| Course | BUS FPX 2007 Introduction to Business Perspectives |
|---|---|
| Assessment | Assessment 2 |
| Paper type | Functional comparison paper |
| Length | About 1,080 words, 5 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Capella University |
| Program | BS in Business |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for BUS FPX 2007 Assessment 2
Two Cases at Full Strength: Marketing and Sales Disagree About Selling Furniture Direct to Consumers
Student Name
Capella University
BUS FPX 2007: Introduction to Business Perspectives
Instructor Name
Month Day, Year
The Situation
Cedar Ridge Outdoor, a composite furniture maker selling almost entirely through independent garden centers and two regional chains, is considering selling directly to consumers online. Since the initial review, the company has gathered some information: a four-week test of online sales to a small list of past warranty registrants, conversations with 12 key retailers, and shipping quotes. The marketing and sales functions have reached opposite conclusions. This paper presents both cases.
The Case for Selling Direct, at Full Strength
Marketing argues that Cedar Ridge must sell direct to survive. Its case rests on four points. First, the retail channel is shrinking: two major garden centers closed last year, and independent garden centers in the region have been declining for a decade. Second, consumers increasingly shop for furniture online; the company's own website receives about 6,000 visits a month from people who cannot buy there. Third, the online test sold 64 pieces in four weeks at full retail price with no advertising beyond emails, suggesting real demand. Fourth, selling direct would give the company customer data and a brand relationship that retailers currently control, which Kotler and Keller (2016) describe as increasingly important as channels multiply. Without direct sales, marketing argues, Cedar Ridge will shrink along with its retailers.
The Case Against Selling Direct, at Full Strength
Sales argues that selling direct would damage the business it depends on. Its case also rests on four points. First, retailers account for nearly all revenue, 12 million dollars a year, and in conversations, 5 of the 12 retailers said they would reduce or drop Cedar Ridge if it sold online at or below their prices. Those 5 represent about 2.1 million dollars in annual sales. Second, the online test sold to past warranty registrants, who already knew and liked the brand, so it overstates demand from new customers. Third, the shipping quotes showed that delivering a dining set to a home costs about 280 dollars, far more than the per-item cost of shipping to retailers, and damage rates for home delivery are higher. Fourth, online furniture is a crowded market with large competitors that spend heavily on advertising, and Cedar Ridge has no experience competing there. Porter (2008) emphasizes that a company's position depends on the bargaining power of its buyers; for Cedar Ridge, retailers are powerful buyers who can switch suppliers easily. Stating each case at its strongest ensures that the decision is made against the best version of each argument, not a weak one.
The Conflict Located Precisely
The conflict is not about whether the company needs to change; both functions agree it does. It is not about whether online demand exists; both accept that some does. The conflict is located precisely in one question: whether the revenue gained from direct sales would exceed the revenue lost from retailers who reduce their orders. Marketing believes online growth will outpace retailer losses over three years. Sales believes retailer losses would come quickly and exceed online gains for several years. The disagreement is about timing and magnitude, not about direction. That matters, because disagreements about timing can often be settled with a test, while disagreements about direction usually cannot.
Agreement Reported Too
The functions agree on more than the conflict suggests. Both agree that the retail channel is declining. Both agree that customer data would be valuable. Both agree that any online strategy must avoid undercutting retailers on price. And both agree that the online test, while encouraging, is too small and too favorable a sample to settle the question. Reporting agreement matters, and is often skipped in conflict analyses, because it shows where a solution might be found: an approach that builds online presence without price competition, or that involves retailers in online sales, would address concerns both sides share.
Evidence on Both Sides
The evidence is mixed, and it is presented for both sides. Supporting marketing: 64 test sales in four weeks, 6,000 monthly website visits, and two closures among major retailers, which show the current channel shrinking. Supporting sales: 5 of 12 retailers threatening to reduce orders, 2.1 million dollars at risk, shipping costs of about 280 dollars per dining set, and a test sample of existing customers. Neither body of evidence is conclusive on its own. The test results come from a small, friendly sample, and the retailer responses are statements of intent made before any online store exists, which retailers may or may not act on. A test with new customers, and a firmer commitment from retailers about how they would respond to specific online pricing, would narrow the uncertainty. Both could be completed within a season, well before the decision needs to be made.
What Would Change Each Side's Mind
Each side has said what would change its view. Marketing would reconsider if a test with new customers, reached through advertising, showed low conversion or high return rates, since that would suggest demand is limited to loyal existing customers. Sales would reconsider if the retailers who threatened to drop Cedar Ridge committed in writing to continue carrying it under a specific online approach, or if online sales could be designed so they did not compete with retailers. Asking each side what evidence would change its mind turns a disagreement into a plan for gathering information.
The Trade Named, Not Resolved
The trade-off is this: Cedar Ridge can protect its current revenue by staying out of direct sales and accepting slow decline as retailers shrink, or it can build a future channel by selling direct and accepting the risk of losing some current revenue now. Each choice gives up something real. This paper names the trade without resolving it, because the resolution depends on how leaders weigh near-term revenue against long-term position, and on information not yet gathered. Naming the trade clearly is what allows leaders to make it deliberately.
