| Course | MBA FPX 5010 Accounting Methods for Leaders |
|---|---|
| Assessment | Assessment 2 |
| Paper type | Costing and budget decision |
| Length | About 1,120 words, 5 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Capella University |
| Program | MBA |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for MBA FPX 5010 Assessment 2
Letting the Question Shape the Costing: A Make-or-Buy Decision for a Machined Pump Housing
Student Name
Capella University
MBA FPX 5010: Accounting Methods for Leaders
Instructor Name
Month Day, Year
Introduction
Managers often ask what something costs, but the right answer depends on the decision being made. This paper examines a decision at a composite industrial pump manufacturer: whether to continue machining a cast-iron pump housing in-house or buy it from an outside supplier who has offered a price of 212 dollars per unit. The plant produces about 9,000 housings a year. The paper lets the decision shape the costing, counts only costs that change with the decision, tests fit with the budget separately, and states the answer in terms the operations manager can use.
The Question Shapes the Costing
The question is not what a housing costs in the accounting system; it is how the company's total costs will change if it stops making housings and buys them instead. Datar and Rajan (2021) describe relevant costs as expected future costs that differ among alternatives, and they caution that allocated fixed costs that will continue regardless of the decision are not relevant. The costing must therefore identify which costs would disappear, which would remain, and which would appear.
The Accounting System's Answer
The plant's standard cost system reports a full cost of 238 dollars per housing: direct materials 96 dollars, direct labor 44 dollars, variable overhead 22 dollars, and allocated fixed overhead 76 dollars. On this basis, buying at 212 dollars appears to save 26 dollars per unit, or 234,000 dollars a year. The accounting system's answer is misleading because it treats all 76 dollars of allocated fixed overhead as if it would disappear, which it will not.
Only What Changes Is Counted
The relevant costs of making are those that would be avoided by buying. Materials, labor, and variable overhead total 162 dollars per unit and would be avoided. Of the 76 dollars of fixed overhead, a review with the plant controller found that only 18 dollars would be avoided: the salary of a machining supervisor who would be reassigned rather than laid off (so not avoided), tooling costs specific to the housing (avoided, 11 dollars per unit), and maintenance on two machines that would be sold (avoided, 7 dollars per unit). The remaining 58 dollars cover plant depreciation, utilities, and management that would continue. Relevant cost of making: 162 plus 18, or 180 dollars per unit. Buying also adds costs the supplier price does not include: inbound freight of 6 dollars per unit, incoming inspection of 3 dollars per unit, and additional inventory carrying cost of about 4 dollars per unit because the supplier requires larger batches. Relevant cost of buying: 212 plus 13, or 225 dollars per unit.
| Cost per unit | Make | Buy |
|---|---|---|
| Materials, labor, variable overhead | 162 | 0 |
| Avoidable fixed overhead | 18 | 0 |
| Supplier price | 0 | 212 |
| Freight, inspection, carrying cost | 0 | 13 |
| Relevant cost | 180 | 225 |
On relevant costs, making is cheaper by 45 dollars per unit, or about 405,000 dollars a year.
Opportunity Cost of Capacity
The analysis must also ask what the freed machine capacity could do. If buying housings freed two machines that could instead produce a new impeller line with a contribution margin of 520,000 dollars a year, the opportunity cost of making housings would exceed the 405,000 dollar cost advantage, and buying would become the better choice. The plant manager confirmed that the new impeller line is planned but requires different machines, so the freed capacity has no immediate alternative use. Opportunity cost is therefore zero for now but should be revisited if plans change.
Budget Fit Tested Separately
Whether the decision fits the budget is a separate question from which option costs less. Continuing to make housings requires replacing one aging machine within 18 months, at a cost of about 350,000 dollars, which is not in the current capital budget. Buying avoids that capital expense. The comparison of relevant operating costs favors making, but the capital requirement must be weighed separately: at a savings of 405,000 dollars a year, the machine replacement pays back in under a year, which suggests it should be added to the capital budget.
What the Numbers Miss
The costing does not capture several factors that could matter as much as the 405,000 dollars. Quality control is one: in-house machining lets the plant hold the tight tolerances the housing needs to seal properly, and a supplier's defect rate is unknown until parts arrive. Supply risk is another: the supplier ships from overseas, and a delay of even a few weeks would stop pump assembly, which carries a cost far above the price of the housing. Flexibility is a third: engineering changes to the housing design are made two or three times a year, and in-house production can adopt them within days, while a supplier would need new tooling and a new price. Finally, the machinists who produce the housing hold skills the company will need for the impeller line, and losing them would make that line harder to start. None of these factors has a reliable dollar value, but all point in the same direction as the costing.
Sensitivity of the Answer
The conclusion depends on a few estimates, so each was tested. If volume fell from 9,000 to 6,000 housings a year, the avoidable fixed costs of 162,000 dollars would be spread over fewer units, and the advantage of making would fall to about 216,000 dollars a year, still in favor of making. If the supplier cut its price to 180 dollars, buying would cost 193 dollars per unit, still 13 dollars more than making. The price at which buying breaks even is about 167 dollars, 45 dollars below the current offer. Only the opportunity cost of capacity could reverse the answer, which is why it is flagged as the condition to revisit. A decision that holds across reasonable ranges of its inputs can be acted on with confidence; one that flips on a small change needs more work before the manager commits.
