| Course | BUS FPX 2012 Leadership Fundamentals |
|---|---|
| Assessment | Assessment 2 |
| Paper type | Leadership theory application |
| Length | About 1,060 words, 5 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Capella University |
| Program | BS in Business |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for BUS FPX 2012 Assessment 2
Two Leadership Theories Tested Against One Incident: Situational and Transformational Leadership in a Warehouse Scanner Rollout
Student Name
Capella University
BUS FPX 2012: Leadership Fundamentals
Instructor Name
Month Day, Year
The Incident
In the composite warehouse incident analyzed earlier, an evening shift supervisor spent three weeks leading 22 order pickers through the introduction of handheld scanners. The supervisor involved the most skeptical experienced picker in testing, secured a written promise from the operations manager that the scanner data would not count against anyone for three months, logged and reported technical problems, and worked the floor during the first hour of each shift. By the end, 20 of 22 pickers used the scanners and errors fell. Two older pickers, who struggled with the small screens, did not fully adopt them; the supervisor at first pressed them as if they were resisting, before recognizing a physical barrier.
Theories as Predictions
A theory is useful if it predicts what will work. Each theory is therefore stated as a prediction about this incident. Situational leadership, proposed by Hersey and Blanchard (1969), holds that the right leadership style depends on followers' readiness: their ability and willingness to do a specific task. Followers who are able but unwilling need a participating style, sharing ideas and facilitating decisions. Followers who are unable but willing need a selling style, explaining decisions and providing clarification. Prediction: the supervisor will succeed if the style matches each picker's readiness for the new task. Transformational leadership, described by Bass (1985), holds that leaders achieve performance beyond expectations through idealized influence, inspirational motivation, intellectual stimulation, and individualized consideration. Prediction: the supervisor will succeed to the extent that these behaviors are present, raising commitment to the change across the shift.
The Same Shape for Both
Each theory is tested in the same way: what it predicts, what happened, and whether the evidence fits. Using one structure for both prevents one theory from being tested against convenient evidence and the other against inconvenient evidence. Situational leadership. The experienced pickers were able but unwilling at first; they had the skill to pick but doubted the scanners. The theory predicts that a participating style would work with them. The supervisor used exactly that approach with the most skeptical picker, involving him in testing and acting on his findings, and it worked: he became an advocate. The two older pickers were willing but unable, because the equipment did not suit them. The theory predicts that a selling style, with explanation and support, would be needed, and possibly a change to the task itself. The supervisor instead pressed them, a style mismatched to their readiness, and it failed. The theory's prediction matched both the success and the failure. Transformational leadership. The theory predicts success where the four behaviors are present. Individualized consideration appeared in the supervisor's attention to the skeptical picker's concerns; idealized influence in working the floor alongside pickers; intellectual stimulation in inviting the picker to challenge the scanner's routes. Inspirational motivation was weak: the supervisor never articulated a vision beyond getting the scanners working. The theory fits the overall success reasonably well, but it does not explain the failure with the two older pickers, since the supervisor's lack of individualized consideration for them is a symptom rather than an explanation of why. Giving both theories the same shape of test makes the comparison fair, since each is judged by the same questions.
Partial Fit Reported Honestly
Neither theory fits perfectly, and forcing the evidence into either would misrepresent what happened. Situational leadership fits the pattern of success and failure well, but its categories are coarse; the two older pickers were not a readiness problem in the usual sense, since their difficulty was with the equipment. Transformational leadership fits the overall success but does not explain why the approach failed with two pickers, and it gives little guidance about adapting style to different individuals within the same change. Reporting partial fit honestly avoids forcing either theory onto the evidence.
The Verdict Argued From Evidence
On this evidence, situational leadership explains the incident better. It predicted both the success with the skeptical picker, where a participating style matched readiness, and the failure with the older pickers, where a pressing style mismatched it. Transformational leadership describes the supervisor's positive behaviors but does not account for the failure. A theory that cannot explain a clear failure in the case it is applied to offers less guidance for the next case, where avoiding such failures is the point. The verdict rests mainly on the failure, which is the more demanding test: a theory that explains both what worked and what did not is more useful than one that explains only what worked.
Why the Comparison Matters in Practice
The comparison is not only academic. A supervisor guided mainly by transformational leadership might focus on inspiring the whole team and miss the individual differences that caused the failure. A supervisor guided by situational leadership would be prompted to assess each picker's readiness and adapt, which is what the incident required. For the warehouse's managers, the lesson is that training supervisors to diagnose individual readiness during a change may be more useful than training them to inspire.
What Neither Explains
Neither theory explains the role of the technical problems, which were a major source of resistance and were resolved not by leadership style but by the supervisor's persistence in reporting them to the information technology team. Neither explains the importance of the written commitment on monitoring, which changed the pickers' calculation of risk rather than their readiness or inspiration. It was a promise about consequences, backed by a manager above the supervisor, and it removed a fear that no leadership style could have dissolved on its own. And neither addresses the organizational context: the supervisor's success depended on an operations manager willing to make the commitment and an information technology team willing to add access points. Leadership theories focused on the leader and followers leave out the system around them. Naming what neither theory explains shows where other explanations, such as organizational support, are needed.
