PSYC FPX 3130 Assessment 3 Policy Position Essay example

Reviewed by Blythe Cavendish, PhD Criminal Psychology and Behavior Capella University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This PSYC FPX 3130 Assessment 3 sample paper is a policy position essay on whether a state should fund multisystemic therapy for serious juvenile offenders. It completes Capella PSYC FPX 3130, Criminal Psychology and Behavior, in the BS in Psychology, catalog code PSYC-FPX3130. The paper states a decision, groups the evaluations by outcome, from rearrest to out-of-home placement, and reports the length of follow-up every time a finding is cited. It argues the opposing case properly, including evaluations with smaller effects, and ends with a recommendation and the conditions attached to it, such as funding only providers who maintain treatment fidelity.

CoursePSYC FPX 3130 Criminal Psychology and Behavior
AssessmentAssessment 3
Paper typePolicy position essay
LengthAbout 1,210 words, 5 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolCapella University
ProgramBS in Psychology
UpdatedSeptember 2026

Free sample paper for PSYC FPX 3130 Assessment 3

1

Should the State Fund Multisystemic Therapy for Serious Juvenile Offenders? A Policy Position Essay That States a Decision, Groups Evaluations by Outcome, Reports Follow-Up Length Every Time, Argues the Opposing Case Properly, and Takes a Position With Conditions

Student Name

Capella University

PSYC FPX 3130: Criminal Psychology and Behavior

Instructor Name

Month Day, Year

What this part is doingThe title poses a decision, not a topic. Policy essays are judged on stating a decision, so the decision leads.
2

A Decision, Not a Topic

The topic of juvenile justice treatment is broad; the decision addressed here is narrow. A state juvenile justice agency must decide whether to fund multisystemic therapy for adolescents aged 12 to 17 who have been adjudicated for serious offenses and are at risk of placement outside the home, in place of its current practice of referring them to standard outpatient counseling. Multisystemic therapy is an intensive, home-based treatment in which a therapist works with the youth's family, school, and peers over several months, addressing the multiple settings thought to sustain offending. The decision is whether the evidence justifies the higher cost per youth compared with outpatient counseling. Stating the decision this way sets the comparison that matters. The question is not whether multisystemic therapy is better than doing nothing, but whether it is better than what the agency already provides, since youths in this group would otherwise receive outpatient counseling. The randomized trial with the longest follow-up compared multisystemic therapy with individual therapy, which makes it directly relevant. The target group is also specified, because a program shown to help serious offenders at risk of placement may not help, or may not be worth its cost for, youths with minor offenses who would likely stop offending without intensive services.

Evaluations Grouped by Outcome Measured

Criminal recidivism. The longest follow-ups come from one randomized trial of 176 serious and violent juvenile offenders assigned to multisystemic therapy or individual therapy. Schaeffer and Borduin (2005), with an average follow-up of 13.7 years, when participants averaged 28.8 years of age, found recidivism rates of 50% for the multisystemic therapy group and 81% for the individual therapy group, with 54% fewer arrests and 57% fewer days of adult confinement. Sawyer and Borduin (2011), following the same participants for an average of 21.9 years, found felony recidivism of 34.8% for the multisystemic therapy group and 54.8% for the individual therapy group, and misdemeanor offending five times lower. Van der Stouwe et al. (2014) conducted a multilevel meta-analysis of 22 studies with 4,066 juveniles, combining outcomes measured at follow-up lengths that varied across studies. They found small but significant effects on delinquency, the primary outcome. Out-of-home placement. The same meta-analysis found small but significant effects on out-of-home placement, across studies with varying follow-up lengths (van der Stouwe et al., 2014). Family and other outcomes. Van der Stouwe et al. (2014) found small but significant effects on psychopathology, substance use, family factors, and peer factors, but no significant effect on skills and cognitions. Sawyer and Borduin (2011), at 21.9 years, found that the odds of involvement in family-related civil suits were twice as high for the individual therapy group. At an average of 21.9 years after treatment, felony recidivism was 34.8% in one group and 54.8% in the other.

