| Course | DB FPX 8720 Strategic Digital Transformation |
|---|---|
| Assessment | Assessment 3 |
| Paper type | Transformation roadmap critique |
| Length | About 1,140 words, 5 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Capella University |
| Program | Doctor of Business Administration (DBA) |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for DB FPX 8720 Assessment 3
Critiquing a Three-Year Digital Roadmap for a Moving Company: Order Argued From Dependencies, Exposure During Each Step, Reversible and Committing Steps Separated, Decision Points Between Steps, and Grounds for Pausing
Student Name
Capella University
DB FPX 8720: Strategic Digital Transformation
Instructor Name
Month Day, Year
The Roadmap Under Review
After the maturity assessment and the redesign of the estimating process, Harbor Line Moving and Storage received a three-year roadmap from the vendor of its customer relationship management system. The roadmap proposed five steps in this order: in year one, replace the current system with the vendor's new enterprise platform and add a customer portal; in year two, introduce route optimization for dispatch and dynamic pricing for local moves; in year three, launch a mobile app for crews that records time, inventory, and damage photos. The vendor's estimate for licenses and implementation over three years was about 610,000 dollars.
Order Argued, Not Assumed
The vendor's order begins with the largest change, a platform replacement, because the other steps are built on its platform. Westerman et al. (2014) found that firms with a sound technology foundation were better able to scale digital initiatives than those that layered new tools on fragmented systems, and that finding is the strongest argument for the vendor's order. That is a reasonable order for the vendor's products, but not necessarily for Harbor Line's needs. An order argued from the firm's dependencies looks different. The redesign already underway, video surveys for local estimates, uses a tool the firm owns and needs no new platform. The crew mobile app, placed last by the vendor, is the step that would supply the data several other steps depend on: dynamic pricing requires accurate labor hours by job, and job profitability, rated low in the maturity assessment, requires the same. Route optimization depends on current truck location, which the firm's GPS units already provide. The customer portal depends on the status data that a crew app and GPS would produce. An order argued from dependencies would therefore run: complete the video survey redesign; connect existing GPS data to dispatch; introduce a crew app for time and job data; then, with a year of job-level data, consider dynamic pricing; and treat a platform replacement as a decision to make when the current system actually limits one of these steps.
Exposure During the Step, Not After
Each step creates exposure while it is being carried out, and the vendor's roadmap discusses benefits after completion but not risks during implementation. The platform replacement is the most exposed step: for three to six months, customer records, estimates, and bookings would move to a new system during the firm's busiest season if the vendor's schedule is followed, since most local moves occur from May through August. A failure during migration could leave customer service unable to find bookings. Dynamic pricing carries a different exposure: while the model is learning, prices could swing in ways that confuse customers and sales staff. The crew app's exposure is modest but real: crews unfamiliar with smartphones may enter time late or incorrectly for the first weeks. The vendor planned the largest migration for the months when a lost booking costs the most.
Reversible and Committing Steps Separated
The steps differ in how easily they can be undone. Connecting GPS data to dispatch is reversible: if dispatchers find it unhelpful, they can return to the whiteboard at no cost beyond the setup time. The crew app is largely reversible, since paper time sheets could be restored, though some data would be lost. Dynamic pricing is partly reversible, but customers who see prices change may not return. The platform replacement is committing: it carries a multi-year license, requires migrating all data, and would be expensive to reverse. A roadmap should place reversible steps first, so the firm learns before it commits, and should delay committing steps until the learning justifies them. The vendor's roadmap does the opposite. Vial (2019) notes that digital transformation typically meets organizational barriers, such as inertia and resistance, that technology alone does not remove. At Harbor Line those barriers are already visible in the unused tools, and a committing step taken before they are addressed would add a large new system to the list of things the firm owns but does not use.
What the Vendor's Order Gets Right
The critique should not dismiss the vendor's reasoning entirely. The current customer relationship management system is eight years old, its vendor will end support for the version in about three years, and it cannot connect easily to the crew app the critique places earlier. A replacement will eventually be needed. The disagreement is about timing and conditions, not about whether the platform matters. A reasonable compromise is to choose any new crew app and dispatch tools for their ability to connect to likely future platforms, so that the eventual replacement is not made harder by the steps taken first.
Decision Points Between Steps
The critique proposes a decision point after each step, with a question the owner answers before the next step begins. After the video survey redesign: did time to estimate fall to one day and the booking rate rise? If not, the firm should fix the process before adding more technology. After connecting GPS to dispatch: did dispatchers use the data daily, and did on-time arrival improve? If not, the problem is adoption, and further tools will face the same obstacle. After the crew app: are labor hours by job available within a week for at least 90% of jobs? If not, dynamic pricing cannot proceed, because it would be built on incomplete data. Before any platform replacement: has a specific step been blocked by the current system's limits? If not, the replacement is not yet needed.
Grounds for Pausing Named
The roadmap should pause if any of three conditions occurs. First, if a step's adoption remains below half of its intended users three months after launch, because adding further steps would stack new tools on unused ones, repeating the pattern the maturity assessment found. Second, if the firm's operating margin falls below 4% for two consecutive quarters, because digital spending would then compete with basic operations. Third, if a step's implementation would fall between May and August, because the exposure during peak season outweighs the benefit of an earlier start.
