PSY FPX 6720 Assessment 1 Theory Comparison Paper example

Reviewed by Blythe Cavendish, PhD Psychology of Leadership Capella University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This PSY FPX 6720 Assessment 1 sample paper is a leadership theory comparison that sets leader-member exchange theory against situational leadership, asking whether good leadership is about relationships or about matching style to follower readiness. It was written for Capella PSY FPX 6720, Psychology of Leadership, an MS in Psychology course listed as PSY-FPX6720. The paper fixes its comparison questions in advance, lets scholarly evidence rather than popular books carry the claims and predicts one workplace situation both ways. It closes with what each theory explains well and where the research behind situational leadership is thinner than its popularity suggests.

CoursePSY FPX 6720 Psychology of Leadership
AssessmentAssessment 1
Paper typeLeadership theory comparison
LengthAbout 1,080 words, 5 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolCapella University
ProgramMS in Psychology
UpdatedSeptember 2026

Free sample paper for PSY FPX 6720 Assessment 1

1

Relationships or Readiness? A Leadership Theory Comparison of Leader-Member Exchange and Situational Leadership With Questions Fixed in Advance, Scholarly Evidence Carrying the Claims, One Situation Predicted Both Ways, and Each Theory's Sampling Stated

Student Name

Capella University

PSY FPX 6720: Psychology of Leadership

Instructor Name

Month Day, Year

What this part is doingThe title names the two theories and the method. Theory comparisons in this course are judged on common questions, so they are promised.
2

Comparison Questions Fixed in Advance

Five questions are asked of each theory, in this order: What is the unit of analysis? What is the mechanism by which leadership affects followers? What does the theory predict a leader should do? What evidence supports it? And on what samples does that evidence rest? Fixing the questions first keeps the comparison from following whichever theory is described first. The questions were chosen because they are the ones a practitioner deciding which theory to use would need answered: what the theory looks at, why it expects leadership to matter, what it tells a leader to do, how well it is supported, and for whom.

Leader-Member Exchange Theory

Unit of analysis: the relationship between a leader and each individual follower, the dyad. Leader-member exchange theory holds that leaders develop relationships of different quality with different followers, ranging from exchanges limited to the formal job to high-quality exchanges marked by trust, mutual support, and influence beyond the job description (Graen & Uhl-Bien, 1995). Mechanism: high-quality relationships give followers more information, support, and opportunity, and followers reciprocate with commitment and effort. Prescription: leaders should offer the opportunity for high-quality relationships to all followers rather than to a favored few, since differentiated relationships are otherwise formed early and tend to persist (Graen & Uhl-Bien, 1995). Evidence: Gerstner and Day (1997), in a meta-analysis, found that the quality of leader-member exchange was related to followers' performance ratings, satisfaction, organizational commitment, and role clarity, and negatively related to role conflict and intentions to leave. Dulebohn et al. (2012), in a larger meta-analysis of 247 studies, found that leader behaviors and perceptions explained the most variance in exchange quality among its antecedents, and confirmed relationships with a wide range of outcomes. Sampling: the evidence comes mostly from employees in organizations in North America, with growing samples from Asia and Europe; Dulebohn et al. (2012) found that power distance and individualism moderated some relationships. Most studies are cross-sectional and rely on follower reports of both relationship quality and outcomes. Gerstner and Day (1997) also noted that leaders and followers agree only moderately when each rates the quality of their relationship, which raises the question of whose view of the relationship the theory is about.

Situational Leadership Theory

Unit of analysis: the leader's style in relation to a follower's readiness, often called maturity, for a particular task. Situational leadership theory, developed by Hersey and Blanchard for management training, holds that the most effective leader style depends on the follower's competence and commitment for the task at hand. Mechanism: a leader who matches style to readiness provides the direction or support the follower needs, neither more nor less. Prescription: leaders should give highly directive guidance to followers with low readiness, shift toward coaching and supporting as readiness grows, and delegate to followers with high readiness. Evidence: the theory has been widely taught but less often tested. Vecchio (1987), studying teachers and their principals, found support for the theory's prescription mainly for employees low in readiness, who performed better and were more satisfied with more structuring leadership, but did not find the predicted pattern for employees with moderate or high readiness. Sampling: the most-cited tests, including Vecchio's, used relatively small samples in single occupations, and much of the theory's popularity rests on training use rather than on published research. The theory's model has also changed across versions, which makes it harder to test, since a study that fails to support one version can be answered by pointing to another. One theory has a large research base and a modest training footprint; the other has the reverse.