What this part is doingEach evaluation is grouped by outcome with its follow-up length. Scorers reward policy essays that report how long effects were tracked.
3

Follow-Up Length Reported Every Time

Follow-up length has been reported for each finding because it changes what the finding means. Effects measured at 13.7 and 21.9 years show durability that few interventions demonstrate, but both come from a single trial of 176 youths conducted by the program's developers and their colleagues. The meta-analysis includes many more youths but combines studies with different follow-up periods, many much shorter, so its average effect describes a mix of shorter-term outcomes. A policymaker reading the long-term trial alone would expect larger and more lasting effects than the broader evidence supports. Reporting follow-up length also exposes a gap: nothing in the evidence reviewed tracks outcomes in routine practice in this state, and the meta-analysis summary does not separate effects at one year from effects at three or five years. A state that adopts the program will therefore be relying on a mix of long-term results from one trial and shorter-term results from many, and it will not know how its own results compare unless it measures them over a comparable period.

The Opposing Case Argued Properly

The case against funding multisystemic therapy is serious and deserves to be argued at full strength. First, the largest effects come from trials conducted by the program's developers. Littell (2005), in a systematic review of randomized trials, concluded that the evidence did not show multisystemic therapy to be consistently more effective than other services, found substantial inconsistency across studies, and raised concerns about how trials had been reported and analyzed. Second, the meta-analysis by van der Stouwe et al. (2014) found that effects on delinquency were small and varied with the country where the study was conducted, study quality, and whether the study tested the program under ideal or routine conditions. Small average effects, if they shrink further in routine practice, may not justify a cost several times that of outpatient counseling. Third, funding one intensive program may reduce funds for other services that reach more youths.

What this part is doingThe opposing case is argued with sources. Scorers reward essays that present the other side at its strongest.
4

A Position With Stated Conditions

The position taken is that the state should fund multisystemic therapy for serious juvenile offenders at risk of placement, under three conditions. First, the program must be delivered with monitored fidelity to its model, because effects in routine practice appear smaller and fidelity is one of the factors most within the agency's control. Second, the agency should prioritize younger adolescents, since van der Stouwe et al. (2014) found the program most effective for juveniles under age 15. Third, the agency should fund an independent evaluation with a follow-up of at least three years, tracking rearrest and out-of-home placement against a comparison group, and should revisit the decision if effects are not found. The position rests on the consistent, if small, effects on delinquency and placement across 22 studies, and on long-term results that, while from a single developer-led trial, suggest the effects can last. The conditions respond directly to the opposing case: they address the gap between developer trials and routine practice, and they build in a way to stop funding if the program does not work locally. The position would change under certain findings. If the local evaluation found no difference in rearrest or placement after three years, or if fidelity could not be maintained in practice, the case for the higher cost would fail, and the agency should return the funds to services with evidence of benefit at lower cost. If, on the other hand, local results matched even the modest effects in the meta-analysis, the savings from fewer placements could offset part of the program's cost, which would strengthen the case for continuing it. Stating these conditions in advance means the program's future will rest on its measured results, not on the momentum a program gathers once it has started.

Conclusion

The decision to fund multisystemic therapy for serious juvenile offenders is supported by a meta-analysis finding small effects on delinquency and placement and by a single trial showing large effects over two decades. Independent reviews temper these findings, and follow-up lengths vary widely. Funding is justified under conditions of monitored fidelity, a focus on younger adolescents, and independent local evaluation.

5

References

Littell, J. H. (2005). Lessons from a systematic review of effects of multisystemic therapy. Children and Youth Services Review, 27(4), 445-463. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.childyouth.2004.11.009

Sawyer, A. M., & Borduin, C. M. (2011). Effects of multisystemic therapy through midlife: A 21.9-year follow-up to a randomized clinical trial with serious and violent juvenile offenders. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 79(5), 643-652. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0024862

Schaeffer, C. M., & Borduin, C. M. (2005). Long-term follow-up to a randomized clinical trial of multisystemic therapy with serious and violent juvenile offenders. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 73(3), 445-453. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-006X.73.3.445

van der Stouwe, T., Asscher, J. J., Stams, G. J. J. M., Deković, M., & van der Laan, P. H. (2014). The effectiveness of multisystemic therapy (MST): A meta-analysis. Clinical Psychology Review, 34(6), 468-481. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cpr.2014.06.006

The Capella PSYC FPX 3130 Assessment 3 instructions

The final assessment in PSYC FPX 3130 asks you to take a position on a criminal justice policy using psychological research. You state the decision in question, review evaluations of the program or policy, organize the evidence by outcome, report study designs and follow-up periods, present the strongest case against your position, and make a recommendation with conditions. Government reports and independent evaluations are appropriate sources alongside peer-reviewed studies, and cost data help show what the state would be buying. Meta-analyses of multisystemic therapy, including those by van der Stouwe and colleagues, support the essay.