Conclusion
Tested against the same incident, situational leadership explains both the success and the failure better than transformational leadership, which describes the supervisor's positive behaviors but not the failure. Neither theory accounts for the technical fixes, the monitoring commitment, or the organizational support that made the supervisor's leadership effective.
References
Bass, B. M. (1985). Leadership and performance beyond expectations. Free Press.
Hersey, P., & Blanchard, K. H. (1969). Life cycle theory of leadership. Training and Development Journal, 23(5), 26-34.
Reading the BUS-FPX2012 Assessment 2 instructions
The instructions ask you to apply two leadership theories to the incident from Assessment 1 and judge which explains it better. You summarize the incident, explain each theory, state what each would predict about the situation, compare the predictions with what happened, reach a verdict and discuss what neither theory captures. Common theories include situational leadership, transformational leadership, path-goal theory and leader-member exchange. The comparison should be fair and follow the same structure for both theories. Scholarly sources on each theory are expected. The verdict should be argued from evidence in the incident, not from which theory the writer likes.
Inside the BUS FPX 2012 Assessment 2 example
Situation, theory one, theory two, verdict. The opening carries the incident forward in a paragraph rather than retelling it. Each theory then gets a block built the same way: what it claims in a line, what it therefore predicts about this specific situation, and whether that prediction held. The parallel structure is what makes the comparison possible and is worth preserving even where one theory takes longer to explain. A verdict block then argues which explains more, naming the evidence that decides it and conceding what the losing theory still accounts for. The closing states what neither theory explains. Headings name the theories, sources are cited to the originators rather than to a textbook summary where the course expects it, and definitions stay short throughout.
BUS FPX 2012 Assessment 2 scoring guide: what Distinguished looks like
The scoring guide rates the theory explanations, the application, the comparison, the verdict and the limits. Theories reach Distinguished when explained briefly and accurately with sources. Application scores higher when each theory is turned into predictions and tested against events, such as situational leadership predicting a directive style for new scanner users. Comparison earns credit when both theories get the same structure. The verdict should follow from evidence. Reporting partial fit and what neither theory explains shows critical thinking. The practical significance of the verdict, such as how the supervisor should handle the next rollout, connects theory to work. A short table of each theory's predictions beside what actually happened makes the comparison easy to check.
BUS FPX 2012 Assessment 2 help from the desk
Students often describe two theories and then assert that both apply. Another common mistake is applying one theory in depth and the other briefly. Predictions are not stated, so the test is not really a test. The verdict reflects preference rather than evidence. Partial fit is hidden. Limits are missing. Situational leadership, for instance, says little about the trust a supervisor builds over years, and transformational leadership says little about the scanner training schedule. Naming such gaps shows faculty you understand what theories can and cannot do. Sources are textbook summaries only. Writing each theory's predictions as a short list before comparing them to events keeps the analysis honest.
Get a BUS FPX 2012 Assessment 2 example written to your instructions
Send the Assessment 2 instructions and your BUS FPX 2012 scoring guide, plus the incident your first assessment established. We write a custom example against those criteria and return it in 24 to 48 hours. The first custom sample is free, and it shows what a theory looks like when it is made to predict something. The paper above is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Capella University document.
More BUS FPX 2012 papers and BS in Business samples
- BUS FPX 2012 Assessment 1: Leadership Incident Analysis
- BUS FPX 2012 Assessment 3: Personal Leadership Plan
- BUS FPX 2021 Assessment 2: Contract Dispute Memo
- BUS FPX 2007 Assessment 2: Functional Comparison
- BUS FPX 2030 Assessment 2: Marketing Mix Plan
- BUS FPX 1050 Assessment 2: Elasticity Problem Set
BUS FPX 2012 Assessment 2 questions, answered
Which two theories work best together?
Ones that would predict different things about your incident. Pairing two that broadly agree produces a comparison with nothing at stake. A trait based account against a situational one, or a transactional account against a transformational one, will usually disagree about the same events, which is what you need.
What if my preferred theory loses?
Report it, because that is the paper working correctly. The criteria are examining whether the evidence decided the conclusion, and a writer who expected one answer and found another has shown precisely that. Adjusting the incident so the preferred theory wins is the version that reads badly.
How much should I define each theory?
A line or two, enough that a reader knows what you are applying. The criteria at this level assume the theories are known and award what you do with them. Every paragraph of definition is a paragraph not spent testing a prediction, and that trade is visible in the scoring.
Where can I find a free BUS FPX 2012 Assessment 2 sample paper?
This page holds the full test of situational and transformational leadership against the warehouse scanner incident, with predictions, partial fit, a verdict and limits. A paper using your own incident is available on request.
Which leadership theories fit BUS FPX 2012 Assessment 2?
Choose two that make different predictions about your incident, such as situational and transformational leadership, path-goal theory or leader-member exchange, so the comparison can reach a verdict.