PSY FPX 6840 Assessment 2 Position Paper example

Reviewed by Blythe Cavendish, PhD Current Issues in Sport Psychology Capella University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This PSY FPX 6840 Assessment 2 sample paper is a position paper arguing that youth soccer players should not commit to year-round, single-sport training before age twelve. It belongs to Capella PSY FPX 6840, Current Issues in Sport Psychology, which MS in Psychology students take as PSY-FPX6840. The paper makes a claim narrow enough to refute, defining the age and what counts as year-round, and supports each sub-assertion, from overuse injury to burnout, one at a time. It gives the opposition real length, including the argument that early specialization builds elite skill, rebuts on the same terms the opposition uses and ends with a conclusion no stronger than the evidence allows.

CoursePSY FPX 6840 Current Issues in Sport Psychology
AssessmentAssessment 2
Paper typePosition paper
LengthAbout 1,100 words, 5 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolCapella University
ProgramMS in Psychology
UpdatedSeptember 2026

Free sample paper for PSY FPX 6840 Assessment 2

1

No Year-Round Commitment Before Twelve: A Position Paper on Youth Soccer With a Claim Narrow Enough to Refute, Sub-Assertions Supported One at a Time, the Opposition Given Real Length, Rebuttal on the Same Terms, and a Concession That Costs

Student Name

Capella University

PSY FPX 6840: Current Issues in Sport Psychology

Instructor Name

Month Day, Year

What this part is doingThe title states the position. Position papers in this course are judged on a refutable claim and a real concession, so both are promised.
2

The Claim

The claim is narrow on purpose: youth soccer clubs in the United States should not require players under 12 to participate year-round in soccer only as a condition of team membership. The claim does not say that children should never specialize, that older players should not train year-round, or that other sports should follow the same rule. It concerns a specific practice, required year-round commitment, at a specific age, in one sport. It could be refuted by evidence that early year-round soccer commitment improves long-term outcomes, such as reaching high levels of play or continued participation, without increasing injury or dropout. Framing the claim narrowly makes it both more defensible and more useful: a club can act on a rule about required commitment, while a general claim that specialization is bad would offer little guidance and invite easy counterexamples.

Sub-Assertion 1: Early Starts Are Not Necessary for High Achievement

The requirement is often justified by the belief that children who start serious training earlier reach higher levels. The sport meta-analysis by Macnamara et al. (2016) undercuts that belief twice over: the most skilled athletes in the pooled studies had not taken up their sport any sooner than the less skilled, and hours of deliberate practice, though they mattered somewhat across all levels, told almost nothing about who stood out among elite competitors. If early starts do not distinguish those who reach high levels, requiring year-round commitment at nine or ten cannot be justified as necessary for later success. The finding does not say practice is unimportant; it says that the timing of the start, which is what a year-round requirement at nine enforces, is not what separates those who excel.

Sub-Assertion 2: Specialization Is Associated With Injury

In the clinic-based comparison by Jayanthi et al. (2015), children and teenagers who had narrowed to one sport showed up more often among the injured, including the serious overuse cases, even with age and weekly sport hours held constant. The study is observational and cannot establish that specialization causes injury, but it shows a consistent association in children of the ages the claim concerns, and it points to a plausible mechanism, repetitive loading of the same tissues without variation. For a soccer player, year-round play means repeated sprinting, cutting, and kicking with the same leg patterns throughout the year, with no season in which different movements and rest give tissues a chance to adapt.

Sub-Assertion 3: Sampling Supports Continued Participation

The International Society of Sport Psychology's position stand, by Côté et al. (2009), concluded that for most sports, early diversification and deliberate play are associated with continued participation and do not hinder elite performance in sports where peak performance occurs after maturity, which includes soccer. This is expert judgment based on the evidence available in 2009 rather than new data, and it is used here as a summary of a research program, not as independent proof. Its postulates also emphasize deliberate play, informal games that children organize themselves, as a source of skill and enjoyment that year-round structured programs tend to crowd out. The strongest single finding is that high-level athletes did not start their sport earlier than others.

