| Course | HRM FPX 5070 Workplace Learning Strategies for the HR Professional |
|---|---|
| Assessment | Assessment 1 |
| Paper type | Training needs assessment |
| Length | About 1,170 words, 6 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Capella University |
| Program | MS in Human Resource Management |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for HRM FPX 5070 Assessment 1
A Training Needs Analysis for Quoting Errors at a Building Supply Distributor: The Gap as a Measurement, Three Levels of Analysis, Non-Training Causes Ruled Out, the Audience Defined, and a Recommendation With Limits
Student Name
Capella University
HRM FPX 5070: Workplace Learning Strategies for the HR Professional
Instructor Name
Month Day, Year
The Gap Stated as a Measurement
Keystone Building Supply, a composite distributor of lumber, roofing, and building materials to contractors, employs 34 inside sales representatives across five branches who prepare price quotes for contractor orders. Eight months ago, the company moved to a new enterprise system with a quoting module that applies contract pricing, volume breaks, and freight charges. Since then, the share of quotes that contain a pricing error found at invoicing or by the customer has risen from about 2% to 7.8%, measured from credit memos and quote revisions over the last three months. The company's target is 2%. The gap is 5.8 percentage points, or about 630 quotes with errors each month out of about 8,100, roughly 470 more than the target allows. Credit memos for underpriced quotes cost about 31,000 dollars a month in lost margin, and overpriced quotes have lost at least four contractor accounts.
Three Levels of Analysis, Not One
Noe (2020) describes needs assessment at three levels: the organization, the task, and the person. Each is used, because a problem that looks like a skill gap at the person level may have causes at the other two. Organization: the move to the new system was a strategic decision, and leadership supports training; the regional sales managers asked for help. The budget allows about 15,000 dollars. Time is limited, because representatives are measured on quote turnaround and cannot leave the phones for long. Task: a quote requires selecting the customer, confirming the customer's price contract, entering items, applying volume breaks, adding freight by zone, and checking the margin. Observation of 20 quotes found errors concentrated in two steps: contract pricing, where the system requires selecting the active contract from a list that includes expired ones, and freight, where zones changed with the new system. Person: errors are uneven. Nine representatives account for 61% of errors, with an average error rate of about 12%; the other 25 average about 5%, much of it from the system and data problems described below. A gap at the person level is often a gap at the task or organization level in disguise.
Non-Training Causes Ruled Out Explicitly
Training helps only when people do not know how to do something. Mager and Pipe (1997) suggest asking whether the person could do the task correctly if their life depended on it; if so, the problem is not a lack of skill. Four non-training causes were tested and addressed. System design: expired contracts appear in the selection list. This is a system problem; the information technology team can hide expired contracts, and a request has been made. Data: freight zone tables in the new system contained errors for 11 ZIP code areas. These were corrected last month; errors in those areas dropped, confirming the cause. Incentives: representatives are measured on quote turnaround, which rewards speed over accuracy. The sales director agreed to add accuracy to the monthly scorecard. Capacity: representatives with the most errors are not busier than others, so workload does not explain their errors. After these causes are addressed, a skill gap remains: the nine representatives with the highest error rates could not correctly apply volume breaks or verify margin in a test scenario, while others could.
The Audience Defined Precisely
The audience for training is defined precisely. Primary: the nine representatives whose error rates exceed 8% and who failed the scenario test on volume breaks or margin verification. Secondary: the five branch sales managers, who approve quotes above 25,000 dollars and need to spot the same errors. Not included: the 25 representatives with error rates near 5%, who passed the scenario test; they will receive a one-page reference on the system changes instead of training. Of the nine, six have been with the company less than two years and learned quoting only in the new system; three are experienced representatives who learned the old system and have not adapted to its differences.
Data Sources and Their Limits
The error rate comes from credit memos and quote revisions, which capture errors that were caught. Errors that customers never noticed, such as a small overcharge on freight, are not counted, so the true rate may be higher. Observation covered 20 quotes, enough to show where errors cluster but not to estimate precise rates for each step. The scenario test was built by the sales operations team from real quotes and reviewed by two branch managers for accuracy. Interviews with the nine representatives, done privately, supported the test results: six said they were never shown how volume breaks work in the new system, and three said they assumed the new system handled breaks the way the old one did.
Stakeholders Consulted
The analysis was reviewed with the vice president of sales, the five branch managers, and the information technology lead for the quoting module before the recommendation was made. The information technology lead confirmed that hiding expired contracts is a configuration change that can be made within two weeks, which is why it is treated as a separate fix rather than a topic for training.
A Recommendation With Stated Limits
Keystone should provide focused training to the nine representatives and five managers on applying volume breaks, verifying margin, and selecting contracts, using real quotes from their branches. The training should be short, practice-based, and delivered in two 90-minute sessions so representatives are away from the phones briefly. The recommendation has limits. Training will not fix errors caused by expired contracts in the selection list, which requires the system change. It will not overcome an incentive that rewards speed over accuracy if the scorecard change is not made. It will address the nine representatives' skill gap, which accounts for most, but not all, of the excess errors. If all non-training fixes are made and training succeeds, the error rate is expected to fall to about 3%, still above the 2% target; the remaining gap will need further review. Training can close a skill gap. It cannot close a gap the system or the scorecard keeps open.
Measures for the Next Stage
The design and evaluation stages will use the same measures: the error rate by representative from credit memos and revisions, the scenario test pass rate, and monthly margin lost to credit memos.
