BUS FPX 2021 Assessment 2 contract dispute memo example

Reviewed by Rupert Danvers, MBA Business Law Fundamentals Capella University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This BUS FPX 2021 Assessment 2 sample paper is a contract dispute memo that analyzes a late espresso machine delivery to a cafe stage by stage, from formation to a quantified remedy. It belongs to Capella BUS FPX 2021, Business Law Fundamentals, which BS in Business students take as BUS-FPX2021. The memo opens with its conclusion for a busy reader, then works through formation before anything else, since each stage can end the analysis. It separates what the contract required from what the cafe expected, analyzes breach, quantifies the remedy where possible, anticipates what the supplier might argue and is written for a business owner rather than a lawyer.

CourseBUS FPX 2021 Business Law Fundamentals
AssessmentAssessment 2
Paper typeContract dispute memo
LengthAbout 1,100 words, 5 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolCapella University
ProgramBS in Business
UpdatedSeptember 2026

Free sample paper for BUS FPX 2021 Assessment 2

1

A Contract Dispute Analyzed Stage by Stage: A Late Espresso Machine Delivery to a Cafe, From Formation to a Quantified Remedy

Student Name

Capella University

BUS FPX 2021: Business Law Fundamentals

Instructor Name

Month Day, Year

What this part is doingThe title names the dispute and the path of analysis. Contract analyses are judged on whether each stage is addressed in order, so the path is named.
2

The Situation

Morning Hour Cafe, a composite independent cafe, needed a new commercial espresso machine before its busy autumn season. On August 4, the owner emailed a supplier asking for a price on a specific two-group machine, delivered and installed by September 1. The supplier replied the same day with a written quote: the machine at 9,800 dollars, delivery and installation "in approximately three to four weeks." The owner replied, "We accept, please proceed," and paid a 2,000 dollar deposit. The machine was delivered and installed on September 22. The cafe says it lost sales during three weeks of operating with its old, slower machine and wants compensation. The supplier says it met the contract.

Formation Before Anything Else

Before asking whether anyone breached a contract, the analysis must establish whether a contract was formed and what its terms were. A contract requires an offer, an acceptance, and consideration. The sale of goods, such as an espresso machine, is governed in most states by Article 2 of the Uniform Commercial Code, which follows these principles but allows some flexibility about terms. The owner's first email was a request for a quote, not an offer, since it invited the supplier to propose terms. The supplier's written quote, stating the machine, price, and delivery estimate, was an offer. The owner's reply, "We accept, please proceed," was an acceptance, and the deposit was part performance. Consideration is present: the cafe promised to pay 9,800 dollars, and the supplier promised to deliver and install the machine. A contract was formed on August 4. The Restatement (Second) of Contracts describes this sequence of offer, acceptance, and exchange of promises as the core of contract formation (American Law Institute, 1981).

Each Stage Can End the Analysis

The analysis proceeds in stages, and each could end it. If no contract had been formed, the analysis would stop there. Since one was, the next stage asks what the terms were. If the terms did not include a delivery date, there may be no breach. If there was a breach, the next stage asks what remedy is available. Treating each stage as able to end the analysis keeps it disciplined.

Required Against Expected

The central question is what the contract required, as distinct from what the cafe expected. The cafe expected delivery by September 1, as its first email requested. But the contract's terms came from the supplier's offer, which stated "approximately three to four weeks," and the owner accepted that offer without objecting to the timing. From August 4, four weeks ends on September 1, and "approximately" allows some variation. Delivery on September 22 was about seven weeks after the contract, well beyond three to four weeks even allowing for "approximately." When a contract states an approximate time, delivery must be within a reasonable time around that estimate. A delay of three weeks beyond the stated range is likely unreasonable, particularly since the supplier knew from the first email that the cafe wanted the machine before September. Separating what the contract required from what the buyer expected keeps the analysis on the agreed terms, not on hopes that were never part of the deal.

What this part is doingThe paper distinguishes the contract's terms from the buyer's expectation. Scorers reward contract analyses that identify what was actually agreed.
3

Breach

The supplier likely breached the contract by delivering about three weeks beyond a reasonable interpretation of "approximately three to four weeks." The breach is probably minor rather than material, because the cafe received the machine it bargained for and accepted it, so the cafe cannot cancel the contract but can recover damages.

Remedy Quantified Where Possible

The cafe's remedy is damages that put it in the position it would have been in had the supplier performed on time. Two kinds of loss are possible. Lost profits from slower service. The cafe's owner says that with the old machine, the cafe could serve about 40 fewer espresso drinks on each of its 15 busiest mornings during the delay. At an average price of 5 dollars and a cost of about 1.50 dollars per drink, the lost profit is 40 times 3.50 times 15, or 2,100 dollars. To recover this, the cafe must show the losses with reasonable certainty, for example through sales records from the same period last year, and must show that the supplier had reason to know that delay would cause such losses; the owner's first email, which mentioned the autumn deadline, helps here. Incidental costs. The cafe paid 180 dollars for an emergency repair to the old machine during the delay. This is likely recoverable as a cost caused by the late delivery. Total claim: about 2,280 dollars, subject to proof. The cafe must also have tried to reduce its losses, for example by keeping the old machine running, which it did.