What this part is doingEach sub-assertion is supported separately with its evidence and its limits. Scorers reward positions built claim by claim.
3

The Opposition Given Real Length

The opposing position deserves a full statement. It holds that expertise is built through thousands of hours of deliberate practice, effortful and focused on improvement, as Ericsson et al. (1993) argued in their influential account of expert performance. On this view, a child who spends winter playing basketball and spring playing baseball accumulates fewer hours of soccer-specific practice than a child who plays soccer year-round, and in a sport where technical skill with the ball takes years to develop, that deficit may never be made up. The opposition also points to the realities of youth soccer in the United States: selection for competitive teams and development academies happens early, and a child who takes a season off may lose a place to a child who did not. Year-round programs, in this view, reflect what the sport demands, and clubs that require them are simply organizing the training their most committed players need. The opposition has real force. Soccer is a skill-intensive sport, practice matters for skill, and early selection is a fact of the current system. Parents who follow this reasoning are not being irrational; they are responding to the system their children must compete in.

Rebuttal on the Same Terms

The rebuttal uses the same kind of evidence the opposition relies on. The deliberate practice account is about accumulated practice, and Macnamara et al. (2016), testing it directly in sport, found that practice explained a modest share of performance differences and almost none among elite athletes, and that elite athletes did not start earlier. The practice hours a child loses by playing other sports before 12 appear not to predict later success in the way the opposition assumes. The point about early selection describes the system, not what is good for children; if early selection drives specialization that the evidence does not support, the selection system is part of the problem the claim addresses.

A Concession That Actually Costs

The position concedes something real. Under the current selection system, a talented 11-year-old whose club allows a season off may be passed over for an academy team by a child in a year-round program, and the family may experience that as a lost opportunity, even if the evidence suggests it will not matter for long-term development. The position also concedes that the evidence is not soccer-specific enough to rule out that soccer differs from other sports, and that no trial has tested required year-round commitment directly. If soccer-specific longitudinal evidence showed that year-round play before 12 predicted later success without greater injury or dropout, the position would have to be revised.

What this part is doingThe concession names a real cost to the position. Scorers reward concessions that are not free.
4

Conclusion

Clubs should not require year-round soccer-only participation before age 12, because high-level athletes do not typically start earlier, specialization is associated with injury, and expert consensus favors sampling for sports like soccer. The deliberate practice view and the realities of early selection are serious opposing considerations, but the evidence on practice in sport does not support the early commitment they imply. The position concedes a real short-term cost to some families and the limits of soccer-specific evidence.

5

References

Côté, J., Lidor, R., & Hackfort, D. (2009). ISSP position stand: To sample or to specialize? Seven postulates about youth sport activities that lead to continued participation and elite performance. International Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology, 7(1), 7-17. https://doi.org/10.1080/1612197X.2009.9671889

Ericsson, K. A., Krampe, R. T., & Tesch-Römer, C. (1993). The role of deliberate practice in the acquisition of expert performance. Psychological Review, 100(3), 363-406. https://doi.org/10.1037/0033-295X.100.3.363

Jayanthi, N. A., LaBella, C. R., Fischer, D., Pasulka, J., & Dugas, L. R. (2015). Sports-specialized intensive training and the risk of injury in young athletes: A clinical case-control study. American Journal of Sports Medicine, 43(4), 794-801. https://doi.org/10.1177/0363546514567298

Macnamara, B. N., Moreau, D., & Hambrick, D. Z. (2016). The relationship between deliberate practice and performance in sports: A meta-analysis. Perspectives on Psychological Science, 11(3), 333-350. https://doi.org/10.1177/1745691616635591

Reading the PSY-FPX6840 Assessment 2 instructions

Assessment 2 in PSY FPX 6840 has you take and defend a position on the issue surveyed in Assessment 1. You state a precise claim, break it into sub-assertions, support each with the strongest available evidence, present the opposing view at full strength, respond to it with evidence rather than dismissal and conclude at the strength your evidence supports. If the evidence will not carry the position you wanted, adjust the position. Research on specialization, injury and burnout, including the AMSSM statement and studies of athlete development pathways, supports the paper.

