| Course | BUS FPX 4014 Operations Management for Competitive Advantage |
|---|---|
| Assessment | Assessment 2 |
| Paper type | Quality and capacity study |
| Length | About 1,090 words, 5 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Capella University |
| Program | BS in Business |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for BUS FPX 4014 Assessment 2
The Cost of Quality in a Cabinet Shop's Finishing Department: Defects Counted, Costs Split Three Ways, Failure Cost Surfaced, and Rework as Lost Capacity
Student Name
Capella University
BUS FPX 4014: Operations Management for Competitive Advantage
Instructor Name
Month Day, Year
The Context
Oakline Cabinetry is the composite 14-person kitchen cabinet shop whose production process was analyzed earlier. That analysis showed the spray booth, where every door and face frame receives its stain or paint and clear coats, to be the point that limits the whole shop: it is busy about 97% of the time, work queues in front of it for about six days, and it can finish roughly 21 kitchens a month while customers are ordering about 24. It also showed that about one piece in twelve goes back through the booth because of a finish defect. This paper asks what poor finishing quality costs the shop.
Defects Counted Over a Stated Period
Defects were counted over a stated period, the three months from January through March, using the booth operator's finishing log, which records each piece refinished and the reason, and the shop's warranty records for defects reported by customers after installation. During the period, the booth finished about 2,040 doors and face frames for 68 kitchens. Of these, 163 pieces, about 8%, were refinished before shipping. The finishing log records a reason for each refinish, and the most common causes were dust in the finish, 41%; runs or sags in the finish, 27%; uneven stain color, 19%; and sanding marks visible through the finish, 13%. In the same period, customers reported finish defects on 22 pieces after installation, requiring a technician visit and replacement. Counting over a stated period makes the figures comparable with later periods and prevents a single bad week from distorting the picture. The same three-month window will be used after improvements, so that before and after can be compared fairly.
Cost Split Three Ways
Campanella (1999) describes a framework in which quality costs are divided into prevention costs, spent to keep defects from occurring; appraisal costs, spent to find defects; and failure costs, incurred when defects occur, divided into internal failures found before delivery and external failures found by customers. The shop's quality costs for the quarter were split this way. Prevention: booth filter replacement and cleaning, about 900 dollars; the booth operator's time spent mixing and testing stain samples, about 1,100 dollars. Total about 2,000 dollars. Appraisal: inspection of finished pieces before final assembly, about 12 hours a week of the lead finisher's time over 13 weeks, about 5,500 dollars. Internal failure: refinishing 163 pieces, including materials and labor, about 45 dollars a piece, about 7,300 dollars. External failure: 22 pieces replaced after installation, including a new piece, a technician's visit, and travel, about 260 dollars a piece, about 5,700 dollars. Total quality cost for the quarter: about 20,500 dollars. Splitting cost three ways shows that the shop spends little to prevent defects and much more when they occur.
Failure Cost Surfaced
Failure costs are often hidden in normal operating costs, because refinishing looks like ordinary production work and warranty visits are charged to service. Surfacing them, by pulling refinishing time from the finishing log and warranty costs from the service records, shows that failure accounts for about 13,000 dollars of the 20,500, or about 63% of all quality cost, while prevention accounts for only about 10%. External failures are the most costly per piece, about six times the cost of an internal refinish, and they also damage the shop's reputation with customers and contractors who refer business.
Rework Counted as Lost Capacity
Because rework happens at the constraint, its true cost is larger than the labor and materials. Every refinished piece uses booth time that could have finished a new piece. The 163 refinished pieces over three months used about 8% of the booth's capacity, equivalent to about 5 kitchens' worth of finishing over the quarter, or about 1.7 kitchens a month. The shop's average contribution margin per kitchen, after materials and direct labor, is about 5,800 dollars. Since demand exceeds capacity, each kitchen not finished is a sale delayed or lost. Rework at the constraint therefore costs about 9,900 dollars a month, or about 29,600 dollars a quarter, in lost contribution, more than the direct cost of all quality failures combined. Hopp and Spearman (2008) note that capacity lost at a bottleneck is lost for the whole system, which is why rework at the constraint is especially expensive.
Headroom Identified
Headroom is the amount by which quality costs could realistically be reduced. The largest defect cause, dust, accounts for 41% of refinishing and can be reduced by improving the booth's air filtration and sealing the area where pieces dry, which a finishing equipment supplier estimates would cut dust defects by about three quarters. Runs and sags, 27%, are linked to spray gun settings and operator technique and could be reduced with a standard setup sheet and training. If these two changes cut refinishing from 8% to about 4%, the shop would recover about 4% of booth capacity, roughly 0.9 kitchens a month, worth about 5,200 dollars a month in contribution. The prevention cost of these changes, about 6,000 dollars for filtration improvements and a day of training, would be recovered in about five weeks. Identifying headroom shows how much of the quality cost is within reach and what it would take to capture it.
Why Prevention Has Been Underfunded
Prevention has been underfunded because its costs are visible and immediate, while failure costs are spread across refinishing labor, materials, warranty visits, and lost sales, none of which is labeled as a quality cost in the shop's accounts. The owner sees the price of a filtration upgrade but not the combined cost of dust defects. Presenting quality costs together, in one table, makes the trade-off visible.
