HRM FPX 5120 Assessment 1 Country Comparison Analysis example

Reviewed by Rupert Danvers, MBA Global Human Resource Practice Capella University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This HRM FPX 5120 Assessment 1 sample paper sets out a country comparison analysis of how a company can dismiss an employee for poor performance in the United States, Mexico and Germany. It was written for Capella HRM FPX 5120, Global Human Resource Practice, an MS in Human Resource Management course with the catalog code HRM-FPX5120. The paper fixes one practice before comparing anything and chooses dimensions suited to it, such as notice, severance and works council involvement. It places every country on the same dimensions, sources each legal position, uses culture only where it explains something and ends with a modification to the company's process, priced.

CourseHRM FPX 5120 Global Human Resource Practice
AssessmentAssessment 1
Paper typeCountry comparison analysis
LengthAbout 1,130 words, 5 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolCapella University
ProgramMS in Human Resource Management
UpdatedSeptember 2026

Free sample paper for HRM FPX 5120 Assessment 1

1

Comparing Performance Dismissal in the United States, Mexico, and Germany: One Practice Fixed First, Dimensions Chosen for It, Every Country on the Same Dimensions, Law Sourced, Culture Used Where It Explains, and a Priced Modification

Student Name

Capella University

HRM FPX 5120: Global Human Resource Practice

Instructor Name

Month Day, Year

What this part is doingThe title names the practice, the countries, and the comparison's features. Global HR comparisons are judged on consistency and sourcing, so both are named.
2

One Practice Fixed Before Any Comparison

Ridgeway Valve, a composite US manufacturer of industrial valves, employs about 600 people in Toledo, Ohio; about 420 at a plant in Monterrey, Mexico; and 35 engineers and sales staff in an office in Stuttgart, Germany. The company wants a consistent approach to one practice: ending the employment of an employee whose performance remains below standard after a documented improvement effort. Discipline for misconduct, layoffs for economic reasons, and resignations are outside the comparison. Fixing the practice first keeps the comparison from drifting across different kinds of separation, which follow different rules in each country.

Dimensions Chosen for This Practice

Six dimensions are chosen because they determine how a performance dismissal works: the legal basis required to dismiss; required warnings or process; notice; severance or indemnity; third parties who must be involved; and cultural expectations about how performance problems are handled. Dimensions such as working hours or benefits are left out because they do not bear on this practice.

Every Country on the Same Dimensions

United States, Ohio. Legal basis: employment is at will, so no cause is required, subject to anti-discrimination and anti-retaliation laws and any contract. Warnings: none required by law, though documented warnings help defend against discrimination claims. Notice: none required for an individual dismissal. Severance: none required. Third parties: none, absent a union. Culture: direct feedback is generally expected. Mexico. Legal basis: the Federal Labor Law (Ley Federal del Trabajo) permits dismissal without liability only for listed causes in Article 47; poor performance alone is generally not a listed cause. A dismissal without a listed cause is unjustified. Warnings: documentation matters because the employer bears the burden of proving cause. Notice: the employer must give written notice of the dismissal and its cause. Indemnity: under Article 48, an unjustly dismissed worker may claim reinstatement or three months' pay plus back wages; Article 50 adds 20 days' pay per year of service in cases where reinstatement is excused; Article 162 provides a seniority premium of 12 days' pay per year, with the daily wage capped at twice the minimum wage. Third parties: a union at the plant may be involved under the collective agreement; settlements are often ratified before the labor authorities. Culture: see below. Germany. Legal basis: the Protection Against Dismissal Act (Kündigungsschutzgesetz) applies to employees with more than six months' service in establishments with more than 10 employees, and requires dismissal to be socially justified; a performance-related dismissal usually requires at least one prior formal warning (Abmahnung) and evidence of significant, continued underperformance. Notice: under the Civil Code, section 622, notice for employees rises with length of service, from four weeks up to seven months after 20 years. Severance: not generally required by statute, but settlements commonly include payments often estimated at around half a month's salary per year of service. Third parties: where a works council exists, it must be heard before every dismissal under section 102 of the Works Constitution Act, and a dismissal without that hearing is invalid. Stuttgart has a works council. In Ohio the question is whether the dismissal is discriminatory. In Stuttgart the question is whether it is justified at all.

