| Course | NURS FPX 8020 Doctoral Executive Leadership in Contemporary Nursing |
|---|---|
| Assessment | Assessment 1 |
| Paper type | Strategic plan appraisal |
| Length | About 1,080 words, 5 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Capella University |
| Program | DNP |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for NURS FPX 8020 Assessment 1
Strategic Plan Appraisal: Judging a Regional Health System's Five-Year Plan Against Criteria Set in Advance
Student Name
Capella University
NURS FPX 8020: Doctoral Executive Leadership in Contemporary Nursing
Instructor Name
Month Day, Year
Introduction
Strategic plans set direction for health systems, and doctoral nurse leaders are expected to read them critically. This paper appraises the five-year strategic plan of a four-hospital regional health system. The plan is quoted directly so that each judgment can be checked. The system's name and identifying details are withheld, figures are rounded, and the appraisal was shared with the system's chief nursing officer before submission.
The Plan, Quoted
The plan's vision statement, printed on the first page, reads: "To be the region's most trusted partner in health." It lists four pillars. Pillar one, "Exceptional Care": "We will deliver safe, high-quality care that ranks among the best in the nation." Pillar two, "People": "We will be the employer of choice for health care professionals." Pillar three, "Growth": "We will expand access across our region through new ambulatory sites and virtual care." Pillar four, "Stewardship": "We will achieve an operating margin of 3% by year five." Each pillar lists three to five initiatives.
Criteria Stated in Advance
The plan is appraised against five criteria stated before the appraisal. First, each goal has a measure, a baseline, and a target. Second, each goal has a named owner accountable for it. Third, each goal has a date. Fourth, the plan identifies the resources and assumptions on which goals depend, especially workforce. Fifth, nursing, the largest workforce and the discipline most involved in care delivery, appears in goals and governance in proportion to its role. These criteria draw on common elements of strategic planning in public and nonprofit organizations, which emphasize clear goals, accountability, and attention to the resources required (Bryson, 2018).
Measure, Owner, Date
Only one of the four pillars fully meets the first three criteria. Stewardship has a measure (operating margin), a target (3%), an implied owner (the chief financial officer), and a date (year five). Exceptional Care has a measure in its initiatives, "top decile in national quality rankings," but no baseline and no named owner. People has no measure; "employer of choice" is not defined, although one initiative mentions "reducing turnover." Growth lists new sites but no access measure, such as time to appointment or percentage of the region within 30 minutes of care. A plan in which only the financial goal is measurable signals, whatever its intentions, that the financial goal is the one that will be managed.
Where Nursing Appears
Nursing appears in the plan twice: in a People initiative to "develop a nurse residency program" and in an Exceptional Care initiative to "achieve Magnet designation at all hospitals." The chief nursing officer is not listed as an owner of any pillar. Nursing-sensitive quality measures, such as falls with injury or pressure injuries, are not mentioned. Given that nurses are the largest workforce and deliver most of the care that determines quality rankings, nursing is underrepresented in the plan's goals and governance.
Workforce Assumptions Tested
The plan's Growth pillar assumes that new ambulatory sites and virtual care can be staffed. The appraisal tested this assumption against the system's own data: registered nurse vacancy rates are 14%, first-year turnover is 24%, and the region's nursing schools graduate fewer nurses than the system hires each year. The plan does not state how the new sites will be staffed, whether through new hiring, redeployment, or different staffing models. Research on nurse staffing and patient outcomes suggests that expanding services without adequate nurse staffing risks worse outcomes (Aiken et al., 2002). Growth that depends on a workforce the system does not have is not a plan but a hope.
Governance and Accountability
The plan names an executive sponsor for each pillar but no accountable owner for each goal, and it does not describe how progress will be reported. A board dashboard with the measures, owners, and dates recommended below, reviewed quarterly, would make accountability visible. The plan also lacks a mechanism for revising goals when conditions change, such as a major payer change or a workforce crisis; a mid-plan review at year two and a half would allow deliberate revision rather than quiet abandonment of goals.
How the Plan Compares With Good Practice
Compared with strategic planning practice described in the literature, the plan does well at articulating vision and pillars and less well at translating them into operational goals. Bryson (2018) emphasizes that strategies must be connected to action plans with resources and responsibilities, and that stakeholder analysis should inform the plan. The plan document gives no evidence that frontline clinicians, including nurses, were consulted, which may explain why nursing-sensitive measures are missing.
Strengths of the Plan
The plan has strengths. Its vision is concise and patient-centered. Its stewardship goal is measurable, realistic, and clearly owned. Its commitment to a nurse residency program addresses first-year turnover. Its attention to virtual care reflects changes in how patients seek care, and its four pillars are few enough for staff to remember, which matters for a plan meant to guide daily decisions across four hospitals.
What Nurses Would Add
If nurses had helped shape the plan, several additions would likely follow. A goal aimed squarely at the harms nurses can prevent, for example injurious falls and pressure injuries acquired in hospital, would connect Exceptional Care to daily nursing work. A goal on nurse staffing adequacy, measured by the percentage of shifts staffed to plan, would link People to patient safety. And a goal on care transitions, measured by readmissions and follow-up within seven days, would give the Growth pillar a clinical purpose beyond new buildings. Each addition is measurable and each has an obvious owner in nursing leadership.
Recommendations
The appraisal recommends five revisions: add baselines, targets, owners, and dates to every goal; define "employer of choice" with measures such as turnover, vacancy, and engagement; add access measures to the Growth pillar; add nursing-sensitive quality measures to Exceptional Care; and include a workforce plan that tests the staffing assumptions behind Growth, owned jointly by the chief nursing officer and chief human resources officer.
