BUS FPX 4070 Assessment 2 Project Evaluation example

Reviewed by Rupert Danvers, MBA Foundations in Finance Capella University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This BUS FPX 4070 Assessment 2 sample paper is a project evaluation for opening a small-format grocery store, discounting the project's cash flows at the cost of capital from Assessment 1. It belongs to Capella BUS FPX 4070, Foundations in Finance, which BS in Business students take as BUS-FPX4070. The paper counts incremental flows only, includes the investment in working capital and its recovery, and treats depreciation as a tax effect rather than a cash cost. It computes the value recovered at the end of the project's life, states the timing conventions, lays out the cash flows year by year, applies the firm's own rate and names what the result depends on.

CourseBUS FPX 4070 Foundations in Finance
AssessmentAssessment 2
Paper typeCapital budgeting project evaluation
LengthAbout 1,100 words, 6 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolCapella University
ProgramBS in Business
UpdatedSeptember 2026

Free sample paper for BUS FPX 4070 Assessment 2

1

Evaluating a Small-Format Grocery Store: Incremental Flows Only, Working Capital Included, Depreciation as a Tax Effect, the Firm's Own Rate, and the End-of-Life Recovery Computed

Student Name

Capella University

BUS FPX 4070: Foundations in Finance

Instructor Name

Month Day, Year

What this part is doingThe title names the project and the analysis steps. Capital budgeting papers are judged on which cash flows are counted, so incremental flows lead.
2

The Project

Heartland Market Group, the composite Midwestern chain with 64 supermarkets, is considering a small-format store in a growing suburb, on a five-year lease with an option to renew. The analysis assumes the store closes at the end of the lease, which is conservative. The store would need 6.0 million dollars of equipment and fit-out and would carry about 800,000 dollars of inventory and other working capital. Heartland's weighted average cost of capital is about 7.45%, and the project's risk is similar to its existing stores.

Incremental Flows Only

The analysis counts a cash flow only if building the store would alter it. Brealey et al. (2020) state the rule as comparing the firm's cash flows with the project to its cash flows without it. Included: the store's revenue, expected at 13.0 million dollars a year; its variable costs of goods and store supplies at 72% of revenue, leaving a contribution of 3.64 million dollars; its fixed costs for rent, staff, and utilities of 1.5 million dollars a year; and lost contribution at an existing Heartland store three miles away, which is expected to lose 1.5 million dollars of revenue a year, or 420,000 dollars of contribution at the same margin. Excluded: a 150,000 dollar site study already paid for, since it is sunk and will not change whether or not the store is built; and 200,000 dollars a year of corporate overhead that would be allocated to the store, since head office costs will not change. Annual earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization: 3.64 million minus 1.5 million minus 0.42 million, or 1.72 million dollars. Cannibalized sales are a real cost of the project, and the sunk study is not.

What this part is doingEach included and excluded item is justified. Scorers reward analyses that apply the incremental test to every flow.
3

Working Capital Included

The project needs 800,000 dollars of inventory, net of supplier credit, from day one. That cash is tied up for the life of the store, so it is an outflow at the start. When the store closes, the inventory is sold down or moved to other stores, and the 800,000 dollars returns. Omitting working capital would overstate the project's value, because money tied up for five years has a cost.

Depreciation as a Tax Effect

Depreciation is not a cash flow, but it reduces taxes, which are. The 6.0 million dollars of equipment and fit-out is depreciated on a straight-line basis over five years to zero for this analysis, 1.2 million dollars a year. At Heartland's 25% tax rate, depreciation saves 300,000 dollars of tax each year. Operating cash flow each year: 1.72 million times 0.75, plus the 300,000 dollar tax saving, or 1.29 million plus 0.30 million, which is 1.59 million dollars. As a check: earnings before interest and taxes are 1.72 million minus 1.2 million, or 0.52 million; tax is 0.13 million; net operating profit is 0.39 million; adding back depreciation gives 1.59 million dollars.

