| Course | HRM FPX 5960 HRM Capstone: Improving and Transforming HR Practice |
|---|---|
| Assessment | Assessment 2 |
| Paper type | Options and business case |
| Length | About 1,110 words, 6 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Capella University |
| Program | MS in Human Resource Management |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for HRM FPX 5960 Assessment 2
Causes and Options for Attendance Administration at a Plastics Manufacturer: Causes Worked Before Options, Criteria Fixed First, the Employment Constraint as a Criterion, Three Options Priced Equally, Doing Nothing Costed, and a Traceable Selection
Student Name
Capella University
HRM FPX 5960: HRM Capstone: Improving and Transforming HR Practice
Instructor Name
Month Day, Year
Where Stage 1 Left Off
Stage 1 found that Brightline Plastics' attendance point policy, which terminates hourly workers at 8 points in 12 months, is applied differently by eight supervisors. Over 12 months, 64 workers were terminated for points; 26 files lacked complete warnings; and 11 terminations included points on dates tied to protected leave or medical documentation. Attendance terminations cost about 269,000 dollars a year in replacement costs and contributed to overtime above budget.
Causes Worked Before Any Option Appears
Five causes were identified from interviews, records, and a walk-through of the systems, before any option was considered. Cause 1: points are entered by hand. The timekeeping system produces a report, but supervisors decide whether and when to enter points, so entry depends on each supervisor. Cause 2: leave records sit in a different system. Leave requests under the Family and Medical Leave Act are handled by a third-party administrator whose records do not reach the timekeeping system, so a supervisor looking at points cannot see protected leave. Cause 3: the policy has no category for protected absence. The handbook lists excused absences such as jury duty and bereavement, but does not mention leave under the Act or accommodation, so supervisors have no instruction. Cause 4: supervisors use discretion to keep workers they value. Five of eight said they excuse absences for reliable workers because the policy would otherwise terminate good employees for a few bad months. Cause 5: human resources lacks capacity. Two generalists support 480 workers and cannot review each warning or termination against leave records. Cause 2 explains the legal exposure. Cause 4 explains the unfairness. A fix that addresses only one will leave the other.
Criteria Fixed Before the Alternatives
Criteria were agreed with the plant managers and HR director before options were developed. Legal compliance: must prevent points on protected leave; pass or fail, no option that fails is considered further. Consistency: how fully the option removes supervisor-to-supervisor variation, weight 30%. Cost: one-time and annual, weight 25%. Supervisor time: added or saved hours, weight 15%. Worker perception of fairness: judged from survey comments and grievance themes, weight 15%. Effect on attendance turnover: weight 15%.
Employment Constraint as a Criterion
Employment law is treated as a criterion, not a note at the end. The Family and Medical Leave Act prohibits counting protected leave under a no-fault attendance policy, and the Americans with Disabilities Act may require leave as an accommodation (U.S. Department of Labor, Wage and Hour Division, 2023). Any option must ensure that absences linked to protected leave or a pending accommodation request are identified before points are assigned. Making this a pass-or-fail gate prevents a cheaper option from winning on points while leaving the core legal problem in place.
Three Options Priced at Equal Depth
Option A, integrate and automate: connect the leave administrator's data to the timekeeping system so protected absences are coded automatically; assign points automatically; require HR review before any written warning or termination; and add a documented "reliability reset" that removes 2 points after 90 days of perfect attendance, giving all workers what supervisors now give some. One-time cost: integration about 38,000 dollars, policy rewrite and counsel review about 6,000 dollars, supervisor training about 80 hours. Annual cost: 0.3 of an HR generalist, about 21,000 dollars. Supervisor time: saves about 1 hour a week each, or about 400 hours a year. Option B, train and audit: keep manual entry, add the protected leave category to the policy, train supervisors, and have HR audit a sample of point entries quarterly. One-time: policy and counsel about 6,000 dollars, training about 80 hours. Annual: about 12,000 dollars in HR audit time. Supervisor time: adds about 0.5 hours a week each to check leave status by phone with HR, about 200 hours a year. Option C, replace points with manager-led attendance conversations: remove points and require supervisors to discuss attendance patterns monthly with HR guidance. One-time: policy and counsel about 8,000 dollars, training about 160 hours. Annual: about 30,000 dollars in HR time. Supervisor time: adds about 1.5 hours a week each, about 600 hours a year.
Doing Nothing Costed as an Option
Doing nothing has costs. Replacement costs from attendance terminations: about 269,000 dollars a year. Legal exposure: if 11 terminations a year involve protected leave and even one in ten leads to a claim, with an average cost including defense of about 60,000 dollars, the expected cost is about 66,000 dollars a year. Overtime above budget: the plants ran 4 points above the 7% overtime budget; if attendance terminations account for a quarter of the excess, that is about 110,000 dollars a year. Total expected cost of doing nothing: about 445,000 dollars a year. Doing nothing also fails the legal compliance gate.
A Selection the Reader Can Trace
Option B fails the legal gate in practice: it relies on supervisors phoning HR, which the records show they do not do consistently. Options A and C pass. Scores out of 5, with weights: Option A, consistency 5, cost 4, supervisor time 5, fairness 4, turnover 4, weighted score 4.45. Option C, consistency 2, cost 3, supervisor time 1, fairness 4, turnover 3, weighted score 2.55. Option A is selected because it removes the causes directly: automation removes Cause 1, integration removes Cause 2, the rewrite removes Cause 3, the reliability reset turns Cause 4's informal discretion into a rule applied to everyone, and HR review addresses Cause 5 by focusing HR time where decisions are made. Its first-year cost of about 65,000 dollars plus staff time is small against the 445,000 dollars expected cost of doing nothing. Each cause maps to a feature of Option A, which is why it wins rather than because it scored highest.
