| Course | MBA FPX 5002 MBA Leadership |
|---|---|
| Assessment | Assessment 3 |
| Paper type | Integrative leadership analysis |
| Length | About 1,080 words, 5 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Capella University |
| Program | MBA |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for MBA FPX 5002 Assessment 3
Leading Change Where There Is Resistance: Consolidating Three Customer Service Centers at a Regional Insurance Company
Student Name
Capella University
MBA FPX 5002: MBA Leadership
Instructor Name
Month Day, Year
Introduction
Change is easiest to lead when people want it. This paper examines a change that many people did not want: the consolidation of a regional insurance company's three customer service centers into a single center, which I led as director of customer operations. The consolidation affected 140 employees, closed two offices, and changed the jobs of nearly everyone who remained. The paper describes the situation, uses my earlier leadership self-assessment as a lens, reports where I was wrong, and draws on change literature to explain what happened.
The Situation and Its Resistance
The company decided to consolidate because call volumes had shifted to online and chat channels, leaving the three centers underused, and because running three sites meant three sets of managers, systems, and leases. Leadership expected the consolidation to reduce costs by about 2.4 million dollars a year and to improve service consistency. Employees saw it differently. Staff in the two closing offices faced a choice between relocating, commuting two hours, or leaving. Staff in the receiving office worried about their workload and about newcomers disrupting their teams. Resistance appeared as rising absenteeism in the closing offices, a petition to keep one office open, and quiet reluctance among receiving-office supervisors to train incoming staff.
The Earlier Work Used as a Lens
My earlier self-assessment described me as highly conscientious and task-focused, with lower scores in relationship management and in tolerating ambiguity. That profile shaped how I led the change. I built a detailed project plan, with timelines for lease exits, system migration, and staffing, and I tracked it closely. I spent far less time listening to employees' concerns than planning logistics. Looking at the change through my self-assessment shows that my strengths produced an efficient project and my weaknesses produced a lonely one: the plan ran on schedule while trust eroded.
Willing to Report It Was Wrong
I was wrong in three ways. First, I announced the consolidation by email before managers in the closing offices had been briefed, so employees heard it before their supervisors could answer questions. Second, I treated resistance as an obstacle to be managed rather than as information. The petition to keep one office open included a point I dismissed: many employees in that office were bilingual in Spanish and served a large share of the company's Spanish-speaking customers, and losing them would harm service for those customers. That turned out to be true. Third, I underestimated the burden on the receiving office, whose supervisors were asked to train newcomers without any reduction in their own targets.
Literature Explains What Happened
The change literature explains these errors. Kotter (2012) describes common reasons change efforts fail, including undercommunicating the vision and failing to build a guiding coalition. I communicated the decision but not a vision employees could see themselves in, and I did not involve supervisors early enough to form a coalition. Research on change recipients shows that reactions depend on how people perceive the change's fairness, their participation in it, and the support they receive, and that resistance is often a response to process as much as to content (Oreg et al., 2011). Employees who were informed by email, without participation or support, reacted predictably.
What Changed Midway
Midway through the consolidation, I changed course in three ways. I met with employees in each closing office in person, answered questions, and acknowledged the announcement's poor handling. I reversed the decision to eliminate all bilingual positions in the closing office by offering remote work to bilingual representatives who could not relocate, which retained 11 of 14. I reduced the receiving office supervisors' performance targets for three months to allow time for training, and I recognized their work publicly. These changes did not end the resistance, but they changed its character: complaints became questions, and several employees who had signed the petition volunteered to help plan the transition.
The Outcomes
The consolidation was completed two months later than planned. Annual cost savings were about 2.0 million dollars, less than projected, partly because of the remote bilingual positions. Service levels dropped for three months and then recovered to above their previous level. Voluntary turnover in the first year was 22%, compared with a typical 14%. Customer satisfaction among Spanish-speaking customers remained stable, which leadership attributed to retaining bilingual staff. The remote work arrangement, created as a concession, has since been extended to other roles and is now considered one of the consolidation's lasting benefits.
The Stakeholders I Overlooked
Beyond employees, I overlooked two stakeholder groups. The first was customers served disproportionately by the closing offices, including Spanish-speaking policyholders and small business clients who had long relationships with specific representatives. The second was the union representing some clerical staff, whose contract required consultation on relocation terms; the consultation happened, but late, which added to mistrust. A stakeholder map at the start would have identified both groups and the timing of their involvement.
What I Would Do Differently
If I led the change again, I would brief managers before any announcement and involve them in shaping the plan, treat the petition as a source of information from the start, and budget for the receiving office's training load. I would also measure employee sentiment regularly during the change, not only operational milestones.
Measuring the Human Side of Change
The project tracked lease exits, system migration dates, and service levels closely, but it had no measure of how employees were experiencing the change until turnover rose. A short monthly pulse survey in each office, asking whether employees understood the plan, felt their concerns were heard, and knew where to get help, would have signaled trouble earlier. I now treat such measures as part of any change plan, alongside operational milestones.
Implications for My Development
The experience confirms the development priorities from my self-assessment. I need to invest in relationship management and to treat listening as part of planning rather than a separate activity. I plan to lead the next change by forming a guiding coalition of supervisors from the start.
