| Course | BHA FPX 3008 Financial Management for Healthcare Organizations |
|---|---|
| Assessment | Assessment 2 |
| Paper type | Variance report |
| Length | About 1,090 words, 5 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Capella University |
| Program | BS in Health Care Administration |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for BHA FPX 3008 Assessment 2
Variance Analysis for an Outpatient Physical Therapy Clinic: A Materiality Threshold, Volume Separated From Rate, and Every Variance Traced to a Decision
Student Name
Capella University
BHA FPX 3008: Financial Management for Healthcare Organizations
Instructor Name
Month Day, Year
A Materiality Threshold Set Up Front
The clinic manager at Summit Health's outpatient physical therapy clinic reviews results for the first six months of the year against budget. Before looking at the numbers, the manager set a materiality threshold: a variance will be investigated if it exceeds 5% of the budgeted line or 10,000 dollars, whichever is smaller. Setting the threshold first prevents the review from focusing only on variances the manager finds interesting and ensures that small variances do not consume time that should go to large ones. Lines below the threshold are still reported, but they are not investigated unless they persist for three months or more.
Results Against Budget
For the six months, the budget assumed 13,200 visits at 105 dollars of net revenue per visit. Actual visits were 12,300, and actual net revenue per visit was 108 dollars. Net patient revenue was 1,328,400 dollars against a budget of 1,386,000 dollars, an unfavorable variance of 57,600 dollars. Therapist and assistant salaries were 571,000 dollars against a budget of 595,000 dollars, favorable by 24,000. Clinical supplies were 43,100 dollars against a budget of 39,600 dollars, unfavorable by 3,500.
Volume Driven Separated From Rate Driven
A single revenue variance mixes two causes. It is split into a volume variance, caused by the difference in visits, and a rate variance, caused by the difference in revenue per visit. Volume variance: (12,300 minus 13,200) times 105 dollars equals minus 94,500 dollars, unfavorable. Rate variance: (108 minus 105) times 12,300 equals plus 36,900 dollars, favorable. The two sum to the total variance of minus 57,600 dollars. The split shows that the clinic is earning more per visit than expected but seeing substantially fewer patients, and that the volume shortfall is the main problem. The supply variance is also split, using a flexible budget: at 3 dollars per visit, the budget for 12,300 actual visits would be 36,900 dollars. Actual spending of 43,100 dollars exceeds the flexible budget by 6,200 dollars, which is a spending variance. Against the flexible budget, supply use per visit rose from 3.00 to about 3.50 dollars. Cleverley and Cleverley (2018) describe flexible budgeting as the way to separate the effect of volume from the effect of efficiency, since a static budget would understate the problem here. Separating volume from rate shows that a revenue shortfall of 57,600 dollars hides a much larger volume problem partly offset by better rates.
Each Variance Traced to a Decision
Each variance above the threshold is traced to a decision or event. Volume: the new orthopedic surgeon, whose patients were expected to add volume, started three months later than planned. In addition, one therapist was on unpaid leave for ten weeks, and the clinic did not use per diem therapists to cover because the manager decided to hold down labor costs. After other therapists absorbed some of the caseload, that decision still cost about 450 visits. Rate: a commercial insurer's rate increase took effect two months earlier than budgeted, and the clinic's payer mix shifted slightly toward commercial patients, who pay more per visit. Salaries: the favorable salary variance is the direct result of the therapist's unpaid leave and the decision not to hire per diem coverage during those ten weeks. Supplies: the clinic began using a new, more expensive type of resistance band for all patients after a therapist recommended it, a decision made without reviewing cost.
Favorable Variances Examined, Not Celebrated
Two variances are favorable: salaries by 24,000 dollars and rate by 36,900 dollars. The rate variance reflects genuine good news for the clinic. The salary variance does not. It came from a vacancy and a decision not to cover it, which saved 24,000 dollars in salary but lost about 450 visits, worth about 47,000 dollars in revenue, and delayed care for patients. The favorable salary variance is therefore part of an unfavorable outcome. Examining favorable variances prevents managers from treating savings as success when they are the other side of a lost opportunity. A favorable variance that comes from not delivering care is not a saving; it is a cost recorded somewhere else.
Controllable Marked Apart From Not
Controllable variances: the decision not to cover the therapist's leave, and the supply choice, are within the manager's control. Not controllable: the surgeon's delayed start, which depended on the hospital's recruitment and credentialing, and the timing of the insurer's rate increase, which depended on contract negotiations led by the hospital's managed care department. Marking them apart focuses the manager's action on what can be changed and makes clear to hospital leadership which variances arose from decisions outside the clinic. The surgeon's delayed start, for example, should be raised with the hospital's physician recruitment office, since future budgets that depend on new physicians need realistic start dates.
What the Analysis Means for Next Year's Budget
The variance analysis also improves next year's budget. The volume assumption tied to a new surgeon should include a start date risk, perhaps budgeting the surgeon's volume from the expected start date plus a margin. The budget should include a line for per diem coverage, since absences are predictable in total even if not in timing. And the supply budget should be set after therapists and the manager agree on standard supplies, so that changes in supply choices are decisions made with cost in view rather than surprises in the variance report. Using variance analysis this way turns it from an explanation of the past into a tool for planning.
Actions
The manager will arrange per diem coverage for future absences of more than two weeks, since each lost visit costs more than the saved labor. The supply choice will be reviewed with therapists to see whether the more expensive bands can be reserved for patients who need them. Volume will be tracked weekly as the new surgeon's practice builds, and the manager will meet monthly with the surgeon's office to anticipate referral volume.
