DB FPX 9804 Assessment 1 Reviewer Response Memo example

Reviewed by Blythe Cavendish, PhD Final Reviews and Presentation Capella University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This DB FPX 9804 Assessment 1 sample paper is a reviewer response memo answering committee comments on a doctoral project about apprentice retention. It was written for Capella DB FPX 9804, Final Reviews and Presentation, a course in the Doctor of Business Administration (DBA) with the catalog code DB-FPX9804. The paper reproduces each comment verbatim and gives the action taken, the reason and the location of the change. It answers declined comments respectfully with evidence and discloses changes the committee did not request. It closes with a summary the chair can check in minutes, grouped by reviewer and by chapter.

CourseDB FPX 9804 Final Reviews and Presentation
AssessmentAssessment 1
Paper typeReviewer response memo
LengthAbout 1,070 words, 5 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolCapella University
ProgramDoctor of Business Administration (DBA)
UpdatedSeptember 2026

Free sample paper for DB FPX 9804 Assessment 1

1

Responding to the Committee: A Reviewer Response Memo for a Doctoral Project on Apprentice Retention, With Comments Reproduced Verbatim, Action, Reason, and Location for Each, Declined Comments Answered, and Unrequested Changes Disclosed

Student Name

Capella University

DB FPX 9804: Final Reviews and Presentation

Instructor Name

Month Day, Year

What this part is doingThe title names the memo's parts. Response memos are judged on completeness and tone, so every comment is promised an answer.
2

Purpose of This Memo

This memo responds to the written comments of the three committee members on the full draft of the doctoral project, received on March 3. Each comment is reproduced exactly as written, followed by the action taken, the reason, and the page and section where the change can be found in the revised draft dated March 24. Comments are numbered in the order they appear in each member's review. Where a comment raised more than one point, each point is answered separately under the same number. The memo does not discuss the merits of any comment beyond the reason for the action taken, since the committee's time is better spent checking the revisions than reading arguments about them. A clean copy and a copy with tracked changes are both attached. Page numbers in this memo refer to the clean copy. Questions about any response can be sent before the next meeting.

Chair

Comment C1: "The definition of primary crew needs a stronger justification. Many apprentices rotate, and I am not convinced the crew with most hours is the crew that mattered." Action: Added a paragraph showing that, although apprentices typically rotated through about three crews, four in five spent over half their first-year hours on the primary crew, and added a sensitivity check in which apprentices whose primary crew accounted for half or less of their hours were removed; the range of crew retention changed from 33%-92% to 38%-92%. Reason: the comment identified a weakness the draft had not addressed with data. Location: Section 3, Definitions, page 41; Section 4, RQ1 results, page 58. Comment C2: "Chapter 5 says crews that pair apprentices keep them. Your design does not allow you to say that." Action: Rewrote the sentence and three others with similar wording to describe association. Reason: the comment is correct. Location: Section 5, pages 71, 73, and 76. The revised sentences now read, for example, that crews with journeyman pairing had higher first-year retention in these cohorts, with no verb implying that pairing produced the difference. Comment C3: "Please add the number of former apprentices you could not reach." Action: Added the counts, 19 not reachable and 8 who declined, and a sentence noting that interviewed leavers overrepresent dismissals. Reason: readers need these numbers to judge the comparison. Location: Section 4, Participants, page 55. The same counts now appear in the limitations section, where the effect of the missing leavers on the comparison is discussed.

What this part is doingEach comment is followed by action, reason, and location in the same order. Scorers reward memos a committee can check line by line.
3

Methodologist

Comment M1: "With 125 apprentices nested in crews, a multilevel logistic model would be more appropriate than descriptive comparison." Action: Not adopted; a paragraph explaining the choice was added. Reason: with 12 crews of six or more apprentices, estimates of variance between crews in a multilevel model would be unstable, and the project's research question asks how much retention varies across crews, which the descriptive table answers directly. The added paragraph states that a multilevel model would be appropriate for a study with more crews and cites this as a direction for future research. Location: Section 3, Data Analysis, page 47; Section 5, Recommendations for Research, page 79. Comment M2: "Report intercoder agreement, not just that two coders were used." Action: Added that the two coders agreed on 84% of code applications in the eight double-coded transcripts before discussion, and described how disagreements were resolved during the review of themes, a phase of the thematic analysis described by Braun and Clarke (2006). Reason: the comment is correct and the figure was available. Location: Section 3, Trustworthiness, page 50. The eight double-coded transcripts are also now identified by participant code in an appendix, so that a reader can see which groups they came from; four came from stayers and four from leavers. Comment M3: "Table 2 percentages for small groups can mislead." Action: Kept percentages but placed counts first in each cell and added a note that percentages are based on 14 and 12 participants. Reason: the counts address the concern while keeping the table comparable across groups. Location: Section 4, Table 2, page 64.

Second Reader

Comment R1: "The literature review spends too long on general turnover models that the study does not use." Action: Reduced the section on turnover models from about 2,600 to about 900 words, keeping only the parts used in Section 5. Reason: the comment is correct. Location: Section 2, pages 18 to 21. The removed material concerned models of job satisfaction and alternatives that were never used in the analysis; the embeddedness research, which Section 5 draws on when discussing why apprentices stayed, was kept. Comment R2: "I would like to see the foremen's perspective given more weight." Action: Declined as a change to the findings; added a sentence in Section 5 explaining the choice. Reason: the research questions concern apprentices' accounts, and foremen's interviews were planned as a check on apprentices' descriptions of crew practices, not as a separate strand; giving them more weight would change the project's questions after data collection. The added sentence identifies foremen's perspectives as a subject for further study. Location: Section 5, Limitations, page 77. A declined comment still gets a full answer and a location, because the committee needs to see where the reasoning now lives.

