| Course | PSYC FPX 2320 Introduction to Counseling and Psychotherapy |
|---|---|
| Assessment | Assessment 2 |
| Paper type | Framework comparison paper |
| Length | About 1,160 words, 5 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Capella University |
| Program | BS in Psychology |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for PSYC FPX 2320 Assessment 2
Two Ways of Helping After a Divorce: A Framework Comparison Paper That Describes One Problem Without Diagnosing It, Defends Its Dimensions, Keeps Both Approaches in Every Section, States Each School in Its Own Terms, and Argues the Difference Without a Winner
Student Name
Capella University
PSYC FPX 2320: Introduction to Counseling and Psychotherapy
Instructor Name
Month Day, Year
One Problem, Described Not Diagnosed
The problem used for comparison is a composite: a 38-year-old man, eight months after a divorce he did not want, who describes feeling flat most days, has stopped seeing friends, sleeps poorly, and says he keeps telling himself he ruined everything and that he will end up alone. He continues to work but says he goes through the motions. The problem is described rather than diagnosed, because diagnosis is a clinical act that requires assessment by a licensed professional, and because the two approaches compared here think about problems differently: one works readily with diagnostic categories, and the other deliberately sets them aside. Describing the problem in terms of what the man says, feels, and does gives both approaches the same starting point.
Dimensions Chosen and Defended
Four dimensions are used for the comparison: the theory of the problem, the role of the therapist, what the approach expects to change, and the evidence for its effectiveness. These were chosen because together they cover why an approach thinks problems arise, what it does about them, and whether that works. Other dimensions, such as the history of each approach or its training requirements, were set aside because they say less about how each would meet this man. Each dimension is examined for both approaches in the same section, so that the comparison is made directly rather than left to the reader.
Both Approaches Inside Every Section: The Theory of the Problem
In cognitive therapy, the man's low mood is understood as maintained by biased interpretations of his situation. Beck et al. (1979) describe a negative view of the self, the world, and the future, visible here in thoughts such as I ruined everything and I will end up alone. These thoughts are treated as distortions that can be examined, and the divorce as an event whose meaning he has interpreted in a particularly harsh way. In person-centered therapy, the problem is understood differently. Rogers (1957) held that psychological distress arises from incongruence, a gap between a person's experience and their self-concept, often shaped by conditions of worth, the sense that one is acceptable only when meeting certain standards. On this view, the man's self-criticism may reflect a self-concept built on being a good husband, which the divorce has contradicted. The problem is not a set of distorted thoughts but a self that no longer fits his experience. The two theories also locate the problem in different places in time. Cognitive therapy focuses mainly on the present, on the thoughts the man is having now and the situations that trigger them, although it recognizes that underlying beliefs may have formed earlier. Person-centered therapy is also oriented to present experience, but it treats the conditions of worth that shaped his self-concept as the background that makes the present distress intelligible. Neither approach requires a detailed history, yet each would listen for different things in whatever history he offers.
Each School Stated in Its Own Terms: The Role of the Therapist
The role of the therapist is where the two schools most clearly speak different languages, and each is stated in its own. In cognitive therapy, the therapist is active and structured, setting an agenda with the client, asking questions that help him examine evidence for his thoughts, and assigning tasks between sessions, such as recording thoughts or scheduling contact with a friend. Beck et al. (1979) call this collaborative empiricism. In person-centered therapy, the therapist does not direct the session or examine the client's thoughts for errors. Rogers (1957) proposed that therapeutic change occurs when the therapist is congruent, or genuine, offers unconditional positive regard, and experiences accurate empathic understanding of the client's inner world, and when the client perceives these conditions. The therapist follows the man's lead and reflects back his experience, trusting that in such a relationship he will move toward a self-concept that fits his experience.
What Each Approach Expects to Change
In cognitive therapy, the target of change is the man's interpretations: if he can come to see the divorce as painful but not as proof that he is worthless, his mood is expected to lift. Changes in behavior, such as seeing friends again, are pursued partly to test his predictions about being alone. In person-centered therapy, the target of change is the man's relationship with his own experience. As he feels understood without judgment, he is expected to become more open to feelings he has avoided, such as grief or anger, and to revise his self-concept to include them. Changes in mood and behavior follow from that shift rather than being pursued directly. One approach asks whether the thought is accurate; the other asks what it is like to be the person thinking it.
The Evidence for Each
Both approaches have research support, measured in different ways. Cuijpers et al. (2013) found that cognitive behavioral therapy for adult depression had a moderate effect compared with control groups once publication bias was considered, and found that it did not clearly outperform or underperform the other psychotherapies it was compared with. For person-centered therapy, much of the research concerns the conditions Rogers described. Elliott et al. (2018) conducted a meta-analysis of therapist empathy and client outcome across 82 samples and more than 6,000 clients and found a correlation of about .28, indicating that empathy is a moderately strong predictor of outcome across many kinds of therapy, not only person-centered therapy.
Difference Argued Without a Winner
The difference between the approaches is argued without declaring a winner, because the evidence does not support one. Cognitive therapy offers structure, a clear rationale, and tasks that may suit a client who wants practical tools and a defined endpoint. Person-centered therapy offers a relationship in which the client leads, which may suit a client whose distress is bound up with feeling judged or who wants to understand his experience rather than change his thinking. The research reviewed suggests that the relationship matters in both approaches, and that cognitive behavioral therapy performs about as well as other established psychotherapies for depression. Which approach would help this man more would depend on his preferences, his response, and the judgment of a clinician, not on a general ranking.
Conclusion
Applied to one described problem, cognitive therapy and person-centered therapy differ in their theory of the problem, the therapist's role, and what they expect to change. Each has research support, and the evidence does not show either to be generally superior for depression. The comparison shows two coherent ways of understanding the same distress rather than a correct and an incorrect one.
