MBA FPX 5014 Assessment 2 Evaluation of Capital Projects example

Reviewed by Rupert Danvers, MBA Applied Managerial Finance Capella University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This MBA FPX 5014 Assessment 2 sample paper evaluates capital projects for a regional food distributor that must choose a portfolio under a six million dollar capital limit. It belongs to Capella MBA FPX 5014, Applied Managerial Finance, which Capella MBA students take as MBA-FPX5014. The paper lays out each project and its cash flows, ranks them under the real constraint and measures return per dollar of capital using the profitability index. It separates projects that cannot be compared, such as a required safety upgrade, recommends a portfolio rather than a single winner and covers the risks and what would reorder the ranking.

CourseMBA FPX 5014 Applied Managerial Finance
AssessmentAssessment 2
Paper typeCapital project evaluation
LengthAbout 1,130 words, 5 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolCapella University
ProgramMBA
UpdatedSeptember 2026

Free sample paper for MBA FPX 5014 Assessment 2

1

Evaluation of Capital Projects: Choosing a Portfolio Under a 6 Million Dollar Capital Limit at a Regional Food Distributor

Student Name

Capella University

MBA FPX 5014: Applied Managerial Finance

Instructor Name

Month Day, Year

What this part is doingThe title names the constraint along with the task. Capital budgeting is judged on how projects are chosen when money is limited, so the limit belongs in the title.
2

Introduction

A composite regional food distributor, here called Harbor Foods, supplies restaurants, schools, and independent grocers across three states. Its board has approved a capital budget of 6.0 million dollars for the coming year, and department heads have submitted six projects that together would cost 12.5 million dollars. The finance team was asked to recommend which projects to fund. This paper ranks the projects under the real constraint, measures return per unit of capital, separates projects that cannot be compared directly, recommends a portfolio, and identifies what would change the recommendation.

The Projects and Their Cash Flows

Each project was evaluated using after-tax incremental cash flows over its useful life, discounted at Harbor's weighted average cost of capital of 9%. The cash flow forecasts came from the sponsoring departments and were reviewed by finance for consistency in assumptions about volume growth, wage rates, and fuel prices.

ProjectCost (millions)NPV (millions)IRRProfitability index
A. Refrigerated warehouse expansion3.01.2016%1.40
B. Route optimization software0.60.4531%1.75
C. Diesel truck replacement (12 trucks)2.40.5012%1.21
D. Electric truck replacement (12 trucks)3.20.6211.5%1.19
E. Rooftop solar array1.50.3011%1.20
F. Warehouse pick-to-light automation1.80.9019%1.50

The profitability index divides a project's discounted inflows by what it costs up front. Every project has a positive net present value, so without a budget limit all of them except one of the truck options would be worth doing.

Ranked Under a Real Constraint

The 6.0 million dollar limit is real. The board set it to keep Harbor's debt within its loan covenants, and it cannot be raised this year without renegotiating those covenants. Brealey et al. (2020) explain that when capital is rationed, the goal is to choose the set of projects that produces the highest total net present value within the limit, not simply the projects with the highest individual returns. Graham and Harvey (2001) reported that NPV and IRR were the two methods the responding CFOs used most, each by roughly 75 percent of the sample, but a ranking by either measure alone can mislead when projects differ in size and money is limited.

Return per Unit of Capital

The profitability index measures net present value per dollar invested, which is the right starting point under a budget limit. Ranked this way, the discretionary projects fall in the order B (1.75), F (1.50), A (1.40), and E (1.20). Under a capital limit, a project that earns a moderate return on a small investment can be worth more to the firm than one with a higher total NPV that consumes most of the budget.

What this part is doingThe paper moves from total NPV to NPV per dollar because the question is how to spend a fixed sum. Scorers reward capital budgeting papers that match the ranking method to the constraint.
3

Non-Comparable Projects Separated

Two features of the list prevent a simple ranking. First, the truck projects C and D are mutually exclusive: Harbor needs to replace 12 trucks that have reached the end of their safe service life, and it will buy either diesel or electric trucks, not both. Second, truck replacement is not optional. The trucks must be replaced this year for safety and reliability, so one of the two options must be funded before any discretionary project is considered. The analysis therefore treats C and D as a required choice and ranks A, B, E, and F as discretionary projects competing for the remaining budget.

A Portfolio, Not a Winner

If Harbor chooses the diesel trucks (C, 2.4 million), 3.6 million dollars remains. Taking discretionary projects strictly in profitability index order funds B and F for 2.4 million, leaving 1.2 million unused because neither A nor E fits. That set produces a total NPV of 1.85 million dollars. However, funding A and B instead uses the full 3.6 million and produces a total NPV of 2.15 million dollars. The index ranking fails here because projects cannot be split; a partial warehouse expansion is not possible. Brealey et al. (2020) note this limitation of the profitability index when projects are indivisible, which is why the combinations must be compared directly.

PortfolioCapital used (millions)Total NPV (millions)
C + A + B6.02.15
C + B + F4.81.85
C + F + E5.71.70
D + B + F5.61.97

If Harbor chooses the electric trucks (D, 3.2 million), only 2.8 million remains, and the best discretionary set is B and F, for a total NPV of 1.97 million dollars. Although the electric trucks have the higher NPV on their own, their extra 0.8 million dollars of capital displaces the warehouse expansion, and the firm is worse off overall. The recommended portfolio is diesel truck replacement, the refrigerated warehouse expansion, and route optimization software, which uses the full 6.0 million dollars and produces a total NPV of 2.15 million dollars.

