| Course | ECO FPX 1150 Personal Economics: Introduction to Financial Planning |
|---|---|
| Assessment | Assessment 2 |
| Paper type | Financial decision paper |
| Length | About 1,090 words, 5 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Capella University |
| Program | BS in Business |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for ECO FPX 1150 Assessment 2
Pay Cash or Finance the Car? A Financial Decision Paper Comparing Both Options Over the Same 48 Months, With Opportunity Cost in Dollars and the Condition That Flips the Answer
Student Name
Capella University
ECO FPX 1150: Personal Economics: Introduction to Financial Planning
Instructor Name
Month Day, Year
The Decision
Marcus Hill, a composite 29-year-old respiratory therapist in Des Moines, Iowa, needs a car after his old one failed inspection. He has found a used sedan for 9,000 dollars, including tax and fees. He has 12,500 dollars in a high-yield savings account and no other debt. His credit union has approved him for a 48-month used car loan at 7.5% annual interest. The decision is whether to pay the 9,000 dollars in cash from savings or to finance the full amount and leave his savings untouched. The horizon for both options is 48 months, the length of the loan, because a comparison must end at the same date for both.
Concepts Used in the Comparison
Three concepts do the work. Opportunity cost is the value of the best alternative given up by a choice (Kapoor et al., 2020); here, it measures what the 9,000 dollars would earn if left in savings, or what the loan interest would cost if he borrows. The time value of money measures how the two paths grow apart over 48 months when money earns or costs interest. Liquidity, the ease of turning an asset into cash, measures the risk each option carries if an emergency occurs.
Stated Rates and Assumptions
The loan rate of 7.5% is the rate on Marcus's written approval from his credit union. His savings account pays 4.3% annual percentage yield, as shown on his most recent statement; the paper assumes it stays at that rate for four years, which is uncertain and is tested below. Interest earned in savings is taxable; at his federal bracket of 12% plus Iowa's income tax, the paper uses a combined 16% tax on interest, leaving an after-tax savings rate of about 3.6%. The paper assumes Marcus sets aside the same monthly amount under both options, so the comparison is fair: the loan payment under one option, and a deposit to savings of the same size under the other.
Both Options Costed
Option A, financing, requires a monthly payment of about 217.61 dollars for 48 months, a total of about 10,445 dollars. The interest cost is about 1,445 dollars. His 12,500 dollars stays in savings, and the 9,000 dollars that would have paid for the car grows at the after-tax rate of about 3.6% to about 10,370 dollars after 48 months. Option B, paying cash, leaves 3,500 dollars in savings on the day of purchase. Marcus then deposits 217.61 dollars a month into savings, the same amount he would have paid the lender. After 48 months at the after-tax rate, those deposits grow to about 11,210 dollars. Comparing the two paths on the portion of money that differs, Option B ends about 840 dollars ahead of Option A after four years (11,210 against 10,370). That 840 dollars is the opportunity cost of financing. It is smaller than the 1,445 dollars of loan interest because the cash left in savings under Option A earns interest too, which partly offsets the loan. The immediate cost differs sharply, however: Option B takes 9,000 dollars out of savings today, while Option A takes nothing.
How the Two Paths Diverge Over Time
The gap grows each year, which shows the time value of money at work. To compare fairly at each point, the remaining loan balance is subtracted from the savings under Option A. After one year, Option A holds about 9,330 dollars in savings against a loan balance of about 7,000 dollars, a net of about 2,330 dollars, while Option B holds about 2,650 dollars, so Option B leads by about 330 dollars. After two years the lead is about 580 dollars, after three years about 750 dollars, and after four years, when the loan is paid, about 840 dollars. The lead grows because each year the loan charges 7.5% on its balance while the savings earn only 3.6% after taxes.
Financing costs about 1,445 dollars in interest, but only about 840 dollars once the savings interest is counted.
The Risk Each Option Carries
The two options carry different risks. Under Option B, Marcus's savings fall to 3,500 dollars, about one and a half months of his expenses of 2,300 dollars a month. A job interruption or a large medical bill in the first year could force him onto a credit card at 22% or more, which would erase the gain quickly. Under Option A, he keeps 12,500 dollars, more than five months of expenses, but he is committed to a fixed payment for four years. His job is in demand, which lowers income risk, but it does not remove it. Non-financial factors are kept separate from the numbers. Marcus values not owing money, which favors paying cash, and he also values the calm of a full emergency fund, which favors financing. Neither preference changes the arithmetic, but each should shape how much risk he is willing to carry.
The Condition That Flips the Answer
The answer depends mainly on the gap between the loan rate and the after-tax savings rate. If the credit union offered a promotional rate below about 3.6%, financing would come out ahead, because the savings would earn more than the loan cost. If savings rates fell to 2%, the advantage of paying cash would grow to about 1,180 dollars. A middle path also exists: Marcus could put down 5,000 dollars and finance 4,000 dollars, keeping 7,500 dollars in savings, or more than three months of expenses, while paying less interest.