References
Beck, A. T., Rush, A. J., Shaw, B. F., & Emery, G. (1979). Cognitive therapy of depression. Guilford Press.
Cuijpers, P., Berking, M., Andersson, G., Quigley, L., Kleiboer, A., & Dobson, K. S. (2013). A meta-analysis of cognitive-behavioural therapy for adult depression, alone and in comparison with other treatments. The Canadian Journal of Psychiatry, 58(7), 376-385. https://doi.org/10.1177/070674371305800702
Elliott, R., Bohart, A. C., Watson, J. C., & Murphy, D. (2018). Therapist empathy and client outcome: An updated meta-analysis. Psychotherapy, 55(4), 399-410. https://doi.org/10.1037/pst0000175
Rogers, C. R. (1957). The necessary and sufficient conditions of therapeutic personality change. Journal of Consulting Psychology, 21(2), 95-103. https://doi.org/10.1037/h0045357
The Capella PSYC FPX 2320 Assessment 2 instructions
Assessment 2 in PSYC FPX 2320 has you compare two counseling approaches applied to the same problem. You describe a common life problem without assigning a diagnosis, choose and justify dimensions for comparison, such as the view of the person, the role of the counselor and the goal of change, discuss both approaches on each dimension, use each approach's own vocabulary, identify the key difference and say what each would offer. The comparison should be fair to both, presenting each at its best. Rogers on person-centered therapy and Beck on cognitive therapy, along with comparative outcome research, support the paper.
Inside the PSYC FPX 2320 Assessment 2 example
The paper is built on dimensions, and the dimensions are justified before they are used. It opens with the problem stated in a neutral paragraph, described rather than diagnosed, followed by a short section explaining why the dimensions were selected, which most papers skip and the criteria notice. Each body section then holds both approaches against one dimension, keeping the same internal order and citing both sides. A section on the outcome evidence follows, reporting what studies say about both approaches for problems of this kind and acknowledging the common-factors finding where it applies. The synthesis states what the comparison actually established: where the approaches differ in ways that would change the work, and where the difference is more of vocabulary than of substance. A closing paragraph names what neither framework addresses about this problem.
Reading the PSYC FPX 2320 Assessment 2 scoring guide
Marks here go to a diagnosis-free account of the problem, the choice of dimensions, the balance between approaches, the use of each school's terms and the argument about the key difference. The problem reaches Distinguished when described without diagnosis. Dimensions score higher when justified. Balance earns credit when both approaches appear in every section. Terms are judged on whether each school is described in its own language, such as congruence and empathy for person-centered work. The key difference should be argued, not assumed, with evidence about what each approach would do in the first sessions. Outcome research should be used fairly. Distinguished comparisons respect both traditions.
Common PSYC FPX 2320 Assessment 2 mistakes, and how to avoid them
Comparison papers often describe one approach in detail and the other briefly, which makes the comparison lopsided. Another weakness is diagnosing the person, which is beyond the scope of the course. Dimensions are chosen without explanation, so the reader cannot tell why these and not others. One school is described in the other's terms, distorting it. The key difference is stated as preference. Outcome research is used to declare a winner. Building a table with the dimensions as rows and both approaches as columns, then writing each section from the table, keeps the comparison balanced and prepares the vignette analysis in Assessment 3.
Get a PSYC FPX 2320 Assessment 2 example written to your instructions
Send the Assessment 2 instructions and scoring guide from your PSYC FPX 2320 courseroom, with the two approaches and the case description your section uses. The example is written to those criteria, dimensions matched on both sides, and returns inside 24-48h. A first custom sample costs you nothing. The paper above is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Capella University document.
More PSYC FPX 2320 papers and BS in Psychology samples
- PSYC FPX 2320 Assessment 1: Approach Overview Essay
- PSYC FPX 2320 Assessment 3: Case Vignette Analysis
- PSYC FPX 2520 Assessment 2: Persuasive Message Analysis
- PSYC FPX 2240 Assessment 2: Motivation at Work Paper
- PSYC FPX 2600 Assessment 2: Developmental Case Reading
- PSYC FPX 2210 Assessment 2: Popular Claim Evaluation
PSYC FPX 2320 Assessment 2 questions, answered
Which two approaches produce the sharpest comparison?
Pairs that genuinely disagree about the mechanism of change. Cognitive-behavioral work against psychodynamic work, or humanistic against behavioral, gives you real conflict to argue. Two approaches with similar assumptions leave the paper straining to find differences, and the criteria reward argued distinction rather than manufactured contrast. If your instructions name the pair, keep it, whatever its degree of difficulty.
Do I have to conclude that one approach is better?
The comparison has to conclude something, which is different from declaring a winner. Say which approach the evidence favors for this kind of problem, if it favors either, and say where the two would produce genuinely different work. The outcome literature backs psychotherapy in general while leaving the ranking of major schools unsettled, and a conclusion that reflects that reads as informed rather than evasive.
Can the two approaches be compared on a real client I know?
No. Case material for this assessment comes from the vignette your section supplies or from published, de-identified examples, never from someone in your life. Beyond the ethics, a real person's situation invites diagnosis and advice, and both are outside what the criteria ask for. Composite or illustrative material keeps the paper analytical, which is where the marks are.
Where can I find a free PSYC FPX 2320 Assessment 2 sample paper?
This page contains the full comparison of two ways of helping after a divorce, with the problem described without diagnosis, defended dimensions, both approaches in every section and each school stated in its own terms.
Do I have to conclude one approach is better in PSYC FPX 2320 Assessment 2?
No. You can argue where the key difference lies and what each offers. Research often finds similar outcomes across approaches.