| Course | PSYC FPX 3700 Statistics for Psychology |
|---|---|
| Assessment | Assessment 3 |
| Paper type | Statistical critique |
| Length | About 1,090 words, 5 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Capella University |
| Program | BS in Psychology |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for PSYC FPX 3700 Assessment 3
Critiquing a Mindfulness App Study: A Statistical Critique That Describes the Analysis Before Judging It, Judges Test Selection Against the Design, Counts Absences as Findings, Checks the Discussion Against the Results, and Restates the Conclusion at Defensible Strength
Student Name
Capella University
PSYC FPX 3700: Statistics for Psychology
Instructor Name
Month Day, Year
The Analysis Described Before It Is Judged
The report, a composite written for this course in the style of a short journal article, describes a study in which 40 undergraduates who reported test anxiety were randomly assigned to use a mindfulness app for 10 minutes a day for four weeks or to a waitlist control group. Before and after the four weeks, all participants completed five measures: a test anxiety scale, a general stress scale, a sleep quality index, a self-esteem scale, and their grade on the next course exam. The report states that 6 of the 20 students in the app group stopped using the app and did not complete the posttest, so the analysis included 14 app users and 20 control participants. The analysis consisted of five independent-samples t tests comparing the two groups' posttest scores on each measure. The report gives the test anxiety result as significant, t(32) = 2.14, p = .04, with the app group scoring lower. The other four tests were not significant, with p values between .21 and .68. No effect sizes or confidence intervals are reported. The discussion concludes that the app "reduces anxiety and improves student well-being" and recommends offering it to all students.
Test Selection Judged Against the Design
The design is a randomized comparison with pretest and posttest measures, but the analysis uses only posttest scores. With pretest scores available, an analysis of covariance with the pretest as a covariate, or a mixed analysis of variance testing the interaction of group and time, would use the design fully, adjusting for any differences between groups at baseline and increasing statistical power. With only 34 participants analyzed, random assignment may not have produced equivalent groups, and a posttest-only comparison cannot show whether the app group started lower. The analysis also compares only the students who completed the study. Excluding the 6 who stopped using the app breaks the randomization, since students who stop may differ from those who continue, for example by being more anxious or less motivated. An intention-to-treat analysis, including all randomized participants, would preserve the comparison that randomization created. Running five separate tests without adjustment raises the chance of a false positive. Suppose the app changed none of the five outcomes: across five independent tests at the .05 level, chance alone would then produce one or more significant results about 23% of the time. With a Bonferroni correction dividing .05 by five, the threshold would be .01, and the test anxiety result, p = .04, would not be significant. Simmons et al. (2011) showed how flexibility of this kind, testing several outcomes and reporting the one that reaches significance, can make false-positive findings much more likely than the nominal 5%. Five uncorrected tests at the .05 level give chance a roughly one-in-four opening, not one in twenty.
Absences Counted as Findings
What the report does not contain is treated as a finding of the critique. There are no effect sizes, so the size of the difference in test anxiety cannot be judged. There are no confidence intervals, so the precision of the estimate is unknown; with groups of 14 and 20, it is likely to be wide. There is no report of whether the outcomes and analyses were specified in advance, so readers cannot tell whether test anxiety was the primary outcome or one of several examined. There is no comparison of the 6 dropouts with completers. There are no pretest means, so baseline equivalence cannot be checked. Wilkinson and the Task Force on Statistical Inference (1999) recommended that effect sizes and intervals be reported routinely, and Cumming (2014) argued that estimation, based on effect sizes and confidence intervals, should replace reliance on significance tests alone. Each absence limits what a reader can conclude. The absences also interact. Without effect sizes and intervals, a reader cannot tell whether the nonsignificant results for stress, sleep, self-esteem, and grades reflect no effect or simply too little power to detect one; with groups of this size, even a moderate effect could easily fail to reach significance. The report's silence on these points means that its null results are as uninformative as its one significant result is fragile. A critique that noted only the missing correction for multiple tests would miss this second problem, which cuts in the opposite direction: the study may have overstated one effect while being unable to detect others.
Discussion Checked Against the Results
The discussion's claims are checked against the results. The claim that the app reduces anxiety rests on one test with p = .04 that would not survive correction for multiple comparisons, in a completer-only analysis that ignores baseline scores. The claim that the app improves student well-being is not supported: stress, sleep quality, and self-esteem showed no significant differences, and the report does not measure well-being as a separate construct. The recommendation to offer the app to all students goes beyond a study of students who reported test anxiety, and it treats a single small study as sufficient evidence for a policy that would affect thousands of students who were never represented in the sample.
A Conclusion Restated at Defensible Strength
Restated at a strength the analysis supports, the conclusion would read: in a small randomized study, students with test anxiety who completed four weeks of a mindfulness app reported lower test anxiety after the program than waitlist students, but this difference was one of five outcomes tested, did not account for baseline scores or dropouts, and would not be significant after correction for multiple tests; no differences were found in stress, sleep quality, self-esteem, or exam grades. The finding is a reason to test the app in a larger, preregistered study with an intention-to-treat analysis, a single primary outcome named in advance, and effect sizes with confidence intervals reported for every measure, not a basis for recommending it to all students.
Conclusion
The report's analysis used five uncorrected posttest-only t tests on completers in a randomized pretest-posttest design, omitted effect sizes, confidence intervals, and baseline comparisons, and drew conclusions about well-being that its results do not support. Restated at defensible strength, the study offers a preliminary signal about test anxiety that requires replication.
