| Course | BHA FPX 3001 Essentials of the Healthcare System |
|---|---|
| Assessment | Assessment 3 |
| Paper type | Policy issue paper |
| Length | About 1,080 words, 5 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Capella University |
| Program | BS in Health Care Administration |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for BHA FPX 3001 Assessment 3
A Policy Position on One Provision of the No Surprises Act: The Independent Dispute Resolution Process for Out-of-Network Payment
Student Name
Capella University
BHA FPX 3001: Essentials of the Healthcare System
Instructor Name
Month Day, Year
An Issue Narrowed to One Provision
The No Surprises Act, enacted in December 2020 as part of the Consolidated Appropriations Act, 2021, contains many provisions. This paper addresses one: the independent dispute resolution process, which decides how much a health plan must pay an out-of-network provider for services the law protects from surprise billing, when the plan and provider cannot agree.
Background Kept Factual and Dated
Since January 1, 2022, patients have been shielded from surprise bills in two situations: emergency care, and some scheduled services delivered by out-of-network clinicians inside in-network facilities, such as anesthesiologists at an in-network hospital. The patient pays only in-network cost-sharing (Internal Revenue Service et al., 2021). The plan then pays the provider an initial amount. If the provider disagrees, the parties negotiate for 30 business days, and if they cannot agree, either may start the independent dispute resolution process, in which a certified entity chooses one of the two parties' offers. The entity must consider the qualifying payment amount, which is generally the plan's median contracted rate for the service in that area, along with other information such as the provider's training and the complexity of the case. The process was used far more than federal agencies expected, and the federal government's rules on how much weight to give the qualifying payment amount were challenged in court, leading to changes in guidance. Federal reports on the process indicate that providers have prevailed in a majority of decided disputes. Shi and Singh (2022) note that US policy often addresses one gap, here surprise bills to patients, while creating new administrative processes among payers and providers.
Stakeholders With the Direction of Effect
Patients: the law's patient protections benefit them directly; the dispute process affects them indirectly, since higher payments to providers may raise premiums over time. Out-of-network providers, especially hospital-based specialists such as emergency physicians, anesthesiologists, and radiologists, and the staffing companies that employ many of them: the process gives them a route to payment above the plan's initial amount. Their incomes depend on how the process weighs the qualifying payment amount, which is why their professional associations have been among the most active participants in litigation over the rules. Health plans and self-insured employers: they bear the higher payments when providers win disputes and the administrative cost of the process. Hospitals: they are affected through their contracts with physician groups and through their own facility claims. The federal government: it administers the process, certifies the dispute resolution entities, and bears the cost of oversight. Stating the direction of effect for each stakeholder shows who gains and who loses from each design choice in the process.
Why This Provision Matters
Of all the law's provisions, the dispute process matters most for costs because it sets the price that applies when parties cannot agree, and that price shapes negotiations even when no dispute is filed. If providers expect arbitrators to award amounts well above in-network rates, they have little reason to accept network contracts at those rates. If plans expect awards close to their median rates, they have little reason to offer more. The process therefore influences network participation and contract rates across the market, not only the disputes it decides.
The Position
This paper argues that the dispute resolution process should give the qualifying payment amount a clear presumption of reasonableness, with other factors able to justify a different amount only when a party shows specific evidence, such as unusual case complexity. The purpose of the law was to take patients out of payment disputes without driving up overall costs. When arbiters choose offers well above typical in-network rates, the cost is passed to employers and patients through premiums, and providers have less reason to join networks, since out-of-network status can pay more than contracting.
The Counterargument Stated at Full Strength
The strongest counterargument is that the qualifying payment amount is calculated by the plans themselves, from their own contracted rates, and may be biased downward. Plans have an incentive to calculate a low median, and providers have limited ability to verify it. Giving it a strong presumption would let one party effectively set the price. Providers also argue that some specialties, such as emergency medicine, must treat every patient regardless of insurance, unlike other businesses, and that low payments could threaten the viability of emergency physician groups in rural or underserved areas. Courts have agreed with parts of this argument, ruling that federal rules gave the qualifying payment amount too much weight relative to what the statute required.
Response to the Counterargument
The response is that the problem of a biased qualifying payment amount should be fixed directly, through audits of how plans calculate it and transparency requirements, rather than by weakening its role. If the benchmark is accurate, giving it a presumption is fair to both sides, since it reflects what the market already pays in-network providers for the same service in the same area. The concern about emergency groups in underserved areas is real but could be addressed through targeted payment adjustments for rural or safety-net providers rather than through higher arbitration awards that apply everywhere.
A Position That Names Its Limits
The position has limits. It depends on the qualifying payment amount being calculated accurately, which requires oversight the federal government has not yet fully provided. It is constrained by the statute and by court decisions, so it may require legislation rather than new rules. And the evidence on how arbitration outcomes affect premiums is still developing, since the process is recent. Finally, the position treats all specialties alike, while the effects of the process may differ between, for example, emergency medicine and elective services, which future analysis should examine separately. The position is therefore offered as the best current approach, to be revisited as data on premiums and network participation accumulate. A position that names its limits invites the reader to test it rather than simply accept or reject it.
