| Course | BHA FPX 3112 Introduction to Healthcare Economics |
|---|---|
| Assessment | Assessment 3 |
| Paper type | Market structure report |
| Length | About 1,100 words, 5 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Capella University |
| Program | BS in Health Care Administration |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for BHA FPX 3112 Assessment 3
Hospital Market Structure in One Metropolitan Area: Competitors Named, Concentration Measured, Entry Barriers, and Pricing Power
Student Name
Capella University
BHA FPX 3112: Introduction to Healthcare Economics
Instructor Name
Month Day, Year
The Market Defined Before It Is Judged
The market is inpatient general acute care hospital services for commercially insured patients in a composite metropolitan area, here called the Lakeview metro, with about 850,000 residents. The product is defined as inpatient care rather than all hospital services, because outpatient services face competition from freestanding centers and physician offices. The geography is the metro area, because most residents seek inpatient care within it, and patient origin data show that about 88% of inpatient admissions of metro residents occur at hospitals in the metro. The market is defined for commercially insured patients because Medicare and Medicaid set prices administratively, while commercial prices are negotiated and therefore reflect market structure.
Competitors Named With Size and Ownership
Five hospital organizations operate in the market. Lakeview Health System, nonprofit, operates two hospitals with a combined 620 beds and about 46% of inpatient admissions in the metro. St. Anne Medical Center, a nonprofit faith-based hospital, has 310 beds and about 24% of admissions. Northgate Regional, owned by a for-profit national chain, has 240 beds and about 17% of admissions. County General, a public hospital, has 180 beds and about 9% of admissions, serving a large share of uninsured and Medicaid patients. Westside Community Hospital, an independent nonprofit, has 90 beds and about 4% of admissions. Admission shares were calculated from the state's hospital discharge data for the most recent year.
Structure Classified and Then Defended
Market concentration can be measured with the Herfindahl-Hirschman Index, the sum of the squared market shares of all firms. Using admission shares: 46 squared is 2,116; 24 squared is 576; 17 squared is 289; 9 squared is 81; 4 squared is 16. The index is 3,078. Federal antitrust guidelines treat markets with an index above 1,800 as highly concentrated. The Lakeview metro hospital market is therefore highly concentrated. The structure is classified as an oligopoly with a dominant firm. It is not a monopoly, because four other hospitals compete, and it is not a competitive market, because a few firms hold most of the share and one holds nearly half. The classification is defended by the numbers, the concentration index and the dominant share, and by behavior: Lakeview Health System is included in every major commercial insurer's network, while the smaller hospitals are sometimes excluded, which suggests that insurers cannot build a marketable network without the dominant system but can without others. Measuring concentration before classifying the market ties the classification to evidence rather than impression.
Entry Barriers Specific to Health Care
Entry into the hospital market is difficult for reasons specific to health care. The state has a certificate of need law requiring approval before new hospitals or major expansions can be built, and existing hospitals can oppose applications. Building a hospital requires hundreds of millions of dollars in capital. A new hospital needs a medical staff, and physicians in the metro are increasingly employed by the existing systems, which limits their availability. Insurers must include a new hospital in their networks for it to attract commercial patients, and they may be reluctant if their contracts with the dominant system discourage it. And licensing and accreditation take time. These barriers protect existing hospitals from new competitors.
Structure Converted Into Pricing Power
Concentration matters because it affects prices. Cooper et al. (2019), using claims data on privately insured patients across the United States, found that hospital prices varied widely across and within markets, and that hospitals in monopoly markets had prices about 12% higher than those in markets with four or more hospitals, after accounting for other factors. In the Lakeview metro, the dominant system's position gives it bargaining power with insurers: an insurer that excludes it would lose members, so it accepts higher rates. Commercial prices at Lakeview Health System, based on publicly posted price transparency files, are about 20% higher than at Northgate Regional for common procedures such as joint replacement and childbirth. The smaller hospitals have less leverage and accept lower rates to stay in networks.
Recommendations the Structure Supports
The recommendations depend on the reader. For St. Anne Medical Center, the second-largest hospital, the structure supports building strength in specialized services where it can be essential to insurers' networks, such as its cardiac program, and pursuing partnerships with independent physician groups. For County General, the structure supports seeking state support for its safety-net role rather than competing on commercial price. For an insurer, the structure supports tiered network products that give members lower cost-sharing at lower-priced hospitals, creating price competition within the concentrated market. For state policy makers, it supports careful review of any merger involving the dominant system, since further concentration would likely raise prices. Recommendations that follow from the structure are more useful than general advice, because they reflect what each party can realistically do in this market.
How the Structure Could Change
The market's structure is not fixed. If the dominant system acquired Westside Community Hospital, its share would rise to about 50%, and the concentration index would rise to about 3,446, a change large enough that federal antitrust agencies would be likely to review it closely. If a new freestanding emergency and short-stay facility opened, it might take some low-acuity admissions but would not change the structure for complex care. And if the state repealed its certificate of need law, entry would become easier, though capital and physician barriers would remain. Tracking these possibilities helps each party anticipate how its position might change.
Limits of the Analysis
The analysis uses admission shares, which may not fully reflect competition for specific services. A hospital with a small overall share may dominate a particular service, such as obstetrics in part of the metro. It also treats the metro as one market, although some patients travel to an academic medical center outside the metro for complex care, which provides some outside competition for high-end services. And price comparisons from transparency files depend on how hospitals report their negotiated rates, which is not always consistent.
