BHA FPX 2002 Assessment 2 comparative analysis example

Reviewed by Rupert Danvers, MBA Evolution of Healthcare Delivery in the United States Capella University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This BHA FPX 2002 Assessment 2 sample paper is a comparative analysis of two Medicare payment reforms: the 1983 prospective payment system and the 2012 Hospital Readmissions Reduction Program. It belongs to Capella BHA FPX 2002, Evolution of Healthcare Delivery in the United States, which BS in Health Care Administration students take as BHA-FPX2002. The paper names both subjects at the start, justifies its dimensions before using them and compares point by point on the problem addressed, the mechanism, the effect on hospital behavior and unintended consequences. It gives equal evidence to both reforms and reaches a judgment in its synthesis about what payment reform can and cannot do.

CourseBHA FPX 2002 Evolution of Healthcare Delivery in the United States
AssessmentAssessment 2
Paper typeComparative analysis paper
LengthAbout 1,080 words, 5 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolCapella University
ProgramBS in Health Care Administration
UpdatedSeptember 2026

Free sample paper for BHA FPX 2002 Assessment 2

1

Two Medicare Payment Reforms Compared: The 1983 Prospective Payment System and the 2012 Hospital Readmissions Reduction Program

Student Name

Capella University

BHA FPX 2002: Evolution of Healthcare Delivery in the United States

Instructor Name

Month Day, Year

What this part is doingThe title names both subjects. Comparison papers are judged on whether they compare throughout, so both reforms appear together from the start.
2

Both Subjects Named

This paper compares two Medicare payment reforms that changed how US hospitals operate: the inpatient prospective payment system, enacted in 1983, which paid hospitals a fixed amount per admission based on diagnosis, and the Hospital Readmissions Reduction Program, created by the Affordable Care Act and applied to payments beginning in October 2012, which reduces payments to hospitals with more readmissions than expected. Both reforms tried to change hospital behavior through payment, but they targeted different problems and used different mechanisms.

Dimensions Justified Before They Are Used

The comparison uses four dimensions, chosen because they explain how a payment reform works and what it achieves. The problem addressed matters because reforms are designed around a specific concern. The mechanism matters because it determines what hospitals are rewarded or penalized for. The effect on hospital behavior matters because that is the purpose of a payment reform. Unintended consequences matter because every payment rule creates incentives that its designers did not intend. Using the same dimensions for both reforms makes the comparison fair.

Problem Addressed

The prospective payment system addressed rising cost. Before 1983, Medicare paid hospitals on the basis of their reasonable costs, which gave hospitals little reason to control spending, since higher costs brought higher payments. Mayes (2007) describes how rapid growth in Medicare hospital spending, together with concerns about the program's finances, led Congress to adopt a payment method based on diagnosis-related groups. The readmission program addressed a quality and cost problem at the point of transition from hospital to home. About one in five Medicare patients hospitalized for common conditions was being readmitted within 30 days, and many readmissions were thought to be preventable through better discharge planning and follow-up. McIlvennan et al. (2015) describe the program's origins in concern about these readmissions. Both reforms, then, responded to concerns about Medicare spending, but the first targeted the cost of each admission while the second targeted what happened after discharge.

Mechanism

Under prospective payment, Medicare pays a predetermined amount for each admission, based on the diagnosis-related group, adjusted for local wages and other factors. If a hospital treats the patient for less than the payment, it keeps the difference; if it spends more, it absorbs the loss. The mechanism rewards efficiency within each stay and leaves quality to other rules. Under the readmission program, Medicare compares each hospital's readmission rates for selected conditions, initially heart attack, heart failure, and pneumonia, with expected rates adjusted for patient characteristics. Hospitals with excess readmissions have their base Medicare payments reduced, by up to 3% (McIlvennan et al., 2015). The mechanism penalizes poor performance on a specific outcome. The mechanisms differ in a basic way: prospective payment set the price of each unit of care, while the readmission program adjusted payment according to results after the unit of care ended. Comparing mechanisms side by side shows that one reform changed what a hospital stay was worth, while the other changed what a hospital stay's aftermath cost.

