PSYC FPX 4600 Assessment 1 Research Question and Review example

Reviewed by Blythe Cavendish, PhD Research Methods in Psychology Capella University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This PSYC FPX 4600 Assessment 1 sample paper sets out a research question and review asking whether a smartphone sitting on the desk reduces working memory, even when it is switched off. It was written for Capella PSYC FPX 4600, Research Methods in Psychology, a BS in Psychology course listed as PSYC-FPX4600. The paper shows how the question was narrowed from a broad interest in technology and attention, defends its definitions of smartphone presence and working memory and organizes the review by finding rather than by article. It weighs the quality of each source as it sorts them and names the open question the proposed study would answer, including failed replications of the original brain drain study.

CoursePSYC FPX 4600 Research Methods in Psychology
AssessmentAssessment 1
Paper typeResearch question and literature review
LengthAbout 1,090 words, 5 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolCapella University
ProgramBS in Psychology
UpdatedSeptember 2026

Free sample paper for PSYC FPX 4600 Assessment 1

1

Does a Smartphone on the Desk Reduce Working Memory? A Research Question and Review That Shows the Narrowing, Defends Its Definitions, Organizes the Review by Finding, Weighs Quality While Sorting Sources, and Names and Occupies the Gap

Student Name

Capella University

PSYC FPX 4600: Research Methods in Psychology

Instructor Name

Month Day, Year

What this part is doingThe title states the research question. Question-and-review papers are judged on showing the narrowing, so the question leads.
2

The Narrowing Shown, Not Hidden

The topic began broadly: do smartphones harm students' learning? That question includes phone use in class, notifications, multitasking, social media, and sleep, each with its own research and mechanisms. The first narrowing set aside active use and notifications and focused on the mere presence of a phone, a question with a clear experimental paradigm. The second narrowing chose one outcome, working memory capacity, because the original research proposed that it would be affected and because a standard measure exists. The third narrowing chose a population, undergraduates, because they are the population in which most studies have been run and to whom a replication would be most directly comparable. The resulting question is: among undergraduates, does having one's own silenced smartphone face down on the desk, compared with having it in another room, reduce working memory capacity as measured by the automated operation span task? Showing each step makes clear what the question includes and what it leaves for other studies.

Definitions Defended Against Alternatives

Mere presence is defined as the phone being physically near the person, silenced and not used, during a task. An alternative definition would include any phone visible in the room, including someone else's; this study uses the participant's own phone because the original hypothesis concerns attention drawn by one's own device. Another alternative would allow notifications; that would test interruption, a different mechanism, rather than presence. Working memory capacity is defined as the ability to hold and manipulate information in mind while performing another task, measured by complex span tasks such as the operation span. An alternative would be fluid intelligence, measured by reasoning tasks, which the original research also examined; this study focuses on working memory because the meta-analytic evidence reviewed below is most consistent for that outcome. Sustained attention is another alternative, but it was not predicted to be affected by presence in the original account.

What this part is doingEach definition is defended against a named alternative. Scorers reward papers that justify their definitions.
3

The Review Organized by Finding

The original effect. Ward et al. (2017) reported that undergraduates whose phones were in another room performed better on the operation span task and a fluid reasoning task than those whose phones were on the desk, with phones in a pocket or bag in between. In a second experiment, the effect of location held whether the phone was on or off, and it was larger for participants who reported greater dependence on their phones. The authors proposed that one's own phone draws on limited cognitive resources even when it is not used, a process they called brain drain. Replications that did not find the effect. Hartmann et al. (2020) tested whether phone presence on the desk affected short-term memory and prospective memory and found no overall effect, although prospective memory was better without the phone among participants with low dependence. Ruiz Pardo and Minda (2022) conducted a preregistered direct replication of the second experiment of Ward et al. (2017), with the same conditions and tasks, and found no difference between phone location conditions on the operation span task or a go/no-go task. The pooled evidence. Parry (2024) conducted a systematic review and six meta-analyses covering 56 effect sizes from 7,093 participants. Only one pooled effect was statistically significant: working memory capacity was negatively affected by the presence of a smartphone, though the effect was smaller than originally theorized. Results for other cognitive functions were null. Parry noted substantial methodological heterogeneity and generally poor statistical power in the literature. Moderation by dependence. The evidence on whether dependence moderates the effect is mixed. Ward et al. (2017) reported larger effects for more dependent participants, Hartmann et al. (2020) found a moderating effect only for prospective memory, in the opposite direction from what might be expected, and Ruiz Pardo and Minda (2022) did not find the predicted moderation. Only one of six pooled effects was significant: a small negative effect on working memory capacity.