Conclusion
The Lakeview metro hospital market, defined as inpatient care for commercially insured patients, is highly concentrated, with an index of about 3,078 and a dominant system holding nearly half of admissions. Health care-specific entry barriers protect the existing hospitals, and the structure gives the dominant system pricing power consistent with national evidence. Recommendations differ for each party, but all follow from the structure.
References
Cooper, Z., Craig, S. V., Gaynor, M., & Van Reenen, J. (2019). The price ain't right? Hospital prices and health spending on the privately insured. The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 134(1), 51-107.
Reading the BHA-FPX3112 Assessment 3 instructions
The final assessment asks you to analyze the market structure in which a health care organization competes and draw strategic recommendations. You define the market by geography and service, identify competitors with their size and ownership, classify the structure, such as oligopoly or monopolistic competition, measure concentration where possible, explain barriers to entry such as certificate of need laws and capital costs, analyze how structure affects pricing and recommend strategies. Market share data can come from state hospital associations, CMS cost reports or published studies. The Federal Trade Commission's guidance on concentration measures supports the analysis. The recommendations should follow from the structure rather than general strategy advice.
Inside the BHA FPX 3112 Assessment 3 example
The example is organized as a market assessment with a decision at the end. It opens with the organization and the market it operates in, defined by geography and service scope. A competitor section identifies who else is in that market, with size, ownership type and service overlap. The structure section then classifies the market using stated criteria, seller count, differentiation, entry conditions and buyer power, and defends the classification against the nearest alternative. An entry and exit section covers what it would take for a new provider to appear and what stops one. Consequences follow: what this structure does to prices, to payer negotiations and to the ability of the organization to differentiate. The close gives two or three recommendations that fit the structure, each tied to something established earlier.
BHA FPX 3112 Assessment 3 scoring guide: what Distinguished looks like
The criteria cover the market definition, the competitor analysis, the structure classification, the barriers, the pricing analysis and the recommendations. The definition reaches Distinguished when geography and services are bounded. Competitors score higher when named with size, ownership and share. Classification earns credit when defended with a concentration measure. Barriers should be specific to health care, such as certificate of need rules, physician relationships and payer contracts. Pricing analysis should connect structure to negotiated rates with commercial insurers. Recommendations should fit the structure, such as partnering rather than competing on price in a concentrated market. Writing and APA are graded.
Common BHA FPX 3112 Assessment 3 mistakes, and how to avoid them
Students often describe competitors without measuring concentration, which leaves the structure classification unsupported and easy to challenge. Another common mistake is defining the market too broadly, such as the whole state, when patients mostly use hospitals within a short drive. Barriers are generic, such as high costs, rather than specific rules like certificate of need laws and relationships like employed physician networks. Pricing power is asserted without linking it to structure or to evidence on negotiated commercial rates. Recommendations are generic strategy advice that would fit any market. Data sources are unnamed or outdated, though market share shifts after every merger. A simple table of competitors, beds, market share and ownership, followed by the concentration calculation, gives the report a solid base and lets the reader check the classification.
Get a BHA FPX 3112 Assessment 3 example written to your instructions
Send the assessment instructions and the scoring guide from your courseroom, plus the organization and market you are reporting on. We write a custom BHA FPX 3112 Assessment 3 example to those criteria, with the competitor set and the structure worked for that market, and return it in 24 to 48 hours. The first custom sample is free. The paper above is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Capella University document.
More BHA FPX 3112 papers and BS in Health Care Administration samples
- BHA FPX 3112 Assessment 1: Economic Concept Application
- BHA FPX 3112 Assessment 2: Supply and Demand Analysis
- BHA FPX 4020 Assessment 3: Implementation Plan
- BHA FPX 3108 Assessment 3: Outcomes and Measurement Plan
- BHA FPX 4104 Assessment 3: Strategic Workforce Report
- BHA FPX 3010 Assessment 3: Research Proposal
BHA FPX 3112 Assessment 3 questions, answered
Do I need concentration ratios or an HHI figure?
Only if your instructions ask for them. Where market share data is available, a concentration ratio strengthens the classification because it replaces an impression with a number. Where it is not, the classification can still be defended from seller count, service overlap and entry conditions. The example shows both routes, using approximate shares where sourced and structural reasoning where they are not.
Can I write about the organization I work for?
Yes, and it usually improves the report, since you know the payer mix and the referral patterns that outsiders cannot see. Keep to information that is public or that you are permitted to discuss, and describe internal detail generally where needed. Competitor figures should come from public filings, state data or news coverage so a grader can verify what the report claims.
How current do the competitor figures need to be?
Recent enough that the structure described still exists, which in healthcare means watching for mergers, closures and system acquisitions in the last few years. A market called competitive on figures from before two systems merged will read as careless. The example dates each figure and notes any pending transaction that would change the classification if it completes.
Where can I find a free BHA FPX 3112 Assessment 3 sample paper?
This page holds the full hospital market structure report, with named competitors, concentration, entry barriers, pricing power and recommendations. A custom report for another market is available free.
How do I measure market concentration in BHA FPX 3112 Assessment 3?
Use the Herfindahl-Hirschman Index: square each competitor's market share and add the results. Federal guidelines treat higher values as more concentrated markets.