BUS FPX 4801 Assessment 2 Stakeholder and Responsibility Analysis example

Reviewed by Rupert Danvers, MBA Ethics and Enterprise Capella University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This BUS FPX 4801 Assessment 2 sample paper is a stakeholder and responsibility analysis of a consumer goods company's refill pouch program, testing whether it is a responsibility effort or ordinary business. It belongs to Capella BUS FPX 4801, Ethics and Enterprise, taken in the BS in Business as BUS-FPX4801. The paper applies a would-do-anyway test, counts forgone revenue as a cost and separates returns by type, financial, reputational and environmental. It considers groups outside the sale, such as waste haulers and recyclers, looks at who else inside the firm is affected, checks the company's own claims against independent sources and lists what the board should ask for.

CourseBUS FPX 4801 Ethics and Enterprise
AssessmentAssessment 2
Paper typeStakeholder and responsibility analysis
LengthAbout 1,090 words, 6 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolCapella University
ProgramBS in Business
UpdatedSeptember 2026

Free sample paper for BUS FPX 4801 Assessment 2

1

A Stakeholder Analysis of a Refill Pouch Program: The Would-Do-Anyway Test, Forgone Revenue Counted as Cost, Returns Separated by Type, Groups Outside the Sale, and the Company's Claims Checked

Student Name

Capella University

BUS FPX 4801: Ethics and Enterprise

Instructor Name

Month Day, Year

What this part is doingThe title names the program and the analysis tests. Responsibility analyses are judged on whether they separate real commitments from marketing, so the tests are named.
2

The Program

Brightwell Home Products launched a refill program two years ago. Customers buy a sturdy dish soap or hand soap bottle once and then buy soft plastic refill pouches, sold at about 20% less per ounce than a new bottle. The company's sustainability report says the program "cuts plastic by 70%" and promotes it as a centerpiece of its responsibility strategy. The board's governance committee asked for an independent analysis of whether the program is a genuine responsibility commitment, what it costs and returns, who it affects, and whether the company's claims hold up.

The Would-Do-Anyway Test

The first test asks whether Brightwell would run the program even if it carried no responsibility label, because commercial choices described as responsibility deserve less credit than choices made at a cost. The program has clear commercial motives. Refill customers are loyal, since the bottle they own fits only Brightwell pouches. Pouches cost less to make and ship than rigid bottles. Retail partners asked for refill options. Porter and Kramer (2011) argue that the best responsibility efforts create shared value, benefiting both company and society, so commercial motive does not make the program illegitimate. But it means the program would likely exist anyway, and the company should not describe it as a sacrifice. The test does not condemn the program; it tells the board how much moral credit to claim for it. A program the company would run for profit anyway is good business. It becomes responsibility only where the company gives something up.

What this part is doingThe would-do-anyway test is applied before crediting the program. Scorers reward analyses that separate commercial from ethical motives.
3

Forgone Revenue Counted as Cost

Where Brightwell does give something up, the cost is counted in full. The 20% discount per ounce reduces revenue from refill customers compared with selling them new bottles. In the last year, refill sales were about 9 million dollars; without the discount, the same volume would have brought about 11.25 million dollars, so the forgone revenue is about 2.25 million dollars. Offsetting this, pouches cost about 1.1 million dollars less to make and ship than the bottles they replaced. The net forgone contribution is therefore about 1.15 million dollars a year, before any gain from loyalty. This is the program's real cost to shareholders, and it is the part that fairly counts as a responsibility commitment.

Return Separated by Type

Returns are separated by type rather than blended into a single claim of success. Financial return: repeat purchase rates among refill customers are about 18 points higher than among bottle buyers, which the finance team estimates recovers roughly 600,000 dollars of the forgone contribution a year; the net financial cost is about 550,000 dollars. Reputational return: the program features in retailer sustainability rankings and news coverage, which is real but hard to measure. Environmental return: this is the return that justifies calling the program responsibility, and it is examined below with the company's claim. Keeping the types separate prevents a large reputational benefit from disguising a small environmental one, or the reverse.

What this part is doingFinancial, reputational, and environmental returns are kept apart. Scorers reward analyses that do not blend different kinds of benefit.
4

Groups Outside the Transaction

Stakeholders include groups who never buy the product. Freeman et al. (2010) emphasize that a firm's effects reach groups with no contract with it. Municipal recycling programs are one such group: rigid bottles made of high-density polyethylene are accepted by most curbside programs, while multilayer soft pouches are accepted by very few. Moving customers from bottles to pouches may reduce plastic weight but shift more plastic from recycling into landfill. Communities near the company's pouch supplier are another group, since pouch lamination involves adhesives and solvents regulated under air permits. Retail store employees who stock and handle leaking pouches are a third. None of these groups appears in the sustainability report.

Who Else Inside the Firm Is Affected

Employees are also stakeholders in the program, and their interests differ. The packaging line that fills rigid bottles runs fewer shifts as pouch volume grows, and pouches are filled by an outside supplier, so about 14 line jobs at the company's Ohio plant have been reduced from full time to part time over two years. The company described the program to employees as a shared environmental achievement without mentioning the hours lost. Customer service staff field complaints about leaking pouches, which make up about a fifth of refill-related calls. A responsibility analysis that praises environmental gains while leaving out the people inside the company who bear part of the cost gives the board an incomplete picture.

Company Claims Checked

The claim "cuts plastic by 70%" is checked against evidence. A 16-ounce bottle weighs about 60 grams, and a pouch holding the same amount weighs about 18 grams, so each pouch used instead of a new bottle uses 70% less plastic by weight. The claim is accurate for one refill. It is not accurate for the program as a whole, because not every pouch replaces a bottle; about a third of pouch buyers also keep buying bottles for other rooms, and the first purchase includes a heavier reusable bottle. Company data suggest the program-wide reduction in plastic weight is closer to 45%. The claim also counts weight, not recyclability; measured by plastic that ends up in landfill, the reduction may be much smaller. A claim that is true for one pouch and false for the program is a claim the report should not make.

