HIM FPX 2660 Assessment 1 ethics case analysis example

Reviewed by Rupert Danvers, MBA Ethics and Compliance in Healthcare Data Management Capella University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This HIM FPX 2660 Assessment 1 sample paper is an ethics case analysis of a release of information request: a life insurer's authorization for all records, including psychotherapy notes and substance use treatment. It was written for Capella HIM FPX 2660, Ethics and Compliance in Healthcare Data Management, a BS in Health Information Management course listed as HIM-FPX2660. The paper sets out the request in detail, checks authority before release and holds the duties of confidentiality, patient autonomy and legal compliance against each other. It applies the scope of the authorization to the answer, addresses timeliness and fees, states what gets documented afterward and explains how to handle a follow-up.

CourseHIM FPX 2660 Ethics and Compliance in Healthcare Data Management
AssessmentAssessment 1
Paper typeRelease of information ethics case
LengthAbout 1,080 words, 5 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolCapella University
ProgramBS in Health Information Management
UpdatedSeptember 2026

Free sample paper for HIM FPX 2660 Assessment 1

1

Deciding a Release of Information Request: A Life Insurer's Authorization for "All Records," Including Psychotherapy Notes and Substance Use Treatment

Student Name

Capella University

HIM FPX 2660: Ethics and Compliance in Healthcare Data Management

Instructor Name

Month Day, Year

What this part is doingThe title names the requester and the two record types that make the request difficult. Release of information cases are judged on whether legal requirements are applied precisely, so the hard parts are named.
2

The Request Set Out in Detail

The release of information unit at a composite 250-bed hospital, here called Brookfield Medical Center, received a request from a life insurance company. The request asks for "all medical records, including but not limited to" hospital records, outpatient behavioral health records, and substance use treatment records, for an applicant who is also a Brookfield patient. It includes a form signed by the applicant eight weeks ago. The patient's record at Brookfield contains inpatient and outpatient medical records, progress notes from the hospital's outpatient behavioral health clinic, separately filed psychotherapy notes kept by the patient's therapist, and records from Brookfield's opioid treatment program, which is a federally assisted substance use disorder program. Setting out the request in this detail matters, because each part of the record is governed by different rules. Treating the request as a single request for "all records" would lead to a single, and wrong, answer.

Authority Checked Before Release

Under the HIPAA Privacy Rule, a disclosure to a life insurer for underwriting is not for treatment, payment, or health care operations, so it requires a valid authorization. A valid authorization must contain specific core elements: a specific description of the information to be disclosed, the name of the person or class of persons authorized to make the disclosure, the recipient, the purpose, an expiration date or event, and the signature of the individual with the date, together with required statements about the right to revoke, whether treatment may be conditioned on signing, and the potential for redisclosure (45 C.F.R. ยง 164.508; U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, 2025). The form was reviewed against each element. It names Brookfield and "any health care provider" as disclosers, the insurer as recipient, and "underwriting and claims" as the purpose. It expires two years after signing and contains the required statements. It is signed and dated by the patient. It is therefore valid for general medical records. Checking each element separately turns "the authorization looks fine" into a documented determination that can be defended later.

What this part is doingThe authorization is tested against each regulatory element. Scorers reward release decisions that verify authority precisely before acting.
3

Duties Held Against Each Other

Several duties apply to this request, and they point in different directions. The duty to honor a valid authorization supports releasing general medical records within the scope described. The duty to protect psychotherapy notes limits release. Under the Privacy Rule, psychotherapy notes, which are notes recorded by a mental health professional analyzing a counseling session and kept separate from the rest of the record, require a separate authorization specifically for psychotherapy notes. They cannot be released under a general authorization for all records. The outpatient behavioral health progress notes, which document medications, session times, and treatment plans, are part of the regular record and may be released under the general authorization. The duty under federal confidentiality rules for substance use disorder records limits release further. Records from a federally assisted program are protected by 42 C.F.R. Part 2, which requires written consent meeting that regulation's own requirements, including the name of the program, the specific kind and amount of information to be disclosed, and a notice about redisclosure. The 2024 changes to Part 2 aligned many of its requirements more closely with HIPAA, particularly for treatment, payment, and health care operations, but a disclosure to a life insurer for underwriting still requires a Part 2 compliant consent (U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, 2024). The insurer's form does not name the opioid treatment program or meet Part 2's requirements. State law also applies. Brookfield's state requires specific written consent for release of HIV test results; the record contains an HIV test, and the form does not include that consent.

Scope of the Authorization Applied to the Answer

The minimum necessary standard does not apply to disclosures made under a valid authorization; instead, the authorization itself defines what may be released. Brookfield must therefore release what the authorization covers and no more. The authorization describes "all medical records," which covers the general medical record, including outpatient behavioral health progress notes. It cannot cover psychotherapy notes, substance use treatment program records, or the HIV test result, because each requires a separate or specific authorization that has not been given. The answer to the insurer is therefore a partial release. Brookfield will send the general medical record, excluding the psychotherapy notes, the opioid treatment program records, and the HIV test result. The cover letter will state that certain records were not released because they require separate authorization under federal or state law, without stating what kind of records they are, since naming them would itself disclose protected information. The cover letter must explain that records were withheld without revealing what the withheld records are.

What this part is doingThe answer releases exactly what the authorization covers and states the withholding without disclosing its content. This is the precise application the assessment asks for.
4

Timeliness and Fees

Brookfield's policy is to respond to third-party authorized requests within 15 business days. The fee follows the hospital's schedule for third-party requests; the cost-based fee limit that applies to patients' own access requests does not apply to insurers acting under an authorization.

