HRM FPX 5090 Assessment 3 Retention Program Evaluation example

Reviewed by Rupert Danvers, MBA Retaining and Engaging Employees for the Modern Workforce Capella University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This HRM FPX 5090 Assessment 3 sample paper is a retention program evaluation of the driver plan, fixing the baseline turnover figure before any claim of success is made. It completes Capella HRM FPX 5090, Retaining and Engaging Employees for the Modern Workforce, in the MS in Human Resource Management, catalog code HRM-FPX5090. The paper keeps activity apart from effect, shows where improvement happened and examines rival explanations honestly, including a freight downturn that reduced hiring elsewhere. It names a comparison unit, weighs cost against what was gained, checks for unintended effects and ends with a decision rather than a summary.

CourseHRM FPX 5090 Retaining and Engaging Employees for the Modern Workforce
AssessmentAssessment 3
Paper typeRetention program evaluation
LengthAbout 1,140 words, 6 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolCapella University
ProgramMS in Human Resource Management
UpdatedSeptember 2026

Free sample paper for HRM FPX 5090 Assessment 3

1

Evaluating a Driver Retention Plan: A Baseline Fixed Before Claims, Activity Kept Apart From Effect, Rival Explanations Examined, a Comparison Named, Cost Weighed Against Gain, and a Decision Rather Than a Summary

Student Name

Capella University

HRM FPX 5090: Retaining and Engaging Employees for the Modern Workforce

Instructor Name

Month Day, Year

What this part is doingThe title names the program and the evaluation's features. Retention evaluations are judged on whether they rule out other explanations, so rivals are named.
2

The Plan Being Evaluated

Clearpath Freight began a retention plan for regional drivers on January 1: fixed home-time schedules, lower driver manager ratios, scheduled check-ins for new drivers, assigned tractors for new drivers, and a revised recruiting message. The plan cost about 146,000 dollars over six months. This evaluation covers January through June.

Baseline Fixed Before Anything Is Claimed

The baseline was fixed in December, before the plan began, and is not revised to suit the results. For regional drivers, January through June of the prior year: average headcount 168; separations 88; six-month turnover 52%; separations within six months of hire 48. For local drivers, the same period: average headcount 208; separations 36; six-month turnover 17%.

Activity Kept Apart From Effect

Activity measures show whether the plan was carried out; effect measures show whether it changed turnover. They are reported separately so that activity is not mistaken for success. Activity: 92% of regional drivers were on a fixed home-time schedule by March; home-time changes averaged 0.8 per driver per month, down from 2.3; driver manager ratios reached 40 or below at six of seven terminals by April, with Gary reaching 42 in June; 86% of scheduled check-ins were completed; all new regional drivers received an assigned tractor. Effect: regional six-month turnover fell from 52% to 36%, with 60 separations on an average headcount of 167. Separations within six months of hire fell from 48 to 29. A plan can be fully carried out and still fail. Activity shows the first, only turnover can show the second.

What this part is doingImplementation measures are kept separate from outcome measures. Scorers reward evaluations that distinguish doing from achieving.
3

Where the Improvement Happened

The improvement was uneven. Terminals that reached the 40-driver ratio early, in February, saw regional turnover fall by more than a third. Gary, which reached 42 only in June, saw a smaller decline. Separations in the first six months fell most among drivers who stayed on a fixed home-time schedule; among the 8% who were not on a fixed schedule, early turnover was about the same as the baseline. These patterns are consistent with the plan working where it was carried out, though they do not prove it.

Rival Explanations Examined Honestly

Other explanations for the drop are examined honestly, because turnover can fall for reasons unrelated to the plan. First, the freight market: during the first half of the year, freight volumes softened and several competitors slowed hiring, which reduces drivers' alternatives and lowers turnover across the industry. Hom et al. (2017) note that labor market conditions strongly influence quit rates. Second, seasonal patterns: turnover may vary by season, although the baseline uses the same months to control for this. Third, regression: the prior year's regional turnover was unusually high, so some decline might have occurred anyway. Fourth, the revised recruiting message may have reduced early departures by itself, independent of the operational changes.

