| Course | HRM FPX 5080 Evidence-Based Decision Making for HR Professionals |
|---|---|
| Assessment | Assessment 2 |
| Paper type | Evidence review |
| Length | About 1,100 words, 6 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Capella University |
| Program | MS in Human Resource Management |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for HRM FPX 5080 Assessment 2
Do Realistic Job Previews Reduce Early Turnover Among Nursing Assistants? A Searchable Question, Search and Exclusions Described, Studies Weighed, Disagreement Left Visible, Practical Size, and Whether the Finding Travels
Student Name
Capella University
HRM FPX 5080: Evidence-Based Decision Making for HR Professionals
Instructor Name
Month Day, Year
A Question Written to Be Searched
Meridian Senior Living's turnover report found that 39.7% of certified nursing assistants hired in the last year left within 90 days. The chief operating officer asked whether giving candidates a realistic preview of the job before they accept an offer would help. The question is written so it can be searched: among newly hired nursing assistants or similar entry-level workers, does a realistic job preview delivered before hire, compared with standard recruiting information, reduce voluntary turnover within the first year? Population, intervention, comparison, and outcome are each stated, so the search can target them.
Search and Exclusions Described
The search covered PsycINFO, Business Source Complete, and CINAHL, using combinations of "realistic job preview," "job preview," "turnover," "retention," and "attrition," for publications in English from 1980 onward. Reference lists of the reviews found were also checked. Meta-analyses were prioritized because they combine many studies. Studies were excluded if they measured only attitudes without turnover, if the preview was delivered after hiring as part of orientation, or if they lacked a comparison group. Three meta-analyses formed the core of the evidence: Premack and Wanous (1985), Phillips (1998), and Earnest et al. (2011). Individual studies in health care settings were sought but few were found that met the criteria. A review that does not say how it searched cannot say what it might have missed.
Studies Weighed, Not Counted
The three meta-analyses are weighed by their design and relevance, not counted as three votes. Premack and Wanous (1985) combined experimental studies and found that realistic previews lowered new hires' initial expectations and were associated with higher job survival, with modest effects. Phillips (1998) combined a larger set of studies and found that realistic previews were associated with lower turnover and with some other outcomes, but that the effects were small on average. Earnest et al. (2011) used a meta-analytic path analysis and found that the effect of previews on turnover operates largely through new hires' perception that the organization was honest with them, rather than only through lowered expectations. The Earnest et al. review is given the most weight for Meridian's purpose because it is the most recent and because it explains how previews work, which helps design one.
Disagreement Left Visible on the Page
The reviews do not fully agree, and the disagreement is left visible rather than smoothed over. Premack and Wanous presented previews as a reliable way to improve survival, while Phillips described the average effects as small enough to question whether previews are worth the effort in every setting. The reviews also differ on why previews work: through lowered expectations and self-selection in the earlier view, or through perceived honesty in the later one. These differences matter for design. If honesty is the mechanism, a preview that feels like a sales pitch or a warning designed to screen people out may not work, while a candid, balanced account may.
Practical Size, Not Only Significance
Statistical significance says whether an effect is likely real; practical size says whether it matters. The average effects in the reviews are small. For Meridian, a small effect could still matter. Meridian hired 131 nursing assistants last year, and 52 left within 90 days. If a preview reduced early turnover by even 4 percentage points, from 39.7% to about 35.7%, about 5 fewer nursing assistants would leave early each year. At an estimated replacement cost of about 4,500 dollars each, covering recruiting, orientation, and agency shifts during the vacancy, that is about 22,500 dollars a year. A preview consisting of a 20-minute shadowing visit and a short video recorded by current nursing assistants would cost about 4,000 dollars to produce and about 40 dollars per candidate to run. A small effect on a large, costly problem can still be worth buying.
Whether the Finding Travels Here
Whether the findings apply to Meridian is a separate question. The meta-analyses pooled studies from a range of occupations and report few, if any, results specific to direct care work in senior living, so the average effect is only a starting estimate. Several features of Meridian's situation suggest previews could work at least as well: nursing assistant work involves physical demands, emotional strain, and night shifts that candidates often underestimate, which gives a preview something real to show. Other features cut the other way: many candidates have already worked as nursing assistants elsewhere and know the job, so a preview may tell them little. The finding about honesty travels well: candidates who feel misled by recruiting are likely to leave in any setting.
What a Preview Would Contain
Based on the evidence, a preview for Meridian would include a 20-minute shadowing visit on the shift the candidate would work, a short video in which current nursing assistants describe a typical shift, including the hard parts such as lifting, resident behaviors in memory care, and short staffing on some nights, and a plain statement of pay, schedule, and how shift assignments are made. It would be given before the offer, so candidates can decide with the information in hand.
Risks of a Preview
A preview could reduce the number of candidates who accept offers, which matters when Meridian already struggles to fill shifts. The reviews suggest that some candidates who withdraw after a preview would have left early anyway, but the trial should track acceptance rates as well as 90-day turnover so that any loss of hires is visible and can be weighed against the reduction in early departures.
Recommendation
The evidence supports a trial, not a full rollout. Meridian should add a candid preview, including a shadowing visit, at two communities with high early turnover, such as Communities C and E, for six months, keep standard recruiting at two comparable communities, and compare 90-day turnover. The preview should be balanced and honest in tone, in line with the Earnest et al. finding.