Conclusion
The independent dispute resolution process is the provision that determines whether the No Surprises Act protects patients without raising overall costs. This paper argues for a presumption in favor of an accurately calculated qualifying payment amount, answers the strongest counterargument with targeted alternatives, and names the limits of its position.
References
Internal Revenue Service, Employee Benefits Security Administration, Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, & Office of Personnel Management. (2021). Requirements related to surprise billing; Part I. Federal Register, 86, 36872.
Shi, L., & Singh, D. A. (2022). Delivering health care in America: A systems approach (8th ed.). Jones & Bartlett Learning.
What the BHA FPX 3001 Assessment 3 instructions ask for
The final assessment asks you to analyze a health policy issue and take a position. You identify a specific policy or provision, give factual background with dates and citations, analyze how it affects stakeholders, state and argue your position, present the strongest counterargument and respond to it. Narrowing the issue to one provision or rule makes the argument manageable and precise. Background should be kept separate from argument. Sources should include the law or rule itself, government guidance and scholarly or policy analyses from several perspectives. The paper should be balanced in presenting views even as it takes a side. A clear thesis in the introduction helps faculty follow the argument.
Inside the BHA FPX 3001 Assessment 3 example
The example runs issue, background, stakeholder analysis, argument, counterargument, position. The background stays factual and dated, with the statute, rule or bill identified precisely enough that a reader could look it up, and no argument mixed into it. The stakeholder section is a set of short subsections, one per party, each ending with the direction of effect rather than a summary. The argument section connects the policy to the system mechanics established earlier in the course, so a claim about behavior is backed by the payment incentive that produces it rather than by assertion. The counterargument gets real space and real sources. The position closes the paper and names its own limits, including what evidence would undermine it. Citations lean on primary policy documents and peer reviewed evaluation, not news coverage, and headings match the criteria.
BHA FPX 3001 Assessment 3 scoring guide: what Distinguished looks like
The scoring guide rates the issue definition, the background, the stakeholder analysis, the position, the counterargument and the writing. The issue reaches Distinguished when narrowed to a provision a reader could look up. Background scores higher when factual, dated and free of argument. Stakeholder analysis earns credit when the direction of effect is stated for each group, such as patients protected from balance bills while physician groups face lower payments. The position should be supported by evidence. The counterargument criterion rewards stating the opposing view at full strength before answering it. Naming the limits of the position shows maturity. Writing and APA citations of legal and policy sources are graded.
BHA FPX 3001 Assessment 3 help: mistakes that cost marks
Students often choose an issue too broad, such as health care reform, to argue in a few pages. Another common mistake is mixing argument into the background, which makes the paper read as biased from the start. Stakeholders are listed without saying how each is affected. The counterargument is weak or missing, which the scoring guide penalizes. Sources come from one side only. Legal details, such as dates and which agency administers the rule, are inaccurate. The position is stated only in the conclusion. Building the paper around one provision, like the dispute resolution process, keeps the facts checkable and the argument sharp.
Get a BHA FPX 3001 Assessment 3 example written to your instructions
Send the instructions and the scoring guide for BHA FPX 3001 Assessment 3 from your courseroom, plus the policy issue your section allows or assigns. A custom example comes back in 24 to 48 hours, written to those criteria, with dated background, stakeholders directed, the counterargument answered and a defended position. The first one is free. The paper above is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Capella University document.
More BHA FPX 3001 papers and BS in Health Care Administration samples
- BHA FPX 3001 Assessment 1: System Analysis
- BHA FPX 3001 Assessment 2: Access and Cost Analysis
- BHA FPX 3004 Assessment 3: Quality Evaluation Plan
- BHA FPX 2110 Assessment 3: Implementation and Evaluation Plan
- BHA FPX 3008 Assessment 3: Financial Recommendation
- BHA FPX 2106 Assessment 3: Improvement Recommendation
BHA FPX 3001 Assessment 3 questions, answered
What policy issue works best for Assessment 3?
One narrow enough to argue and recent enough to have evidence. Site neutral payment, a state scope of practice change, prior authorization rules, or a specific provision of a recent act all work. Avoid whole reform packages. The example picks a single provision so the stakeholder section can name real effects instead of describing general political positions.
Am I allowed to take a political position in this paper?
You are expected to take a position, but it has to be argued from evidence about effects rather than from values. The example never says a policy is right or wrong in the abstract. It says who gains, who loses, by how much, and why the balance favors one answer, then states what finding would reverse it.
How many sources does a policy issue paper need?
Fewer than students assume, used harder. The example carries a primary policy document for what the rule says, one or two evaluations for what it did, and a source for the counterargument written by people who hold it. Twelve citations that each support one uncontested sentence score worse than five that carry the argument.
Where can I find a free BHA FPX 3001 Assessment 3 sample paper?
This page contains the full policy position on the No Surprises Act dispute resolution provision, with dated background, stakeholders, the counterargument and limits. A custom policy paper is available free.
How narrow should the policy issue be in BHA FPX 3001 Assessment 3?
Narrow enough to be one provision, rule or bill a reader could look up, such as a specific section of a law. That lets you give accurate background and a focused argument.