Quality Weighed While Sources Are Sorted

Quality is weighed as each source is sorted. The preregistered direct replication by Ruiz Pardo and Minda (2022) carries particular weight for the working memory question because its hypotheses and analysis were specified in advance and it used the original tasks, reducing the flexibility that can inflate effects. The study by Hartmann et al. (2020) is a conceptual replication with different memory tasks, so its null result speaks to generality more than to the original finding. The meta-analysis by Parry (2024) has the broadest evidence base but inherits the limits of the studies it combines, including their low power. The original study by Ward et al. (2017) is the source of the hypothesis and was not preregistered.

What this part is doingSources are weighed by design as they are reviewed. Scorers reward reviews that assess quality rather than only summarize.
4

The Gap Named and Occupied

The gap is specific. The pooled evidence suggests a small negative effect on working memory capacity, but individual studies, including a preregistered replication, have been too small to detect an effect of that size reliably, and the moderating role of dependence remains unresolved. What is missing is a preregistered experiment with enough participants to detect a small effect of phone location on operation span performance, comparing the two conditions that produced the largest difference in the original study, desk and another room, and testing dependence as a preregistered moderator. The proposed study occupies that gap by being designed around the smaller effect size that the meta-analysis suggests, rather than the larger one originally reported. Occupying the gap this way has a consequence worth stating. If the study finds no effect with adequate power, that result will narrow the range of plausible effect sizes and weigh against the brain drain hypothesis for working memory; if it finds a small effect, it will support the meta-analytic estimate over the null replications. Either outcome would add to the literature, which is the mark of a gap worth filling.

Conclusion

Narrowed from a broad question about smartphones and learning, the research question asks whether a silenced phone on the desk, compared with one in another room, reduces undergraduates' working memory capacity. The review shows an original effect, failed replications including a preregistered one, and a meta-analysis finding a small effect on working memory only, with poor power throughout. The gap is an adequately powered, preregistered test of the working memory effect and its moderation by dependence.

5

References

Hartmann, M., Martarelli, C. S., Reber, T. P., & Rothen, N. (2020). Does a smartphone on the desk drain our brain? No evidence of cognitive costs due to smartphone presence in a short-term and prospective memory task. Consciousness and Cognition, 86, Article 103033. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.concog.2020.103033

Parry, D. A. (2024). Does the mere presence of a smartphone impact cognitive performance? A meta-analysis of the "brain drain effect." Media Psychology, 27(5), 737-762. https://doi.org/10.1080/15213269.2023.2286647

Ruiz Pardo, A. C., & Minda, J. P. (2022). Reexamining the "brain drain" effect: A replication of Ward et al. (2017). Acta Psychologica, 230, Article 103717. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.actpsy.2022.103717

Ward, A. F., Duke, K., Gneezy, A., & Bos, M. W. (2017). Brain drain: The mere presence of one's own smartphone reduces available cognitive capacity. Journal of the Association for Consumer Research, 2(2), 140-154. https://doi.org/10.1086/691462

PSYC FPX 4600 Assessment 1 instructions, in plain terms

The first assessment in PSYC FPX 4600 asks you to develop a research question and review the literature behind it. You start with a topic, narrow it to a specific, testable question, define the key variables, search for and select relevant peer-reviewed studies, group the studies by what they found, evaluate the quality of the evidence and identify the gap your study would address. The question should be narrow enough to test in a single study. Research by Ward and colleagues on smartphone presence and later replication attempts support the review.

