| Course | BHA FPX 4020 Health Care Administration Capstone Project |
|---|---|
| Assessment | Assessment 2 |
| Paper type | Root cause and options analysis |
| Length | About 1,080 words, 5 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Capella University |
| Program | BS in Health Care Administration |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for BHA FPX 4020 Assessment 2
Analyzing Why Patients Leave the Emergency Department Without Being Seen: A Named Method, the Root Cause, and Three Options Scored on Criteria Set First
Student Name
Capella University
BHA FPX 4020: Health Care Administration Capstone Project
Instructor Name
Month Day, Year
The Problem Restated
At Brookside Hospital, a composite community hospital, the share of emergency visits ending before any provider evaluation stands at 6.8%, more than three times the 2% goal set by department leaders. Departures climb steeply once patients have waited an hour and a half after triage for a room, a delay that is most common between early afternoon and late evening.
A Named Method, Worked Visibly
The analysis uses two linked tools. The first is a cause-and-effect diagram, which sorts possible causes into categories, followed by the five whys technique, which asks "why" repeatedly to move from a symptom to its underlying cause. Both were worked over two sessions with a team of emergency department nurses, physicians, a registration supervisor, and the inpatient bed manager, using data from the tracking system. Cause-and-effect categories. People: 3.5 vacant nursing positions; afternoon shifts often short one nurse. Process: all patients, regardless of acuity, wait for a treatment room before being seen by a provider; no provider is assigned to triage. Environment: an average of seven of 28 treatment spaces occupied by boarded inpatients during the afternoon and evening. Equipment and technology: the tracking system shows waiting times but does not alert anyone when waits exceed 60 minutes. Policies: the hospital does not move boarded patients to inpatient hallways when units are full. Five whys, starting from the symptom. Why do patients leave? Because they wait too long without any evaluation or explanation of the delay. Why do they wait too long? Because no treatment room is available. Why is no room available? Because rooms are occupied by boarded inpatients and by lower-acuity patients whose care could be done elsewhere. Why are rooms occupied this way? Because the department's process places every patient in a room before a provider sees them, and boarded patients remain until inpatient beds open. Why does the process require a room for every patient? Because the department's model was designed when volumes were lower, and it has not been redesigned for current volumes and boarding. Working the method visibly lets the reader follow the reasoning from symptom to cause, rather than accepting a cause named without support.
Contributing Factors Separated From the Root
Several factors contribute, but they are not all the root cause. Nursing vacancies contribute by reducing the number of rooms that can be staffed. Boarding contributes by reducing the number of rooms available. The lack of wait-time alerts contributes by allowing long waits to go unnoticed. The root cause, identified through the five whys, is the department's front-end model, which requires every patient to wait for a treatment room before a provider evaluates them. Even with full nursing staff and less boarding, a model that sends every patient to a room would still produce long waits at peak times. Changing the model addresses the root; filling vacancies and reducing boarding address contributing factors.
How the Findings Compare With Other Hospitals
The pattern at Brookside fits what has been reported elsewhere. Hsia et al. (2011) found that rates of leaving without being seen varied widely among hospitals and were associated with hospital characteristics rather than only with patient behavior, which supports looking for causes in the department's operations. Brookside's afternoon and evening peak, when boarding and staffing shortages coincide, shows the same principle: patients leave when the system cannot see them promptly, not because they are unusually impatient.
Criteria Set Before Options Are Scored
The team set criteria and weights before identifying options, so that the scoring could not be shaped to favor an option someone already preferred: expected effect on the rate of leaving without being seen (35%), safety for higher-acuity patients (25%), cost (20%), feasibility within six months (10%), and staff acceptance (10%).
Three Options at Equal Detail
Option 1, provider in triage. A physician or advanced practice provider works at triage from noon to midnight, evaluating patients on arrival, ordering tests, and treating and discharging lower-acuity patients in a separate area where they wait for results, with no treatment room needed. Cost: about 320,000 dollars a year for an advanced practice provider for 12 hours a day. Effect: patients are seen soon after arrival, removing the long wait that drives most departures. Option 2, hire nurses to fill vacancies and add a boarding nurse. Fill the 3.5 vacant positions and add a dedicated nurse to care for boarded patients, freeing emergency nurses to staff more rooms. Cost: about 420,000 dollars a year, including recruitment incentives. Effect: more rooms staffed, but patients still wait for a room before any evaluation. Option 3, inpatient hallway placement policy. When the emergency department has more than five boarded patients, admitted patients are moved to inpatient unit hallways to wait for beds, freeing emergency rooms. Cost: low, about 30,000 dollars for equipment and training. Effect: frees rooms at peak times, but depends on inpatient units' cooperation and raises nursing and patient concerns about hallway care.
A Selection You Can Trace
Scored on the criteria from 1 to 5: Option 1 scores 5 on effect, 4 on safety, 3 on cost, 4 on feasibility, and 3 on acceptance, for a weighted score of 4.05. Option 2 scores 3, 4, 2, 2, and 4, for 3.05. Option 3 scores 3, 3, 5, 3, and 2, for 3.30. Option 1 is selected because it addresses the root cause, the front-end model, and scores highest. The selection can be traced from the root cause to the option that changes it, and from the criteria to the scores. Options 2 and 3 address contributing factors and may be pursued later as complements. Filling nursing vacancies remains necessary regardless, since the new model still needs nurses to staff treatment rooms for higher-acuity patients, and reducing boarding would further increase the number of rooms available at peak times. The selection does not dismiss these problems; it identifies which change will have the largest effect on the problem the capstone set out to solve.