What this part is doingEach theory answers the same five questions in the same order. Scorers reward comparisons that are symmetrical.
3

One Situation, Several Predictions

Rosa, a composite new dispatcher at a county emergency communications center, has completed training and has been on the floor for three weeks. She is competent at routine calls but hesitant on complex multi-agency incidents. Her supervisor has seven dispatchers on her shift. Situational leadership predicts that the supervisor should be directive with Rosa on complex incidents, giving clear instructions and close supervision, while giving her more autonomy on routine calls where her readiness is higher. Its prediction concerns the style for each task. Leader-member exchange theory predicts that what matters most is the relationship the supervisor builds with Rosa in these early weeks. If the supervisor invests in her, offering information, support, and chances to handle challenging calls with backup, a high-quality exchange is likely to form, with benefits for her commitment and performance. If the supervisor instead invests mainly in the experienced dispatchers already close to her, Rosa may settle into a lower-quality exchange limited to the formal job, and leader-member exchange theory predicts lower commitment and a higher chance she will leave. The two predictions are compatible in part, since a supervisor can be directive on complex incidents while building a strong relationship, but they direct attention to different things: task-by-task style versus the relationship over time. They also differ in what counts as success. Situational leadership would judge the supervisor by whether Rosa's performance on complex incidents improves; leader-member exchange would also ask whether Rosa feels trusted, informed, and likely to stay, outcomes that matter in a center where training a dispatcher takes months.

What this part is doingBoth theories predict the same situation, and their predictions are compared. Scorers reward comparisons that make theories commit.
4

Which Explains More

On the evidence, leader-member exchange theory has the stronger research base, and its predictions about outcomes are well supported, though mostly by correlational data. Situational leadership offers intuitive and practical advice, especially for new employees, where Vecchio's findings gave it partial support, but its broader prescriptions have not held up well when tested. A practitioner can reasonably use situational leadership's advice to be more directive with new employees, which is its best-supported element, while relying on leader-member exchange for the longer-term question of how to build relationships that keep people.

Conclusion

Compared on the same questions, the theories differ in unit, mechanism, and evidence. Leader-member exchange focuses on relationships with individual followers and is supported by large meta-analyses, mostly of cross-sectional data from North American organizations. Situational leadership focuses on matching style to readiness and is supported mainly for inexperienced followers. For a new dispatcher, both have something to say, but the relationship built in her first weeks is the prediction with more evidence behind it.

5

References

Dulebohn, J. H., Bommer, W. H., Liden, R. C., Brouer, R. L., & Ferris, G. R. (2012). A meta-analysis of antecedents and consequences of leader-member exchange: Integrating the past with an eye toward the future. Journal of Management, 38(6), 1715-1759. https://doi.org/10.1177/0149206311415280

Gerstner, C. R., & Day, D. V. (1997). Meta-analytic review of leader-member exchange theory: Correlates and construct issues. Journal of Applied Psychology, 82(6), 827-844. https://doi.org/10.1037/0021-9010.82.6.827

Graen, G. B., & Uhl-Bien, M. (1995). Relationship-based approach to leadership: Development of leader-member exchange (LMX) theory of leadership over 25 years: Applying a multi-level multi-domain perspective. The Leadership Quarterly, 6(2), 219-247. https://doi.org/10.1016/1048-9843(95)90036-5

Vecchio, R. P. (1987). Situational leadership theory: An examination of a prescriptive theory. Journal of Applied Psychology, 72(3), 444-451. https://doi.org/10.1037/0021-9010.72.3.444

PSY FPX 6720 Assessment 1 instructions, in plain terms

The first assessment in PSY FPX 6720 asks you to compare two leadership theories. You choose the theories, set the questions you will compare them on before writing, such as what effective leadership consists of, how it develops and how it is measured, answer each question for both theories with research evidence, apply both to the same situation to show where they predict different actions and conclude with each theory's strengths and limits. Popular leadership books may illustrate but should not carry claims. Research by Graen and Uhl-Bien on leader-member exchange and reviews of situational leadership research, such as Thompson and Vecchio, support the paper.