What this part is doingEach dimension discusses both reforms together. Scorers reward comparisons that proceed point by point rather than as two separate essays.
3

Effect on Hospital Behavior

Prospective payment had a large and rapid effect. Hospitals shortened lengths of stay, invested in cost accounting, and shifted some care to outpatient settings, which were not paid under the new system. Mayes (2007) describes it as one of the most significant changes in Medicare's history. The readmission program also changed behavior. Hospitals invested in discharge planning, follow-up calls, and partnerships with post-acute providers. Zuckerman et al. (2016) found that readmission rates for the targeted conditions declined faster than rates for other conditions after the law was passed, and that the decline was not explained by increased use of observation stays.

Unintended Consequences

Prospective payment created an incentive to discharge patients sooner, raising concern about patients leaving the hospital before they were ready, and it encouraged hospitals to classify patients into higher-paying diagnosis groups. The readmission program raised concerns that hospitals serving poorer patients were penalized for factors outside their control, and that hospitals might place returning patients in observation status to avoid counting readmissions. Later changes to the readmission program compared hospitals with peers serving similar shares of low-income patients to address the first concern. In both cases, the unintended consequences did not undo the reform but required later adjustments, showing that payment rules are revised continually as hospitals respond to them. Administrators who understand this cycle can prepare for adjustments rather than being surprised by them.

What the Comparison Shows About Payment Reform

Placing the two reforms side by side shows a pattern in Medicare policy. Each reform solved one problem while creating incentives that later reforms had to address. Prospective payment controlled the cost of each stay but encouraged shorter stays and shifting care to settings outside the payment system. Later programs, including the readmission program, responded partly to the fragmentation that shorter stays and faster discharges produced. For administrators, the lesson is that payment rules change over time in response to the behavior earlier rules created, so an organization's strategy must anticipate the next reform, not only respond to the current one.

What this part is doingThe paper draws a broader lesson from the comparison. Scorers reward comparisons that yield insight beyond the two cases themselves.
4

Equal Evidence on Both Sides

Each reform is supported here by a scholarly source on its history and design and by evidence of its effects: Mayes (2007) for prospective payment, and McIlvennan et al. (2015) and Zuckerman et al. (2016) for the readmission program. Neither reform is presented with evidence of success while the other is described only by its intentions.

A Synthesis That Reaches a Judgment

The comparison supports a judgment: prospective payment was the more consequential reform, because it changed the basic unit of payment for all Medicare inpatient care and reshaped hospital management, while the readmission program adjusted payment at the margin for a limited set of conditions. However, the readmission program marked a more significant shift in direction, since it tied payment to an outcome after the hospital stay, a principle later extended through value-based purchasing and alternative payment models. Prospective payment made hospitals manage cost; the readmission program began making them responsible for what happens after the patient leaves.

Conclusion

Comparing the two reforms across problem, mechanism, effect, and unintended consequences shows that both used payment to change hospital behavior, but in different ways. The first had the larger immediate effect; the second marked the more important change in direction.

5

References

Mayes, R. (2007). The origins, development, and passage of Medicare's revolutionary prospective payment system. Journal of the History of Medicine and Allied Sciences, 62(1), 21-55.

McIlvennan, C. K., Eapen, Z. J., & Allen, L. A. (2015). Hospital readmissions reduction program. Circulation, 131(20), 1796-1803. https://doi.org/10.1161/circulationaha.114.010270

Zuckerman, R. B., Sheingold, S. H., Orav, E. J., Ruhter, J., & Epstein, A. M. (2016). Readmissions, observation, and the Hospital Readmissions Reduction Program. New England Journal of Medicine, 374(16), 1543-1551.

