| Course | PSY FPX 7310 Biological Basis of Behavior |
|---|---|
| Assessment | Assessment 3 |
| Paper type | Evidence appraisal |
| Length | About 1,110 words, 5 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Capella University |
| Program | Doctoral psychology |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for PSY FPX 7310 Assessment 3
Does Aerobic Exercise Enlarge the Aging Hippocampus? An Evidence Appraisal With the Claim Rewritten to Be Testable, the Evidence Base Chosen Openly, Designs Read Before Conclusions, the Laboratory-to-Life Gap Examined, and a Verdict With Its Confidence
Student Name
Capella University
PSY FPX 7310: Biological Basis of Behavior
Instructor Name
Month Day, Year
The Claim Rewritten to Be Testable
The claim as it circulates in media is that exercise makes the brain grow. That version cannot be tested: it does not say which exercise, which part of the brain, in whom, or by how much. It also invites a vague kind of confirmation, since almost any study showing any brain difference in people who exercise can be cited in its support. Rewritten, the claim is: among adults aged 55 and older, a supervised aerobic exercise program lasting at least six months increases hippocampal volume, measured by structural brain imaging, compared with a non-aerobic control activity. Written this way, the claim fixes who is studied, what they do, what they are compared with, and how the brain change is measured, so that any study can be checked against it.
How the Evidence Base Was Chosen
The evidence base was chosen in two steps. First, the most cited randomized trial of aerobic exercise and hippocampal volume in older adults was identified, because its findings launched the popular claim. Second, a systematic review and meta-analysis of all controlled trials of aerobic exercise and hippocampal volume in humans was identified, because a single trial, however well designed, can overstate an effect. Observational studies comparing fit and unfit people were excluded, because they cannot separate the effect of exercise from other differences between people who exercise and people who do not. The choice is stated because it shapes the verdict: including observational studies would likely make the evidence look stronger, since fitter people tend to have larger hippocampi for many reasons, some of which have nothing to do with exercise itself.
Designs Read Before Conclusions
The landmark trial. Erickson et al. (2011) randomly assigned 120 older adults to a year of aerobic walking or to a control program of stretching and toning. Design features: randomized, with an active control that provided attention and social contact, a one-year intervention, and hippocampal volume measured by imaging before and after. Conclusion: the aerobic group's hippocampal volume increased by about 2%, while the control group's declined, a difference the authors described as reversing about one to two years of age-related loss. Increased volume was associated with improved spatial memory and higher levels of a growth factor in the blood. A single trial of 120 people, even a well-designed one, can produce an effect larger than the true average, and it measured memory with one type of task. Its design shows that exercise can change hippocampal volume under good conditions; it does not show how large the typical change is. The meta-analysis. Firth et al. (2018) identified 14 controlled trials with 737 participants. Design features: a systematic search, a random-effects meta-analysis, and separate analyses for the left and right hippocampus. Conclusion: aerobic exercise had no significant effect on total hippocampal volume across the trials, but had a significant positive effect on left hippocampal volume, and post-hoc analyses suggested that the effect came mainly from exercise preventing the decline in volume that occurs over time rather than from growth. The meta-analysis combined trials with different ages, durations, and imaging methods, which makes heterogeneity likely, and post-hoc analyses are more suggestive than planned ones; its finding is best read as a caution against the strongest version of the claim rather than as a precise estimate. The meta-analysis found no significant effect on total hippocampal volume; the effect it did find looked more like slowed shrinkage than growth.
The Laboratory-to-Life Gap Examined
Even where the evidence supports an effect, the conditions under which it was found differ from everyday life. The trials used supervised programs, often three days a week for 40 minutes or more, with staff monitoring intensity and attendance, for six months to a year. Participants volunteered, were screened for health conditions, and were likely more motivated than the average older adult. An older adult who walks occasionally, without supervision, or who stops after a few months, is not receiving the intervention that was tested. The evidence therefore speaks to what a sustained, structured program can do in willing participants, not to what casual exercise does in the general population. Structural change in the hippocampus is also not the outcome most older adults care about. They care about memory and independence, and the link from preserved volume to those outcomes in daily life has been studied far less than volume itself.
Reconciling the Two Sources
The trial and the meta-analysis are not in simple contradiction. The trial found both a gain in the exercise group and a decline in the control group, and the meta-analysis suggests that across trials the more consistent finding is the prevention of decline. The trial's 2% gain may be larger than typical, as the first well-known findings in a field often are. Both sources agree, however, on the direction of the effect in the left hippocampus and on the value of exercise relative to a non-aerobic control, which is the part of the claim with the firmest support. The difference between left and right hippocampus in the meta-analysis is not easily explained and may reflect chance or differences in measurement across studies.
A Verdict With Its Confidence Stated
The verdict on the rewritten claim is: partially supported, with moderate confidence. There is moderate-quality evidence from randomized trials that sustained, supervised aerobic exercise helps preserve hippocampal volume in older adults compared with non-aerobic activity, with the most consistent effect on the left hippocampus. There is weaker evidence that it increases total volume above baseline. The popular version, that exercise makes the brain grow, overstates the evidence. For a practitioner advising older adults, the verdict still supports recommending regular aerobic activity, which has well-established benefits for cardiovascular health, while describing its effects on the brain accurately as protection against loss rather than growth. Confidence would increase with larger trials using standardized imaging methods and longer follow-up, and with evidence that preserved volume translates into lasting benefits for memory in daily life.
Conclusion
Rewritten as a testable claim about supervised aerobic programs and hippocampal volume in older adults, the idea is partly supported: a landmark trial found a gain, but a meta-analysis of 14 trials found no significant effect on total volume and suggested exercise mainly slows age-related loss. The conditions of the trials differ from everyday exercise, and the verdict is held with moderate confidence.