What this part is doingThe remedy is calculated with its inputs and the proof required. Scorers reward remedies that are quantified.
4

What the Supplier Might Argue

The supplier has arguments of its own. It may say that "approximately" signaled that the date was an estimate and that the cafe accepted that uncertainty. It may point to a manufacturer's backorder as the cause and argue that the delay was beyond its control, although unless the contract included a clause excusing delays of that kind, a supplier generally bears the risk of its own sourcing problems. And it may argue that the cafe's lost profits are speculative, since sales vary for many reasons. The cafe's sales records from the same weeks last year are the best answer to that argument.

Written for a Business Reader

For the cafe's owner, the practical conclusion is this: a contract was formed on the supplier's terms, which gave an approximate delivery time rather than a firm date. The supplier was late beyond what "approximately" allows, so the cafe has a claim, but only for its actual, provable losses, about 2,280 dollars, not for canceling the purchase. The owner should gather last year's sales records for the same weeks, the repair invoice, and the email showing the autumn deadline, and send the supplier a written request for compensation before considering small claims court. For future purchases, the owner should require a firm delivery date in writing and a stated remedy for delay.

Conclusion

A contract was formed when the cafe accepted the supplier's quote. Its terms, not the cafe's hopes, set the delivery time, but the supplier's delivery was late beyond a reasonable reading of those terms. The breach is minor, and the cafe's remedy is about 2,280 dollars in provable lost profits and incidental costs.

5

References

American Law Institute. (1981). Restatement (second) of contracts.

The Capella BUS FPX 2021 Assessment 2 instructions

The instructions ask you to analyze a contract dispute and advise a business in memo form. You determine whether a valid contract was formed, identify its terms, decide whether a party breached, consider defenses and calculate or describe the remedies available. For sales of goods, the Uniform Commercial Code Article 2 applies rather than common law, which affects terms and remedies. The memo should lead with the conclusion and explain the reasoning in plain language. Damages, such as lost profits during the delay, should be estimated where the facts allow. Business law texts and the UCC support the analysis. The memo should also note the other side's likely arguments.

Inside the BUS FPX 2021 Assessment 2 example

Three questions, answered in sequence. A short conclusion opens the memo, since a reader wants the answer before the reasoning. Formation is then worked through element by element against the facts, with any doubt reported rather than resolved by assumption. Breach follows only if formation held, and it distinguishes what the contract actually required from what one party expected, which is where most disputes in this course live. Remedy comes last and asks what would put the injured party where performance would have, quantified where the scenario supplies figures. A short block names what would change the analysis. Headings name the three questions, the register stays that of a memo to a business reader rather than a court, and authority is cited where required.

BUS FPX 2021 Assessment 2 scoring guide: what Distinguished looks like

The scoring guide rates formation, terms, breach, defenses, remedies and memo format. Formation reaches Distinguished when offer, acceptance and consideration are each checked against the facts. Terms score higher when what was required is separated from what was expected, such as a delivery date in writing against a verbal hope. Breach earns credit when tied to a specific term. Remedies should be quantified where possible, such as lost sales per day of delay. Anticipating the supplier's arguments, such as a force majeure clause or the cafe's own delay in confirming the order, shows balance. The memo format rewards a conclusion first and plain language a cafe owner can act on. Accurate references to the UCC sections used strengthen the memo.

BUS FPX 2021 Assessment 2 help from the desk

Students often jump to breach without confirming a contract was formed. Another common mistake is applying common law rules to a sale of goods, which UCC Article 2 governs. Terms are assumed rather than drawn from the facts. Remedies are named without estimates. The supplier's side is ignored, so the advice is one-sided. Legal jargon makes the memo hard for a business owner to use. Opening with a short answer and then working stage by stage keeps the memo clear. Remember that the cafe must usually take reasonable steps to limit its losses, such as renting a machine, and the memo should say whether it did. Estimating damages per day of delay, with the assumptions stated, turns a legal conclusion into a number the owner can use in negotiation.

Get a BUS FPX 2021 Assessment 2 example written to your instructions

Send the Assessment 2 instructions and your BUS FPX 2021 scoring guide, along with the scenario your version uses. We write a custom example against those criteria and return it in 24 to 48 hours. The first custom sample is free, and it works formation properly even when the interesting facts are all about the breach. The paper above is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Capella University document.

More BUS FPX 2021 papers and BS in Business samples

BUS FPX 2021 Assessment 2 questions, answered

Why spend time on formation when it is obviously a contract?

Because it frequently is not, and the criteria award the check. Scenarios in this course often hide a formation problem: an acceptance that changed a term, consideration that never passed, an agent without authority. Even where formation is clean, establishing it in a short paragraph costs little and secures a criterion.

How do I quantify a remedy?

Work from what the scenario gives you and show the arithmetic. Expectation damages aim to put the injured party where performance would have. Where figures are missing, describe the category and say what would need to be known. A number invented to look precise is worse than a characterized remedy honestly bounded.

What if both parties breached?

Then say so and handle them separately, which is a stronger answer than choosing one. Establish each obligation, each failure and each consequence in turn. Scenarios with fault on both sides are common precisely because they test whether a writer will simplify the situation into a single wrongdoer.

Where can I find a free BUS FPX 2021 Assessment 2 sample paper?

This page holds the full contract dispute memo for the late espresso machine, with formation, required versus expected terms, breach, a quantified remedy and the supplier's likely arguments. A memo on your own dispute is available on request.

Does the UCC apply in BUS FPX 2021 Assessment 2?

If the contract is for the sale of goods, such as equipment, UCC Article 2 applies and affects terms, breach and remedies. Contracts mainly for services follow common law.