Conclusion
A cause-and-effect diagram and the five whys, worked visibly, identify the department's front-end model as the root cause, with nursing vacancies, boarding, and missing alerts as contributing factors. With criteria set first and three options described equally, placing a provider in triage scores highest and addresses the root cause.
References
Hsia, R. Y., Asch, S. M., Weiss, R. E., Zingmond, D., Liang, L.-J., Han, W., McCreath, H., & Sun, B. C. (2011). Hospital determinants of emergency department left without being seen rates. Annals of Emergency Medicine, 58(1), 24-32. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.annemergmed.2011.01.009
What the BHA FPX 4020 Assessment 2 instructions ask for
The instructions ask you to analyze the root cause of your capstone problem and evaluate options to address it. You restate the problem, apply a named analysis method such as a fishbone diagram or the five whys, separate contributing factors from the root cause, compare findings with evidence from other organizations, set evaluation criteria, develop several options in equal detail, score them and select one. Criteria should be set before options are scored, so the selection is fair. Evidence from literature and benchmarking supports both the analysis and the options. The selected option becomes the implementation plan in Assessment 3.
How the BHA-FPX4020 Assessment 2 example is put together
The example runs cause first, options second, decision last. It opens with a short restatement of the problem so the reader does not have to hold the first assessment in memory. The root cause section names the analysis method, works through it, and presents the causes with the evidence behind each one. A transition paragraph identifies which cause the project will address and why that one. The options section then introduces the alternatives, each described at the same level of detail so none is a straw man. Criteria are defined next, with a reason for each, and then applied to every option in a table or in parallel passages. The recommendation section states the selected option, ties it to the criteria, and names what the implementation assessment will have to work out.
Reading the BHA FPX 4020 Assessment 2 scoring guide
Faculty grade the method, the root cause, the comparison with evidence, the criteria, the options and the selection. The method reaches Distinguished when named and worked visibly, for example a fishbone diagram with categories for staffing, process, space and information. The root cause scores higher when separated from contributing factors and defended against rival explanations. Comparison with other hospitals earns credit, since benchmarking shows whether the cause is unusual. Criteria should be set before options, such as cost, time to implement and expected effect on the walkout rate. Options should be developed at equal detail, so the comparison is fair. The selection must follow from the scoring rather than from preference, and the paper should show that link in a sentence.
BHA FPX 4020 Assessment 2 help: mistakes that cost marks
Students often jump from problem to solution without a real root cause analysis, which the capstone scoring guide treats as a gap. Another common mistake is naming a method without showing it, so the reader cannot follow the reasoning. Contributing factors, such as a busy Monday, are presented as the root cause. Criteria are chosen after the preferred option, which biases the result. One option is developed in detail and the others are straw men. The selection cannot be traced to the scoring. Evidence from other hospitals is left out. A scoring table with criteria as rows and options as columns makes the selection transparent, and a sentence on why the losing options lost shows fairness.
Get a BHA FPX 4020 Assessment 2 example written to your instructions
Send the assessment instructions and the scoring guide from your courseroom, along with the problem definition you submitted for the first assessment. We write a custom BHA FPX 4020 Assessment 2 example to those criteria, with causes and options traced back to your own problem, and return it in 24 to 48 hours. The first custom sample is free. The paper above is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Capella University document.
More BHA FPX 4020 papers and BS in Health Care Administration samples
- BHA FPX 4020 Assessment 1: Problem Definition
- BHA FPX 4020 Assessment 3: Implementation Plan
- BHA FPX 4020 Assessment 4: Capstone Presentation
- BHA FPX 4104 Assessment 2: Recruitment and Retention Plan
- BHA FPX 3112 Assessment 2: Supply and Demand Analysis
- BHA FPX 2002 Assessment 2: Comparative Analysis
- BHA FPX 3108 Assessment 2: Management Strategy
BHA FPX 4020 Assessment 2 questions, answered
How many options do I need to compare?
Three is the usual expectation, and it is enough to show selection rather than justification of a decision already made. What matters more than the count is that every option is genuinely viable and described at the same depth. The example builds three real candidates and scores each against every criterion, so the reader can see why the winner won.
Which root cause method should the analysis use?
Any recognized method works if the reasoning is shown. Fishbone diagrams suit problems with several contributing categories, five whys suits a single causal chain, and driver diagrams suit improvement work with measurable drivers. The method matters less than the evidence attached to each cause. The example names its method, works through it in the text and cites what supports each branch.
Can my recommendation change from what I originally planned?
Yes, and a changed recommendation often reads as stronger work, because it shows the criteria were applied rather than decorated. What has to hold is the chain: the option you select must address the root cause you identified, and the implementation assessment then plans that option. Tell your faculty if the change affects work you have already submitted.
Where can I find a free BHA FPX 4020 Assessment 2 sample paper?
This page holds the full root cause and options analysis for ED walkouts, with the named method, root cause, benchmarks, criteria, three options and a traceable selection. A custom analysis is available free.
How many options should BHA FPX 4020 Assessment 2 include?
Usually three, developed at equal detail and scored on criteria set in advance. Fewer than three makes the comparison thin; more than four makes it hard to develop each fairly.