What Option A Does Not Solve
Option A does not address why some workers accumulate points: shift schedules, childcare, and transportation. Those causes were outside this capstone's scope and are referred to the plant managers.
Conclusion
Five causes explain inconsistent attendance administration at Brightline. With legal compliance as a gate and weighted criteria fixed first, three options were priced equally and compared with doing nothing, which costs about 445,000 dollars a year. Option A, integrating leave data, automating points, adding HR review, and a reliability reset, is selected because each feature answers a cause.
References
U.S. Department of Labor, Wage and Hour Division. (2023). Fact sheet #28: The Family and Medical Leave Act. U.S. Department of Labor.
The Capella HRM FPX 5960 Assessment 2 instructions
Assessment 2 in HRM FPX 5960 has you identify why the problem found in the audit exists and build a business case for solving it. You analyze causes, set the criteria that any solution must meet, including legal constraints, develop at least three options, price each one including manager time, cost the option of doing nothing, compare the options against the criteria and select one with reasoning a reader can follow. The audit from Assessment 1 provides the baseline. Business case methods and HR research support the analysis.
Inside the HRM FPX 5960 Assessment 2 example
The example runs cause, then criteria, then options, then the decision, because each stage constrains the next. A short opening passage recalls the audited gap and the baseline attached to it. The cause section applies a recognized method and shows the reasoning behind each branch, ending by naming the cause the project will act on and why the rest are downstream of it. Criteria come next, each defined with a reason it belongs and a way it will be judged, covering money, manager hours, employment constraint, time to effect and fit with the work as performed. The options section presents the alternatives at matching depth, priced with assumptions visible, and keeps the status quo alive as a costed option. Comparison is applied evenly across all of them. The close states what the roadmap stage must now plan.
Reading the HRM FPX 5960 Assessment 2 scoring guide
The scoring guide weighs the cause analysis, the criteria, the options, the pricing, the treatment of the status quo and the selection. Causes reach Distinguished when worked before any option appears, for example tracing miscoded absences to a timekeeping system that lets supervisors override codes without a reason. Criteria score higher when fixed before the alternatives are described, and when they include the legal constraint, since any option that mishandles FMLA leave fails regardless of cost. Options earn credit when three are developed at equal depth, not one favorite and two straw men. Pricing is judged on whether supervisor and HR hours are included alongside software and training costs. Doing nothing should be costed in overtime, rework and legal exposure. The selection should be traceable from the scoring table. Distinguished business cases also say what the chosen option leaves unsolved, which builds credibility with leadership.
HRM FPX 5960 Assessment 2 help: mistakes that cost marks
Business cases often start with the favored solution and add two weaker options only to make it look good, which experienced leaders notice at once. Another weakness is skipping the cause analysis, so the options treat symptoms like late timecards instead of the reasons behind them. Criteria are written after the options have been compared, quietly shaping the result. Legal constraints appear as a footnote rather than a test every option must pass. Manager time is left out of costs, making labor-intensive options look cheap. The status quo is never priced, so every option looks expensive by comparison. The selection is announced without showing the scores. Building a table with the criteria as rows and the options as columns, completing it before choosing and adding a line for doing nothing, makes the selection transparent and hands Assessment 3 a recommendation it can implement.
Get a HRM FPX 5960 Assessment 2 example written to your instructions
Forward the instructions and the scoring guide from your courseroom, along with the audit you submitted at the first stage. Your custom HRM FPX 5960 Assessment 2 example is written to those criteria, with causes, priced options and a traceable selection built on your own problem, and it returns in 24 to 48 hours. First one, no charge. The paper above is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Capella University document.
More HRM FPX 5960 papers and MS in Human Resource Management samples
- HRM FPX 5960 Assessment 1: HR Practice Audit
- HRM FPX 5960 Assessment 3: Implementation Roadmap
- HRM FPX 5960 Assessment 4: Capstone HR Strategy
- HRM FPX 5002 Assessment 2: Strategic Alignment Brief
- HRM FPX 5403 Assessment 2: Organizational Development Plan
- HRM FPX 5055 Assessment 2: Compensation Plan
- HRM FPX 5402 Assessment 2: Sourcing Strategy
HRM FPX 5960 Assessment 2 questions, answered
How do I put a price on manager time?
Estimate the hours each option demands from supervisors, then apply published wage data for the role and region and show the arithmetic. Labeling the hours as an assumption is stronger than omitting them, because the reader can substitute their own figure. The example prices manager time separately from project cost, since that is the line a line manager will argue with first.
Does the status quo count as one of the options?
In most sections it should, and pricing it usually strengthens the case rather than weakening it. Continuing as things are carries overtime, vacancy duration, rework or exposure, and putting a figure on that is what makes any investment look proportionate. The example carries the status quo through every criterion at the same depth as the alternatives it competes with.
Can the recommendation differ from what the audit suggested?
Yes. A selection that moves away from the writer's first instinct usually reads as evidence that the criteria did real work rather than sitting on the page as decoration. The chain still has to hold, since the option carried forward must act on the cause named earlier and the roadmap then plans that option alone. Where a shift affects graded work, raise it with faculty.
Where can I find a free HRM FPX 5960 Assessment 2 sample paper?
This page contains the complete options analysis for attendance administration, with causes worked first, criteria fixed before the alternatives, three options priced equally, doing nothing costed and a traceable selection.
How do I price manager time in HRM FPX 5960 Assessment 2?
Multiply the hours each option asks of supervisors by their loaded hourly cost, including benefits. Time spent on administration is time not spent running the line.