What this part is doingAll six dimensions are applied to each country. Scorers reward comparisons that keep the same frame across countries.
3

Legal Position Sourced, Not Assumed

Each legal position above is tied to a named statute a reader can locate: Ohio's at-will doctrine, Mexico's Federal Labor Law Articles 47, 48, 50, and 162, and Germany's Protection Against Dismissal Act, Civil Code section 622, and Works Constitution Act section 102. Dowling et al. (2017) emphasize that multinational HR policies must be built on the actual legal requirements of each host country rather than on assumptions carried from the home country. Before any policy is adopted, local employment counsel in Monterrey and Stuttgart will confirm these positions.

Culture Used Where It Explains Something

Culture is used only where it explains a difference in practice, not as a general description. Hofstede et al. (2010) describe Mexico as scoring high on power distance and collectivism relative to the United States. At Monterrey, this helps explain why supervisors often avoid delivering direct negative feedback and why a performance problem may be handled informally through a senior worker or family connection before reaching HR. A performance improvement process imported from Ohio, relying on direct written feedback from the supervisor, may be delivered in a softened way that employees do not recognize as a warning. In Germany, culture adds less explanation than law; the formal process is driven by statute and the works council.

What this part is doingCulture is applied to a specific practice difference. Scorers reward papers that use culture to explain, not decorate.
4

What the Comparison Shows Side by Side

Read across the six dimensions, the three countries differ most on legal basis and third parties. Ohio requires no reason and involves no one outside the company. Mexico requires a listed cause or payment, and often involves the union and labor authorities in any settlement. Germany requires justification, a prior warning, and a works council hearing before notice can even be given. Notice and severance follow the same pattern, rising from none in Ohio to months of notice and a customary settlement in Germany. Only the need for documentation is shared across all three, which is why documentation becomes the backbone of the common process.

The Modification Named and Priced

The company's current practice is the Ohio model: a 60-day performance improvement plan, then dismissal without severance. Applied unchanged, it would produce unjustified dismissals in Mexico and invalid dismissals in Germany. The modification is a common performance improvement process with local legal steps built in. In Mexico, the process ends in a negotiated separation with the standard indemnity, and supervisors are trained to state the performance gap explicitly in a meeting witnessed by HR. In Germany, the process includes a formal written warning, a works council hearing before any dismissal, and a budgeted settlement. Estimated cost per dismissal: Ohio, about 2,000 dollars in HR time; Monterrey, for a five-year employee earning about 600 pesos a day, roughly 250 days' pay, or about 150,000 pesos, plus HR time; Stuttgart, for a five-year engineer earning about 6,000 euros a month, a two-month notice period plus a settlement of about 15,000 euros, plus works council and counsel time.

Conclusion

Performance dismissal is simple in Ohio, costly and cause-dependent in Mexico, and heavily regulated with works council involvement in Germany. Compared on the same six dimensions with sourced law, the Ohio model cannot be exported as is. A common process with local legal steps, priced per site, gives consistency where possible and compliance where required.

5

References

Dowling, P. J., Festing, M., & Engle, A. D. (2017). International human resource management (7th ed.). Cengage Learning.

Hofstede, G., Hofstede, G. J., & Minkov, M. (2010). Cultures and organizations: Software of the mind (3rd ed.). McGraw-Hill.

What the HRM FPX 5120 Assessment 1 instructions ask for

The first assessment in HRM FPX 5120 asks you to compare how one HR practice works across several countries. You select a practice, choose the dimensions that matter for it, describe each country on every dimension, source the legal requirements from statutes or reputable employment law guides, bring in cultural frameworks only where they explain a difference, summarize the comparison side by side and recommend how the organization should adjust its practice. Sources such as the ILO's employment protection database, country law firm guides and research on comparative HR support the analysis.

