NURS FPX 6116 Assessment 3 Criteria and Rubric Development example

Reviewed by Odette Lachlan, MSN, RN Nursing Education Assessment and Evaluation Capella University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This NURS FPX 6116 Assessment 3 sample paper covers criteria and rubric development: an analytic rubric for student performance in a deteriorating-patient simulation. It comes from Capella NURS FPX 6116, Nursing Education Assessment and Evaluation, the MSN course with the catalog code NURS-FPX6116. The paper explains the rubric's purpose and context and the principles used to write it, then presents the rubric itself, with criteria written as observable behaviors and levels that differ in substance rather than in degree words. It tests the rubric on a borderline case, plans evaluator calibration, sets scoring and grading rules including safety criteria that cannot be offset, explains how the rubric is shared with students and discusses fairness and limitations.

CourseNURS FPX 6116 Nursing Education Assessment and Evaluation
AssessmentAssessment 3
Paper typeRubric development paper
LengthAbout 1,080 words, 5 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolCapella University
ProgramMSN
UpdatedSeptember 2026

Free sample paper for NURS FPX 6116 Assessment 3

1

Criteria and Rubric Development: An Analytic Rubric for Student Performance in a Deteriorating-Patient Simulation

Student Name

Capella University

NURS FPX 6116: Nursing Education Assessment and Evaluation

Instructor Name

Month Day, Year

What this part is doingThe title names the rubric type and what it evaluates. A rubric is judged on whether different evaluators would score the same performance the same way, so the performance is defined from the start.
2

Introduction

Rubrics make expectations visible and scoring consistent, but only if their criteria and levels are written well. This paper develops an analytic rubric for evaluating baccalaureate students' performance in a simulation in which a postoperative patient develops hypovolemic shock. It explains the purpose of the rubric, the principles used to write its criteria and levels, the rubric itself, how it was tested, and how evaluators will be calibrated.

Purpose and Context

The rubric will be used in the first medical-surgical course, where each student participates in the shock scenario as the primary nurse while two peers assist. The scenario is formative in the first half of the course and summative near the end. The rubric must therefore give useful feedback and support fair grading. It must also align with the course objective that students recognize and respond to clinical deterioration, which is one of the program's clinical judgment outcomes.

Principles Used

Four principles guided development. First, criteria describe observable behavior. A criterion such as "demonstrates critical thinking" cannot be observed; "states a concern about the patient's rising heart rate and falling blood pressure" can. Second, performance levels differ in substance, describing what the student does at each level, rather than relying on adjectives such as "good" and "excellent." Brookhart (2013) recommends that rubric levels describe the quality of performance in terms of the criteria, so that students can see what distinguishes one level from the next. Third, patient safety is assessed separately, as a pass or fail gate, rather than averaged with other criteria. Fourth, the rubric draws on an established model of clinical judgment in which noticing, interpreting, responding, and reflecting are distinct phases (Lasater, 2007).

The Rubric

CriterionBeginning (1)Developing (2)Accomplished (3)
Noticing: focused assessmentChecks vital signs only when promptedChecks vital signs and one related system without promptingAssesses vital signs, surgical site, output, and mental status within the first five minutes
Interpreting: recognizing the patternDescribes findings without linking themLinks two findings to possible bleedingStates that the pattern suggests hypovolemic shock and names the likely source
Responding: nursing actionsPerforms actions only when directedStarts oxygen or fluids but not both, or in the wrong orderPositions patient, starts oxygen, and requests fluid bolus and labs in an order that fits priorities
Responding: communicationCalls provider without a clear requestUses SBAR but omits a key finding or recommendationUses SBAR with all key findings and a specific recommendation
Reflecting: debriefingDescribes events onlyIdentifies one thing to do differentlyExplains reasoning at each decision point and identifies specific improvements

Safety gate, scored pass or fail: patient identification before interventions, allergy check before any medication, and hand hygiene. A failure on any safety item results in a remediation session regardless of the rubric score. Keeping safety outside the point total prevents the situation in which a student who gives a medication to the wrong patient still earns a passing score because the rest of the performance was strong.