Conclusion
With a materiality threshold set in advance, the analysis separated a 57,600 dollar revenue shortfall into a 94,500 dollar volume problem and a 36,900 dollar rate gain. Each variance was traced to a decision, the favorable salary variance was shown to be part of a loss, and controllable variances were separated from those decided elsewhere.
References
Cleverley, W. O., & Cleverley, J. O. (2018). Essentials of health care finance (8th ed.). Jones & Bartlett Learning.
What the BHA FPX 3008 Assessment 2 instructions ask for
The instructions ask you to analyze the differences between budgeted and actual results for a health care department over a period. You present the variances in a table, set a threshold for which ones matter, explain the causes of each material variance, separate volume effects from price or rate effects, identify which variances the manager controls and recommend actions for the rest of the year and the next budget. Favorable variances deserve analysis too, since lower supply spending may reflect fewer visits and lower salary costs may reflect vacant positions that hurt access. Show budget, actual, dollar and percentage variance on every row. Many students use the budget from Assessment 1. Healthcare finance texts describe flexible budgets and volume variance methods that support the analysis.
Inside the BHA FPX 3008 Assessment 2 example
The example opens with the period, the department and the materiality rule, then presents a variance table with budget, actual, dollar variance, percentage variance and a favorable or unfavorable label on every row. What follows is one subsection per material variance, and each subsection does the same four things: states the gap, decomposes it into volume and rate components where the data allows, names the operational cause, and says whether the cause is controllable at department level. A separate section handles the interaction between variances, because agency staffing that inflates salary expense often explains a favorable line elsewhere. The closing summarizes the net position and flags which variances will repeat next period if nothing changes. Terminology stays consistent, favorable and unfavorable rather than positive and negative, and every figure ties to the table.
BHA FPX 3008 Assessment 2 scoring guide: what Distinguished looks like
The scoring guide rates the variance table, the materiality threshold, the explanations, the volume and rate analysis, the controllability and the recommendations. The threshold reaches Distinguished when stated before the analysis, such as five percent and five thousand dollars. Explanations score higher when each variance is traced to a decision or event, for example a therapist vacancy or a payer contract change. Separating volume from rate shows analytic skill, since fewer visits and lower payment per visit need different responses. Examining favorable variances earns credit, because they can hide problems. Controllability should be marked for each variance. Recommendations should follow from causes and feed into next year's budget. Clear tables, arithmetic that checks and correct citations also count toward the grade.
BHA FPX 3008 Assessment 2 help from the desk
Students often explain every variance, however small, which buries the ones that matter. Another common mistake is explaining variances with guesses, such as costs went up, rather than causes a manager could act on. Volume and rate effects are mixed, so a clinic that saw fewer patients looks like it spent less efficiently. Favorable variances are praised without asking why they happened. Controllability is ignored, so the manager is blamed for allocated costs set elsewhere. Recommendations are generic, such as monitor spending. The analysis is not connected to next year's budget. A materiality rule, stated up front, keeps the report focused, and a sentence on each material variance's cause, controllability and action makes it useful.
Get a BHA FPX 3008 Assessment 2 example written to your instructions
Send the instructions and the scoring guide for BHA FPX 3008 Assessment 2 from your courseroom, with the budget and actual figures your section supplies. A custom example comes back in 24 to 48 hours, written to those criteria, with variances calculated, labelled correctly and each one tied to an operational cause. The first one is free. The paper above is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Capella University document.
More BHA FPX 3008 papers and BS in Health Care Administration samples
- BHA FPX 3008 Assessment 1: Budget Analysis
- BHA FPX 3008 Assessment 3: Financial Recommendation
- BHA FPX 3009 Assessment 2: Revenue Cycle Analysis
- BHA FPX 3004 Assessment 2: Improvement Plan
- BHA FPX 3010 Assessment 2: Study Appraisal
- BHA FPX 3001 Assessment 2: Access and Cost Analysis
BHA FPX 3008 Assessment 2 questions, answered
How do I explain a variance when I only have the numbers?
You reason from what the numbers can support and say that is what you are doing. If salary expense rose while worked hours per unit stayed flat, the cause sits in rate rather than volume, which points at overtime or agency use. The example states the inference and its basis rather than asserting a cause the data cannot show.
Should I explain every line that differs from budget?
No, and doing it usually costs marks rather than earning them. Real variance reporting sets a threshold in dollars or percentage and works what clears it. The example states its threshold in the opening and defends it in one sentence, then spends its length on the few variances that matter instead of spreading attention across rows nobody would discuss.
Is a favorable variance always good news?
Not in healthcare finance, and the criteria reward saying so. Supplies under budget can mean deferred purchasing, salaries under budget can mean posts held open that showed up as overtime the next quarter, and revenue over budget can mean a coding change that will be audited. The example examines its favorable lines with the same suspicion as the unfavorable ones.
Where can I find a free BHA FPX 3008 Assessment 2 sample paper?
This page holds the full variance report for the physical therapy clinic, with the threshold, volume and rate effects, causes, favorable variances and controllability. A custom report is available free.
What is a materiality threshold in BHA FPX 3008 Assessment 2?
A rule for which variances are large enough to explain, often a percentage and a dollar amount together. It keeps the report focused on the variances that matter to decisions.