| Course | BUS FPX 4068 Contemporary Auditing Using Investigative Accounting Practices |
|---|---|
| Assessment | Assessment 1 |
| Paper type | Risk and control evaluation |
| Length | About 1,120 words, 6 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Capella University |
| Program | BS in Business |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for BUS FPX 4068 Assessment 1
Evaluating Control Risk in a Small Nonprofit's Payables: The Process Written as People, Incompatible Duties Identified, What the Gap Would Allow, Compensating Controls, and a Separation That Can Be Staffed
Student Name
Capella University
BUS FPX 4068: Contemporary Auditing Using Investigative Accounting Practices
Instructor Name
Month Day, Year
The Organization
Riverbend Family Services, a composite nonprofit, runs after-school programs and a food pantry in a mid-sized Midwestern city. Annual spending is about 2.4 million dollars, of which roughly 700,000 dollars goes to outside vendors for food, supplies, facility repairs, and transportation. The organization has a paid staff of 22, but only four people touch finance: the executive director, an office manager, a part-time bookkeeper, and a program director who orders supplies. A volunteer board treasurer reviews financial reports each quarter. The board asked for a review of payables after a peer organization lost money to a fake vendor.
The Process Written as People
The process is written as the people who perform each step, because controls fail or hold at the level of who does what. Maria, the program director, decides what supplies are needed and emails the office manager. Linda, the office manager, places the order, sets up any new vendor in the accounting system, receives the invoice by email, enters it, and prints checks every other Friday. Linda also signs checks under 2,500 dollars with a stamp of the executive director's signature. Checks over 2,500 dollars go to Denise, the executive director, for a hand signature. Linda mails the checks. At month end, Linda reconciles the bank account and gives the reconciliation to Paul, the bookkeeper, who posts adjusting entries. The board treasurer sees a budget-to-actual report each quarter. A control exists only if a named person does it, on a schedule, with something to show for it.
Incompatible Duties Identified
The Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission (2013) frames control activities to include segregating authorization, custody of assets, and recording, so that no one person can both commit and hide an error or fraud. At Riverbend, Linda holds all three. She authorizes by creating vendors and placing orders. She has custody through the signature stamp and by mailing checks. She records by entering invoices. She also performs the reconciliation that would detect a problem. Four incompatible pairs are present: vendor setup with payment entry, payment entry with check signing, check signing with mailing, and all of these with the bank reconciliation.
What the Gap Would Allow
Each gap allows a specific scheme. Because Linda can add a vendor and enter its invoices, she could create a fictitious vendor using an address she controls and pay it invoices for supplies never ordered. Because she holds the stamp, payments under 2,500 dollars would need no second person, so a scheme could stay just below that amount. Because she mails the checks, she could change the payee on a real check or divert it. Because she reconciles the bank account, cleared checks to a fake vendor would pass through her own review. The Association of Certified Fraud Examiners (2024) reports that billing schemes are among the most common forms of asset misappropriation and that small organizations suffer proportionally larger losses, often because of exactly this concentration of duties.
Compensating Controls Looked For
Before recommending change, the review looks for compensating controls that might already reduce the risk. Three partial controls exist. Denise signs checks above 2,500 dollars, but she sees only the check and invoice Linda gives her, so a fictitious invoice would still pass. The board treasurer reviews budget-to-actual reports quarterly, which could catch a large overspend on supplies, but small, steady fraud would stay within budget. The bank offers online access that Denise could use but rarely does. None of these would reliably catch a fictitious vendor paid in amounts under 2,500 dollars. Arens et al. (2020) note that compensating controls are most effective when performed by someone independent of the process who looks at original evidence, which is the missing element here. A control that only sees what the suspect hands over does not compensate for anything.
A Separation That Can Be Staffed
With four people, full separation is not possible, but a workable separation is. Vendor setup moves to Paul, the bookkeeper, who must verify each new vendor's tax identification number and address against an independent source before adding it; Linda keeps invoice entry. The signature stamp is destroyed, and all checks require Denise's signature or, when she is away, the board treasurer's; Riverbend writes about 60 checks a month, which takes Denise under an hour. Checks go from the signer straight to the mail, not back to Linda. The bank reconciliation moves to Paul, with Denise reviewing and initialing it monthly and opening the bank statement images herself. Maria confirms receipt of goods by initialing the packing slip before an invoice can be paid.
Testing the New Design
Before the changes are adopted, the review walks one transaction through the new design to confirm that each step has an owner. Maria requests paint and cleaning supplies for the fall program; Linda places the order with an existing vendor; Maria initials the packing slip when the supplies arrive; Linda enters the invoice and matches it to the slip; Denise signs the check and hands it to the front desk for mailing; Paul reconciles the bank account at month end; and Denise initials the reconciliation after opening the statement images. No single person can now both create and hide a payment.
Cost and Residual Risk
The changes cost little: some of Denise's time, a few extra hours of Paul's time each month, and a vendor change report the accounting system can print. Residual risk remains. Paul now sets up vendors and reconciles the bank account, which is a new pairing; Denise's monthly review of statement images and a quarterly vendor list review by the treasurer address that. Collusion between two people would defeat most of these controls, which is a risk small organizations must accept and address through culture and periodic outside review.
Monitoring
The board treasurer should review the vendor master list every quarter for new names, post office box addresses, and vendors with addresses matching employees. Every two years, an outside accountant should perform an agreed-upon procedures review of payables.