What this part is doingThe company's headline claim is tested with its own data. Scorers reward analyses that verify rather than repeat claims.
5

What the Board Should Ask For

The governance committee should ask management for three changes. First, restate the claim as the program-wide figure, with the method explained. Second, report pouch recyclability plainly and set a target for a recyclable pouch material, since a mono-material pouch accepted by store drop-off programs would address the recycling concern. Third, add groups outside the sale to the next stakeholder review, including local recycling programs and the supplier's community, and report the effect on plant employees alongside the environmental results.

Conclusion

Brightwell's refill program would likely exist for commercial reasons, but it also forgoes about 1.15 million dollars of contribution a year, of which about 550,000 dollars remains after loyalty gains, and that is its genuine responsibility cost. Its returns differ by type, and it affects recycling programs and communities that never buy the product. The 70% claim holds for a single refill but overstates the program, and the board should require a program-wide figure and a plan for recyclable pouches.

6

References

Freeman, R. E., Harrison, J. S., Wicks, A. C., Parmar, B. L., & de Colle, S. (2010). Stakeholder theory: The state of the art. Cambridge University Press.

Porter, M. E., & Kramer, M. R. (2011). Creating shared value. Harvard Business Review, 89(1/2), 62-77.

What the BUS FPX 4801 Assessment 2 instructions ask for

Assessment 2 in BUS FPX 4801 has you analyze a company's corporate responsibility program from the viewpoint of its stakeholders. You describe what the program actually does, identify the stakeholders affected, including groups outside the customer relationship, estimate its costs, including revenue given up, assess the returns by type, check the company's claims against independent evidence and judge whether the program serves stakeholders or mainly the company's image. A useful test is whether the company would do this anyway for commercial reasons. Sources include the company's sustainability reporting, independent studies and research on stakeholder theory.

How the BUS-FPX4801 Assessment 2 example is put together

Program, cost, return, stakeholders. The opening describes what the company actually does under this heading, from its own reporting and from independent sources where any exist. A cost block prices each activity, including the ones whose cost is forgone revenue rather than spend. A return block asks what the business receives and when, distinguishing reputation from risk reduction from genuine commercial advantage. A stakeholder block identifies who gains and who pays, including groups outside the transaction entirely. An assessment block then judges the program, separating what is substantive from what is presentational. The closing recommends one change with its cost stated. Company claims are checked against independent reporting rather than reproduced. A short block names what the analysis could not establish, since responsibility reporting is voluntary and the gaps in it are frequently the most informative part.

BUS FPX 4801 Assessment 2 scoring guide: what Distinguished looks like

The scoring guide weighs the program description, the stakeholder identification, the costs, the returns, the evidence and the judgment. The description reaches Distinguished when based on what the company does, drawn from its reports and independent sources. Stakeholders score higher when groups beyond customers and shareholders are included. Costs earn credit when forgone revenue is counted. Returns are judged on whether they are separated by type. Evidence should include independent checks of company claims, since sustainability reports are written by the company. The judgment should be supported by the analysis, with a clear verdict on whether the program earns the word responsibility. Distinguished papers test the program rather than describe it.

BUS FPX 4801 Assessment 2 help from the desk

Stakeholder papers commonly repeat the company's sustainability report as though it were independent evidence. Another weakness is listing stakeholders without analyzing how each is affected. Costs are limited to spending, missing revenue given up. Returns are lumped together, so it is unclear whether the program helps the environment or only the brand. Groups outside the sale are ignored. The judgment is not tied to the evidence, so a reader cannot see why the program passes or fails. Applying the would-do-anyway test first, then building a table of stakeholders with the effect on each and the source of the evidence, makes the analysis rigorous and gives the board questions at the end a clear basis.

Get a BUS FPX 4801 Assessment 2 example written to your instructions

Send the Assessment 2 instructions and your BUS FPX 4801 scoring guide, along with the company or case your first assessment established. We write a custom example against those criteria and return it in 24 to 48 hours. The first custom sample is free, and the test of what the business would do anyway is the analytical move worth copying. The paper above is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Capella University document.

More BUS FPX 4801 papers and BS in Business samples

BUS FPX 4801 Assessment 2 questions, answered

Is corporate responsibility just public relations?

Sometimes, and a good paper distinguishes the cases rather than settling the question in advance. An activity carrying a real cost and no obvious commercial return is evidence of something; one generating favorable coverage for very little outlay is evidence of considerably less. Applying that test initiative by initiative is what earns the credit here. Deciding it beforehand is the failure.

Where do I find independent information?

Regulatory filings, court records, investigative reporting and industry bodies, and it is worth the effort. A company's own sustainability report tells you what it wants understood. The gap between that and what independent sources describe is frequently the most interesting paragraph available to you. The gap between the two accounts is where the analysis lives.

How do I judge a group I cannot get information about?

Say what you would need and reason from what the business does to them. Communities near a facility and workers in a supplier's factory rarely publish anything, and that silence is itself worth noting, since the groups a company hears least from are usually the ones bearing most of what it externalizes.

Where can I find a free BUS FPX 4801 Assessment 2 sample paper?

This page presents the full stakeholder analysis of the refill pouch program, with the would-do-anyway test, forgone revenue counted, returns separated by type and the company's claims checked.

What is the would-do-anyway test in BUS FPX 4801 Assessment 2?

A question asking whether the company would run the program for purely commercial reasons. If so, calling it responsibility adds little; the test separates real responsibility from ordinary business.