| Course | HRM FPX 5065 Employment Law in the Successful Workplace |
|---|---|
| Assessment | Assessment 1 |
| Paper type | Employment law analysis |
| Length | About 1,100 words, 6 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Capella University |
| Program | MS in Human Resource Management |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for HRM FPX 5065 Assessment 1
An ADA Accommodation Case at a Call Center: Facts Separated From Characterization, Coverage Settled First, Elements Taken One at a Time, the Employer's Defense Argued Properly, and a Conclusion a Manager Can Act On
Student Name
Capella University
HRM FPX 5065: Employment Law in the Successful Workplace
Instructor Name
Month Day, Year
Facts Separated From Characterization
The facts are stated first, separately from how either side describes them. Clearwater Insurance Services, a composite company with about 260 employees, runs a customer service call center. Dana Hughes has worked there as a customer service representative for four years, with performance ratings of meets or exceeds expectations. In March, Dana gave her supervisor a note from her physician stating that she has generalized anxiety disorder, that her symptoms are worse in the open call floor environment, and recommending that she work from home two days a week. The supervisor told Dana that representatives must work on site and did not forward the note to human resources. Over the next two months, Dana missed six days, citing her condition. In May, Clearwater terminated her employment under its attendance policy, which allows five unexcused absences in a rolling six months. Characterizations are set aside for now. Dana's representative describes the termination as "punishing her for her disability." The supervisor describes Dana as "unreliable." Neither statement is a fact; each is a conclusion the analysis must test. A characterization is a conclusion wearing the clothes of a fact.
Coverage Settled Before the Argument
Coverage is settled before any argument about the merits. Title I of the Americans with Disabilities Act reaches any employer with at least 15 employees, and Clearwater, at about 260, is well above that line. Dana is an employee, not a contractor. The question of whether she has a disability under the Act is an element, addressed below, not a coverage question. The Family and Medical Leave Act may also apply to her absences, since Clearwater has more than 50 employees and Dana has worked there for four years, but this analysis addresses only the Americans with Disabilities Act claim and notes the leave question for separate review.
Elements Taken One at a Time
A failure-to-accommodate claim requires that the employee has a disability, is qualified to perform the essential functions of the job with or without reasonable accommodation, that the employer knew of the disability and the need for accommodation, and that the employer failed to provide a reasonable accommodation. Each element is taken separately. Disability: the Act, as amended in 2008, defines disability broadly as a physical or mental impairment that substantially limits a major life activity, and the regulations state that the determination should not demand extensive analysis. Generalized anxiety disorder can substantially limit major life activities such as concentrating and thinking, and brain function is itself a major bodily function. On the facts, this element is likely met. Qualified: Dana has performed the job for four years with good ratings, which strongly suggests she can perform its essential functions. The dispute is whether working on site is itself an essential function. Knowledge: Dana gave her supervisor a physician's note describing the condition and requesting an accommodation. Notice to a supervisor is generally notice to the employer, even if the supervisor did not forward it. This element is met. Failure to accommodate: Clearwater did not engage in any discussion with Dana about the request or possible alternatives. The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (2002) guidance describes an informal, interactive process in which employer and employee identify the limitation and possible accommodations. Refusing without that process weakens the employer's position, because it leaves the company unable to show that no workable accommodation existed.
The Employer's Defense Argued Properly
The employer's best defense is argued at full strength, not dismissed. Clearwater can argue that on-site presence is an essential function of the job: representatives handle sensitive policyholder information, supervisors monitor calls live and step in on escalations, and the company's security policy restricts remote access for call center staff. If on-site work is essential, working from home would eliminate an essential function, which the Act does not require. Clearwater can also argue undue hardship: setting up secure home access for one representative would require new equipment and security review. Finally, Clearwater can argue that it applied its attendance policy consistently to all employees. The defense has weaknesses. Clearwater allowed some representatives to work from home during a building repair two years ago without reported security problems, which undercuts the claim that presence is essential. The cost of secure remote access for one employee is likely modest for a company of 260 employees. And the attendance policy does not override the duty to consider accommodation; absences caused by a disability that the employer refused to accommodate cannot simply be counted against the employee without first considering whether an accommodation, including leave, would have prevented them. A defense that the company waived when it was convenient is a defense that will not hold.
Alternatives the Employer Did Not Consider
Even if full remote work were not required, other accommodations might have met Dana's needs: a workstation in a quieter area of the floor, noise-canceling headsets, scheduled short breaks, or a temporary schedule with fewer consecutive days on the floor. The guidance makes clear the employer may choose among effective accommodations, but it must consider them.
A Conclusion a Manager Can Act On
Clearwater's position is weak. Dana likely has a disability, is qualified, and gave notice, and Clearwater did not engage in the interactive process before terminating her for absences related to her condition. The company should consult employment counsel promptly about reinstatement or settlement, and preserve the supervisor's notes and Dana's attendance records. For the future, the actions are these: every supervisor who receives a medical note or request tied to a health condition must forward it to human resources within one business day; human resources must meet with the employee within five business days to discuss the request and alternatives; and no termination based on attendance may proceed for an employee with a pending or recent accommodation request without human resources review.
