| Course | BUS FPX 2062 Finance Fundamentals |
|---|---|
| Assessment | Assessment 3 |
| Paper type | Capital budgeting recommendation |
| Length | About 1,080 words, 5 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Capella University |
| Program | BS in Business |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for BUS FPX 2062 Assessment 3
A Capital Budgeting Decision, Not a Set of Results: Replacing a Regional Distributor's Delivery Trucks When NPV and IRR Disagree
Student Name
Capella University
BUS FPX 2062: Finance Fundamentals
Instructor Name
Month Day, Year
A Decision, Not a Set of Results
Keystone Supply, a composite plumbing supply distributor, must replace six aging delivery trucks. It will choose one of two options, which are mutually exclusive. The decision: Keystone should choose Option B, the larger investment in new trucks with telematics, because it adds more value to the company, even though Option A has the higher rate of return. The analysis below explains why.
The Options
Option A: buy six used trucks, about three years old, for 270,000 dollars. They would reduce repair costs and fuel use compared with the current trucks, saving about 95,000 dollars a year for five years, with a combined resale value of 60,000 dollars at the end. Option B: buy six new trucks with telematics, which track routes and driving, for 510,000 dollars. They would save about 150,000 dollars a year for five years, including better fuel economy, lower repairs, and route savings from the telematics, with a combined resale value of 140,000 dollars at the end. Savings are after-tax cash flows, estimated by the operations manager and reviewed by the company's accountant.
The Rate Justified Before Use
The discount rate is chosen before any calculation. Keystone finances most investments with a bank line of credit costing 7.5% and owner's equity, and the owner expects equity to earn more than debt because it carries more risk. Brealey et al. (2020) explain that the discount rate should reflect the opportunity cost of capital, the return investors could earn on investments of similar risk. Weighing Keystone's mix of debt and equity, and the owner's expected return of about 12% on equity, the company uses a discount rate of 10%. The rate is justified before use so that it is not chosen afterward to favor one option. Justifying the discount rate before using it prevents the rate from being adjusted to produce a preferred answer.
The Results
Net present value at 10%: Option A: present value of five annual savings of 95,000 dollars is 95,000 times 3.79079, the present value factor for five years at 10%, equal to 360,125 dollars. Present value of 60,000 dollars resale in year five is 60,000 times 0.62092, equal to 37,255 dollars. Total present value 397,380 dollars, minus the 270,000 dollar cost, gives a net present value of about 127,380 dollars. Option B: 150,000 times 3.79079 equals 568,619 dollars. Resale: 140,000 times 0.62092 equals 86,929 dollars. Total 655,548 dollars, minus 510,000 dollars, gives a net present value of about 145,548 dollars. Internal rate of return, the discount rate at which net present value equals zero, found by trial: Option A about 25.9%; Option B about 19.6%. Both options have positive net present values and returns above 10%, so both would add value to the company. But they cannot both be chosen.
Disagreement Between Measures Explained
The measures disagree: Option A has the higher internal rate of return, but Option B has the higher net present value. The disagreement arises because the options differ in size. Option A earns a higher percentage return on a smaller investment, while Option B earns a lower percentage on a much larger investment, producing more total value. Brealey et al. (2020) explain that when mutually exclusive projects differ in scale, internal rate of return can mislead, because it measures the rate of return rather than the amount of value created, and that net present value is the more reliable guide. Choosing Option A would give Keystone a high return on 270,000 dollars but leave about 18,000 dollars of value, the difference in net present values, unrealized. The difference can also be seen by examining the incremental investment: Option B costs 240,000 dollars more than Option A and produces 55,000 dollars more in annual savings and 80,000 dollars more in resale. The return on that extra investment is about 12.5%, above the 10% cost of capital, so the extra investment is worthwhile.
The Reversing Assumption Named
One assumption would reverse the decision: the telematics route savings. About 35,000 dollars of Option B's annual savings come from telematics, which depends on drivers following optimized routes and on the software working as promised. If route savings were only 15,000 dollars a year, Option B's net present value would fall by about 75,800 dollars to about 69,700 dollars, below Option A's 127,380 dollars. Keystone should therefore verify the route savings, for example by asking the telematics vendor for references from similar distributors, or by piloting telematics on one of the current trucks, before committing. Naming the assumption that would reverse the decision tells the owner exactly what to verify before signing.
Why Not Simply Choose the Higher Return
Many managers instinctively prefer the option with the higher percentage return, and in some situations that preference is sensible. If Keystone had limited capital and other attractive projects competing for it, a higher return on a smaller investment might free money for those projects. But the owner has confirmed that the line of credit can fund Option B without displacing other investments, so capital is not the constraint. In that situation, the goal is to create as much value as possible, which net present value measures directly. Choosing the higher internal rate of return would mean leaving value on the table to achieve a more impressive percentage.
What Was Left Out of the Model
The model left out several factors that could matter to the decision. It did not include the risk of breakdowns with used trucks, which could disrupt deliveries and cost customers. It did not include warranty coverage, which new trucks have and used trucks may not. It did not include driver satisfaction or recruitment effects of newer vehicles. And it assumed savings are constant for five years, although fuel prices and repair costs vary. Most of these factors favor Option B, which strengthens the decision if the telematics savings hold. None of them favors Option A strongly enough to overturn the result.
