape the analysis, not decorate it. A Proficient analysis describes the firm's strengths; a Distinguished one tests whether they amount to an advantage.

Common DB FPX 8710 Assessment 1 mistakes, and how to avoid them

Competitive analyses often list the firm's strengths from its own website and call them advantages, which confuses claims with evidence. Another weakness is skipping the category's economics, so the analysis cannot explain why margins are what they are. The test for advantage is never stated, so any strength seems to qualify. Evidence from outside the firm is missing. Weak spots are ignored or softened, although the uncomfortable findings are what make the analysis useful. Theory appears only in a literature section. Writing the test as three questions before looking at the firm, then answering each with an outside source, keeps the analysis honest and prepares the strategy formulation in Assessment 2.

Get a DB FPX 8710 Assessment 1 example written to your instructions

Send the Assessment 1 instructions and the scoring guide from your DB FPX 8710 courseroom, plus the firm your section specified if it named one. We write a custom example against those exact criteria and return it in 24 to 48 hours. The first custom sample is free, and it applies the inimitability test rather than mentioning it. The paper above is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Capella University document.

More DB FPX 8710 papers and DBA samples

DB FPX 8710 Assessment 1 questions, answered

Which firm should I choose for this analysis?

One with published financials and identifiable rivals, in an industry whose economics you can establish. Listed companies in concentrated industries work best. A private firm leaves the industry economics section resting on estimates, and a conglomerate spreads the analysis across businesses with different competitive logics.

What if the firm holds nothing that passes the test?

That is a legitimate and often striking finding. Many firms compete on execution of things anybody could obtain, and saying so with evidence is stronger analysis than manufacturing a distinctive capability. It also gives the strategy assessment behind this one a genuinely difficult problem to work on.

How much industry data do I actually need?

Enough to say where returns concentrate and why. Margins at different points in the value chain, the returns of a few named competitors, and the structural reason for the difference will carry most analyses. Exhaustive market sizing consumes space that the capability test and the intersection need more.

Where can I find a free DB FPX 8710 Assessment 1 sample paper?

The premium ice cream maker's position analysis is here in full, with category economics first, a stated test for advantage, evidence from outside the firm and the uncomfortable intersection faced.

What if the firm holds nothing that passes the test in DB FPX 8710 Assessment 1?

Say so. Finding that a firm has no sustainable advantage is a valid and useful result, and it sets up a stronger strategy paper.