Inside the HRM FPX 5120 Assessment 1 example

The example organizes itself by dimension, not by country. It opens by naming the HR practice under examination and the business reason the organization wants it in more than one place. A short section justifies the dimensions, explaining why these particular obligations decide whether the practice survives the crossing. Each dimension then gets one section covering every country in the same order, with a source for each national position, because a reader has to be able to check what is claimed about an unfamiliar system. The next section reads the pattern: where the practice transfers intact, where it transfers with adjustments, and where it cannot operate as designed. The closing section states the modification each setting requires and the cost or delay attached. Nothing in the analysis treats the home country as the default that others deviate from.

Where the marks sit in the HRM FPX 5120 Assessment 1 scoring guide

Capella's grading here looks at which practice was picked, the dimensions, the consistency of comparison, the legal sourcing, the use of culture and the recommendation. The practice reaches Distinguished when fixed narrowly, such as dismissal for performance rather than employment law in general. Dimensions score higher when chosen because they matter for that practice. Consistency earns credit when every country is described on every dimension, so gaps are visible. Legal positions are judged on whether each is sourced rather than assumed, since at-will employment in the United States contrasts sharply with German protections. Culture should explain something specific, not decorate the paper. The recommendation should name a change and its cost. A Proficient comparison describes differences; a Distinguished one shows what the company must do about them.

HRM FPX 5120 Assessment 1 help from the desk

Country comparisons often describe each country in its own section with different topics, making real comparison impossible. Another weakness is choosing a broad topic, like "HR in Germany," that cannot be covered properly. Legal claims appear without sources and are sometimes out of date. Cultural dimensions are recited for every country whether or not they explain anything. The paper ends with general observations and no recommendation. Costs are not considered. Building a grid with countries as columns and dimensions as rows, filling every cell with a sourced fact, and then writing the analysis from the grid keeps the comparison even and leads naturally to the global strategy in Assessment 2.

Get a HRM FPX 5120 Assessment 1 example written to your instructions

Send the Assessment 1 instructions and the scoring guide from your HRM FPX 5120 courseroom, plus the countries and the practice your section set. We write a custom example to those criteria, with dimensions justified and both settings sourced equally, and return it in 24 to 48 hours. The first custom example carries no charge. The paper above is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Capella University document.

More HRM FPX 5120 papers and MS in Human Resource Management samples

HRM FPX 5120 Assessment 1 questions, answered

Which countries make this assessment easier to write?

Ones with accessible published employment information in a language you read. A common pairing is the United States with a European member state, because the contrast on notice, consultation and data protection is sharp and well documented. If your instructions name the countries, use those. Whatever you choose, confirm you can source the obligations rather than relying on general impressions.

How much cultural theory should the analysis carry?

Use it where it explains a practical difference, such as why direct performance feedback works differently in one setting. Cite it properly. What the criterion will not credit is a paper that scores two countries on a cultural framework and treats that as the whole analysis, because employment obligations decide whether a practice is lawful where you place it.

Do I need to cite the actual employment law?

You need to be accurate and sourced, which usually means citing a government labor ministry, a reputable international employment guide or scholarly comparative work rather than a consultancy blog. Describe the obligation and its effect on the practice rather than attempting a legal opinion, and treat the whole analysis as academic study rather than advice on any real placement.

Where can I find a free HRM FPX 5120 Assessment 1 sample paper?

The three-country comparison of performance dismissal is on this page, with one practice fixed first, dimensions chosen for it, every country on the same dimensions, law sourced and a priced modification.

Do I need to cite employment law in HRM FPX 5120 Assessment 1?

Yes. Legal requirements differ sharply across countries and change over time, so each claim should cite a statute, government source or reputable law firm guide.