Reading the BHA-FPX2002 Assessment 2 instructions

The instructions ask you to compare two developments, eras or systems in US health care delivery. You identify both subjects, choose dimensions for comparison and explain why, compare the subjects dimension by dimension, support each side with comparable evidence and reach a judgment about what the comparison shows. The comparison should be integrated rather than written as two separate essays. Common pairs include two payment reforms, two eras of hospital care or the US and another country's approach to a problem. A table can hold the facts while the prose interprets them. Several credible sources are expected, balanced across both subjects. The judgment at the end is what turns a comparison into analysis.

Inside the BHA FPX 2002 Assessment 2 example

The example is organized around the dimensions rather than around the subjects. It opens by naming both subjects and stating the basis of comparison, then devotes a short section to justifying why those particular dimensions were chosen, which is the move most papers skip. Each body section then takes one dimension and treats both subjects inside it, in the same order every time, with sources for each. After the dimensions are exhausted, a synthesis section states the pattern that the point-by-point work exposed and answers the question the comparison exists to answer. A brief limitation paragraph acknowledges what the comparison cannot show, and the conclusion returns to a management consequence rather than restating the body. Because every section keeps the same internal order, a reader can check the balance of the paper at a glance.

Reading the BHA FPX 2002 Assessment 2 scoring guide

The scoring guide rates the identification of subjects, the choice of dimensions, the comparison, the balance of evidence and the synthesis. Dimensions reach Distinguished when justified before they are used, which is the move most papers skip. The comparison scores higher when organized point by point, so every dimension treats both subjects. Balance earns credit when each subject gets similar evidence, not one detailed and one sketched. The synthesis rewards a clear judgment about what the comparison reveals, such as the limits of changing behavior through payment alone. Unintended consequences show depth. APA formatting and clear writing are graded. The margin notes show where each of these moves happens.

BHA FPX 2002 Assessment 2 help: mistakes that cost marks

The most common mistake is writing two essays, one per subject, joined by a comparison paragraph. Another is choosing dimensions without explaining why they matter. Evidence is uneven, with rich detail on one subject and generalities on the other. The conclusion summarizes rather than judges. Some students compare subjects so different that the comparison yields little. Tables are sometimes used instead of analysis rather than alongside it. Keep dimensions to three or four and treat both subjects inside each one in the same order.

Get a BHA FPX 2002 Assessment 2 example written to your instructions

Send the Assessment 2 instructions and the scoring guide from your BHA FPX 2002 courseroom, along with the two eras or systems you have been asked to compare. We write a custom example against those criteria, with the dimensions matched on both sides, and return it in 24 to 48 hours. The first custom sample is free. The paper above is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Capella University document.

More BHA FPX 2002 papers and BS in Health Care Administration samples

BHA FPX 2002 Assessment 2 questions, answered

Can I compare the United States system with another country?

Often yes, if your instructions allow an international comparison rather than requiring two American eras. Cross-country work is harder because the sources report different measures, so pick a country with accessible published data and be explicit about what does not translate. If the instructions name the two subjects, use those and do not substitute.

Do I need a comparison table in BHA FPX 2002 Assessment 2?

A table is not usually required and it never replaces the analysis. When a table appears in the example it holds the raw facts so the prose can spend its space on interpretation, which keeps the body from turning into a list. If you include one, label it properly, cite inside the cells, and make sure every row is discussed in the text.

How is Assessment 2 different from Assessment 1 in this course?

The first assessment typically establishes one development and the conditions behind it, working in a single line. The second sets two subjects against shared dimensions and has to reach a judgment between them. The research is similar, the reasoning is not, and reusing an Assessment 1 paper with a second subject bolted on is the fastest way to miss the comparison criterion.

What should I compare in BHA FPX 2002 Assessment 2?

Two developments, eras or approaches that address a similar problem, such as two Medicare payment reforms or two ways of financing hospitals, so the comparison can reach a judgment about what worked.

Where can I find a free BHA FPX 2002 Assessment 2 sample paper?

This page holds the full comparison of Medicare's prospective payment system and the readmissions reduction program, with justified dimensions, balanced evidence and a judgment. A custom comparison is available free.