| Course | BUS FPX 4014 Operations Management for Competitive Advantage |
|---|---|
| Assessment | Assessment 3 |
| Paper type | Operations improvement proposal |
| Length | About 1,160 words, 5 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Capella University |
| Program | BS in Business |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for BUS FPX 4014 Assessment 3
Improving One Constraint at a Cabinet Shop: A Drying System and Extended Booth Hours, Throughput Computed, the Next Constraint Named, and Full Cost
Student Name
Capella University
BUS FPX 4014: Operations Management for Competitive Advantage
Instructor Name
Month Day, Year
One Constraint, Not a Program
The earlier analyses established that Oakline's spray booth is its constraint and that roughly one piece in twelve returns to it for refinishing. This proposal therefore concentrates on finishing alone rather than a program of improvements across the shop, because gains at other stations would not raise output. Goldratt and Cox (1984) emphasize focusing improvement on the constraint, since an hour gained there is an hour gained for the whole system.
How the Booth Is Used Now
The booth is a single spray room large enough to hold about 30 doors and face frames at once. Each batch is sprayed with stain or primer, dries for about 6 hours, is sprayed with a first topcoat, dries for about 6 hours, and receives a final topcoat and dries again. Because pieces dry inside the booth, the booth cannot be used for spraying while a batch dries. Over a single eight-hour shift, the booth completes about one coat on one batch, and a kitchen's pieces take about three shifts to finish. Spraying itself takes about 45 minutes per coat per batch; most of the booth's time is drying.
What Would Change
Three changes are proposed. First, reduce rework from 8% to about 4% by improving filtration and standardizing spray setup, as identified in the cost of quality analysis. Second, install a separate drying room with rolling racks next to the booth, so that pieces can be sprayed in the booth and moved to the drying room, freeing the booth for the next batch. Third, extend booth hours by adding a second finisher working a later shift, from 2 p.m. to 10:30 p.m., overlapping with the first finisher for part of the day.
Throughput Computed From the Timings
Throughput is computed from the timings rather than estimated. With a separate drying room, the booth's cycle is spray time plus loading and unloading, about 60 minutes per coat per batch, instead of spraying plus 6 hours of drying. Over one eight-hour shift, the booth can complete about 7 coats on different batches. A kitchen of about 30 pieces needs three coats, so one shift can finish about 2.3 kitchens' worth of coats a day, compared with about 1.1 now. The drying room must hold enough batches: at 7 coats a shift, each drying 6 hours, it needs capacity for about 6 batches at a time, which the proposed room provides. With the second shift, booth time roughly doubles again, but the drying room would become the limit; with a room sized for 8 batches, the booth could complete about 12 coats a day, or 4 kitchens a day. After reducing rework to 4%, effective finishing capacity would be about 3.8 kitchens a day, or about 80 a month, far above demand of 24. Computing throughput from the timings shows exactly how much the change adds, which keeps the proposal from resting on a general promise of more capacity.
The Next Constraint Named
With finishing capacity of about 80 kitchens a month, finishing would no longer be the constraint. The next constraint is the step with the lowest capacity after finishing. According to the earlier analysis, the remaining stations top out at roughly 30 kitchens a month, and among them final assembly and inspection, done by two workers, is the tightest at about 28 kitchens a month. Demand of 24 is below 28, so the shop would have headroom, but if sales grow above about 28 kitchens a month, final assembly becomes the constraint. Naming the next constraint prevents the shop from assuming that one improvement solves capacity permanently. It also suggests that the second finishing shift may not be needed immediately; the drying room alone raises finishing capacity to about 45 kitchens a month, well above demand and above the next constraint.
Full Cost Including Disruption
The full cost includes items often left out. The drying room, with rolling racks, ventilation, and temperature control, costs about 38,000 dollars. Filtration improvements cost about 6,000 dollars. Training and a spray setup standard cost about 1,500 dollars. A second finisher costs about 52,000 dollars a year including benefits. Installation disrupts production: the booth must be shut for about four working days while the drying room is connected to the ventilation system, losing about four days of finishing, or about four kitchens' worth of output, worth about 23,000 dollars in delayed contribution, some of which may be recovered later. Given the next-constraint analysis, the recommendation is to build the drying room and improve filtration now, at a one-time cost of about 45,500 dollars plus the disruption, and to defer the second shift until demand exceeds about 40 kitchens a month. With the drying room, the shop can finish as many kitchens as final assembly can complete, about 28 a month, instead of 21, an increase of 7 kitchens a month. At about 5,800 dollars contribution per kitchen, if sales fill that capacity, the gain is about 40,600 dollars a month. Even if sales fill only 3 additional kitchens, the gain of about 17,400 dollars a month would repay the investment and disruption in about four months.
How Fast a Rival Could Copy It
A rival cabinet shop could copy the drying room approach, since it uses standard equipment and is widely known in finishing. Copying would take a rival about two to three months, including planning and installation. The advantage to Oakline, therefore, is not the drying room itself but the shorter lead times and higher capacity it creates while demand is strong. Oakline should use the next few months to reduce its lead time from about 16 days to under 10 and market that reliability to contractors, building relationships that are harder to copy than equipment. Considering how fast a rival could copy the change shows whether it offers a lasting advantage or a temporary one to be used quickly.