What the Analysis Does Not Capture
The analysis does not capture the effect of external failures on referrals and reputation, which is likely significant but hard to measure. It also relies on the finishing log being complete; if some refinishing is not recorded, internal failure is understated.
Conclusion
Over one quarter, finishing defects cost Oakline about 20,500 dollars in direct quality costs, with about 63% in failures and only about 10% in prevention. Because rework occurs at the constraint, its larger cost is lost capacity, about 29,600 dollars in lost contribution a quarter. Improving filtration and spray setup offers headroom that would pay for itself within weeks.
References
Campanella, J. (Ed.). (1999). Principles of quality costs: Principles, implementation, and use (3rd ed.). ASQ Quality Press.
Hopp, W. J., & Spearman, M. L. (2008). Factory physics (3rd ed.). McGraw-Hill/Irwin.
Reading the BUS-FPX4014 Assessment 2 instructions
The instructions ask you to analyze quality and capacity in an operation, often using the cost of quality framework. You count defects over a stated period, classify quality costs into prevention, appraisal, internal failure and external failure, estimate each, show how defects and rework consume capacity, identify the capacity that improved quality would free and explain the findings for management. The analysis usually continues the process from Assessment 1. Operations texts on quality management and the cost of quality support the work. Estimates should be labeled with their basis. The paper should connect quality to capacity, since rework at the constraint directly reduces output.
Inside the BUS FPX 4014 Assessment 2 example
Defects, cost categories, capacity, headroom. The opening states the period observed and the defect count, with how the count was obtained. A categorization block splits quality spend into prevention, appraisal and failure, defining each briefly and assigning the figures. An analysis block reads the split, since the balance between the three is the argument: heavy appraisal with light prevention means the process is catching problems rather than avoiding them. A capacity block states current output, the capacity consumed by rework, and the theoretical output if defects fell to a stated level. A headroom block identifies whether the constraint is capacity or quality. The closing names what the study could not measure. Units and periods are stated once and held throughout.
Reading the BUS FPX 4014 Assessment 2 scoring guide
The scoring guide rates the defect data, the cost classification, the failure cost analysis, the capacity link and the conclusions. Defect data reach Distinguished when counted over a stated period with the method described. Classification scores higher when every cost is placed in prevention, appraisal or failure with a basis. Failure costs earn credit when hidden ones are surfaced, such as warranty visits and lost referrals. The capacity link rewards counting rework hours at the finishing booth as lost output. Headroom should be stated in units, such as cabinets per week, so the owner can see the gain. Explaining why prevention is underfunded shows insight.
BUS FPX 4014 Assessment 2 help from the desk
Students often discuss quality in general terms without counting defects. Another common mistake is listing quality costs without classifying them. Failure costs are underestimated because only visible costs are counted. The link to capacity is missing, so the argument for prevention is weak. Estimates have no basis. Headroom is not quantified. Conclusions stay general. Showing that each hour of rework at the constraint costs a finished cabinet makes the case for prevention concrete and prepares the improvement proposal. Estimates for failure costs should state their basis, such as the average refinish time multiplied by the shop's labor rate. Customer returns and complaints count as external failure and often carry the highest cost, including lost future orders.
Get a BUS FPX 4014 Assessment 2 example written to your instructions
Send the Assessment 2 instructions and your BUS FPX 4014 scoring guide, along with the process your first assessment timed. We write a custom example against those criteria and return it in 24 to 48 hours. The first custom sample is free, and the three way cost split is the part that makes the improvement argument possible. The paper above is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Capella University document.
More BUS FPX 4014 papers and BS in Business samples
- BUS FPX 4014 Assessment 1: Process Analysis With Timings
- BUS FPX 4014 Assessment 3: Operations Improvement Proposal
- BUS FPX 4015 Assessment 2: Strategic Objectives Set
- BUS FPX 4013 Assessment 2: Organizational Learning Analysis
- BUS FPX 4016 Assessment 2: Entry Mode Recommendation
- BUS FPX 4012 Assessment 2: Framework Application Case
BUS FPX 4014 Assessment 2 questions, answered
What counts as a defect in a service process?
Anything that has to be redone or corrected: a claim returned for missing information, an order picked wrongly, an appointment booked twice. The definition matters more than the label, so state yours early. A clear definition applied consistently is worth more to the criteria than a technically precise one applied unevenly.
How do I estimate failure cost?
Start with the time it takes to fix one instance and multiply by the count, then add whatever you can defend for lost sales or expedited handling. State each component separately. What earns credit is a total whose derivation is visible on the page, and a figure you can walk somebody through beats an authoritative one you cannot.
Is more prevention always better?
Up to a point, and saying where that point sits demonstrates real understanding. Prevention spending has diminishing returns, and past a certain level the cost of avoiding a defect exceeds the cost of fixing it. Noting that, even without precise figures, distinguishes a considered study from an enthusiastic one.
Where can I find a free BUS FPX 4014 Assessment 2 sample paper?
This page holds the full cost of quality study for the finishing department, with defects counted, costs split three ways, hidden failure costs and rework as lost capacity. It uses the timings from Assessment 1.
What are the categories of quality cost in BUS FPX 4014 Assessment 2?
Prevention costs stop defects from happening, appraisal costs find them through inspection, and failure costs, internal and external, come from defects that occur, such as rework, returns and warranty repairs.