Conclusion
The health system's strategic plan expresses a clear vision but meets the appraisal criteria only for its financial goal. Nursing is underrepresented, and the Growth pillar rests on workforce assumptions the system's own data do not support. The recommended revisions would make the plan measurable, accountable, and realistic.
References
Aiken, L. H., Clarke, S. P., Sloane, D. M., Sochalski, J., & Silber, J. H. (2002). Hospital nurse staffing and patient mortality, nurse burnout, and job dissatisfaction. JAMA, 288(16), 1987-1993. https://doi.org/10.1001/jama.288.16.1987
Bryson, J. M. (2018). Strategic planning for public and nonprofit organizations: A guide to strengthening and sustaining organizational achievement (5th ed.). Wiley.
Reading the NURS-FPX8020 Assessment 1 instructions
The first assessment in NURS FPX 8020 asks you to appraise an organization's strategic plan from a nursing executive perspective. You describe the plan, set criteria for a strong strategic plan based on the literature, evaluate each goal against them, examine how nursing is represented, test assumptions about workforce and resources, assess governance, identify strengths and gaps and recommend improvements. Many students use their own organization's public plan or a published plan from another system. Quoting the plan directly makes the appraisal verifiable. Scholarly and professional sources on strategic planning support the criteria. The appraisal should be fair, noting strengths as well as weaknesses.
Inside the NURS FPX 8020 Assessment 1 example
The appraisal is designed so that every judgment can be checked. It opens by describing the regional system and quoting its five-year plan's mission, pillars and goals in the plan's own words. The criteria come next, drawn from the strategic planning literature and stated before any judgment, so every judgment has a yardstick. Each goal is then tested for a measure, an owner and a date. A section asks where nursing appears in the plan, by name and by implication, and another tests the workforce assumptions the plan depends on, such as the supply of experienced nurses. Governance and accountability are examined, the plan is compared with good practice, strengths are acknowledged, and the paper closes with what nurses would add and specific recommendations.
Reading the NURS FPX 8020 Assessment 1 scoring guide
Six things carry the grade here: the plan description, the criteria, the goal tests, the nursing analysis, the assumptions and the recommendations. Criteria rise to Distinguished when drawn from the strategic planning literature and fixed before the plan is judged. Goal evaluation scores higher when every goal is checked for a measure, an owner and a date, with gaps listed plainly. The nursing analysis earns credit when it shows where nursing is present, absent or silently assumed, for example staffing goals written without nursing input. Testing workforce assumptions against labor data shows executive insight. Recommendations should be specific and tied to findings, and fairness, including strengths, adds credibility. The margin note beside the quoted plan explains why verbatim quotation makes each judgment checkable. Doctoral synthesis and correct APA form are expected throughout.
NURS FPX 8020 Assessment 1 help from the desk
Students often summarize the plan and add opinions, which is description rather than appraisal. Another common gap is criteria invented after reading the plan, so the verdict and the standard are shaped by each other. Goals are judged as good or bad without applying any test, such as whether a measure exists. Nursing's role is sometimes assumed rather than examined, even when the plan never mentions nurses. Workforce assumptions, such as filling hundreds of vacancies in a tight labor market, are rarely tested against data. Recommendations may be vague, such as involve nursing more, when the paper could name the goal and the change. Quote the plan accurately and cite it with its date. A model appraisal of another organization's plan can be drafted for you on request.
Get a NURS FPX 8020 Assessment 1 example written to your instructions
Send the Assessment 1 instructions and the scoring guide from your NURS FPX 8020 courseroom, plus the plan your own appraisal works from. We write a custom example against those exact criteria and return it in 24 to 48 hours. The first custom sample is free, and asking whether a nurse executive could act on the plan is what makes this an appraisal. The paper above is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Capella University document.
More NURS FPX 8020 papers and DNP samples
- NURS FPX 8020 Assessment 2: Strategic Plan Development
- NURS FPX 8020 Assessment 3: Quality Improvement Proposal
- NURS FPX 8022 Assessment 1: Using Data to Make Evidence-Based Technology Recommendations
- NURS FPX 8008 Assessment 1: When Correct Care Still Fails
- NURS FPX 8024 Assessment 1: Burden Profiled in Comparable Indicators
- NURS FPX 8006 Assessment 1: Searching for Evidence on a Clinical Question
NURS FPX 8020 Assessment 1 questions, answered
What should a strategic plan appraisal in NURS FPX 8020 include?
A real or realistic plan quoted directly, criteria stated before the appraisal, an assessment of each goal's measurability and accountability, and attention to nursing's role and workforce assumptions.
Can I appraise my own organization's plan?
Yes, if you have permission and can describe it without disclosing confidential information. Quote the parts you appraise so a reader can see what you are judging.
What makes a strategic goal strong?
A measure, a baseline and target, an owner, and a date. Goals without these may express values but cannot be managed.
Can I appraise my own organization's plan in NURS FPX 8020 Assessment 1?
Yes, if it is public or you have permission, and many students do. Quote it accurately, keep confidential details out, and apply the same criteria you would use for any other organization.
Where can I find a free NURS FPX 8020 Assessment 1 sample paper?
This page holds the full appraisal of a regional health system's five-year plan, with criteria, goal tests, nursing's place, workforce assumptions and recommendations. A free custom appraisal is available.