| Course | BUS FPX 4012 Leadership in Organizations |
|---|---|
| Assessment | Assessment 2 |
| Paper type | Leadership framework case |
| Length | About 1,080 words, 5 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Capella University |
| Program | BS in Business |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for BUS FPX 4012 Assessment 2
Making a Framework Predict: Kotter's Change Model Tested Against a Grocery Chain's Centralization of Purchasing
Student Name
Capella University
BUS FPX 4012: Leadership in Organizations
Instructor Name
Month Day, Year
The Case in Brief
The case is the composite grocery chain examined in the previous assessment. Two years ago its new chief executive moved product selection from the 34 individual stores to a central buying team, taking that authority away from store managers. The move raised margins by roughly two points. It also cost the chain in other ways: shoppers rated product variety lower, rural stores lost about a twentieth of their sales, and far more store managers resigned than in an ordinary year, seven against the usual two.
The Framework Made to Predict
Kotter (1995) identified eight steps for leading change, based on his observation of why transformation efforts fail: establishing a sense of urgency, forming a powerful guiding coalition, creating a vision, communicating the vision, empowering others to act on the vision, planning for and creating short-term wins, consolidating improvements, and institutionalizing new approaches. The framework can be turned into a prediction: a change effort will succeed to the extent that these steps are carried out, and it will fail or produce resistance at the points where steps are skipped. Making the framework predict, rather than describing it, allows it to be tested against what actually happened. A framework that only describes can be fitted to any outcome; one that predicts can be shown to be wrong, which is what makes a test meaningful.
The Prediction Committed To
Based on the case records, the prediction is committed to before examining outcomes in detail. The chief executive officer established urgency with the board, using the cost comparison with national competitors, but not with store managers. The guiding coalition included the board, the chief executive officer, and the new purchasing team, but no store managers or regional directors from the existing organization. The vision, lower costs through scale, was communicated to managers as a decision, not as a shared direction. Store managers were not empowered to shape how centralization would work. Short-term wins, margin gains, were visible at headquarters but not in stores. The prediction: the change will achieve its financial goal, since the steps at headquarters level were carried out, but will face resistance and loss among store managers and weakened commitment at the store level, since steps involving them were skipped. Committing to a prediction before testing it prevents the framework from being fitted to the outcome after the fact.
Tested Against Evidence
The evidence supports much of the prediction. The financial goal was achieved: margins rose by about 2 points. Store manager turnover more than tripled, from two to seven, consistent with resistance and loss. Exit interviews with departing managers, summarized by human resources, cited loss of autonomy and not being consulted as the main reasons. In a survey of remaining managers, only 30% agreed that they understood why centralization was necessary, consistent with a failure to establish urgency and communicate the vision at their level. These findings fit the prediction that skipped steps would produce resistance. The survey result is especially telling: managers who did not understand the reason for the change were being asked to carry it out, and many resisted quietly by continuing to request local items through the formal process at high rates, which slowed the buying team. The evidence also fits a finer prediction: stores in rural towns, where managers had the strongest local supplier relationships and customers valued local products most, saw the largest sales declines. The framework predicts that the loss would be greatest where the change most affected what people valued and where they had least voice.
The Unexplained Residue Named
Some outcomes are not explained by Kotter's framework. The drop in customer satisfaction with variety is not mainly a result of how the change was led; it follows from the decision to drop 60% of local suppliers, a design choice that a well-led change would still have produced. The framework addresses how to lead change, not whether the change itself is well designed. Similarly, the rural sales decline reflects customer preferences for local products, which the framework does not address. This residue shows the framework's limit: it explains resistance to the change but not the effects of the change's content. A change that is well led but poorly designed will still produce poor results, and Kotter's framework does not help judge the design itself. Naming the unexplained residue shows where the framework stops being useful and another explanation is needed.
What a Framework-Guided Change Would Have Looked Like
If the chief executive officer had followed the steps the framework predicts would reduce resistance, the change would have looked different. Store managers would have seen the cost comparison with national competitors and been asked how to close the gap. Several respected managers would have joined the guiding coalition. The vision might have been framed as competing on price for staples while keeping local variety, which store managers could have supported. Short-term wins, such as lower prices on popular national brands, would have been visible in stores. The framework predicts that this approach would have kept more managers and produced less resistance, though it would have taken longer to implement.
A Competing Account Gestured At
A competing account would focus on organizational design rather than change leadership. From a design perspective, the problem was not that store managers were insufficiently persuaded but that centralizing all assortment removed local responsiveness, a capability that distinguished Maple Street from national chains. Galbraith (2014) describes organizational design as aligning structure with strategy, and a design account would ask whether Maple Street's strategy depended on local adaptation. If it did, even a well-led centralization would have weakened it. This account explains the customer and sales effects that Kotter's framework leaves unexplained, though it says less about the management turnover. The two accounts are complementary: one explains how the change was received, the other what the change itself did to the chain's ability to serve local markets.