Conclusion
Keystone should choose Option B. Although Option A has the higher internal rate of return, Option B adds more value, about 145,548 dollars in net present value compared with 127,380 dollars, and the extra investment earns more than the cost of capital. The decision depends on the telematics route savings, which should be verified before purchase.
References
Brealey, R. A., Myers, S. C., & Allen, F. (2020). Principles of corporate finance (13th ed.). McGraw-Hill Education.
The Capella BUS FPX 2062 Assessment 3 instructions
The course ends with a capital budgeting decision you have to make and defend. You describe the project options and cash flows, justify the discount rate, calculate net present value, internal rate of return and payback, compare the results, explain any disagreement between measures, test key assumptions and recommend a decision. NPV and IRR can rank projects differently when the projects differ in size or timing, and the paper should explain why NPV usually governs. Finance texts and the company's cost of capital support the analysis. The recommendation should be clear and qualified by the assumptions it depends on.
How the BUS-FPX2062 Assessment 3 example is put together
Inputs, measures, disagreement, decision, sensitivity. The opening states the project and the figures it rests on, each with a source or an assumption label. The measures are then computed and presented together, so they can be compared rather than encountered in sequence. Where they conflict, a block explains the cause and argues which governs for this decision. The recommendation follows in one sentence somebody could act on, with the reasoning compressed beneath it. A sensitivity block then names the assumptions the answer is most exposed to and says what value would reverse it. The closing states what the model left out altogether. Figures in the prose match the working exactly, and the rate is justified before it is used rather than afterward.
Reading the BUS FPX 2062 Assessment 3 scoring guide
The scoring guide rates the cash flow estimates, the discount rate, the calculations, the comparison of measures, the sensitivity analysis and the recommendation. The discount rate reaches Distinguished when justified before use, such as the company's weighted average cost of capital. Calculations score higher when shown. The comparison earns credit when disagreement between NPV and IRR is explained. Sensitivity analysis rewards naming the assumption that would reverse the decision, like fuel prices or truck resale values, and showing the NPV under a pessimistic value. Clear tables of cash flows by year help faculty follow the analysis. The recommendation should follow from NPV and state its conditions.
BUS FPX 2062 Assessment 3 help from the desk
Students often choose the project with the highest IRR without checking NPV. Another common mistake is using a discount rate without justification. Cash flows omit salvage value or maintenance savings. Measures are reported separately without comparison. Sensitivity is skipped. The recommendation ignores non-financial factors. Presenting all measures in one table, followed by a paragraph explaining the conflict, makes the decision clear. Taxes and depreciation affect cash flows and are often left out of introductory analyses, so say how you treated them. Inflation should be handled consistently, either in both the cash flows and the rate or in neither. The recommendation should also mention timing, such as replacing the oldest trucks first. A short note on safety and driver retention reminds the reader that not every benefit fits in a spreadsheet.
Get a BUS FPX 2062 Assessment 3 example written to your instructions
Send the Assessment 3 instructions and the BUS FPX 2062 scoring guide from your courseroom, with the project data your version supplies. We write a custom example against those exact criteria and return it in 24 to 48 hours. The first custom sample is free, and the sensitivity section is the part most recommendations never include. The paper above is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Capella University document.
More BUS FPX 2062 papers and BS in Business samples
- BUS FPX 2062 Assessment 1: Time Value Calculation
- BUS FPX 2062 Assessment 2: Ratio Analysis
- BUS FPX 3022 Assessment 3: Resilience and Risk Plan
- BUS FPX 2061 Assessment 3: Statement Interpretation Memo
- BUS FPX 3040 Assessment 3: Performance Appraisal Design
- BUS FPX 2030 Assessment 3: Sales Strategy Paper
BUS FPX 2062 Assessment 3 questions, answered
Which measure should decide it?
Net present value where they conflict, in most cases, because it measures value added rather than a rate or a speed. Say why you preferred it. Payback tells you about risk exposure and ignores everything past the cutoff, and internal rate of return misleads when project scales differ, and naming those limits demonstrates the understanding being assessed.
What if the project is marginal?
Say so, which is a legitimate finding and often the honest one. A net present value close to zero means the decision turns on the assumptions rather than on the arithmetic, and the sensitivity section becomes the substance of the paper. Forcing a confident recommendation from marginal figures reads worse than reporting the closeness.
How do I do sensitivity without a spreadsheet model?
Change one input at a time and recompute, which is enough at this level. Find the rate at which the project breaks even, or the revenue shortfall that would sink it, and report those thresholds. Two well chosen sensitivities beat a table of variations nobody interprets.
Where can I find a free BUS FPX 2062 Assessment 3 sample paper?
This page contains the full truck replacement recommendation, with the justified rate, NPV, IRR and payback, the disagreement explained and the reversing assumption. A recommendation on your own investment is available through the request form.
Why can NPV and IRR disagree in BUS FPX 2062 Assessment 3?
When projects differ in size or in the timing of cash flows, IRR can favor a smaller or quicker project while NPV favors the one that adds more value in dollars. NPV is usually the better guide.