| Course | BUS FPX 2012 Leadership Fundamentals |
|---|---|
| Assessment | Assessment 1 |
| Paper type | Leadership incident analysis |
| Length | About 1,060 words, 5 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Capella University |
| Program | BS in Business |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for BUS FPX 2012 Assessment 1
One Leadership Incident, Narrowly Drawn: A Shift Supervisor Introducing Handheld Scanners in a Warehouse
Student Name
Capella University
BUS FPX 2012: Leadership Fundamentals
Instructor Name
Month Day, Year
One Incident, Narrowly Drawn
The incident took place over three weeks at a composite regional distribution warehouse that supplies grocery stores. The warehouse introduced handheld scanners for order picking, replacing paper pick lists. The evening shift supervisor, responsible for 22 order pickers, was asked to have the shift fully using the scanners within three weeks. The incident is limited to those three weeks and that one shift, so that the analysis can be specific. It does not include the company's decision to buy the scanners, the day shift's experience, or events after the three weeks.
Resistance Established First
Before examining the supervisor's leadership, it is necessary to establish what the supervisor faced. The resistance had three sources. Experienced pickers doubted the scanners would help. Several had worked at the warehouse for more than ten years and were among the fastest pickers using paper lists. They believed the scanners would slow them down, because the paper list let them see the whole order and plan their route, while the scanner showed one item at a time. Pickers feared being monitored. The scanners recorded each pick with a time stamp and the picker's identification, and pickers believed management would use the data to discipline slower workers. One picker said at a shift meeting that the scanners were "a stopwatch on a belt." The scanners had technical problems in the first week. The wireless network had dead spots in two aisles, and scanners lost connection, forcing pickers to restart orders. Yukl (2013) describes resistance to change as often rational, arising from people's concerns about how the change will affect them, rather than simple unwillingness. Establishing the resistance first allows the supervisor's actions to be judged against what they actually faced. Establishing resistance first sets the standard for judging leadership, since influence only matters where there was something to overcome.
Influence Argued From What Was Done
The supervisor's influence is argued from specific actions, not from general descriptions of style, because what a leader does is observable while labels for style are not. The supervisor started with the most skeptical picker, the fastest on the shift, and asked for help testing the scanner on real orders for two nights. The picker found that the scanner's suggested route was sometimes worse than his own, and the supervisor reported this to the systems team, who adjusted the route settings. The picker then told others that the scanner "wasn't as dumb as we thought." The supervisor addressed the monitoring fear directly. At a shift meeting, the supervisor explained what data the scanners recorded, and obtained a written statement from the operations manager that pick rates would not be used for discipline during the first 90 days. The supervisor posted the statement in the break room. The supervisor logged every connection failure on a sheet by the dock and sent it to the information technology team each morning. When the team added two wireless access points in week two, the supervisor announced it at the start of the shift and credited the pickers who had reported the dead spots. The supervisor worked the floor for the first hour of every shift, helping pickers with scanner problems rather than supervising from the office. Being present showed that the supervisor was willing to share the frustration of the early days, and it gave pickers a chance to raise problems on the spot instead of saving them for a complaint after work. These actions used several influence tactics that Yukl (2013) describes: consultation, by involving the skeptical picker; rational persuasion, by showing route changes and data; and building trust, by obtaining the written commitment on monitoring. By the end of week three, 20 of 22 pickers were using scanners for all orders, and the shift's error rate, wrong items picked, had fallen from 1.1% to 0.4%. Pick speed, which pickers had feared would fall, returned to its pre-scanner level by the end of week two, which the supervisor shared at a shift meeting as evidence that the early fears had not come true.
The Part That Failed Reported
Not everything worked. Two pickers never fully adopted the scanners during the three weeks. Both were older workers who struggled with the small screen and buttons, and one had difficulty reading the display in the warehouse's dim aisles. The supervisor treated their slower adoption as resistance at first, pressing them at shift meetings, which embarrassed them in front of coworkers. Only in week three did the supervisor recognize that their problem was physical, not attitudinal, and request scanners with larger displays, which had not arrived by the end of the period. The supervisor's influence tactics, built around persuading skeptics, did not fit a problem that was about the tool itself. Reporting this failure is important because it shows the limits of the approach that worked for most of the shift. Reporting the part that failed makes the analysis credible and shows where the leader's approach needed to change.
What the Incident Shows About Leading Change
The incident shows several features of leading change at the front line. The supervisor had no authority over the scanner decision, the technology, or the monitoring policy, but influenced all three by relaying concerns upward and returning with answers. The supervisor's credibility came from working alongside pickers rather than from position. And the most effective step was involving the strongest skeptic, whose endorsement carried more weight with coworkers than anything the supervisor could say. These features suggest that front-line leadership during change is less about persuading people to accept a decision and more about making the decision work for them.