Conclusion
Three meta-analyses show that realistic job previews are associated with modestly lower turnover, with disagreement about the size of the effect and how it works. The effect is small on average but could save Meridian about 22,500 dollars a year at modest cost, and the findings may apply to nursing assistants with some uncertainty. A six-month comparison at four communities would test whether it works here.
References
Earnest, D. R., Allen, D. G., & Landis, R. S. (2011). Mechanisms linking realistic job previews with turnover: A meta-analytic path analysis. Personnel Psychology, 64(4), 865-897. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1744-6570.2011.01230.x
Phillips, J. M. (1998). Effects of realistic job previews on multiple organizational outcomes: A meta-analysis. Academy of Management Journal, 41(6), 673-690. https://doi.org/10.2307/256964
Premack, S. L., & Wanous, J. P. (1985). A meta-analysis of realistic job preview experiments. Journal of Applied Psychology, 70(4), 706-719. https://doi.org/10.1037/0021-9010.70.4.706
HRM FPX 5080 Assessment 2 instructions, in plain terms
Assessment 2 in HRM FPX 5080 has you review the research evidence on an HR practice that might address the problem from Assessment 1. You frame an answerable question, search databases and describe how, state what you included and excluded, appraise the quality of each study, synthesize what the studies show, including where they disagree, report the size of effects in practical terms, judge whether the findings apply to your organization and make a recommendation. The approach follows evidence-based management methods from the Center for Evidence-Based Management. Peer-reviewed studies and meta-analyses carry the most weight.
How this HRM FPX 5080 Assessment 2 example is built
The review runs question, sources, weighing, application. It opens by stating the practice question in a form that could be searched, and by naming who wants the answer and what decision hangs on it. The second section describes the evidence gathered: where the search ran, which kinds of source were accepted, and what was deliberately left out, so the reader can judge the coverage. The third is the weighing, and it takes most of the room: studies are compared on design, setting, sample and outcome measure, with conflicting results held side by side rather than averaged into a comfortable sentence. The fourth moves to this organization and asks whether the population, the sector and the conditions match closely enough for a finding to travel. The closing section states what the evidence supports, what it does not, and how much confidence the reader should carry away.
HRM FPX 5080 Assessment 2 scoring guide: what Distinguished looks like
The scoring guide weighs the question, the search, the appraisal, the synthesis, the effect size, the applicability and the recommendation. The question reaches Distinguished when specific enough to search, naming the practice, the group and the outcome. The search scores higher when databases, terms and exclusions are described. Appraisal earns credit when studies are weighed by design and quality. Synthesis is judged on whether disagreement is shown. Effect sizes should be translated into practical terms, such as fewer departures per hundred hires. Applicability should consider differences between the studied groups and nursing assistants. Distinguished reviews are transparent about what the evidence can and cannot support.
Common HRM FPX 5080 Assessment 2 mistakes, and how to avoid them
Evidence reviews often read like literature summaries, describing each study in turn without weighing them. Another weakness is a vague question, like "how to reduce turnover," which no search can answer. The search method is not described, so the reader cannot judge what was missed. All studies are treated as equal, regardless of design. Disagreement is smoothed over. Statistical significance is reported without effect size. The findings are applied without asking whether they fit this workforce. A table of studies with design, sample, finding and quality rating keeps the review transparent and supports the recommendation in Assessment 3.
Get a HRM FPX 5080 Assessment 2 example written to your instructions
Send the Assessment 2 instructions and the scoring guide from your HRM FPX 5080 courseroom, plus the practice question you were given or the one you framed. We produce a custom example to those criteria, with the studies weighed and the local fit tested, and return it within 24 to 48 hours. First one is free. The paper above is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Capella University document.
More HRM FPX 5080 papers and MS in Human Resource Management samples
- HRM FPX 5080 Assessment 1: Workforce Metrics Report
- HRM FPX 5080 Assessment 3: HR Analytics Recommendation
- HRM FPX 5090 Assessment 2: Engagement Strategy
- HRM FPX 5075 Assessment 2: Change Leadership Plan
- HRM FPX 5118 Assessment 2: Grievance Case Analysis
- HRM FPX 5070 Assessment 2: Learning Program Design
HRM FPX 5080 Assessment 2 questions, answered
How many sources does an evidence review need?
Check your instructions first, because many sections set a floor. Where the number is open, enough to show the state of the evidence on your question, which usually means several peer-reviewed studies plus whatever practitioner material you use with appropriate caution. Adding sources you never compare with anything raises the count without improving the criterion that matters.
Can practitioner sources be used at all?
Yes, with their weight stated. Industry surveys and professional association reports describe what organizations are doing, which is useful, but they rarely establish that a practice works. Use them for prevalence and context, use peer-reviewed research for effect, and say in the text which kind of claim each source is supporting. Silence about source type is what costs marks.
What if the research disagrees with itself?
Then you have a finding, and it belongs in the review. Explain the disagreement where you can, by setting, sector, measure or study design, and state which body of evidence you find stronger and why. A review that reports genuine conflict and reasons through it demonstrates more command than one reporting an unbroken consensus.
Where can I find a free HRM FPX 5080 Assessment 2 sample paper?
This page holds the full review on realistic job previews and early turnover, with a searchable question, the search described, studies weighed, disagreement visible, practical size and applicability judged.
What is a realistic job preview in HRM FPX 5080 Assessment 2?
Information given to candidates before hiring that shows both the good and hard parts of the job, such as a video of a shift. It helps candidates who would not fit to opt out early.