| Course | BUS FPX 4070 Foundations in Finance |
|---|---|
| Assessment | Assessment 3 |
| Paper type | Capital structure recommendation |
| Length | About 1,120 words, 6 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Capella University |
| Program | BS in Business |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for BUS FPX 4070 Assessment 3
Financing a Distribution Center With Debt or Equity: The Need Shapes the Instrument, Both Options Computed, Capacity for Fixed Payments, What Current Holders Give Up, and When the Other Choice Would Win
Student Name
Capella University
BUS FPX 4070: Foundations in Finance
Instructor Name
Month Day, Year
The Need
Heartland Market Group, a Midwestern supermarket operator with 64 stores and publicly traded shares, plans to build a 150 million dollar distribution center to replace an aging leased warehouse. The new center will cut delivery and warehouse costs, and management expects it to add about 15 million dollars a year to earnings before interest and taxes, raising the total from 140 million to 155 million dollars. The question is whether to raise the 150 million dollars through new long-term debt or new common stock.
The Need Shapes the Instrument
The nature of the need points toward certain instruments. A distribution center is a long-lived, tangible asset that will produce steady cost savings for 25 years or more. Brealey et al. (2020) note that firms tend to match the maturity of financing to the life of the assets it funds and that tangible assets support borrowing because they hold value as collateral. That suggests long-term debt, such as 15-year notes or a mortgage on the building, rather than short-term bank loans that would need refinancing. Equity is also suitable for a long-lived asset, but it is more costly and dilutes ownership. The comparison below tests whether debt's advantages hold for Heartland. A 25-year building should not be financed with money due back in three years.
Both Options Actually Computed
Current position: 40 million shares at 32 dollars; 560 million dollars of existing debt at 5.5%, with annual interest of 30.8 million dollars; tax rate of 25%. Option A, debt: 150 million dollars of 15-year notes at 6.5%, adding 9.75 million dollars of annual interest. Total interest is 40.55 million dollars. With earnings before interest and taxes of 155 million dollars, pretax income is 114.45 million, net income is 85.84 million, and earnings per share across 40 million shares are about 2.15 dollars. Option B, equity: 5 million new shares sold at a net price of 30 dollars after the offering discount and fees. Interest stays at 30.8 million dollars. Pretax income is 124.2 million, net income is 93.15 million, and earnings per share across 45 million shares are about 2.07 dollars. At the expected earnings level, debt gives about 8 cents more per share.
Capacity for Fixed Commitment
Debt brings fixed payments that must be met in bad years too. Interest coverage, earnings before interest and taxes divided by interest, would be about 3.8 times under Option A and 5.0 times under Option B. Heartland's existing loan agreements require coverage of at least 3.0 times. Under Option A, earnings could fall to about 121.7 million dollars, a drop of about 21%, before breaching the covenant. Debt to earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization, which would be about 215 million dollars, rises from about 2.8 times today to about 3.3 times under Option A, close to the 3.5 times limit in the same agreements. Grocery earnings are stable, but a price war or a failed remodel program could test these limits.
What Existing Holders Lose
Each option takes something from current shareholders. Under Option B, they give up about 11% of their ownership, since the 5 million new shares are 11.1% of the 45 million total, and a share of every future dollar of earnings. Selling shares at 30 dollars when they trade at 32 also transfers some value to new buyers. Under Option A, they keep full ownership but take on more risk: earnings per share become more volatile, the company's beta rises, and its financial flexibility falls, since it would have little room to borrow for another opportunity or a downturn. Lenders would also gain tighter covenants over future decisions.
When the Alternative Would Win
The two options give equal earnings per share where earnings before interest and taxes satisfy: (EBIT minus 40.55) times 0.75 divided by 40 equals (EBIT minus 30.8) times 0.75 divided by 45. Solving gives earnings before interest and taxes of about 118.6 million dollars. Above that, debt gives higher earnings per share; below it, equity does. Expected earnings of 155 million dollars are well above this point, but a fall of about 23.5% would reach it. Equity would also win if Heartland expected to need more borrowing capacity soon, for example for an acquisition, or if the rate on new notes rose above about 9.2%, where debt's earnings advantage disappears entirely. The indifference point shows how far earnings must fall before the other choice becomes the better one.
Other Options Considered
Two other routes were considered and set aside. A sale and leaseback, in which Heartland builds the center and sells it to an investor who leases it back, would avoid new debt on the balance sheet in a narrow sense, but lease accounting now records the obligation anyway, and lease payments on a specialized building tend to cost more than secured borrowing. A mix of the two, such as 100 million dollars of notes and 50 million dollars of stock, would keep leverage well under the limit at the cost of some dilution. That mix becomes the fallback if lenders price the full 150 million dollars above 7%, or if a downturn makes the covenant cushion look too thin at the time of issue.
Signals to Investors
The choice also sends a message. Issuing stock after a period of flat share prices can signal that management thinks the shares are fully valued, which often pushes the price down on announcement. Issuing debt signals confidence that the center's savings will cover the interest. For a stable grocer with predictable cash flows, that signal supports the debt route.
