| Course | HIM FPX 4650 Decision Support and Quality Management in Health Information Management |
|---|---|
| Assessment | Assessment 3 |
| Paper type | Decision support evaluation |
| Length | About 1,090 words, 5 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Capella University |
| Program | BS in Health Information Management |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for HIM FPX 4650 Assessment 3
Evaluating a Clinical Decision Support Alert: The Admission Venous Thromboembolism Prophylaxis Advisory, Its Overrides, and Whether to Retire It
Student Name
Capella University
HIM FPX 4650: Decision Support and Quality Management in Health Information Management
Instructor Name
Month Day, Year
The Decision Described Without the Tool
Before evaluating the tool, it helps to describe the clinical decision it supports. When an adult is admitted to the hospital, the admitting clinician should assess the patient's risk of venous thromboembolism, a blood clot in the veins that can travel to the lungs, and the patient's risk of bleeding. Based on these risks, the clinician decides whether to order preventive treatment: a blood thinner, mechanical compression devices, or neither. The decision should be made within 24 hours of admission and reassessed when the patient's condition changes. Describing the decision without the tool makes clear what the tool is supposed to improve: whether the assessment is done, and whether prophylaxis matches the assessed risk.
The Tool
At a composite 230-bed hospital, here called Fairmont Hospital, a best-practice advisory in the electronic health record supports this decision. Osheroff et al. (2012) set out five conditions that decision support must meet, often called its five rights, covering what the tool says, whom it reaches, the form it takes, the route it uses, and the moment in the workflow when it appears. The evaluation uses those five conditions as a lens, and the findings below show that the advisory fails most clearly on whom it reaches and when.
Trigger, Timing, and Audience Specified
Trigger: the advisory fires when an admission order is signed for a patient aged 18 or older and no venous thromboembolism risk assessment has been completed. Timing: it appears as a pop-up when the clinician signs the admission order set, and again each time the clinician opens the patient's chart until the assessment is completed. Audience: any user with ordering privileges who opens the chart, including admitting physicians, hospitalists, surgeons, consultants, and residents. Content: the advisory states that a risk assessment is required and offers a link to the assessment tool, which scores risk and suggests prophylaxis options. It can be overridden with one of four reasons: already on anticoagulation, comfort care, will complete later, or not my patient.
Override Examined, Not Just Counted
Over three months, the advisory fired about 14,200 times for about 3,100 admissions, an average of more than four times per admission. It was overridden 81% of the time. A simple count would suggest the advisory is ignored. Examining overrides tells a different story. A review of 300 overrides found that 44% were by consultants and residents who were not responsible for admission orders and selected "not my patient." Another 27% selected "will complete later," and in most of these cases the admitting clinician did complete the assessment within four hours. Eleven percent were for patients already on anticoagulation, which the advisory should have recognized automatically. Only 18% of overrides were by the responsible clinician with no assessment completed within 24 hours. Ancker et al. (2017) found that clinicians' likelihood of accepting alerts fell as they received more alerts and as repeated alerts accumulated for the same patient, which is consistent with the pattern at Fairmont, where repeated firing to the wrong audience trains clinicians to override. Examining overrides by reason and user shows that most reflect poor targeting rather than disregard for the decision.
Effect on the Decision
Despite the overrides, the tool has had some effect. Before the advisory, 74% of admissions had a documented risk assessment within 24 hours. With it, 93% do. However, the share of high-risk patients receiving appropriate prophylaxis rose only from 82% to 85%, suggesting that the advisory improved documentation more than it changed treatment decisions.
Downstream Effect on the Record
The advisory affects the record in ways that matter to health information management. The "will complete later" override creates an entry in the audit trail but no clinical documentation, so the record can show a period with no assessment even when the clinician intended one. The risk assessment tool generates a structured score, which is useful for quality reporting and coding of risk. However, some clinicians complete the assessment only to stop the advisory, selecting default answers, which may make the documented risk score inaccurate. A review of 50 completed assessments found that 12 had risk factors in the assessment that contradicted the history and physical, such as "no recent surgery" in a postoperative patient. Inaccurate structured data in the record can mislead later clinicians and distort quality reports.
Retiring the Tool Kept on the Table
Three options were considered: keep the advisory as is, redesign it, or retire it and rely on the admission order set. Keeping it as is was rejected because of its alert burden and the inaccurate assessments it encourages. Retiring it was seriously considered: the admission order set could require the risk assessment as a mandatory section, which would make the decision part of ordering rather than an interruption. However, surgeons often admit patients through procedure order sets that do not include the assessment, so retiring the advisory would leave a gap for surgical patients. Keeping retirement on the table forces the evaluation to justify the tool's continued existence rather than assume it.
Cost of the Current Design
The advisory's burden can be estimated. At an average of about five seconds per alert, 14,200 firings in three months consumed nearly 20 hours of clinician time, most of it by clinicians who were not responsible for the decision. More important than the time is the effect on attention: an alert that is overridden four times out of five teaches clinicians to dismiss alerts, which can carry over to more important ones.
Recommendation
Fairmont should redesign the advisory rather than retire it: fire only for the attending of record and the admitting clinician; suppress it for patients already on therapeutic anticoagulation; fire once at admission and once at 12 hours rather than every time the chart is opened; and add the risk assessment to the surgical admission order sets. After six months, the hospital should reevaluate the advisory with the same measures and consider retiring it if the order set changes achieve the same results.