Nobody Identified
The analysis identifies no one by name. The supervisor, pickers, operations manager, and information technology staff are described by role only. The incident is a composite, and even in a real case, naming individuals would be unnecessary for the analysis and unfair to people who cannot respond.
Conclusion
Over three weeks, an evening shift supervisor moved 20 of 22 pickers onto handheld scanners, overcoming skepticism, fear of monitoring, and technical problems through consultation, persuasion, and trust building. The approach failed for two pickers whose problem was physical rather than attitudinal, a lesson the supervisor learned late.
References
Yukl, G. (2013). Leadership in organizations (8th ed.). Pearson.
BUS FPX 2012 Assessment 1 instructions, in plain terms
The first assessment in BUS FPX 2012 asks you to analyze one leadership incident from your own work life. You describe the incident, the people involved and the challenge, explain how the leader tried to influence others, evaluate what worked and what did not, and connect the incident to leadership concepts. The incident should be narrow enough to analyze in detail, such as one change introduced on one team, rather than a whole career. Resistance or tension makes the analysis richer. Leadership texts and research on influence and change support the paper, and at least one scholarly source should be used. The incident carries through the theory application and personal plan that follow, so choose one you remember in detail.
How the BUS-FPX2012 Assessment 1 example is put together
Incident, resistance, influence, limit. The opening sets the incident with the detail that makes it analyzable: who wanted what, who did not, and what the constraint was. The second block establishes the resistance specifically, saying what the person stood to lose, since resistance with no reason behind it reads as invented. The third identifies the influence that changed the outcome and argues it from what was said and done rather than from the leader's manner. A fourth block reports what failed, an attempt that landed badly or a person who was never persuaded, which is where the analysis earns its credibility. The closing states what the incident shows about influence in this setting. Headings follow the prompt and individuals stay unidentifiable.
Where the marks sit in the BUS FPX 2012 Assessment 1 scoring guide
Faculty grade the incident description, the analysis of resistance, the analysis of influence, the evaluation of outcomes and the use of concepts. The incident reaches Distinguished when narrowly drawn with who wanted what, who resisted and what constrained the leader. Resistance scores higher when described specifically, such as experienced pickers fearing the scanners would be used to track their speed. Influence earns credit when argued from what the supervisor actually did, like demonstrating the scanner on her own shift first. Reporting the part that failed shows honesty. Concepts should be applied rather than defined. Keeping people anonymous is expected, even in a small workplace.
BUS FPX 2012 Assessment 1 help from the desk
Students often choose an incident too broad to analyze, such as a manager's leadership style over several years. Another common mistake is describing what a good leader should have done instead of what actually happened. Resistance is mentioned in a sentence without explaining its cause. Influence tactics are named from a textbook without evidence from the incident. The outcome is presented as a complete success. Concepts appear only in the introduction. Coworkers are identifiable. Staying with one incident and asking what the leader did, how people responded and why, produces the strongest analysis and sets up the theory comparison.
Get a BUS FPX 2012 Assessment 1 example written to your instructions
Send the Assessment 1 instructions and the scoring guide from your BUS FPX 2012 courseroom, along with the incident you have in mind. We write a custom example against those exact criteria and return it in 24 to 48 hours. The first custom sample is free, and it shows how narrow an incident has to be to actually be analyzable. The paper above is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Capella University document.
More BUS FPX 2012 papers and BS in Business samples
- BUS FPX 2012 Assessment 2: Theory Application Paper
- BUS FPX 2012 Assessment 3: Personal Leadership Plan
- BUS FPX 2021 Assessment 1: Case Analysis
- BUS FPX 2007 Assessment 1: Business Analysis
- BUS FPX 2030 Assessment 1: Market Analysis
- BUS FPX 1050 Assessment 1: Marginal Analysis
BUS FPX 2012 Assessment 1 questions, answered
What if I have never been a leader?
The assessment does not require you to be one. An incident you watched, or one where somebody influenced you, works as well and is often described more honestly. What the criteria want is a moment with resistance in it that you can describe closely, and being the person who resisted gives you unusually good access to that.
How small can the incident be?
Very small. One conversation where somebody changed their mind is enough, and is usually better than a project spanning months. Small incidents can be described in detail, and detail is what the analysis runs on. Broad accounts force the paper into generalities the criteria do not reward.
Can I write about a leader I only know about publicly?
Where your instructions allow it, though the difficulty is access to the moment. Published accounts rarely record what was said in the room, so the resistance and the influence both become inference. An incident you witnessed gives you the specifics that make this analysis work.
Where can I find a free BUS FPX 2012 Assessment 1 sample paper?
This page contains the full analysis of a warehouse scanner rollout led by a shift supervisor, with resistance, influence from actions, the failed part and lessons. An analysis of your own incident can be requested through the form.
What kind of incident works for BUS FPX 2012 Assessment 1?
A single, specific event where someone tried to influence others, ideally with some resistance, such as introducing a new process, resolving a conflict or leading a short project. It should be narrow enough to analyze in detail.