What this part is doingEach level describes a different action, not a stronger adjective, and safety is scored separately. Scorers reward rubrics whose levels could be distinguished by an observer watching the simulation.
3

Testing on the Borderline Case

A rubric is most tested at the boundary between levels. Two faculty members independently scored a recorded performance from a previous term in which the student recognized deterioration but delayed calling the provider for eight minutes while repeating vital signs. One faculty member initially scored "responding: communication" at level 2 and the other at level 3, because the student eventually used SBAR completely. The disagreement revealed that the rubric did not address timeliness. The communication criterion was revised so that level 3 requires contacting the provider within three minutes of recognizing the pattern. After revision, both faculty members scored the same performance at level 2.

Evaluator Calibration

All faculty who will use the rubric will complete a calibration session before the term. They will independently score three recorded performances representing low, middle, and borderline levels, compare scores, and discuss differences until they agree on how the criteria apply. Calibration will be repeated at midterm with one new recording. Oermann and Gaberson (2021) note that rater training improves the consistency of performance evaluations, particularly for clinical and simulation assessments.

Scoring and Grading Rules

The rubric yields a score from 5 to 15. In the formative simulation, scores are used only for feedback. In the summative simulation, a score of 10 or higher with a pass on the safety gate is required to pass the simulation component of the course. A student who scores below 10 or fails the safety gate completes a remediation session with a faculty member and repeats the scenario within two weeks. Setting the passing threshold at 10 means that a student must reach at least the developing level on every criterion, or the accomplished level on some, which reflects the course's expectation that second-year students can recognize and begin to respond to deterioration without yet performing like experienced nurses.

What this part is doingThe scoring rules explain how the rubric becomes a grade and what happens when a student falls short. Scorers look for rubrics that are usable in practice, including for remediation.
4

Sharing the Rubric With Students

Students will receive the rubric before their first simulation, along with a recorded example of an accomplished performance and a short explanation of the safety gate. In the formative simulation, the debriefing will use the rubric to discuss each criterion so that students learn the language of the rubric before it is used for grading.

Fairness Considerations

A performance rubric can disadvantage some students if it rewards behaviors unrelated to competence. The communication criterion was reviewed to make sure it rewards clear, complete information rather than a particular speaking style or accent. Students who are nonnative English speakers may use SBAR effectively with simple sentences, and the level descriptors were written to reward completeness and a specific recommendation rather than fluency. Students with documented accommodations will receive them in the simulation as in other assessments, for example additional time for the debriefing reflection.

Limitations

The rubric focuses on one scenario and may need adaptation for other simulations. Its levels were tested on a small number of recordings. Its validity for predicting clinical performance is unknown and will be examined by comparing rubric scores with clinical evaluation ratings at the end of the course.

Conclusion

The analytic rubric for the shock simulation describes observable behaviors, uses levels that differ in substance, separates safety from the point total, and was improved by testing on a borderline case. Calibration and early sharing with students will support consistent scoring and learning.

5

References

Brookhart, S. M. (2013). How to create and use rubrics for formative assessment and grading. ASCD.

Lasater, K. (2007). Clinical judgment development: Using simulation to create an assessment rubric. Journal of Nursing Education, 46(11), 496-503. https://doi.org/10.3928/01484834-20071101-04

Oermann, M. H., & Gaberson, K. B. (2021). Evaluation and testing in nursing education (6th ed.). Springer Publishing.

The Capella NURS FPX 6116 Assessment 3 instructions

The instructions ask you to develop assessment criteria and a rubric for a learning activity in a nursing course, such as a simulation, clinical performance, paper or presentation. You explain the purpose and context, link criteria to course and program outcomes, write performance levels that evaluators can tell apart, address how safety-critical behaviors are scored, describe how the rubric will be tested and how evaluators will be calibrated, and discuss fairness and use with students. Most versions ask for the rubric as a table plus a paper explaining the design. Scholarly sources on rubric development and clinical evaluation support it. Testing the rubric on a real or described case, especially a borderline one, shows whether it works.