Recommendation
Heartland should finance the distribution center with 15-year notes, because the asset is long-lived and tangible, debt gives higher earnings per share at expected earnings, and earnings would have to fall about 23.5% before equity became better. Because leverage would approach the 3.5 times limit, management should hold capital spending on remodels to planned levels for two years and apply part of the distribution center's savings to reducing debt.
Conclusion
Both options were computed: debt gives earnings per share of about 2.15 dollars and equity about 2.07 dollars at expected earnings. Debt keeps full ownership but narrows coverage to 3.8 times and leverage to 3.3 times, near covenant limits, while equity costs current holders about 11% of ownership. Debt wins unless earnings fall below about 118.6 million dollars or Heartland needs its borrowing capacity for another purpose.
References
Brealey, R. A., Myers, S. C., & Allen, F. (2020). Principles of corporate finance (13th ed.). McGraw-Hill Education.
Reading the BUS-FPX4070 Assessment 3 instructions
The final assessment in BUS FPX 4070 asks you to recommend how a company should finance a need. You state the amount and purpose, set out the realistic options, such as a term loan, bonds or new shares, compute the effect of each on earnings per share, interest coverage and ownership, assess whether the company can carry more fixed payments, and recommend an option. The recommendation should say when the other option would be the better choice. The cost of capital and project evaluation from the earlier assessments provide context. Finance texts on capital structure, including the trade-off between tax benefits and financial distress, support the analysis.
How the BUS-FPX4070 Assessment 3 example is put together
Need, options, effects, recommendation. The opening states how much is needed and for what, since a permanent expansion and a seasonal shortfall call for different instruments. An options block sets out each realistic route with its cost and its conditions. An effects block computes what each does to the weighted cost of capital, to earnings per share and to the coverage of fixed obligations, which is the analysis the criteria are reading. A capacity block asks how much fixed commitment this firm can carry given the volatility of its cash flows. A recommendation block commits and states what existing holders give up. The closing names the circumstances under which the alternative would have been right. Figures carry their basis and the arithmetic is visible throughout.
BUS FPX 4070 Assessment 3 scoring guide: what Distinguished looks like
Marks go to the statement of need, the options, the computations, the capacity analysis, the dilution, the alternative case and the recommendation. The need reaches Distinguished when its size, purpose and duration are stated, since a permanent facility and a seasonal gap call for different financing. Options score higher when each has a cost and conditions. Computations earn credit when both options are worked in full, including earnings per share and coverage. Capacity is judged on whether the company could meet fixed payments in a weak year. Dilution should be quantified. Saying when the other option would win shows balance. Distinguished recommendations are clear about their conditions.
BUS FPX 4070 Assessment 3 help from the desk
Capital structure papers often choose debt because interest is tax deductible, without checking whether the company can carry the payments. Another weakness is computing one option in detail and the other in a sentence. Dilution is mentioned but not measured. The need is not described, so the instrument does not match it. Interest coverage in a bad year is not tested. The paper never says when equity would be better, so the recommendation seems one-sided. A side-by-side table showing earnings per share, coverage and ownership under each option, in a normal year and a weak one, makes the trade-off clear and closes the course with a practical financing decision.
Get a BUS FPX 4070 Assessment 3 example written to your instructions
Send the Assessment 3 instructions and the BUS FPX 4070 scoring guide from your courseroom, with the rate and project work your earlier assessments produced. We write a custom example against those exact criteria and return it in 24 to 48 hours. The first custom sample is free, and the capacity question is where this recommendation is really decided. The paper above is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Capella University document.
More BUS FPX 4070 papers and BS in Business samples
- BUS FPX 4070 Assessment 1: Cost of Capital Working
- BUS FPX 4070 Assessment 2: Project Evaluation
- BUS FPX 4801 Assessment 3: Ethics Recommendation and Disclosure
- BUS FPX 4068 Assessment 3: Fraud Examination Write Up
- BUS FPX 4802 Assessment 3: Adoption Measurement Plan
- BUS FPX 4065 Assessment 3: Planning Strategy Memo
BUS FPX 4070 Assessment 3 questions, answered
Is there an optimal capital structure?
In theory a level where the tax benefit of debt is balanced against the rising cost of financial distress, and in practice a range rather than a point. What the criteria reward is showing you understand the trade rather than locating a precise optimum, which the available information rarely supports anyway.
How much debt is too much?
Judge it by coverage rather than by ratio. Ask what happens to the ability to service the debt if revenue falls by a quarter, which is a downturn many businesses have seen. A structure that survives that is defensible, and one that does not needs an explicit argument for taking the risk.
Does dilution matter if the money is well used?
It matters to the people diluted, which is enough to require stating. If the investment earns more than the cost of the equity raised, existing owners can still be better off, and showing that arithmetic is a strong answer. Ignoring dilution entirely is what the criteria penalize.
Where can I find a free BUS FPX 4070 Assessment 3 sample paper?
The full debt or equity recommendation for the distribution center is here, with both options computed, capacity for fixed payments tested, dilution measured and the conditions under which the other choice would win.
What is interest coverage in BUS FPX 4070 Assessment 3?
Operating income divided by interest expense. It shows how many times the company could pay its interest, and lenders often require a minimum level in loan covenants.