Conclusion
At Riverbend, one office manager authorizes, records, holds custody, and reconciles, which would allow a fictitious vendor scheme to run undetected in amounts below the hand-signature limit. Existing reviews do not compensate because they rely on documents the same person prepares. Moving vendor setup and reconciliation to the bookkeeper, ending the signature stamp, requiring receipt confirmation, and adding director and treasurer reviews gives a separation four people can staff.
References
Arens, A. A., Elder, R. J., Beasley, M. S., & Hogan, C. E. (2020). Auditing and assurance services (17th ed.). Pearson.
Association of Certified Fraud Examiners. (2024). Occupational fraud 2024: A report to the nations. Association of Certified Fraud Examiners.
Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission. (2013). Internal control: Integrated framework. American Institute of Certified Public Accountants.
What the BUS FPX 4068 Assessment 1 instructions ask for
The first assessment in BUS FPX 4068 asks you to evaluate the internal controls over a process and the risks they leave. You describe the process as a series of tasks with the person or role performing each, identify which incompatible functions sit with the same person, such as authorizing, recording and custody of assets, explain what fraud or error each weakness would allow, look for compensating controls and recommend changes that the organization could realistically staff. The COSO internal control framework, auditing standards on risk assessment and research on fraud in small organizations support the evaluation. The risks identified here shape the audit program in Assessment 2.
How this BUS FPX 4068 Assessment 1 example is built
Process, duties, weaknesses, exposure. The opening describes the process as a sequence of tasks with a person or role against each, since a process written as departments has no separation of duties visible in it. A duties block identifies which incompatible functions sit together: authorization with custody, recording with reconciliation, or all three in a small operation. A weakness block states each one with what it would allow somebody to do and how long that could run before anybody noticed. A compensating controls block looks for what else might catch it, because owner review or a bank reconciliation may already cover the gap. An exposure block estimates what is actually at stake. The closing recommends a separation somebody could staff, with what it costs in hours rather than in principle.
Where the marks sit in the BUS FPX 4068 Assessment 1 scoring guide
Capella's scoring guide weighs the process description, the identification of incompatible duties, the exposure, the compensating controls and the recommendations. The process reaches Distinguished when each step names a person or role, since separation cannot be judged from departments. Duties score higher when incompatible combinations are named precisely, such as one person who can add a vendor and approve payments. Exposure earns credit when each gap is linked to a specific scheme or error it would allow. Compensating controls are judged on whether they are looked for and assessed honestly. Recommendations should be possible with the staff the nonprofit has, with cost and remaining risk stated. Proficient papers find weaknesses; Distinguished ones fix them in ways a small organization could sustain.
BUS FPX 4068 Assessment 1 help from the desk
Control evaluations often describe the process by department, which hides the fact that one person does most of the work. Another weakness is listing weaknesses without saying what each would allow, so the reader cannot judge which matter most. Compensating controls are ignored, or assumed to exist without checking. Recommendations call for hiring more staff, which a small nonprofit cannot do. Residual risk is left out, as if the new design removed all risk. Monitoring is missing. Drawing the process as a table with each task, the person who performs it and the function it represents makes incompatible duties easy to spot, and a board member reviewing the bank statement is often the cheapest compensating control available.
Get a BUS FPX 4068 Assessment 1 example written to your instructions
Send the Assessment 1 instructions and the scoring guide from your BUS FPX 4068 courseroom, plus the process or case your version describes. We write a custom example against those exact criteria and return it in 24 to 48 hours. The first custom sample is free, and writing the process as people rather than departments is the move worth taking from it. The paper above is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Capella University document.
More BUS FPX 4068 papers and BS in Business samples
- BUS FPX 4068 Assessment 2: Audit Procedures and Evidence
- BUS FPX 4068 Assessment 3: Fraud Examination Write Up
- BUS FPX 4070 Assessment 1: Cost of Capital Working
- BUS FPX 4065 Assessment 1: Taxable Position With Authority
- BUS FPX 4801 Assessment 1: Ethical Dilemma Case
- BUS FPX 4064 Assessment 1: Product Costing Working
BUS FPX 4068 Assessment 1 questions, answered
What are the incompatible duties I should look for?
Authorizing a transaction, having custody of the asset, and recording it. Any two together create an opportunity, and all three in one person creates a serious one. Checking those three against every step of your process will find most of what this assessment is looking for.
What if the organization is too small to separate duties?
Then say so and design around it, which is the realistic answer for most small businesses. Owner review of bank statements, a monthly reconciliation by somebody outside the process, or mandatory time off all reduce the risk without adding staff. That reasoning scores better than an ideal structure nobody could implement.
Do I need to quantify the exposure?
Roughly, and it strengthens everything else. Knowing that the weakness sits in a process handling a few hundred dollars a week is very different from one handling payroll. An estimate with a stated basis lets a reader judge whether the recommended control is worth what it costs.
Where can I find a free BUS FPX 4068 Assessment 1 sample paper?
The full control evaluation of the nonprofit's payables is on this page, with the process written as people, incompatible duties named, the exposure each gap creates and a separation that can be staffed. The audit program follows.
What are compensating controls in BUS FPX 4068 Assessment 1?
Controls that reduce the risk left by a weakness when duties cannot be fully separated, such as a board member reviewing bank statements or vendor changes each month.