How the NURS-FPX6116 Assessment 3 example is put together

Purpose, competencies, criteria, levels, safety, testing, training. A purpose block states what the rubric assesses and where in the program. A competencies block ties criteria to the professional or program standards they serve. A criteria block writes each as observable behavior. A levels block describes performance at each point with substantive differences rather than degree words, so an evaluator can tell them apart. A safety block handles criteria where a single failure cannot be offset by strength elsewhere. A testing block reports applying the rubric to real or described cases, particularly borderline ones. A training block covers how evaluators would be calibrated. Space for narrative comment is included, because rubrics cannot capture everything that matters. Wording is tested by asking whether two readers would apply it identically.

NURS FPX 6116 Assessment 3 scoring guide: what Distinguished looks like

The scoring guide rates the rubric's alignment, the clarity of criteria, the performance levels, the handling of safety, the testing and calibration plan and the writing. Criteria reach Distinguished when each describes observable behavior. Levels score higher when they differ in substance, such as naming what the student did, rather than using words like adequate and excellent. The safety criterion rewards rules that prevent a critical failure from being offset by strengths elsewhere. Testing on a borderline case earns credit because it exposes ambiguity. Calibration of evaluators shows attention to reliability. Fairness and sharing the rubric with students round out the analysis. The margin notes explain each design choice.

NURS FPX 6116 Assessment 3 help from the desk

The frequent weakness is performance levels separated only by degree words, which two evaluators will apply differently. Another is criteria that describe traits, such as confidence, rather than behaviors. Students often forget safety, allowing a student who misses a critical action to pass on points. Rubrics are rarely tested before use; trying one on a borderline performance quickly shows where wording fails. Too many criteria make scoring slow and unreliable. Leave space for narrative comments. For a model rubric built for a different learning activity, the desk can draft one at no cost.

Get a NURS FPX 6116 Assessment 3 example written to your instructions

Send the Assessment 3 instructions and the scoring guide from your NURS FPX 6116 courseroom, plus the competency and setting your own rubric covers. We write a custom example against those exact criteria and return it in 24 to 48 hours. The first custom sample is free, and writing levels that differ substantively rather than by degree is what makes a rubric produce agreement. The paper above is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Capella University document.

More NURS FPX 6116 papers and MSN samples

NURS FPX 6116 Assessment 3 questions, answered

Why are degree words a problem in performance levels?

Because they describe the evaluator's confidence rather than the student's performance. Consistently, usually and sometimes give two assessors nothing to agree on, and the same student receives different scores from different preceptors. Write what actually differs: at one level the learner recognizes the change and reports it, at another they recognize it and act.

How should safety criteria be handled?

Separately, and without compensation. In a total score, a serious safety failure can be offset by strength elsewhere, which is not how clinical practice works. Mark those criteria as ones where a single failure determines the outcome regardless of other scores, and say what happens when one is triggered.

Do I need to test the rubric?

Testing it on the borderline student is the most informative thing you can do. Strong and weak performers sort themselves under almost any instrument; the marginal case is why rubrics exist. Apply the draft, see whether it produces a defensible result, and report what you changed as a consequence.

Where can I find a free NURS FPX 6116 Assessment 3 sample paper?

This page holds the full rubric development paper for the deteriorating-patient simulation, including the rubric, the borderline test, calibration, scoring rules and fairness. Request a free custom rubric for your activity.

Should NURS FPX 6116 Assessment 3 use an analytic or holistic rubric?

Analytic rubrics, which score each criterion separately, give more specific feedback and suit simulations and clinical performance. Holistic rubrics are faster but less diagnostic. Explain your choice in terms of the activity's purpose.