What this part is doingDepreciation enters only through the tax it saves. Scorers reward papers that treat depreciation as a tax effect.
4

The End-of-Life Recovery Computed

At the end of year five, two amounts return. The working capital of 800,000 dollars is recovered. The equipment is expected to sell for 500,000 dollars; with a book value of zero, the full 500,000 dollars is a taxable gain, leaving 375,000 dollars after tax. The total recovered in year five is 1.175 million dollars, on top of that year's operating cash flow.

Taxes and Timing Conventions

The analysis uses Heartland's 25% combined tax rate and assumes that each year's operating cash flow arrives at year end, a common simplification that slightly understates value because grocery cash comes in daily. Straight-line depreciation is used for clarity; accelerated tax depreciation, which would be available for much of the equipment, would move tax savings earlier and raise net present value. Inflation is assumed to affect revenue and costs equally, so the flows are in nominal terms consistent with a nominal cost of capital. Financing costs such as interest are excluded from the cash flows, because the cost of capital already reflects them; subtracting interest and then discounting at the weighted average rate would count the cost of debt twice.

The Cash Flows

Year 0: negative 6.0 million for equipment and negative 0.8 million for working capital, or negative 6.8 million dollars. Years 1 through 4: 1.59 million dollars each year. Year 5: 1.59 million plus 1.175 million, or 2.765 million dollars.

The Firm's Own Rate Applied

The flows are discounted at Heartland's own weighted average cost of capital of 7.45%, because the store's risk is like the company's existing business and the rate reflects what its lenders and shareholders require. Using a generic rate, or the rate a lender quotes on a loan, would ignore the cost of equity. Discount factors at 7.45%: 0.9307, 0.8661, 0.8061, 0.7502, and 0.6982. Present value of years 1 through 4: 1.59 million times 3.3531, or 5.33 million dollars. Present value of year 5: 2.765 million times 0.6982, or 1.93 million dollars. Total present value: 7.26 million dollars. Net present value: 7.26 million minus 6.8 million, or about 0.46 million dollars. The internal rate of return is about 9.8%, above the 7.45% cost of capital. The end-of-life recovery is worth about 0.82 million dollars today, more than the project's entire net present value.

What this part is doingThe discount factors and present values are shown. Scorers reward papers that make the arithmetic checkable.
5

What the Result Depends On

The recovered working capital and equipment are worth about 0.82 million dollars in present value, more than the 0.46 million dollar net present value, so the project's value depends on getting that money back. If the equipment sold for nothing, net present value would fall by about 0.26 million dollars but stay positive. If cannibalization were 3.0 million dollars of revenue instead of 1.5 million, annual cash flow would fall by 315,000 dollars and net present value would turn negative. The lease renewal option, not counted here, adds value if the store performs well, because Heartland could keep a profitable store open for another term without new fit-out spending, and management should revisit the decision in year four with actual sales.

Conclusion

Counting only incremental flows, including cannibalization and excluding the sunk study and allocated overhead, the store produces 1.59 million dollars of operating cash flow a year, with depreciation contributing through its 300,000 dollar tax saving. Including 800,000 dollars of working capital and a year-five recovery of 1.175 million dollars, and discounting at Heartland's 7.45%, net present value is about 0.46 million dollars and the internal rate of return about 9.8%. The project should proceed, with close attention to cannibalization.

6

References

Brealey, R. A., Myers, S. C., & Allen, F. (2020). Principles of corporate finance (13th ed.). McGraw-Hill Education.

Reading the BUS-FPX4070 Assessment 2 instructions

Assessment 2 in BUS FPX 4070 has you evaluate a capital investment. You define the project and its horizon, estimate the incremental cash flows for each year, including the initial investment, operating flows, working capital and terminal value, account for taxes and the tax effect of depreciation, discount the flows at the appropriate rate, and work out the project's net present value, its internal rate of return and the payback period. Costs that would occur anyway, such as allocated overhead or money already spent on a site study, are excluded. You then test how sensitive the result is to key assumptions and make a recommendation. Finance texts on capital budgeting support the analysis.