A Comparison Unit Named

To separate the plan's effect from the market, the evaluation uses local drivers as a comparison group. Local drivers were not part of the plan but faced the same labor market. Local six-month turnover fell from 17% to 14%, a relative decline of about 18%. Regional turnover fell from 52% to 36%, a relative decline of about 31%. The difference suggests that the market accounts for part of the regional decline, but that regional drivers improved more than the comparison group. A reasonable estimate is that the plan accounts for roughly 40% of the regional improvement, or about 6 to 7 percentage points of the 16-point drop, though local and regional drivers differ in ways that limit how well one group represents the other.

What this part is doingA comparison group is named and its limits are stated. Scorers reward evaluations that use a comparison to estimate the effect.
4

Cost Weighed Against What Was Gained

The plan cost about 146,000 dollars over six months. Regional separations fell by 28 compared with the baseline period. If only the portion attributed to the plan is counted, about 40%, that is about 11 fewer departures, worth about 82,500 dollars at 7,500 dollars each. If all 28 are counted, the value is about 210,000 dollars. On the conservative estimate, the plan has not yet paid for itself; on the full estimate, it has. The most expensive element, leasing four tractors for about 52,800 dollars over six months, has the weakest link to the results, since the turnover analysis found equipment a secondary cause. The honest answer is that the plan may or may not be paying for itself, depending on how much credit the market deserves.

Unintended Effects Checked

The evaluation also checked for unintended effects. On-time delivery for regional freight held steady at about 96%, so fixed home-time schedules did not visibly hurt service. Dispatch overtime rose slightly in January and February while schedules were set up, then returned to normal. Local drivers did not report resentment about regional drivers' new schedules in the June survey, though several asked for more predictable start times.

What Drivers Said

A short survey of 60 regional drivers in June found that 71% rated their home-time predictability as good or very good, compared with 34% in a similar survey the prior year. Drivers hired after January frequently mentioned the check-ins, with several saying they would have quit in the first month without being able to raise problems with their driver manager. Drivers said little about the assigned tractors. These comments support the quantitative results for home time and check-ins and fit the weak link for equipment.

A Decision, Not a Summary

The evaluation ends with a decision for the vice president of operations. Continue the home-time schedules, driver manager ratios, and check-ins, which cost little beyond the new driver managers and show the clearest link to results; the home-time change is the plan's core. Stop leasing the four additional tractors when the leases can be ended in September, and instead assign tractors from the existing fleet to new drivers where available. Complete the Gary hiring to reach the 40-driver ratio. Re-evaluate at 12 months, when a full year of data and a clearer view of the freight market will allow a better estimate of the plan's effect. If the freight market recovers and drivers' options widen, the 12-month result will be a stronger test, because the plan will then have to hold drivers against more competition.

What this part is doingThe evaluation ends with specific decisions. Scorers reward evaluations that lead to action.
5

Conclusion

Measured against a fixed baseline, regional driver turnover fell from 52% to 36% over six months, while activity measures show the plan was largely carried out. A softer freight market explains part of the drop, and comparison with local drivers suggests the plan accounts for roughly 40% of it. The plan should continue without the tractor leases and be re-evaluated at 12 months.

6

References

Hom, P. W., Lee, T. W., Shaw, J. D., & Hausknecht, J. P. (2017). One hundred years of employee turnover theory and research. Journal of Applied Psychology, 102(3), 530-545. https://doi.org/10.1037/apl0000103

What the HRM FPX 5090 Assessment 3 instructions ask for

The final assessment in HRM FPX 5090 asks you to evaluate whether the retention strategy worked. You state the baseline turnover from Assessment 1, separate what was done from what changed, measure results by group, consider other explanations such as market conditions or pay changes, compare with a unit that did not receive the program, weigh the cost of the program against savings from reduced turnover, check for side effects and recommend whether to continue, change or stop. Program evaluation methods and retention research support the evaluation, and the cost categories from Assessment 1 supply the savings side.