What this part is doingThe comparison table shows why the best set is not the set of best projects. Presenting the combinations openly lets the board see the trade-off rather than trusting a ranking.
4

Risks in the Recommended Portfolio

The warehouse expansion carries most of the portfolio's value, so its forecast deserves the closest scrutiny. Its cash flows assume that Harbor's frozen and chilled volume grows 6% a year, based on three new school district contracts signed this year. If growth were 3% instead, the expansion's NPV would fall to about 0.4 million dollars, and the portfolio C + B + F would become the better choice. Finance recommends that the board approve the expansion in two payments, with the second released only after the first half year's volume is confirmed.

What Would Reorder Them

Three changes would alter the recommendation. First, if the capital limit rose to 6.8 million dollars, the portfolio D + A + B would fit and produce a total NPV of 2.27 million dollars, making the electric trucks the better choice. Second, if a purchase incentive reduced the net cost of the electric trucks by about 0.8 million dollars, D would cost the same as C and have the higher NPV, so it would win at the current limit. Third, if Harbor's cost of capital rose to 11%, the NPVs of the solar array and both truck options would fall close to zero, while the software and warehouse projects would still add value. Naming the conditions that would reorder the projects tells the board what to watch rather than asking it to treat the ranking as permanent.

Conclusion

Under a real 6.0 million dollar limit, Harbor Foods should fund the diesel truck replacement, the refrigerated warehouse expansion, and the route optimization software. Separating the required truck decision from the discretionary projects and comparing combinations directly produces a higher total NPV than ranking by any single measure. The recommendation should be revisited if the budget, electric truck costs, or the cost of capital changes.

5

References

Brealey, R. A., Myers, S. C., & Allen, F. (2020). Principles of corporate finance (13th ed.). McGraw-Hill Education.

Graham, J. R., & Harvey, C. R. (2001). The theory and practice of corporate finance: Evidence from the field. Journal of Financial Economics, 60(2-3), 187-243. https://doi.org/10.1016/s0304-405x(01)00044-7

What the MBA FPX 5014 Assessment 2 instructions ask for

Assessment 2 in MBA FPX 5014 has you evaluate several capital projects when funds are limited. You estimate each project's cash flows, work out its present value, its rate of return and its profitability index, rank the projects under the capital limit, separate mandatory projects from optional ones, choose the combination that creates the most value within the budget, assess risks and explain what would change the ranking. Capital rationing means the highest net present value project is not always chosen, since smaller projects may create more value per dollar. Corporate finance texts support the evaluation.

How this MBA FPX 5014 Assessment 2 example is built

Projects, evaluation, constraint, ranking. The opening states the projects, the capital available and the period, since the constraint is what makes this an evaluation rather than a calculation. An evaluation block works each project with its cash flows and the firm's rate, showing the arithmetic. A comparability block separates projects that can be ranked on return from those justified on other grounds, such as compliance or capability. A ranking block orders the comparable ones by what they return per unit of capital consumed, which is the measure a constrained budget actually needs. A selection block commits to a portfolio that fits the budget and states what was excluded. The closing names what would change the ordering. Every flow carries its basis and the rate is the one the firm actually uses.

Where the marks sit in the MBA FPX 5014 Assessment 2 scoring guide

Capella's criteria here cover the cash flow estimates, the measures, the ranking, the treatment of mandatory projects, the portfolio and the risks. Cash flows reach Distinguished when estimated with stated assumptions. Measures score higher when computed accurately and used appropriately. The ranking earns credit when it respects the capital limit, using value per dollar. Mandatory projects are judged on whether they are funded first and kept out of the ranking. The portfolio should maximize total value within the limit. Risks should be named with what would reorder the projects, such as a fuel price shift that changes the fleet project's savings. Distinguished evaluations choose a portfolio, not a winner.

MBA FPX 5014 Assessment 2 help: mistakes that cost marks

Capital project papers often rank projects by net present value and fund from the top until money runs out, which can leave value on the table. Another weakness is mixing mandatory safety or compliance projects into the ranking. Cash flow assumptions are hidden. Internal rate of return is used to compare projects of very different sizes. Risks are listed without saying how they would change the choice. The recommendation names one project, ignoring that the budget can fund several smaller ones together. A table of projects with investment, net present value and profitability index, followed by the portfolio that fits the limit, makes the reasoning clear and prepares the shareholder value analysis in Assessment 3.

Get a MBA FPX 5014 Assessment 2 example written to your instructions

Send the Assessment 2 instructions and the scoring guide from your MBA FPX 5014 courseroom, plus the project data and budget your version supplies. We write a custom example against those exact criteria and return it in 24 to 48 hours. The first custom sample is free, and the ranking under constraint is what separates this from a foundations exercise. The paper above is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Capella University document.

More MBA FPX 5014 papers and MBA samples

MBA FPX 5014 Assessment 2 questions, answered

Why not just fund every project that clears the hurdle?

Because the money runs out, which is the situation every capital committee is actually in. Under a constraint the question stops being whether a project is acceptable and becomes whether it is the best use of the next dollar. That shift is the whole point of this assessment.

How do I rank projects of different sizes?

By what they return relative to the capital they consume, which stops a large mediocre project from crowding out two strong small ones. Show the calculation. Where the projects have different lives as well, say so, because comparing them over unequal horizons introduces a distortion of its own.

What about projects that are not optional?

Handle them separately and say why. A compliance investment is not competing on return; it is a condition of continuing to operate. Deducting those from the available budget before ranking the discretionary projects is the realistic approach and demonstrates you understood what the constraint actually is.

Where can I find a free MBA FPX 5014 Assessment 2 sample paper?

This page presents the food distributor's capital portfolio in full, with each project's cash flows, a ranking under the six million dollar limit, return per unit of capital and non-comparable projects separated.

How do I rank projects of different sizes in MBA FPX 5014 Assessment 2?

Use the profitability index, which divides present value by the investment. It shows value created per dollar and works well when capital is limited.