How this BUS FPX 4070 Assessment 2 example is built

Flows, rate, measures, sensitivity, in that order. The opening fixes the project and the horizon it is judged over. A cash flow block lays out each period's incremental amounts with the basis for each, and states explicitly what was excluded and why. A rate block carries forward the figure from the first assessment, with any adjustment if this project differs in risk from the firm as a whole. A measures block computes what the assessment requires and presents them together for comparison. A disagreement block explains any conflict between them. A sensitivity block identifies the input the answer is most exposed to and computes the value at which the recommendation reverses. The closing states the recommendation plainly with the figure that decided it. Every flow carries its period and its source.

Reading the BUS FPX 4070 Assessment 2 scoring guide

The scoring guide weighs the cash flows, the treatment of taxes and depreciation, working capital, the discount rate, the measures, the sensitivity and the recommendation. Cash flows reach Distinguished when each is incremental, with excluded items named and the reason stated. Depreciation scores higher when treated as a tax shield rather than an outflow. Working capital earns credit when included at the start and recovered at the end. The rate is judged on whether it comes from Assessment 1 and suits the project's risk. Measures should be computed accurately and explained where they disagree. Sensitivity should target the assumptions that matter most, such as sales per square foot. Proficient evaluations compute net present value; Distinguished ones show what could change the answer.

BUS FPX 4070 Assessment 2 help: mistakes that cost marks

Project evaluations commonly include sunk costs, such as a completed market study, which have already been paid regardless of the decision. Another weakness is subtracting depreciation as a cash outflow instead of using it to reduce taxes. Working capital is left out, or added at the start and never recovered. The end-of-life value is ignored. A generic discount rate is used instead of the firm's own. Sensitivity is skipped, so the recommendation rests on a single set of assumptions. Laying out the cash flows in one table with a row for each component and a column for each year, then showing net present value under a low and a high sales case, makes the evaluation clear and grounds the recommendation.

Get a BUS FPX 4070 Assessment 2 example written to your instructions

Send the Assessment 2 instructions and your BUS FPX 4070 scoring guide, along with the project data and the rate your first assessment produced. We write a custom example against those criteria and return it in 24 to 48 hours. The first custom sample is free, and computing the reversing value is what turns an evaluation into advice. The paper above is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Capella University document.

More BUS FPX 4070 papers and BS in Business samples

BUS FPX 4070 Assessment 2 questions, answered

Why do net present value and internal rate of return disagree?

Usually because of scale or because of what each assumes about reinvesting the cash that comes back. A rate of return implicitly assumes those amounts earn that same rate again, which is rarely available. Present value assumes they earn the firm's own cost of capital, which is the more defensible assumption and the reason to prefer it here.

How do I treat depreciation?

As a tax shield rather than a cash outflow. It reduces taxable income, so it reduces tax paid, and that tax saving is the cash effect. Deducting the depreciation itself from the cash flows is the single most common technical error in this assessment and it understates every project.

Should the project rate differ from the company rate?

If the project carries different risk, yes, and saying so earns credit. A stable company entering a volatile new line should not discount that venture at its own low rate. Where you adjust, explain the basis; where you do not, say why the project's risk resembles the firm's existing business.

Where can I find a free BUS FPX 4070 Assessment 2 sample paper?

This page holds the complete evaluation of the small-format store, with incremental flows only, working capital included, depreciation as a tax effect, the end-of-life recovery and the firm's own rate applied.

Is depreciation a cash flow in BUS FPX 4070 Assessment 2?

No. Depreciation is not paid out, but it lowers taxable income and so lowers the tax paid. That tax saving is the cash effect the evaluation counts.