How the PSYC-FPX4600 Assessment 1 example is put together

Three stages, and the first is longer than students expect. Stage one takes the topic to a question: the area of interest is stated, then narrowed through explicit decisions about population, variables and scope, each decision written down with its reason. Stage two builds the operational definitions, giving each construct a measurable form, naming the instrument or index that would supply it, and comparing that choice with one rival definition the literature also uses. Stage three is the review, arranged by finding rather than by study, which means grouping work that agrees, work that conflicts and work that has not been done, and reading methodological quality as part of the grouping. The document closes by stating the gap and showing that the narrowed question sits inside it, which is the sentence tying the whole assessment together.

PSYC FPX 4600 Assessment 1 scoring guide: what Distinguished looks like

Grading here looks at the narrowing of the question, the definitions, the organization of the review, the weighing of quality and the identification of the gap. The narrowing reaches Distinguished when the steps from topic to question are shown, so the reader sees why this question was chosen. Definitions score higher when each variable is defined in a way that could be measured, such as working memory as performance on an operation span task. Organization earns credit when studies are grouped by finding, like those showing an effect and those that did not replicate it. Quality is judged on whether sample size, design and preregistration are weighed while sorting. The gap should follow from the review rather than being asserted. Sources should be peer-reviewed and current. A Proficient review summarizes studies; a Distinguished one builds a case for the next one.

Common PSYC FPX 4600 Assessment 1 mistakes, and how to avoid them

Research question papers often start with a broad question, like "how does technology affect students," that no single study could answer. Another weakness is defining variables loosely, so the review mixes studies that measured different things. The review summarizes one article per paragraph instead of grouping findings. Quality is ignored, so a small unreplicated study carries the same weight as a large preregistered one. Failed replications are left out. The gap is asserted as "no one has studied this." Writing the narrowing as three short steps, then sorting the studies into a small table by finding and quality, keeps the review organized and prepares the study design in Assessment 2.

Get a PSYC FPX 4600 Assessment 1 example written to your instructions

Send the Assessment 1 instructions and scoring guide from your PSYC FPX 4600 courseroom, plus the topic area you are working in. The example is written to those criteria and reaches you in 24-48h, showing how a question gets narrowed and how definitions are defended. Your own question and your own reading stay with you; the first custom sample is free. The paper above is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Capella University document.

More PSYC FPX 4600 papers and BS in Psychology samples

PSYC FPX 4600 Assessment 1 questions, answered

How narrow does the question have to be?

Narrow enough that someone could tell you were wrong. That usually means a specified population, a named outcome with a measure attached, a stated comparison and a period. Whether social media affects wellbeing is not answerable; whether daily passive use predicts a change on one wellbeing scale among first-year undergraduates across a semester is. The narrowing is what the criteria are grading.

How many sources belong in the review?

Your section sets a floor and the argument sets the rest. What matters more is that the sources form groups: work that agrees, work that conflicts, and the absence that leaves your question open. Fifteen articles summarized one after another read as thinner than eight organized around findings, because the review criterion is about structure rather than about volume.

Can a sample research question be reused?

It would not survive the rest of the sequence. Your later assessments build a design, an ethics treatment and an analysis plan on top of the question, and a question you did not narrow yourself leaves you defending decisions you never made. Read the example for how the narrowing was argued, then run the same process on the area your own interest and your section allow.

Where can I find a free PSYC FPX 4600 Assessment 1 sample paper?

The smartphone and working memory question and review is here in full, showing the narrowing, defending its definitions, organizing the review by finding and naming the open question.

How narrow should the question be in PSYC FPX 4600 Assessment 1?

Narrow enough that one study could answer it, with variables you could actually measure in a course project or small experiment.