Inside the PSY FPX 6720 Assessment 1 example

Four passes, and none of them is a theory tour. The first pass sets the terms of comparison, naming the questions every account will have to answer and justifying the choice of questions from what leadership research argues about. The second pass runs each theory through those questions in a fixed sequence, letting a reader read down one column instead of holding three summaries in mind. The third pass is the comparison proper, taking a situation, a turnaround, a crisis, a stable unit with a morale problem, and showing what each account predicts there and which prediction the evidence favors. The fourth pass states the boundaries: the conditions each theory was developed under, the populations its studies sampled, and the kinds of leadership it has never been tested against. A short close says which account the writer would reach for first and when.

Where the marks sit in the PSY FPX 6720 Assessment 1 scoring guide

Capella's grading here looks at the fixed comparison questions, the use of scholarly evidence, the prediction of one situation both ways and the balanced conclusion. Questions reach Distinguished when stated in advance and applied identically to both theories. Evidence scores higher when drawn from peer-reviewed research, including meta-analyses of leader-member exchange outcomes. The shared situation earns credit when both theories are used to predict what a leader should do, such as with a new hire who is eager but inexperienced. The conclusion is judged on whether it weighs strengths and limits fairly, noting that situational leadership has weaker empirical support. Accuracy in describing each theory is expected. Popular sources should be kept to illustration. A Proficient comparison describes both theories; a Distinguished one shows where they disagree and which evidence favors.

PSY FPX 6720 Assessment 1 help: mistakes that cost marks

A frequent failing is two separate portraits of the theories, each organized its own way, so nothing is actually compared. Another weakness is relying on popular leadership books, which describe theories favorably but offer little evidence. The theories are never applied to the same situation, so their different predictions stay hidden. The weaker evidence base of situational leadership is not mentioned. The conclusion names a favorite without reasons. Key constructs, like follower readiness, are defined loosely. Answering the same four questions for both theories side by side, then applying both to one case, keeps the comparison sharp and prepares the leader case analysis in Assessment 2.

Get a PSY FPX 6720 Assessment 1 example written to your instructions

Which theories your section names changes this paper more than the length does. Attach the Assessment 1 instructions and the scoring guide, and say which accounts your courseroom expects to see compared. A paper built to those documents and those theories typically arrives within 24-48h, with the first custom sample free of charge. The paper above is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Capella University document.

More PSY FPX 6720 papers and MS in Psychology samples

PSY FPX 6720 Assessment 1 questions, answered

Do I have to pick a best theory at the end?

A ranking by situation works better than a champion. Leadership research supports the position that different accounts explain different conditions, so a conclusion saying which framework you would reach for in a crisis and which in a stable unit shows more judgment than crowning one. The one ending the criteria reject is a close that finds merit everywhere and commits nowhere.

Are popular leadership books acceptable sources?

They can supply behavior and they cannot supply evidence. A well reported profile is a legitimate place to learn what a leader did in a particular week, and citing it for that is fine. The generalization about why the behavior worked has to come from research, because the trade author is arguing a case and the graduate criteria are scoring whether you noticed the difference.

Does this prepare me for the case analysis?

It supplies the frameworks and none of the discipline the case demands. Comparing theories is done at the level of general claims, while the case analysis has to hold one leader's documented actions against one account and explain the actions that do not fit. Read this example for how boundaries are stated, then let the leader's record decide the rest.

Where can I find a free PSY FPX 6720 Assessment 1 sample paper?

The leader-member exchange and situational leadership comparison is here in full, with questions fixed in advance, scholarly evidence carrying the claims and one situation predicted both ways.

Are popular leadership books acceptable in PSY FPX 6720 Assessment 1?

For illustration only. The claims about how well each theory works should rest on peer-reviewed research.