Recommendation
The recommended choice is the middle path: pay 5,000 dollars down and finance 4,000 dollars over 48 months. This keeps his emergency fund above three months of expenses and cuts the interest cost to about 640 dollars. It gives up roughly 370 dollars of the 840 dollar advantage that paying fully in cash would have produced, and that 370 dollars is the price Marcus pays for keeping a safe cushion while he is new to his job.
Conclusion
Paying cash is about 840 dollars cheaper over four years once savings interest and taxes are counted, but it drains Marcus's emergency fund. A partial down payment keeps most of the saving while protecting his liquidity, and the decision would change if a much lower loan rate were offered.
References
Kapoor, J. R., Dlabay, L. R., Hughes, R. J., & Hart, M. M. (2020). Personal finance (13th ed.). McGraw-Hill Education.
What the ECO FPX 1150 Assessment 2 instructions ask for
Assessment 2 in ECO FPX 1150 has you analyze a personal financial decision. You state the choice, the amount at stake and the time horizon, explain the relevant concepts, such as interest, opportunity cost and time value of money, list your assumptions, including loan and savings rates, calculate the total cost of each option over the same period, compare the results, consider risks such as losing an emergency fund, and make a recommendation. Both options must be compared over the same horizon so the figures are fair. Sources include lender rate data, savings account rates and course readings on consumer finance.
How the ECO-FPX1150 Assessment 2 example is put together
The paper works forward from the decision to the evidence and only then to the recommendation. It opens by stating the choice precisely, including the amount at stake and the time horizon, because a decision without a horizon cannot be compared. A second section defines the concepts that will do the work and says what each will be used to measure, which keeps them from becoming a glossary. The comparison follows, holding both options to identical dimensions in a fixed order: immediate cost, total cost over the horizon, what the money does elsewhere, and the risk each carries. Assumptions sit beside the calculations, including any rate the paper had to source. A sensitivity paragraph asks what would flip the answer. The recommendation closes the paper and names what is being given up to take it.
ECO FPX 1150 Assessment 2 scoring guide: what Distinguished looks like
The scoring guide rewards a decision paper that compares options fairly and in dollars. The decision reaches Distinguished when stated with an amount and a horizon. Concepts score higher when used in the calculations rather than defined separately. Assumptions earn credit when the rates are stated and sourced. Costing is judged on whether both options are totaled over the same forty-eight months, including interest paid and interest forgone. Opportunity cost should be given in dollars. Risks, such as having no cash reserve, should be weighed. The condition that would reverse the recommendation shows real understanding. Distinguished papers turn the concepts into numbers.
ECO FPX 1150 Assessment 2 help: mistakes that cost marks
Decision papers often compare the monthly payment with the cash price, which ignores what the cash could have earned. Another weakness is using different time periods for each option. Interest rates appear with no source. Opportunity cost is defined but not calculated. Risk is left out, so paying cash seems best even when it would empty the emergency fund. The recommendation does not say when the answer would change, such as a higher loan rate or a lower savings rate. A table showing each option's cost month by month, or at least year by year, with cumulative totals makes the comparison clear and lets the reader see exactly where the paths separate.
Get a ECO FPX 1150 Assessment 2 example written to your instructions
Give us the Assessment 2 instructions and scoring guide from your ECO FPX 1150 section, plus the decision your prompt sets or the one you intend to analyze. A custom example comes back with both options costed over a stated horizon and the concepts doing real work, inside 24 to 48 hours. First custom sample, no charge. The paper above is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Capella University document.
More ECO FPX 1150 papers and BS in Business samples
- ECO FPX 1150 Assessment 1: Budget Analysis
- ECO FPX 1150 Assessment 3: Personal Financial Plan
- BUS FPX 1011 Assessment 2: Planning Memo
- BUS FPX 4993 Assessment 2: Cross Functional Analysis
- BUS FPX 1050 Assessment 2: Elasticity Problem Set
- BUS FPX 4802 Assessment 2: Transition and Communication Plan
ECO FPX 1150 Assessment 2 questions, answered
Which financial decision makes the strongest paper?
One with two defensible options and numbers you can find, which is why renting against buying, financing against paying cash, and clearing debt against building savings all work well. Avoid decisions where one side is obviously correct, since the comparison collapses. If your instructions name the decision, use it and put your effort into the arithmetic instead of the choice of topic.
How much calculation does the assessment expect?
Arithmetic rather than anything advanced: totals, percentages, interest accumulated over a stated period, often with a calculator the course points you toward. Marks are seldom lost on computation and regularly lost on skipping it. Show the small math in the text or a table so a reader can follow each step, and label what every figure represents.
Can I bring in factors that are not financial?
Yes, and strong papers do, provided they stay separate from the numbers. Stability, commute time, flexibility and stress are real inputs to a decision, so name them, say how much weight you are giving each, and keep them out of the cost comparison itself. What loses credit is using them to escape an arithmetic result you did not like.
Where can I find a free ECO FPX 1150 Assessment 2 sample paper?
This page contains the complete pay cash or finance comparison, with both options costed over the same 48 months, opportunity cost in dollars, the risk each carries and the condition that flips the answer.
What is opportunity cost in ECO FPX 1150 Assessment 2?
The value of the best alternative you give up. Paying cash for the car means losing the interest that money could have earned in savings over the same period.