References
Cumming, G. (2014). The new statistics: Why and how. Psychological Science, 25(1), 7-29. https://doi.org/10.1177/0956797613504966
Simmons, J. P., Nelson, L. D., & Simonsohn, U. (2011). False-positive psychology: Undisclosed flexibility in data collection and analysis allows presenting anything as significant. Psychological Science, 22(11), 1359-1366. https://doi.org/10.1177/0956797611417632
Wilkinson, L., & Task Force on Statistical Inference. (1999). Statistical methods in psychology journals: Guidelines and explanations. American Psychologist, 54(8), 594-604. https://doi.org/10.1037/0003-066X.54.8.594
PSYC FPX 3700 Assessment 3 instructions, in plain terms
The final assessment in PSYC FPX 3700 asks you to critique the statistics in a published article. You summarize the study's design and analysis, evaluate whether the statistical tests suit the design and data, check what is reported and what is missing, such as effect sizes, confidence intervals or how dropouts were handled, compare the authors' conclusions with the results and give an overall judgment. The critique should be fair, recognizing sound analysis where it exists. Guidance on reporting randomized trials, such as the CONSORT statement, supports the critique.
How this PSYC FPX 3700 Assessment 3 example is built
Five sections, and the evaluation is held back until the third. The first identifies the article and states its research question and its headline conclusion in the authors' own terms. The second describes the analysis neutrally: design, variables and their measurement levels, sample size, the tests run and the values reported, written from the results section rather than from the abstract. The third section evaluates test selection, asking what the variables and design called for and whether the paper's choice matches, with an alternative named where it does not. The fourth section evaluates reporting and interpretation: assumptions addressed or not, effect sizes present or absent, confidence intervals, multiple tests without correction, and any place where the discussion says more than the results paragraph did. The fifth section credits what the analysis does establish and then restates the finding at its defensible strength.
PSYC FPX 3700 Assessment 3 scoring guide: what Distinguished looks like
Marks go to the description of the analysis, the judgment of test selection, the attention to missing information, the comparison of discussion with results and the overall verdict. The description reaches Distinguished when it accurately states the design, sample, measures and tests before any judgment is made. Test selection scores higher when judged against the design, such as whether a pre-post comparison without a control group can support claims about the app. Missing information earns credit when counted as a finding, like absent effect sizes, no report of how many participants dropped out or no correction for multiple comparisons. Credit also goes to spotting places where the discussion claims more than the results show. The verdict should be fair, recognizing sound choices. Statistical terms should be used correctly. Distinguished critiques are specific and balanced.
PSYC FPX 3700 Assessment 3 help: mistakes that cost marks
Statistical critiques often list general problems, like small samples, without linking them to this study. Another weakness is judging tests without understanding the design. Missing information is not noticed. The discussion's claims are accepted at face value. The critique is entirely negative. Terms are used incorrectly. Summarizing the analysis in a short paragraph, then checking the article against a reporting checklist and comparing each claim in the discussion with the results, keeps the critique fair and closes the course with a skill for reading research.
Get a PSYC FPX 3700 Assessment 3 example written to your instructions
Post over the Assessment 3 instructions and scoring guide from your PSYC FPX 3700 courseroom, with the article your section assigned or a candidate you are considering. We write the example to those criteria, decisions evaluated and the conclusion resized, and it reaches you in 24-48h. The first custom sample is at no charge. The paper above is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Capella University document.
More PSYC FPX 3700 papers and BS in Psychology samples
- PSYC FPX 3700 Assessment 1: Descriptive Statistics Report
- PSYC FPX 3700 Assessment 2: Hypothesis Test Write-Up
- PSYC FPX 3770 Assessment 3: Intervention Design Paper
- PSYC FPX 3520 Assessment 3: Persuasion Campaign Essay
- PSYC FPX 4101 Assessment 3: Contemporary Connection Paper
- PSYC FPX 3501 Assessment 3: Evidence-Based Recommendation Report
PSYC FPX 3700 Assessment 3 questions, answered
How do I critique statistics I have not been taught?
Work from the logic rather than the formula. You can ask whether the variables suit the test, whether the sample supports the claim, whether an effect size is reported and whether the discussion outruns the results, all without being able to run a mixed model yourself. Where a technique is beyond you, say what it is for and evaluate what you can.
Which article should I choose if the choice is mine?
Something with a simple design and a full results section you can actually read. A two-group comparison or a correlational study reported in detail gives you far more to evaluate than an elaborate modeling paper you can only admire. Open access helps, since you need the tables and not just the abstract, and a modest recent study is usually a better subject than a famous one.
What if the study's analysis looks entirely sound?
Then say so and evaluate the interpretation instead, which is where most sound analyses still stretch. Check whether the discussion stays inside the design, whether the sample supports the population being addressed, and whether an association is described anywhere as an effect. A critique that finds the statistics defensible and the conclusion slightly oversized is a real result and scores well.
Where can I find a free PSYC FPX 3700 Assessment 3 sample paper?
The complete mindfulness app study critique is here, describing the analysis before judging it, judging test selection against the design, counting absences as findings and checking the discussion against the results.
What if the study's analysis looks entirely sound in PSYC FPX 3700 Assessment 3?
Say so and explain why. A fair critique can conclude that the analysis is appropriate, while noting any limits in what it can show.