References
Erickson, K. I., Voss, M. W., Prakash, R. S., Basak, C., Szabo, A., Chaddock, L., Kim, J. S., Heo, S., Alves, H., White, S. M., Wojcicki, T. R., Mailey, E., Vieira, V. J., Martin, S. A., Pence, B. D., Woods, J. A., McAuley, E., & Kramer, A. F. (2011). Exercise training increases size of hippocampus and improves memory. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 108(7), 3017-3022. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1015950108
Firth, J., Stubbs, B., Vancampfort, D., Schuch, F., Lagopoulos, J., Rosenbaum, S., & Ward, P. B. (2018). Effect of aerobic exercise on hippocampal volume in humans: A systematic review and meta-analysis. NeuroImage, 166, 230-238. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neuroimage.2017.11.007
Reading the PSY-FPX7310 Assessment 3 instructions
The final assessment in PSY FPX 7310 asks you to appraise the evidence behind a popular claim about biology and behavior. You restate the claim precisely enough to test, explain how you selected the studies you reviewed, evaluate the design and quality of each, consider whether laboratory or imaging findings translate to outcomes that matter in daily life and reach a verdict proportionate to the evidence. Concluding that the evidence does not support the claim is an acceptable result. Research such as Erickson and colleagues' 2011 trial, later randomized trials and meta-analyses of exercise and hippocampal volume supports the appraisal.
How the PSY-FPX7310 Assessment 3 example is put together
Five stages, and the first one decides the rest. The claim is restated in falsifiable form, since a psychological assertion loose enough to accommodate any result cannot be appraised at all. The second stage assembles the evidence base and says how it was assembled, which studies were included and on what basis, so the appraisal is not simply a convenience sample of what turned up first. The third stage evaluates the studies individually against their own designs, reporting what each can and cannot show. The fourth stage looks across them for convergence, contradiction and the patterns that suggest a literature has systematic problems rather than mixed results. The fifth delivers the verdict at a stated level of confidence and names the study that would move it.
PSY FPX 7310 Assessment 3 scoring guide: what Distinguished looks like
Credit goes to how testably the claim is framed, the openness of study selection, the reading of designs, the attention to the laboratory-to-life gap and the proportion of the verdict. A Distinguished appraisal rewrites the claim as something like one year of moderate aerobic exercise increasing hippocampal volume in adults over sixty compared with stretching. Selection scores higher when the search and inclusion rules are described openly. Designs earn credit when read before conclusions, noting sample size, control condition and whether imaging analysts were blinded. The gap is judged on whether the paper asks if small volume changes translate into better memory in daily life. The verdict should be proportionate to the evidence. Replications should be weighed. Distinguished appraisals are fair and precise.
PSY FPX 7310 Assessment 3 help from the desk
Evidence appraisals often accept a famous finding, repeated in popular articles, without checking whether it has replicated. Another weakness is leaving the claim vague, like "exercise is good for the brain," which no single study could test. Study selection is hidden, so readers cannot tell whether contrary studies were left out. Designs are not examined, so a small unblinded trial counts as much as a large, well-controlled one. The gap between brain measures and daily memory is ignored. The verdict overstates the case. Replication failures are dismissed. Listing the key studies with design, sample and result in a table keeps the appraisal honest and closes the course with careful scientific judgment.
Get a PSY FPX 7310 Assessment 3 example written to your instructions
This assessment turns on which claim you are appraising, and sections name very different ones. Send the Assessment 3 instructions, the scoring guide and the claim or literature you have been given, and an appraisal built against them is usually ready in 24-48h. The first custom sample costs nothing. The paper above is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Capella University document.
More PSY FPX 7310 papers and Doctoral psychology samples
- PSY FPX 7310 Assessment 1: Mechanism Explanation Paper
- PSY FPX 7310 Assessment 2: Brain-Behavior Integration Essay
- PSY FPX 7421 Assessment 3: Interaction Synthesis Paper
- PSY FPX 7610 Assessment 3: Test Selection Rationale
PSY FPX 7310 Assessment 3 questions, answered
Is it acceptable to conclude that the evidence does not support the claim?
It is often the strongest available conclusion, and doctoral criteria reward it when the appraisal earns it. What separates that verdict from mere skepticism is specificity: which designs fall short, on what point, and what a better-built study would need to demonstrate before the claim stands. A negative verdict without that detail reads as a preference rather than an appraisal.
How many studies should the appraisal cover?
Enough to represent the literature and few enough to read properly. Six studies whose methods you can describe in detail support a judgment; twenty cited from their abstracts support nothing, and the difference is obvious to a reader who knows the field. If your instructions set a number, meet it and choose the studies that most directly test the claim rather than the ones easiest to find.
Does an appraisal need statistical expertise I may not have?
Less than people fear, and more attention to design than to arithmetic. Most of the judgment in this assessment comes from asking who was measured, against what comparison, and whether the task really represents the behavior. Where effect sizes and power matter, report what the paper states and what its authors concede, and say plainly which questions you are not equipped to settle.
Where can I find a free PSY FPX 7310 Assessment 3 sample paper?
The complete exercise and hippocampus appraisal is here, with the claim rewritten to be testable, the evidence base chosen openly, designs read before conclusions and the laboratory-to-life gap examined.
Is it acceptable to conclude the evidence does not support the claim in PSY FPX 7310 Assessment 3?
Yes. A reasoned conclusion that the evidence is weaker than the popular claim is a valid and valuable result.