Changes Not Requested by the Committee

Three changes were made that no comment requested, and they are disclosed here. First, a coding error was found in the records: one apprentice's start date had been entered a year late, which placed that apprentice in the 2021 cohort instead of 2020; correcting it did not change any crew totals. Second, the figure was redrawn to show the number of apprentices beside each crew's point. Third, the abstract was rewritten to reflect the revised wording on causation. Fourth, two references cited in the draft with incorrect page ranges were corrected after the reference list was checked against the original sources, and one reference that was listed but not cited was removed.

What this part is doingUnrequested changes are disclosed so the committee can check them. Scorers reward transparency about everything that changed.
4

Summary

All eight comments received a response: five were adopted in full, one was adopted in a different form, and two were declined with stated reasons. Three unrequested changes are disclosed above.

5

References

Braun, V., & Clarke, V. (2006). Using thematic analysis in psychology. Qualitative Research in Psychology, 3(2), 77-101. https://doi.org/10.1191/1478088706qp063oa

What the DB FPX 9804 Assessment 1 instructions ask for

DB FPX 9804 Assessment 1 asks you to respond to reviewer or committee feedback on your doctoral project. You list every comment exactly as written, state what you did in response, explain why, give the page and section where the change appears, explain respectfully and with evidence when you decline a suggestion, and note any other changes you made that were not requested. The memo should let reviewers confirm quickly that each concern was addressed. Guidance on responding to peer review, such as advice from journal editors, and Capella's doctoral review procedures support the memo.

How this DB FPX 9804 Assessment 1 example is built

Cover note, then comment by comment. The opening is a short paragraph telling the reviewer what changed at the document level, which orients them before the detail. Comments then appear in the order the reviewer raised them, each reproduced verbatim and numbered so both parties can refer to the same item. Under each, the response states the action taken, the reasoning where it is not obvious, and the location in the revised document by page or section. Declined comments carry a reason and an alternative. A closing block lists changes made that no comment asked for, which is a courtesy and prevents a reviewer discovering them unexpectedly. Formatting is plain and consistent, and every location reference is checked against the revised document.

Where the marks sit in the DB FPX 9804 Assessment 1 scoring guide

The scoring guide weighs the completeness of the memo, the verbatim reproduction of comments, the action and reason for each, the location references, the handling of declined comments and the disclosure of other changes. Completeness reaches Distinguished when every comment from every reviewer appears, including small editorial ones. Comments score higher when reproduced verbatim, since paraphrase can shift meaning. Action and reason earn credit when both are given, not just "revised." Location is judged on whether page and section are precise enough for the reviewer to go straight there. Declined comments should be answered respectfully with evidence from the literature or the data. Other changes should be disclosed so nothing surprises the committee. Tone should stay professional. Distinguished memos make approval easy.

Common DB FPX 9804 Assessment 1 mistakes, and how to avoid them

Response memos often paraphrase comments, which can change their meaning and irritate the reviewer who wrote them. Another weakness is replying "done" without saying what was done or where. Locations are missing, so reviewers must search the whole document. Comments that were not acted on are quietly skipped, which reviewers always notice. Changes the committee did not request are hidden, although they may raise new questions. The tone becomes defensive when a comment seems unfair. Comments from different reviewers are merged. Using a table with the comment, action, reason and page for each item, and answering declined comments with a short, evidenced explanation, keeps the memo professional and speeds final approval.

Get a DB FPX 9804 Assessment 1 example written to your instructions

Send the Assessment 1 instructions and the scoring guide from your DB FPX 9804 courseroom, plus the comment set your version supplies. We write a custom example against those exact criteria and return it in 24 to 48 hours. The first custom sample is free, and responses to the review of your own project remain yours to write and stand behind. The paper above is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Capella University document.

More DB FPX 9804 papers and DBA samples

DB FPX 9804 Assessment 1 questions, answered

What if a reviewer comment is based on a misreading?

Assume the text caused it, because usually something did. Rather than explaining the misreading, change the passage so it cannot be read that way, then say that is what you did. That response satisfies the reviewer and improves the document, where a correction of their reading achieves neither.

Can I decline a comment?

Yes, sparingly and with an alternative. State the reason in a sentence or two, describe what you did instead, and move on. A memo declining several comments will be read as resistance regardless of how sound each reason is, so choose the one or two that genuinely matter and accept the rest.

How detailed should the location references be?

Precise enough that the reviewer finds the change without searching: page and section, or paragraph where the document is long. Check every one against the revised file before sending, since a reference pointing to the wrong place undermines the whole memo and is the easiest error to prevent.

Where can I find a free DB FPX 9804 Assessment 1 sample paper?

The complete reviewer response memo is here, with comments reproduced verbatim, action, reason and location for each, declined comments answered and unrequested changes disclosed.

Can I decline a comment in DB FPX 9804 Assessment 1?

Yes, if you explain respectfully why, with evidence. Reviewers accept reasoned disagreement more readily than silence.