Risks
The main risks are that the drying room's temperature and humidity control is inadequate, causing finish defects, and that sales do not grow to use the added capacity. The first is addressed by specifying controls with the supplier and testing with sample pieces before full use; the second by the sales plan to market shorter lead times.
Conclusion
Focusing on the finishing constraint, a separate drying room and reduced rework raise finishing capacity from about 21 to about 45 kitchens a month, making final assembly, at about 28, the next constraint. The full cost, including four days of disruption, is recovered within months if sales grow modestly, and a second finishing shift should wait until demand requires it. A rival could copy the equipment quickly, so the advantage lies in using shorter lead times to win customers.
References
Goldratt, E. M., & Cox, J. (1984). The goal: A process of ongoing improvement. North River Press.
BUS FPX 4014 Assessment 3 instructions, in plain terms
The course ends with one improvement, proposed from the numbers gathered in the first two papers. You restate the constraint and current capacity, specify the change, calculate its effect on throughput, identify the next constraint that will limit the process, estimate the full cost, including disruption during installation, and assess whether the improvement creates a competitive advantage. The theory of constraints suggests improving the bottleneck first and expecting the constraint to move. Operations texts and supplier information support the proposal. Calculations should use the timings from Assessment 1. The proposal should be specific enough that the owner could approve it.
How the BUS-FPX4014 Assessment 3 example is put together
Constraint, change, arithmetic, next constraint, cost. The opening restates the constraint and the current capacity in one paragraph, drawing on the earlier work rather than repeating it. The change block specifies exactly what would be different: a step removed, an approval delegated, a second station added, a batch size altered. The arithmetic block then computes the new throughput from the existing timings, showing the working so the claim can be checked. A next constraint block names what limits the process afterward, which is what stops the proposal overclaiming. The cost block totals implementation, ongoing spend and lost output during the change. A competitive block asks how quickly a rival could match it. The closing states the payback period with its assumptions.
BUS FPX 4014 Assessment 3 scoring guide: what Distinguished looks like
The scoring guide rates the focus on the constraint, the specification of the change, the throughput calculation, the next constraint, the cost and the competitive analysis. The change reaches Distinguished when specified precisely, such as a forced-air drying system cutting cure time from eight hours to three. Throughput scores higher when computed from the Assessment 1 timings. Naming the next constraint shows understanding that bottlenecks move. Full cost should include downtime during installation. The competitive analysis earns credit when it considers how quickly rivals could copy the change. Risks should be named with responses.
Common BUS FPX 4014 Assessment 3 mistakes, and how to avoid them
Students often propose several improvements at once, diluting focus. Another common mistake is calculating throughput without the earlier timings. The next constraint is ignored, so the gain is overstated. Costs leave out disruption. The competitive angle is missing. Risks are not considered. Staying with one constraint and showing the arithmetic makes the proposal credible. Payback period, the months until added cabinet sales cover the drying system's cost, gives the owner a simple decision figure. Installation timing matters too: scheduling the work during a slow month limits lost output. Training the finishing crew on the new system should be part of the cost and the plan. A quick look at whether demand can absorb the extra capacity keeps the proposal from building output the shop cannot sell. Supplier quotes, labeled as estimates, strengthen the cost figures.
Get a BUS FPX 4014 Assessment 3 example written to your instructions
Send the Assessment 3 instructions and the BUS FPX 4014 scoring guide from your courseroom, with the timings and quality figures your earlier assessments produced. We write a custom example against those exact criteria and return it in 24 to 48 hours. The first custom sample is free, and computing the gain from your own timings is what makes the proposal defensible. The paper above is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Capella University document.
More BUS FPX 4014 papers and BS in Business samples
- BUS FPX 4014 Assessment 1: Process Analysis With Timings
- BUS FPX 4014 Assessment 2: Quality and Capacity Study
- BUS FPX 4015 Assessment 3: Implementation and Control Plan
- BUS FPX 4013 Assessment 3: Performance Systems Proposal
- BUS FPX 4016 Assessment 3: Cross Border Relationship Plan
- BUS FPX 4012 Assessment 3: Leadership Development Plan
BUS FPX 4014 Assessment 3 questions, answered
What if relieving the constraint is too expensive?
Then say so with the figures, which is a legitimate and well regarded conclusion. Compare the cost against the throughput gain, show the payback exceeds any reasonable horizon, and propose the smaller change that is affordable instead. A proposal that declines the obvious answer for a stated reason reads as considerably more rigorous.
Should I recommend technology?
Only where you can say which step it removes and what the data would have to be for it to help. Technology proposed as a general answer is the commonest weak recommendation in this course. Naming the specific step, the specific saving and the implementation cost turns it into an argument rather than an aspiration.
How do I handle the effect on people?
Address it directly rather than leaving it implicit in the arithmetic. If a change removes work, say what happens to those doing it now. The criteria treat an operations proposal that quietly eliminates roles without mentioning them as incomplete, and a paragraph on redeployment or timing costs nothing to include.
Where can I find a free BUS FPX 4014 Assessment 3 sample paper?
This page contains the full improvement proposal for the finishing booth, with the change specified, throughput computed, the next constraint named, full cost and competitive analysis. It completes the three-part operations sequence.
What happens after the constraint is improved in BUS FPX 4014 Assessment 3?
Another step becomes the limit. Name it in the proposal and estimate the new capacity, so the owner knows how much of the gain will actually reach finished output.