Inside the HRM FPX 5090 Assessment 3 example

The evaluation is built backwards from the claim it wants to make. It opens with the program, its objective as originally stated, and the claim now being tested. The second section fixes the baseline and the data sources, including what was not captured before the program started, which is usually where retention evaluations run into trouble. The third separates activity measures from outcome measures and reports both, so effort is never presented as effect. The fourth handles attribution: what else changed during the window, whether a comparison unit or period exists, and how much of the movement the program can honestly claim. The fifth weighs the cost against what was gained. The final section reaches a decision, continue, modify or discontinue, and states what evidence would have been needed for the option it did not choose.

HRM FPX 5090 Assessment 3 scoring guide: what Distinguished looks like

Marks go to the baseline, the separation of activity and effect, the rival explanations, the comparison, the cost-benefit analysis and the decision. The baseline reaches Distinguished when fixed before results are discussed. Activity and effect score higher when kept apart, since holding meetings is not the same as retaining drivers. Rival explanations earn credit when examined honestly, such as a rival carrier cutting its own hiring. The comparison is judged on whether a named unit is used, like a terminal that did not run the program. Cost should be weighed against savings in turnover cost categories. Unintended effects should be checked. Distinguished evaluations end in a clear decision with the evidence that supports it.

HRM FPX 5090 Assessment 3 help from the desk

Retention evaluations often report activity, like the number of stay interviews held, as if it proved success. Another weakness is comparing turnover before and after without asking what else changed. No comparison group is used, so any change could reflect the market rather than the program. Costs are counted but savings are not, or the reverse. Unintended effects, such as dispatchers burning out, are missed. The evaluation ends with a summary instead of a decision. Setting the baseline and comparison unit at the start, then showing results by tenure band alongside the rival explanations, keeps the evaluation honest and closes the course with a decision leaders can act on.

Get a HRM FPX 5090 Assessment 3 example written to your instructions

Send the Assessment 3 instructions and the scoring guide from your HRM FPX 5090 courseroom, along with the program and any results your section supplies. We write a custom example against those criteria, with baseline, comparison and attribution handled properly, and return it in 24 to 48 hours. The first one costs nothing. The paper above is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Capella University document.

More HRM FPX 5090 papers and MS in Human Resource Management samples

HRM FPX 5090 Assessment 3 questions, answered

What if the program has no baseline data?

Say so and work with what exists. Reconstructing an approximate before figure from payroll or headcount records, or using the equivalent period a year earlier, is defensible when you state the limitation. An evaluation that admits a weak baseline and reasons carefully around it scores better than one presenting a post-program figure as though it proved something.

How long should the evaluation window be?

Long enough for the outcome to move. Retention measured six weeks after a program starts shows almost nothing, because the people most likely to leave were already partway out. A window covering at least a full hiring and onboarding cycle is more defensible, and stating why you chose that window is part of what the design criterion reads for.

Can I evaluate a program that failed?

That is often the stronger paper. A program that did not move the measure gives you something to explain, and explaining it well, through design flaws, implementation gaps or a driver misread at diagnosis, shows more command than a success story with thin evidence. Recommending closure with reasons is a legitimate conclusion for this deliverable.

Where can I find a free HRM FPX 5090 Assessment 3 sample paper?

The complete evaluation of the driver retention plan is here, with a baseline fixed before claims, activity kept apart from effect, rival explanations examined, a comparison unit named and a decision.

Can I evaluate a program that failed in HRM FPX 5090 Assessment 3?

Yes. An honest evaluation of a program that did not work, with the reasons, is as valuable as one that did and often leads to a better next step.