Conclusion
The vendor's roadmap puts a committing platform replacement first, schedules it during the busiest season, and places the step that supplies the most needed data last. Reordered by dependency, the roadmap would begin with steps the firm can take with tools it owns, move to reversible steps that produce job-level data, and treat committing steps as decisions to earn. Decision points between steps and named grounds for pausing would let the owner learn before spending most of the 610,000 dollars.
References
Vial, G. (2019). Understanding digital transformation: A review and a research agenda. Journal of Strategic Information Systems, 28(2), 118-144. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jsis.2019.01.003
Westerman, G., Bonnet, D., & McAfee, A. (2014). Leading digital: Turning technology into business transformation. Harvard Business Review Press.
DB FPX 8720 Assessment 3 instructions, in plain terms
The final assessment in DB FPX 8720 asks you to critique a transformation roadmap. You examine whether the sequence follows real dependencies, identify the operational and financial exposure during each step, distinguish steps that can be undone from those that cannot, place decision points where leaders should decide whether to continue, and state the conditions that should trigger a pause. The maturity assessment and redesign from the earlier assessments provide the context. Research on transformation sequencing and real options thinking supports the critique, and the roadmap's own budget shows where money is committed early.
How the DB-FPX8720 Assessment 3 example is put together
Sequence, exposure, reversibility, decision points. The opening restates the target model compactly and the maturity position it starts from, since a roadmap is a route between two established points. The second block sets out the sequence with an explicit argument for each ordering decision. The third gives every step its exposure statement, covering the period during which the step is in progress rather than only its end state. The fourth classifies steps by reversibility, separating the ones that can be undone from the ones that commit the organization. The fifth places decision points between steps, naming what would have to be true to proceed. The closing states what would justify pausing or abandoning the transformation. Headings follow the prompt, and dependency claims rest on the earlier assessments.
Reading the DB FPX 8720 Assessment 3 scoring guide
Marks go to the dependency analysis, the exposure, the reversibility, the decision points and the pause conditions. The order reaches Distinguished when argued from dependencies, such as dispatch data cleaned before automated scheduling is switched on. Exposure scores higher when stated for each step, including timing against the busy summer season. Reversibility earns credit when committing steps, like retiring the old booking system, are separated from reversible pilots. Decision points are judged on whether they sit between steps with clear criteria. Pause conditions should be specific and measurable. Cost should be considered where it shapes exposure. The critique should end with concrete changes to the roadmap. Distinguished critiques make the plan safer without making it slower than it needs to be.
DB FPX 8720 Assessment 3 help from the desk
Roadmap critiques often comment on the timeline without asking whether the steps are in the right order. Another weakness is ignoring exposure, so a major system change lands in the busiest month. Reversible and irreversible steps are treated alike. Decision points are missing, so the roadmap runs on autopilot. Pause conditions are vague or absent. The critique lists concerns without proposing changes. Cost is ignored, although spending committed early limits the firm's ability to change course. Marking each step as reversible or committing, with its exposure and the decision that must precede it, gives the critique structure and ends the course with a roadmap leaders can steer.
Get a DB FPX 8720 Assessment 3 example written to your instructions
Send the Assessment 3 instructions and the DB FPX 8720 scoring guide from your courseroom, with the maturity assessment and redesign your earlier work produced. We write a custom example against those exact criteria and return it in 24 to 48 hours. The first custom sample is free, and the exposure statements are the part most drafts have never attempted. The paper above is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Capella University document.
More DB FPX 8720 papers and DBA samples
- DB FPX 8720 Assessment 1: Digital Maturity Assessment
- DB FPX 8720 Assessment 2: Operating Model Redesign
- DB FPX 8730 Assessment 3: Creativity Intervention Proposal
- DB FPX 8710 Assessment 3: Implementation Critique
- DB FPX 8740 Assessment 3: Conceptual Framework Draft
- DB FPX 8650 Assessment 3: Literature Review Paper
DB FPX 8720 Assessment 3 questions, answered
How many steps should the roadmap have?
Few enough that each can be argued and given an exposure statement, which usually means four to six. A roadmap with fifteen steps has room for none of that, and the criteria are examining the reasoning behind the order rather than the granularity of the plan.
What does exposure mean if the step is just a pilot?
A pilot still exposes something: the customers or staff inside it, the credibility of the whole program if it fails visibly, and the time consumed while nothing else moves. Stating those honestly is what the criteria want. A step described as risk free is one whose risks were not examined.
Should the critique include cost?
Where your instructions ask for it, and in categories rather than false precision. What matters more for this assessment is the sequencing argument and the exposure, since a well costed plan in the wrong order still fails. A stated order of magnitude per step is usually sufficient unless the prompt requires more.
Where can I find a free DB FPX 8720 Assessment 3 sample paper?
The complete critique of the moving company's three-year roadmap is here, with order argued from dependencies, exposure during each step, reversible and committing steps separated and grounds for pausing.
What does exposure mean for a pilot in DB FPX 8720 Assessment 3?
Even a pilot can affect real customers, crews and revenue. Exposure is what the firm could lose during the step if it goes wrong.