Conclusion
The facts show a four-year employee with a documented anxiety disorder who requested partial remote work, received no interactive process, and was terminated for related absences. Coverage is clear, each element of the claim is likely met, and the employer's essential function and hardship defenses are weakened by its own past practice. The manager's actions are to seek counsel on this case and to route every accommodation request through human resources within set deadlines.
References
U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission. (2002). Enforcement guidance: Reasonable accommodation and undue hardship under the Americans with Disabilities Act. U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission.
HRM FPX 5065 Assessment 1 instructions, in plain terms
The first assessment in HRM FPX 5065 asks you to analyze an employment situation under the law that governs it. You set out the facts neutrally, identify the statute, such as the Americans with Disabilities Act, confirm that the employer and employee are covered, work through each legal element in order, present the employer's strongest defense fairly, consider options the parties overlooked and reach a conclusion with practical guidance. Case law helps where it settles a disputed element, and EEOC enforcement guidance is often the clearest source on accommodation. The analysis should be usable by an HR manager, not only by counsel.
How the HRM-FPX5065 Assessment 1 example is put together
The example runs the reasoning in the order a lawyer would. It opens with the facts, stripped to what matters and free of characterization. The applicable law section names the statute, establishes that the employer and the employee are both covered, and lists the elements that have to be satisfied. The application section is the body of the paper: one element per subsection, with the facts that support it, the facts that undercut it and a stated finding. Where the employer would raise a defense, business necessity, undue hardship, a legitimate non-discriminatory reason, that defense gets its own treatment rather than a dismissive sentence. A section on remedies and exposure follows, describing what the employer risks in practical terms. The conclusion states the position and the immediate action, and the analysis stays inside the statute the facts engage rather than surveying employment law generally.
Where the marks sit in the HRM FPX 5065 Assessment 1 scoring guide
Capella's criteria for this analysis cover the statement of facts, coverage, the elements, the defense, the alternatives and the conclusion. Facts reach Distinguished when separated from the labels each side attaches, such as "unreliable" or "discriminated against." Coverage scores higher when settled first, including employer size and whether the condition is a disability under the amended definition. Elements earn credit when taken one at a time, each with the facts that support or undercut it. The defense is judged on whether undue hardship is argued with evidence of cost and operational impact, not asserted. Alternatives the employer skipped, like a shift swap, show depth. The conclusion should tell a manager what to do next. Proficient analyses apply the statute; Distinguished ones make the manager's next step obvious.
HRM FPX 5065 Assessment 1 help from the desk
Employment law analyses often start with a conclusion and select only the facts that support it. Another weakness is skipping coverage and assuming the ADA applies, when the employer's size or the nature of the condition may be in question. Elements are blended into one paragraph, so it is unclear which are met. The employer's defense is dismissed rather than argued at its strongest. Alternatives are never explored, though the interactive process requires exploring them. The conclusion is a legal opinion with no practical guidance. Listing the elements as numbered headings, working each against the facts and closing with two or three concrete actions for the supervisor keeps the analysis rigorous and useful.
Get a HRM FPX 5065 Assessment 1 example written to your instructions
Send the Assessment 1 instructions and the scoring guide from your HRM FPX 5065 courseroom, along with the scenario you were given. We write a custom example against those criteria, with the statute identified and each element worked through the facts, returned in 24 to 48 hours. The first custom sample is free, and it sets the pattern for the rest of the course. The paper above is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Capella University document.
More HRM FPX 5065 papers and MS in Human Resource Management samples
- HRM FPX 5065 Assessment 2: Policy Analysis
- HRM FPX 5065 Assessment 3: Compliance Recommendation
- HRM FPX 5070 Assessment 1: Training Needs Assessment
- HRM FPX 5060 Assessment 1: Job Analysis
- HRM FPX 5075 Assessment 1: Stakeholder Influence Analysis
- HRM FPX 5055 Assessment 1: Job Evaluation Analysis
HRM FPX 5065 Assessment 1 questions, answered
How do I know which statute the scenario engages?
Start from what the employer did and to whom. Adverse action linked to race, sex, religion, color or national origin points to Title VII; age forty and over to the ADEA; disability, medical inquiry or accommodation to the ADA; leave for a serious health condition to the FMLA; pay, hours and classification to the FLSA. Where two statutes reach the same facts, address both.
Do I need to cite actual court cases?
Check your instructions, since some sections require case support and others accept statutory text with agency guidance. Where cases are expected, use reported decisions from a credible database rather than a summary blog, and use them to establish the test being applied rather than to prove your conclusion. Agency material from the enforcing body is citable and frequently more current.
Can I use a situation from my own workplace?
Only if your instructions allow it, and only with identifiers removed: no employee names, no case numbers, nothing about an ongoing matter. Describe the employer by size and sector and the people by role. Many sections supply a scenario precisely so this question does not arise, and where one is supplied you should use it rather than substituting your own.
Where can I find a free HRM FPX 5065 Assessment 1 sample paper?
The call center ADA case is analyzed in full on this page, with facts separated from characterization, coverage settled first, elements taken one at a time, the employer's defense argued and a conclusion a manager can use.
What is undue hardship in HRM FPX 5065 Assessment 1?
A significant difficulty or expense in providing an accommodation, judged against the employer's size, resources and operations. The employer must show it with evidence, not assume it.