Conclusion
The consolidation met resistance that I partly caused through how the change was communicated and managed. Using my self-assessment as a lens, reporting my errors honestly, and drawing on change literature shows that resistance carried useful information and that the process of change mattered as much as its content.
References
Kotter, J. P. (2012). Leading change. Harvard Business Review Press.
Oreg, S., Vakola, M., & Armenakis, A. (2011). Change recipients' reactions to organizational change: A 60-year review of quantitative studies. The Journal of Applied Behavioral Science, 47(4), 461-524. https://doi.org/10.1177/0021886310396550
The Capella MBA FPX 5002 Assessment 3 instructions
The final assessment in MBA FPX 5002 asks you to analyze a real leadership situation using what you learned about yourself in the earlier assessments. You describe the situation and the resistance you faced, apply your self-assessment results and development goals to explain your actions, use leadership and change research to interpret what happened, report the outcomes honestly, identify stakeholders you missed and say what you would do differently. The analysis should integrate the earlier work rather than summarize it. Research on change leadership and resistance supports the analysis.
How the MBA-FPX5002 Assessment 3 example is put together
Situation, lens, test, revision. The opening establishes the leadership situation in enough depth for a reader to see what was at stake and who pushed back. A lens block applies what the self-assessment established, stating what it would predict about how the writer behaved. A test block compares that prediction with what happened, using evidence from the situation rather than recollection of intent. A literature block brings in scholarship where it explains the gap, which is where graduate criteria concentrate. A revision block updates the development plan, adding, dropping or reframing targets in light of the evidence. The closing states what the writer still does not know about their own leadership. Individuals stay unidentifiable throughout, and the register holds to analysis rather than sliding into reflection.
Reading the MBA FPX 5002 Assessment 3 scoring guide
Marks go to the description of the situation, the integration of earlier work, the honesty of the account, the use of literature, the reporting of outcomes and the lessons drawn. The description reaches Distinguished when the resistance is specific, such as senior agents refusing to transfer to a new site. Integration scores higher when the self-assessment and development plan explain particular actions in this situation, for example a preference for control that slowed delegation. Honesty earns credit when the writer reports being wrong and says how they knew. Literature is judged on whether it explains what happened, such as research on loss and identity in change, rather than decorating the paper. Outcomes should be reported as they were, including the ones that disappointed. Overlooked stakeholders should be named. Lessons should be specific enough to act on. Distinguished analyses show growth across the course.
MBA FPX 5002 Assessment 3 help from the desk
Integrative analyses often summarize the three assessments one after another instead of using them to explain a real situation. Another weakness is presenting the writer as having handled everything well, which reads as defensive and teaches nothing. Literature is cited in its own section without being connected to events. Outcomes are reported selectively, leaving out turnover or missed targets. Stakeholders who were missed, such as the union steward or the call center's biggest client, go unmentioned. Lessons are general, like "communicate more," with no link to what happened. Choosing one situation with real resistance and asking at each turning point what the self-assessment predicted and what actually happened gives the paper integration. Ending with two or three specific changes the writer will make gives it a strong finish.
Get a MBA FPX 5002 Assessment 3 example written to your instructions
Send the Assessment 3 instructions and the MBA FPX 5002 scoring guide from your courseroom, with the self-assessment and plan your earlier assessments produced. We write a custom example against those exact criteria and return it in 24 to 48 hours. The first custom sample is free, and testing the earlier work rather than restating it is what integration means here. The paper above is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Capella University document.
More MBA FPX 5002 papers and MBA samples
- MBA FPX 5002 Assessment 1: Leadership Self-Assessment
- MBA FPX 5002 Assessment 2: Development Plan Business Case
- MBA FPX 5006 Assessment 3: Strategy Implementation
- MBA FPX 5910 Assessment 3: Final Recommendation
- MBA FPX 5008 Assessment 3: Analytics Synthesis
- MBA FPX 5016 Assessment 3: Operations Synthesis
MBA FPX 5002 Assessment 3 questions, answered
What makes an analysis integrative rather than a summary?
The earlier work has to be used on something, not described. Take what the self-assessment claimed, apply it to a situation to make a prediction, and check the prediction. A paper that reports what the first two assessments said has recapped them, which the criteria score as the sequence stalling on its final step.
Can I write about a situation that went badly?
It is usually the better choice. A failure gives the lens something to explain and produces a genuine revision, while a success tends to confirm everything and revise nothing. Being specific about what you would do differently is worth considerably more than defending what happened.
How much literature does this need?
Enough that each source explains something the situation raised, which is usually fewer sources used better rather than more. Check your instructions for a number. What loses marks at this level is a citation attached to a claim that would have stood without it, since that reads as decoration rather than support.
Where can I find a free MBA FPX 5002 Assessment 3 sample paper?
The full analysis of leading the service center consolidation is here, with the earlier work used as a lens, a willingness to report being wrong, literature explaining what happened and the stakeholders overlooked.
Can I write about a situation that went badly in MBA FPX 5002 Assessment 3?
Yes. Situations that went badly often produce the most honest analysis and the clearest lessons, which the scoring guide rewards.