Conclusion
Marketing and sales each make a strong case, grounded in evidence. They conflict on one question, whether online gains will exceed retailer losses and how soon, while agreeing on the decline of the current channel, the value of customer data, and the need to avoid price competition with retailers. The trade-off between protecting current revenue and building a future channel is named for leaders to decide.
References
Kotler, P., & Keller, K. L. (2016). Marketing management (15th ed.). Pearson.
Porter, M. E. (2008). The five competitive forces that shape strategy. Harvard Business Review, 86(1), 78-93.
BUS FPX 2007 Assessment 2 instructions, in plain terms
The instructions ask you to compare the perspectives of two business functions on the decision from Assessment 1. You choose two functions whose views conflict, present each case fairly and with evidence, identify exactly where they disagree and where they agree, and explain the trade-off the organization must weigh. Each case should be made as its strongest advocate would make it. Evidence can include market data, sales figures and industry research. The comparison prepares the recommendation in Assessment 3, so it should end by naming the key trade-off rather than choosing a winner. Business texts on functional areas and strategy support the paper.
How this BUS FPX 2007 Assessment 2 example is built
Case, case, then the conflict. The opening restates the decision in one paragraph and names the two functions being set against each other, with a reason for that pairing. The first case is then made in full, using the reasoning and the evidence that function would bring, and the second follows with equal weight and length. A comparison block identifies the actual point of disagreement, separating a genuine conflict of interest from a difference in time horizon or in what each function measures. A short block notes where the two functions agree, which is often overlooked and is useful to the recommendation. The closing states what would have to be traded whichever way the decision goes. Headings name the functions, and every claim on either side carries support.
Where the marks sit in the BUS FPX 2007 Assessment 2 scoring guide
The scoring guide rates the choice of functions, the presentation of each case, the location of the conflict, the evidence and the trade-off. Each case reaches Distinguished when presented at full strength, as its own advocates would argue it. The conflict scores higher when located precisely, such as whether online prices undercut dealers. Agreement earns credit when reported. Evidence should support both sides, not only one. Stating what would change each side's mind shows fairness. The trade-off should be named clearly for the recommendation to address. Organization and sources complete the rubric, and a short table setting the two cases side by side on the same points helps faculty see the comparison at once.
BUS FPX 2007 Assessment 2 help: mistakes that cost marks
Students often present one function's case well and the other as a straw man. Another common mistake is describing the functions' general priorities instead of their positions on this decision. The conflict is stated vaguely, such as marketing and sales disagree, without the specific point of disagreement. Agreement is left out. Evidence supports only the side the writer prefers. The paper picks a winner, which belongs in the next assessment. Stating the trade-off in one sentence at the end gives the recommendation report a clear starting point. Sources for sales' side often come from dealer agreements and channel conflict research, while marketing's side draws on direct-to-consumer growth data, so both deserve real citations.
Get a BUS FPX 2007 Assessment 2 example written to your instructions
Send the Assessment 2 instructions and your BUS FPX 2007 scoring guide, along with the decision your first assessment framed. We write a custom example against those criteria and return it in 24 to 48 hours. The first custom sample is free, and it argues the side the writer disagrees with as carefully as the other one. The paper above is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Capella University document.
More BUS FPX 2007 papers and BS in Business samples
- BUS FPX 2007 Assessment 1: Business Analysis
- BUS FPX 2007 Assessment 3: Recommendation Report
- BUS FPX 2012 Assessment 2: Theory Application Paper
- BUS FPX 1050 Assessment 2: Elasticity Problem Set
- BUS FPX 2021 Assessment 2: Contract Dispute Memo
- BUS FPX 1011 Assessment 2: Planning Memo
BUS FPX 2007 Assessment 2 questions, answered
Which two functions should I compare?
The two your decision actually divides. Automation splits operations against people, a price change splits marketing against finance, a new location splits finance against operations. Choose the pairing where the disagreement is real, since comparing two functions that broadly agree produces a short paper with nothing to weigh.
What if I already know which side is right?
Argue the other one first and argue it hard, which usually complicates the certainty. The criteria are reading whether both cases were made, not whether you reached the answer you expected. A comparison that changed the writer's mind slightly is generally the one that scores best.
Do both cases need the same amount of evidence?
Roughly, and noticeable imbalance reads as bias rather than as availability. Where one function genuinely has better data, say so, because that asymmetry is itself worth a sentence. What loses marks is one case with figures and the other with adjectives, presented as though they were equally supported.
Where can I find a free BUS FPX 2007 Assessment 2 sample paper?
This page holds the full comparison of marketing's and sales' cases on direct furniture sales, with each case at full strength, the precise conflict, agreements and the trade-off. A comparison for your own decision can be requested through the form.
Should I choose a side in BUS FPX 2007 Assessment 2?
Not yet. Present both cases fairly and name the trade-off; the recommendation comes in Assessment 3.