What Gets Documented Afterward

Brookfield must document the decision. The authorization must be retained for six years from its creation or last effective date, as required for HIPAA documentation (U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, 2025). The release of information system will record the request date, the requester, the authorization review, each category of record released and withheld with the reason, the date sent, and the staff member who processed it. Disclosures made under an authorization do not have to be listed in the patient's accounting of disclosures, but the internal log allows Brookfield to answer any later question from the patient, the insurer, or a regulator.

Handling a Follow-Up

If the insurer wants the withheld records, it must obtain a separate authorization for psychotherapy notes and a Part 2 compliant consent for the treatment program records, and meet the state's requirements for the HIV result. Brookfield can provide the forms to the insurer or the patient on request.

Conclusion

Setting out the request in detail showed that one request involved four sets of rules. The authorization was valid for general records but not for psychotherapy notes, substance use treatment records, or HIV results. The release was limited to what the authorization covered, the withholding was explained without disclosing content, and the decision was documented.

5

References

U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. (2024). Confidentiality of substance use disorder (SUD) patient records. Federal Register, 89(33), 12472-12628.

U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. (2025). Security and privacy (45 C.F.R. pt. 164). U.S. Government Publishing Office.

What the HIM FPX 2660 Assessment 1 instructions ask for

The first assessment in HIM FPX 2660 asks you to analyze an ethical and legal case in health information management. You describe the case facts, identify the ethical principles and professional standards involved, determine the applicable laws and regulations, analyze how they apply, reach a decision and explain the documentation and follow-up required. Release of information cases often involve HIPAA authorizations, psychotherapy notes and 42 CFR Part 2 for substance use disorder records. The AHIMA Code of Ethics provides professional standards. The analysis should reach a specific decision about what may be released. Legal citations should be accurate and current, since Part 2 was revised recently.

How the HIM-FPX2660 Assessment 1 example is put together

The example is arranged the way an access decision is actually made. It opens with the case facts, stripped of anything that would identify a real person, and states the question the analysis has to answer. The second section establishes what permission would look like here, naming the authority that would make release lawful and checking whether it exists in the case as given. The third section sets out the duties in conflict and applies a named ethical framework to each one, so the tension is analyzed rather than asserted. The fourth section reaches the decision and states its limits, including the narrowest set of information that satisfies the stated purpose. The final section covers what happens next: the documentation, the notification and the point at which the matter is escalated.

Where the marks sit in the HIM FPX 2660 Assessment 1 scoring guide

The scoring guide rates the case description, the ethical analysis, the legal analysis, the decision and the documentation. The legal analysis reaches Distinguished when each rule is applied precisely, such as the separate authorization required for psychotherapy notes and the consent rules for Part 2 records. Ethical analysis scores higher when duties are weighed against each other rather than listed. The decision earns credit when it states exactly what will and will not be released. Documentation and accounting of disclosures show professional practice. Timeliness and fees should be addressed, including the 30-day response window HIPAA sets for access requests. Citations of the AHIMA Code and federal rules should be accurate.

HIM FPX 2660 Assessment 1 help from the desk

Students often treat an all records authorization as permission to release everything. Another common mistake is overlooking the special protections for psychotherapy notes and substance use records. Ethical principles are named without being applied. The decision is vague, such as release what is appropriate. Documentation is left out. Legal citations are outdated. Fees are sometimes ignored, though HIPAA limits what can be charged when patients request their own records and state law may set rates for other requesters. The analysis should read like a decision a release of information specialist could defend to a patient, an auditor and a court.

Get a HIM FPX 2660 Assessment 1 example written to your instructions

Send the Assessment 1 instructions and the scoring guide from your HIM FPX 2660 courseroom, plus the case your section assigned. We write a custom example against those criteria, with the authority examined and the decision defended, and return it in 24 to 48 hours. The first custom sample is free. The paper above is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Capella University document.

More HIM FPX 2660 papers and BS in Health Information Management samples

HIM FPX 2660 Assessment 1 questions, answered

Which ethical framework should the analysis use?

Whichever your instructions allow, applied properly rather than listed. Principle-based analysis fits most access cases because confidentiality, autonomy and the duty to prevent harm map onto the facts directly. A code of ethics from a health information professional body works well alongside it, since it speaks to records practice specifically. Name the framework, then use it on every disputed point.

Does the analysis need to cite the privacy rule?

In most sections yes, because an ethical decision about a record still has to be lawful. Cite the provision or the agency guidance governing the release, then treat the ethical reasoning as what happens when the law permits something the situation still makes questionable. Legal permission and ethical justification are not the same finding, and the strongest papers say so.

Can I use a case from my own workplace?

Check your instructions first. Where a real case is allowed, remove every identifier, including the setting if naming it would narrow the field, and remember that your own duty to that record does not end because the case became coursework. A published or instructor-supplied case avoids the question entirely and is usually the safer choice.

Where can I find a free HIM FPX 2660 Assessment 1 sample paper?

This page holds the full release of information case analysis for the insurer's all-records request, with authority, ethics, scope, fees and documentation. A model analysis of your own case is available free.

Can psychotherapy notes be released with a general authorization in HIM FPX 2660 Assessment 1?

No. HIPAA requires a separate, specific authorization for psychotherapy notes, and substance use treatment records under 42 CFR Part 2 have their own consent rules.