Conclusion
Keystone's quoting error rate has risen to 7.8% against a 2% target. Organization, task, and person analysis shows the errors concentrate in contract selection and freight steps and among nine representatives. System, data, and incentive causes were identified and assigned to other fixes. Focused training for the nine representatives and five managers is recommended, with the explicit limit that training alone will not reach the target.
References
Mager, R. F., & Pipe, P. (1997). Analyzing performance problems: Or, you really oughta wanna (3rd ed.). Center for Effective Performance.
Noe, R. A. (2020). Employee training and development (8th ed.). McGraw-Hill Education.
HRM FPX 5070 Assessment 1 instructions, in plain terms
In the first HRM FPX 5070 assessment you decide whether a drop in performance is a learning problem at all, and if so, whose. You describe the gap with data, analyze it at the organization, task and person levels, test whether causes other than missing skill, such as pricing software, incentives or unclear policy, explain the gap, define exactly who needs to learn what, describe your data sources and their weaknesses, and recommend a course of action with its limits. The three-level model from McGehee and Thayer, and later work in training research, provides the framework. The findings shape the program design in Assessment 2.
Inside the HRM FPX 5070 Assessment 1 example
The example is built to arrive at its recommendation reluctantly. It opens with the business problem and the gap expressed as a measurement, with the source of each figure named. The organizational analysis follows, connecting the gap to a goal, a cost or a risk the employer already recognizes, and establishing that support and resources exist. The task analysis describes what competent performance actually involves, broken into the components someone would have to be able to do. The person analysis identifies who is affected and how their current performance was assessed. The cause section then works through the alternatives to training deliberately, one at a time, with evidence for the conclusion reached about each. Only afterward does the recommendation appear, naming what training should cover, for whom, and which parts of the gap require a management fix instead.
Where the marks sit in the HRM FPX 5070 Assessment 1 scoring guide
Capella's scoring guide rates the gap statement, the three levels, the ruling out of other causes, the audience, the data and the recommendation. The gap reaches Distinguished when stated as a measurement, such as the percentage of quotes revised after the customer disputes them. The three levels score higher when each is analyzed with evidence, not named in passing. Non-training causes earn credit when tested one by one, since a pricing screen that hides freight charges will defeat any course. The audience is judged on precision, naming which representatives, by tenure or branch, show the gap. Data sources should carry their limits. The recommendation should say what training can and cannot fix. Proficient assessments find a need; Distinguished ones prove it is a learning need.
Common HRM FPX 5070 Assessment 1 mistakes, and how to avoid them
Needs assessments often begin with a training topic already chosen and gather data to justify it. A second weakness is stating the gap in words like "poor accuracy" with no figure, so no one can tell later whether it closed. The organization and task levels are skipped in favor of a survey of employees. Other causes, such as confusing software or sales targets that reward speed, are never checked. Everyone in the department is named as the audience, although the errors cluster among newer staff. Data limits go unmentioned. Sorting the quote errors by representative, branch and error type before deciding anything reveals where the gap really sits and keeps the recommendation honest.
Get a HRM FPX 5070 Assessment 1 example written to your instructions
Send the Assessment 1 instructions and the scoring guide from your HRM FPX 5070 courseroom, plus the performance problem you have been asked to examine. We write a custom example to those criteria, with the gap measured and the non-training causes worked through, returned in 24 to 48 hours. The first custom sample is free. The paper above is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Capella University document.
More HRM FPX 5070 papers and MS in Human Resource Management samples
- HRM FPX 5070 Assessment 2: Learning Program Design
- HRM FPX 5070 Assessment 3: Training Evaluation Plan
- HRM FPX 5075 Assessment 1: Stakeholder Influence Analysis
- HRM FPX 5065 Assessment 1: Employment Law Analysis
- HRM FPX 5080 Assessment 1: Workforce Metrics Report
- HRM FPX 5060 Assessment 1: Job Analysis
HRM FPX 5070 Assessment 1 questions, answered
What if the organization has no performance data?
Use what exists and say what it is. Error rates, rework, customer complaints, safety incidents, turnover, cycle times and quality audits all sit in systems most employers already run. Where nothing is available, observation and structured supervisor interviews can establish a baseline, provided you say how the data was collected and treat the resulting figures as an estimate rather than a fact.
How do I show that a gap is really a training problem?
Ask whether the employees could perform the task if their life depended on it. If they could, the gap is motivation, expectation, feedback, tooling or consequence, and a course will not repair any of those. If they genuinely could not, a skill or knowledge deficiency exists. Document the evidence for whichever conclusion you reach, since the criteria reward the reasoning rather than the answer.
Can I use my own workplace for this assessment?
In many sections yes, and access to real performance data makes the analysis considerably stronger. Check your instructions first, report figures in aggregate and keep employee identifiers out of the document entirely. Describe the employer by size, sector and structure. If internal data is unavailable, published industry benchmarks can establish the required performance side of the gap.
Where can I find a free HRM FPX 5070 Assessment 1 sample paper?
The needs assessment for the quoting errors is on this page, with the gap stated as a measurement, three levels of analysis, non-training causes ruled out, a precise audience and a recommendation with limits.
What are the three levels of needs analysis in HRM FPX 5070 Assessment 1?
Organization analysis asks whether the problem matters to strategy and whether support exists. Task analysis asks what the job requires. Person analysis asks who lacks the capability.