Stated in the Manager's Terms
For the operations manager, the answer is: keep making the housing. Buying would raise costs by about 405,000 dollars a year once freight, inspection, and inventory costs are included and fixed costs that will not disappear are excluded. Plan to replace the aging machine next year; it pays for itself in under a year. Revisit the decision if the impeller line needs this machining capacity.
Conclusion
Letting the decision shape the costing reverses the accounting system's answer. Counting only relevant costs, including the costs of buying, and testing budget fit separately shows that making the housing is cheaper and that the needed capital investment is justified.
References
Datar, S. M., & Rajan, M. V. (2021). Horngren's cost accounting: A managerial emphasis (17th ed.). Pearson.
MBA FPX 5010 Assessment 2 instructions, in plain terms
Assessment 2 in MBA FPX 5010 has you use cost information to make a business decision. You define the decision, show how the standard cost report would answer it, identify the relevant costs that differ between options, exclude costs that stay the same, include the opportunity cost of capacity, test whether the choice fits the budget, consider factors the numbers do not capture, such as quality and supplier reliability, check how sensitive the answer is to key assumptions and present the conclusion in plain terms. Managerial accounting texts on relevant costing support the analysis.
Inside the MBA FPX 5010 Assessment 2 example
Question, costs that change, budget fit, decision. The opening fixes the management question precisely, since the costing that follows takes its shape from it. The costing block then sets out what moves under each option and, just as importantly, what was left out and why, which is where the reasoning becomes visible. A budget block asks whether the preferred answer fits the resources this period actually has, and what would have to give if it does not. A decision block commits in terms a manager would use, naming the figure that settled it. A qualitative block covers what the numbers cannot reach. The closing states what would change the answer. Tables carry units and periods, and every figure carries a source or an assumption marker.
MBA FPX 5010 Assessment 2 scoring guide: what Distinguished looks like
The scoring guide weighs the framing, the relevant costs, the opportunity cost, the budget test, the qualitative factors and the sensitivity. Framing reaches Distinguished when the decision determines which costs matter. Relevant costs score higher when only changing costs are counted, with excluded ones named. Opportunity cost earns credit when the value of freed machine time is included. The budget test is judged on whether it is kept separate from the decision itself. Qualitative factors should be weighed. Sensitivity should show what would reverse the answer. Distinguished analyses explain why the accounting report gave the wrong answer.
MBA FPX 5010 Assessment 2 help from the desk
Costing decisions often use the full unit cost from the accounting system, including fixed overhead that will not change, which makes producing in-house look more expensive than it really is. Another weakness is forgetting the opportunity cost of capacity, so the analysis ignores what else the machines could be making. Budget constraints are mixed into the economic decision, and a good option is rejected because this year's budget is tight. Qualitative factors, such as the supplier's quality record, are listed without any weight. Sensitivity is skipped, so the reader cannot tell how close the decision is. The conclusion is written for accountants rather than for the plant manager who must decide. A two-column table showing only the costs that differ, followed by a line for opportunity cost and a sentence on what would change the answer, keeps the decision clear and prepares the synthesis in Assessment 3.
Get a MBA FPX 5010 Assessment 2 example written to your instructions
Send the Assessment 2 instructions and your MBA FPX 5010 scoring guide, along with the figures your version supplies. We write a custom example against those criteria and return it in 24 to 48 hours. The first custom sample is free, and letting the management question decide what belongs in the costing is the habit worth taking from it. The paper above is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Capella University document.
More MBA FPX 5010 papers and MBA samples
- MBA FPX 5010 Assessment 1: Statement Reading for Managers
- MBA FPX 5010 Assessment 3: Accounting Synthesis for Leaders
- MBA FPX 5012 Assessment 2: Positioning and Mix Defense
- MBA FPX 5008 Assessment 2: Costed Recommendation From Data
- MBA FPX 5014 Assessment 2: Evaluation of Capital Projects
- MBA FPX 5006 Assessment 2: Business Strategy
MBA FPX 5010 Assessment 2 questions, answered
Which costs belong in the analysis?
Only the ones that change because of the decision. A cost the business incurs either way tells you nothing about which option is better. Saying explicitly what you excluded and why is where most of the reasoning credit sits, because the exclusions are harder than the inclusions.
What if the right decision is unaffordable?
Say both things, since they are different findings. The option is correct on the analysis and cannot be funded this period, and what would have to move for it to become possible. That is a genuinely useful answer for a manager and a stronger paper than pretending the constraint does not exist.
How do I handle factors I cannot quantify?
Name them separately and say whether they change the recommendation. A long standing customer, an effect on staff, a reputational risk are all real considerations. What loses marks is either passing over them in silence or allowing them to quietly overturn arithmetic that was never put on the page. Both failures are common and both are visible.
Where can I find a free MBA FPX 5010 Assessment 2 sample paper?
This page presents the full make-or-buy decision on the pump housing, with the question shaping the costing, only changing costs counted, the opportunity cost of capacity and budget fit tested separately.
Which costs belong in MBA FPX 5010 Assessment 2?
Only costs that differ between the options. Fixed overhead that stays the same either way should be left out, even though the accounting system includes it in unit cost.