Inside the PSYC FPX 3130 Assessment 3 example

The essay is arranged so the position arrives last and looks earned. It opens on the practical question, stated as a choice between real options rather than as a topic, and says who would act on the answer. A short background section establishes the behavior the practice is meant to affect, carrying over the theoretical work from earlier in the course without repeating it. The evidence section is the longest and is organized by outcome, reoffending, program completion, cost per participant, so that studies measuring different things are not stacked as though they agreed. Each outcome ends with a plain statement of how strong the evidence is at that point. A counterposition section presents the best case against the writer's conclusion using its own sources. The closing states the position, its conditions and the study that would change it.

Reading the PSYC FPX 3130 Assessment 3 scoring guide

Marks go to the statement of the decision, the organization by outcome, the reporting of follow-up, the opposing case and the recommendation. Distinguished essays frame the decision as a choice a legislature could actually make. Organization scores higher when evidence is grouped by outcome. Follow-up earns credit when reported for every finding, since effects often fade. The opposing case is judged on whether it is argued at full strength, including independent trials with weaker results. The recommendation should carry conditions, such as fidelity monitoring and a review of outcomes after three years. Sources should include independent evaluations. Distinguished essays persuade through evidence.

PSYC FPX 3130 Assessment 3 help from the desk

Policy essays often cite only developer-led studies, which tend to show larger effects than independent ones. Another weakness is reporting outcomes without follow-up length. Evidence is grouped by study rather than outcome, making it hard to see what the program changes. The opposing case is a straw man that no skeptical legislator would recognize. The recommendation has no conditions. Cost is ignored, although legislators will weigh it against detention and probation costs. Grouping the evaluations in a table by outcome and follow-up, then writing the recommendation with the conditions the evidence supports, keeps the essay persuasive and closes the course with a policy judgment grounded in research.

Get a PSYC FPX 3130 Assessment 3 example written to your instructions

Give us the Assessment 3 instructions and scoring guide from your PSYC FPX 3130 courseroom, along with the practice or policy question your section put in front of you. An example is composed to those criteria, evaluations weighed and conditions stated, and reaches you within 24-48h. The first custom sample is free. The paper above is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Capella University document.

More PSYC FPX 3130 papers and BS in Psychology samples

PSYC FPX 3130 Assessment 3 questions, answered

Does a position essay need a recommendation?

Almost always, and it should be narrow enough to act on. Recommending that the justice system take psychology seriously satisfies nothing; recommending that a named diversion program be extended to a specified group, on the strength of two evaluations with stated follow-up periods, is a claim a grader can check against your sources. Specificity is where this criterion lives.

Can I use government reports as sources?

Yes, and for some questions they are the best available, since agencies publish evaluation data that never reaches a journal. Read them the way you would read any study: find the design, the sample and the follow-up, and note who commissioned the work. Where a report summarizes research done elsewhere, trace the underlying studies and cite those instead.

How does this differ from the earlier two assessments?

The first two are about explanation and this one is about consequence. Assessment 1 weighs competing accounts of why offending happens and Assessment 2 tests one account against a documented life; here the theory is settled background and the argument runs on evaluation evidence about what a practice produces. Carrying the comparison paper forward with a policy paragraph attached misses the criterion entirely.

Where can I find a free PSYC FPX 3130 Assessment 3 sample paper?

The complete multisystemic therapy policy essay is here, stating a decision, grouping evaluations by outcome, reporting follow-up length every time and arguing the opposing case properly.

Can I use government reports in PSYC FPX 3130 Assessment 3?

Yes. Government and independent evaluations are valuable in policy essays, as long as you report their methods and consider possible bias.