Conclusion
Turned into a prediction, Kotter's framework correctly anticipated that the centralization would meet its financial goal but face resistance and loss among store managers, because the steps involving them were skipped. The evidence supports this. The framework does not explain the loss of customer satisfaction and rural sales, which a competing account based on organizational design explains better.
References
Galbraith, J. R. (2014). Designing organizations: Strategy, structure, and process at the business unit and enterprise levels (3rd ed.). Jossey-Bass.
Kotter, J. P. (1995). Leading change: Why transformation efforts fail. Harvard Business Review, 73(2), 59-67.
The Capella BUS FPX 4012 Assessment 2 instructions
The instructions ask you to apply a leadership or change framework to the case from Assessment 1. You explain the framework, turn it into predictions about the case, test the predictions against what happened, identify what the framework explains well and what it misses, and describe how a leader using the framework would have acted differently. Kotter's eight steps, Lewin's model and the ADKAR model are common choices. The key move is making the framework predict something testable rather than simply mapping events onto its steps. Leadership and change management research supports the analysis.
Inside the BUS FPX 4012 Assessment 2 example
Framework, prediction, test, residue. The opening carries forward the organization and the decision in a short paragraph, since re establishing them wastes the space the analysis needs. The framework block states the theory in its own terms and identifies precisely what it claims about leadership behavior. The prediction block applies it to this situation and commits to what should have followed, which is the step that makes the rest testable. The test block compares that against what happened, using evidence rather than impression. A residue block names what the framework failed to explain, which is where the strongest writing in this assessment tends to sit. The closing states what a competing framework would have predicted differently, which shows the theory was selected on purpose rather than simply picked up.
BUS FPX 4012 Assessment 2 scoring guide: what Distinguished looks like
The scoring guide rates the explanation of the framework, the predictions, the test against evidence, the unexplained residue and the application. Predictions reach Distinguished when committed to in advance, such as Kotter predicting resistance if no guiding coalition included store managers, and short-term wins being needed to hold support through the first quarter. The test scores higher when evidence from the case confirms or contradicts each prediction in turn, with the source of the evidence named. Naming what the framework cannot explain, such as a supplier dispute that had nothing to do with change management, shows critical thinking. Describing a framework-guided alternative shows practical value. A competing account, perhaps from sensemaking or power theory, shows awareness of other lenses. Sources should support the framework's claims.
BUS FPX 4012 Assessment 2 help from the desk
Students often map events onto a framework's steps, step one happened here and step two there, without testing anything. Another common mistake is describing the framework at length and applying it in a paragraph. Predictions are made after looking at the outcome, which makes the framework look better than it is. The residue, the part of the story the framework cannot explain, is ignored. The framework-guided alternative is vague, such as the company should have communicated better, when it could name the coalition members and the first short-term win. Competing theories are not mentioned. The evidence is thin, relying on one news article. Writing predictions first, then checking each against the case, makes the analysis honest and shows faculty that the framework was tested rather than decorated.
Get a BUS FPX 4012 Assessment 2 example written to your instructions
Send the Assessment 2 instructions and your BUS FPX 4012 scoring guide, plus the organization and decision your first assessment established. We write a custom example against those criteria and return it in 24 to 48 hours. The first custom sample is free, and watching a framework fail partially is more instructive than watching one fit. The paper above is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Capella University document.
More BUS FPX 4012 papers and BS in Business samples
- BUS FPX 4012 Assessment 1: Organizational Leadership Analysis
- BUS FPX 4012 Assessment 3: Leadership Development Plan
- BUS FPX 4013 Assessment 2: Organizational Learning Analysis
- BUS FPX 4011 Assessment 2: Collaboration Technology Evaluation
- BUS FPX 4014 Assessment 2: Quality and Capacity Study
- BUS FPX 3121 Assessment 2: Stakeholder Impact Paper
BUS FPX 4012 Assessment 2 questions, answered
What if the framework does not fit at all?
That is a finding and a strong one, provided the work is shown. Apply it properly, state the prediction it produced, show what happened instead, and reason about why this situation sits outside what the theory was built to cover. A misfit argued carefully demonstrates more understanding than a comfortable fit reported without any examination.
Which framework should I choose?
One that would predict something surprising about your situation. A framework broadly agreeing with what already happened teaches a reader nothing, and the criteria reward the testing far more than the choosing. Where two candidates would disagree about your decision, that pairing is worth considering, because the disagreement itself gives you something to argue.
Do I need to cite the original theorists?
Where the course asks for it, yes, and it repays the effort anyway. The work that proposed a theory states its claims more precisely than any summary does, and precision is what you need when deriving a prediction from it. One accurate primary citation carries more weight with the criteria than three paraphrases taken at second hand.
Where can I find a free BUS FPX 4012 Assessment 2 sample paper?
This page holds the full Kotter test against the grocery chain's purchasing change, with predictions, evidence, residue and a framework-guided alternative. It builds on the Assessment 1 decision trace.
How do I make a framework predict in BUS FPX 4012 Assessment 2?
Turn each step of the framework into a statement about what should happen in your case if the step is done or skipped, then check the case evidence against each statement.