Inside the PSY FPX 6840 Assessment 2 example

The architecture is a defense, and it runs in five moves. The claim comes first, qualified to the point where a hostile reader knows exactly what would refute it. The second move breaks the claim into the sub-assertions it actually contains, since a position about youth sport or technology in training usually bundles three or four separate propositions that the research supports unevenly. The third move builds the affirmative case, one sub-assertion at a time, with the strength of each piece of evidence described rather than implied. The fourth move hands the argument to the other side and lets it run at length, sourced properly, and answers it on the same evidentiary terms rather than by changing the subject. The fifth concedes what the objection earned and restates the claim in its surviving form.

PSY FPX 6840 Assessment 2 scoring guide: what Distinguished looks like

Marks go to the precision of the claim, the support for each sub-assertion, the length and fairness given to the opposition, the quality of the rebuttal and the calibration of the conclusion. The claim reaches Distinguished when narrow enough to refute, naming soccer, age twelve and more than eight months a year in one sport. Sub-assertions score higher when each is supported separately, so injury evidence supports the injury claim and burnout evidence supports the burnout claim. The opposition earns credit when given real length and its strongest form, including research on deliberate practice. The rebuttal is judged on whether it answers the opposition's evidence with evidence. The conclusion should match what the studies can show. Qualifiers should remain. Distinguished papers argue honestly and could persuade a skeptic.

Common PSY FPX 6840 Assessment 2 mistakes, and how to avoid them

Position papers often make broad claims, like "early specialization is harmful," that no body of evidence could fully support. Another weakness is supporting the claim as a whole rather than each part, so strong injury data are used to prop up weaker burnout claims. The opposing view gets a sentence and is dismissed. Rebuttals rely on assertion rather than evidence. The conclusion overshoots, claiming certainty the studies do not provide. The writer refuses to narrow the position when the evidence is weak. Qualifiers from Assessment 1 disappear. Writing the claim in one sentence with its age and definition, then supporting each sub-assertion with one strong study, keeps the paper honest and prepares the practice argument in Assessment 3.

Get a PSY FPX 6840 Assessment 2 example written to your instructions

Position papers are only worth reading when the architecture is visible, and that shows best against your own criteria. Forward the Assessment 2 instructions and scoring guide, plus the claim you are considering, and a paper built to defend it typically arrives inside 24-48h. First custom sample at no charge. The paper above is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Capella University document.

More PSY FPX 6840 papers and MS in Psychology samples

PSY FPX 6840 Assessment 2 questions, answered

What if the evidence will not carry the position I want to argue?

Narrow the position until it will. A claim about specific outcomes at specific ages is usually defensible where the sweeping version is not, and the narrowing itself displays the judgment being scored. Writers who keep the broad claim and stretch the studies to fit produce exactly the overreach these criteria are built to catch, and the stretch is visible in the citations.

How long should the counterargument section be?

Long enough that someone holding that view would nod through it. There is no word count that guarantees this, but a useful test is whether a reader could reconstruct the opposing case from your paragraph alone. Sections in this course tend to weight that passage heavily, so cutting it to make room for more supporting evidence trades a scored criterion for an unscored one.

Can I change my position while writing the paper?

Change it and say nothing, or change it and say so; both are honest, and the second sometimes reads better. What matters is that the paper you submit argues the position the evidence supports rather than the one you started with. A thesis quietly abandoned in the middle, with the opening paragraph left in place, produces a document arguing against itself.

Where can I find a free PSY FPX 6840 Assessment 2 sample paper?

This page presents the youth soccer position paper, with a claim narrow enough to refute, sub-assertions supported one at a time, the opposition given real length and rebuttal on the same terms.

How long should the counterargument be in PSY FPX 6840 Assessment 2?

Long enough to present the opposing view at its strongest, often a full section, before you respond to it.