Conclusion
Describing the decision without the tool, specifying its trigger and audience, examining overrides, and tracing its effect on the record shows that the advisory improves documentation but fires too often to the wrong people and encourages inaccurate assessments. It should be redesigned, with retirement reconsidered after the redesign.
References
Ancker, J. S., Edwards, A., Nosal, S., Hauser, D., Mauer, E., & Kaushal, R. (2017). Effects of workload, work complexity, and repeated alerts on alert fatigue in a clinical decision support system. BMC Medical Informatics and Decision Making, 17, Article 36. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12911-017-0430-8
Osheroff, J. A., Teich, J. M., Levick, D., Saldana, L., Velasco, F. T., Sittig, D. F., Rogers, K. M., & Jenders, R. A. (2012). Improving outcomes with clinical decision support: An implementer's guide (2nd ed.). HIMSS.
The Capella HIM FPX 4650 Assessment 3 instructions
The final assessment asks you to evaluate a clinical decision support tool from a health information and quality perspective. You describe the decision the tool supports, how it works, when it fires and for whom, analyze override data and reasons, assess its effect on the decision and on documentation, consider its costs, including alert fatigue, and recommend whether to keep, change or retire it. The five rights of clinical decision support provide a useful framework. Data such as override rates and prophylaxis rates, from reports or a composite, support the evaluation. Retiring a tool is a legitimate outcome if it does not help.
How the HIM-FPX4650 Assessment 3 example is put together
The example is arranged around the decision the tool touches. It opens by describing that decision as it happens without support, so the evaluation has a baseline to reason from. The tool is then described operationally: trigger, audience, timing, content and options. The criteria section states what a working support tool would do and how each of those would be evidenced, before any judgment appears. Findings run criterion by criterion, with acceptance, override and downstream record effects treated separately. The unintended effects section covers fatigue, workarounds and the burden a prompt adds to a workflow already tight. Recommendations attach to specific findings, and the example is willing to recommend narrowing or retiring the tool. The evaluation closes with what would be measured again and when.
Reading the HIM FPX 4650 Assessment 3 scoring guide
The scoring guide rates the baseline decision, the tool description, the override analysis, the effect evaluation, the costs and the recommendation. The baseline reaches Distinguished when the decision is described as it happens without the tool, giving a comparison. The tool description scores higher when trigger, timing and audience are specified. Override analysis earns credit when reasons are examined, such as alerts firing for patients already on anticoagulants. Effect evaluation should cover both the clinical decision and documentation. Costs include clinician time and fatigue, which can reduce attention to alerts that matter more. The recommendation should consider retiring the tool.
Common HIM FPX 4650 Assessment 3 mistakes, and how to avoid them
Students often count overrides without asking why clinicians override. Another common mistake is assuming the alert works because it exists. The baseline is missing, so no one knows what the tool changed. Costs are ignored. Documentation effects, such as reasons entered only to dismiss the alert, are overlooked. Retiring the tool is never considered, even when data show it rarely changes a decision. The five rights framework is named but not applied to this alert's content, recipient, timing, channel and format. Pharmacy and nursing views are left out, though both groups respond to the advisory. Grounding the evaluation in the decision rather than the software keeps it useful, and a short table of override reasons with their frequency makes the case for change.
Get a HIM FPX 4650 Assessment 3 example written to your instructions
Send the Assessment 3 instructions and the scoring guide from your HIM FPX 4650 courseroom, plus the tool or scenario your evaluation covers. We write a custom example against those criteria, with effect on decisions evidenced and override behavior examined, and return it in 24 to 48 hours. The first custom sample is free. The paper above is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Capella University document.
More HIM FPX 4650 papers and BS in Health Information Management samples
- HIM FPX 4650 Assessment 1: Quality Indicator Analysis
- HIM FPX 4650 Assessment 2: Reporting and Dashboard Proposal
- HIM FPX 1610 Assessment 3: Plain-language Translation
- HIM FPX 4630 Assessment 3: Statistical Interpretation Paper
- HIM FPX 2660 Assessment 3: Compliance Program Evaluation
- HIM FPX 3640 Assessment 3: EHR Optimization Proposal
HIM FPX 4650 Assessment 3 questions, answered
What counts as clinical decision support here?
Anything putting information in front of a decision at the point it is made. Drug interaction alerts, order sets, documentation templates requiring an element, reminders for overdue care, duplicate order warnings and calculated risk scores all qualify. Choose one with a describable trigger and an observable outcome, since a tool you cannot measure produces an evaluation with no findings.
How do I evaluate a tool without access to real usage data?
State the evidence your evaluation would use and reason from the scenario, published studies of similar tools, or clearly labeled assumptions. The criteria read for the evaluation method as much as for the result. Saying which data you would pull, from which system and over what period, is stronger than presenting an impression as a finding.
Is a high override rate always a failure?
No, and treating it as one is the common error. Overrides can mean the prompt fires on cases it should not, that its threshold is set too wide, or that it duplicates a check made earlier in the workflow. They can also mean it is being ignored. The reasons separate those readings, which is why the evaluation examines them individually.
Where can I find a free HIM FPX 4650 Assessment 3 sample paper?
This page contains the full evaluation of the VTE prophylaxis advisory, with the baseline decision, trigger and audience, override reasons, effects, costs and the retirement question. An evaluation of another tool is available on request.
Is retiring an alert a valid recommendation in HIM FPX 4650 Assessment 3?
Yes. If an alert does not change decisions for the better and adds burden, retiring or redesigning it can improve care. The evaluation should keep that option open and support it with data.