MBA FPX 5006 Assessment 2 Business Strategy example

Reviewed by Rupert Danvers, MBA Business Strategy Capella University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This MBA FPX 5006 Assessment 2 sample paper sets out a business strategy for a regional grocery chain squeezed between national discounters and online delivery services, choosing among options that differ in kind rather than degree. It belongs to Capella MBA FPX 5006, Business Strategy, which Capella MBA students take as MBA-FPX5006. The paper describes the firm's position and develops its criteria from that position before judging any option. It reasons through each rejected option, recommends one strategy and states plainly what it forecloses, including some customers the chain will lose. It then covers implications for operations and culture and explains how success will be measured.

CourseMBA FPX 5006 Business Strategy
AssessmentAssessment 2
Paper typeBusiness strategy recommendation
LengthAbout 1,080 words, 5 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolCapella University
ProgramMBA
UpdatedSeptember 2026

Free sample paper for MBA FPX 5006 Assessment 2

1

Business Strategy: Choosing a Strategic Direction for a Regional Grocery Chain Squeezed Between Discounters and Online Delivery

Student Name

Capella University

MBA FPX 5006: Business Strategy

Instructor Name

Month Day, Year

What this part is doingThe title names the firm, its situation, and the question. A strategy paper is judged on whether its choice fits a specific firm, so the firm's position is summarized in the title.
2

Introduction

Regional grocery chains face pressure from two sides: national discounters that compete on price, and online delivery services that compete on convenience. This paper develops a strategy for a composite regional chain, here called Harbor Market, with 42 stores in three states, annual sales of about 1.3 billion dollars, and thin operating margins of about 2%. It builds on an earlier analysis of the chain's environment, develops three strategic options, sets criteria for choosing among them, reasons through the rejected options, and describes what the chosen strategy forecloses.

The Firm's Position

Harbor Market's position is mixed. Its stores are older and mid-sized, located in suburban and small-town areas. It has a loyal customer base, particularly among shoppers over 50, and strong prepared foods and bakery departments, which earn higher margins than center-store groceries. Its prices are higher than those of the discount chains that have opened nearby, and its online ordering system is basic, with pickup only. Its private-label brand is well regarded but covers only a small share of products. Its distribution center and relationships with regional farms give it access to local produce that national competitors do not carry.

Options That Differ in Kind

Three options differ in kind, not only in degree. Option one: compete on price. Cut prices on the most frequently purchased items to within 5% of discounters, expand private label to lower costs, and reduce service departments to fund the price investment. Option two: differentiate on fresh, local, and prepared food. Invest in expanding prepared foods, bakery, and local produce; remodel stores to emphasize these departments; and position Harbor Market as the place for quality fresh food rather than the cheapest basket. Option three: become a convenience-led omnichannel grocer. Invest heavily in home delivery and a better app, convert some store space to fulfillment, and compete with online services on speed and ease. Porter (1996) argued that strategy requires choosing a unique position and a distinctive set of activities, rather than trying to match competitors on operational effectiveness. The three options represent different positions, not different levels of the same effort.

What this part is doingEach option represents a distinct strategic position. Scorers reward strategy papers whose alternatives are real choices rather than variations on one plan.
3

Criteria From This Firm's Position

Criteria for choosing among options are drawn from Harbor Market's own resources and situation, not from generic strategy checklists. First, the option should build on resources the firm has that competitors lack, since advantages based on valuable, rare, and hard-to-imitate resources are more sustainable (Barney, 1991). Second, it should be affordable within the firm's capital budget of about 60 million dollars over three years. Third, it should fit the firm's loyal customer base. Fourth, it should not require the firm to win on a dimension where larger competitors have structural advantages.

Rejected Options Reasoned

Option one, competing on price, is rejected. Discounters have lower costs through scale, lean store formats, and supply chain efficiency that Harbor Market cannot match. Cutting prices would compress already thin margins, and cutting service departments would remove the prepared foods and bakery that loyal customers value. The option asks the firm to win on the dimension where it is weakest. Option three, omnichannel convenience, is also rejected as a primary strategy. National online services and large chains are investing billions in delivery and technology. Harbor Market's capital budget could not build a competitive delivery operation, and its older customers are less likely than younger shoppers to prefer delivery. The option would consume capital without creating an advantage. Rejecting the two options is not a judgment that price and convenience do not matter; it is a judgment that Harbor Market cannot win on them.

The Recommended Strategy

Option two, differentiation on fresh, local, and prepared food, is recommended. It builds on the firm's rare resources: relationships with regional farms, strong prepared foods and bakery departments, and a customer base that values quality. It can be funded within the capital budget by remodeling stores in phases. It targets higher-margin categories, which can improve overall margins even if center-store sales decline. And it positions Harbor Market where discounters and online services are weakest. The strategy will still include competitive prices on a limited set of staple items and an improved pickup service, but these support the position rather than define it.

What the Strategy Forecloses

The strategy forecloses several things. Harbor Market will not try to match discounters' prices across the store. It will not build its own delivery fleet; delivery will be offered through a third-party partner for customers who want it. It will not expand into large-format stores. And it will reduce center-store variety to make room for fresh departments, which means some customers who want a wide selection of packaged goods will shop elsewhere. Accepting these losses is the cost of a clear position, and leadership must be prepared to hold that position when some customers complain.

What this part is doingThe paper states what the strategy rules out, including some customers the firm will lose. Scorers reward strategies that accept trade-offs rather than promising everything.
4

Implications for Operations and Culture

The strategy has implications beyond marketing. Store staffing must shift toward skilled roles in prepared foods, bakery, and produce, which require training and higher wages than center-store stocking. Purchasing must strengthen relationships with regional farms and producers, including contracts that guarantee supply of signature items. Store managers must be evaluated on fresh department quality and margin, not only on overall sales. The company's culture, which has emphasized efficiency and consistency across stores, will need to allow some local variation, since fresh and local offerings differ by region.

How Success Will Be Measured

Success will be measured by the share of sales from fresh and prepared categories, gross margin by department, customer satisfaction with quality and freshness, and customer retention among the loyal base. A target of raising fresh and prepared food from 28% to 35% of sales over three years gives the strategy a measurable goal.

Risks

The main risks are that differentiation may not justify higher prices for price-sensitive shoppers in an economic downturn, that remodels may disrupt stores and sales during construction, and that competitors may expand their own fresh offerings. The implementation plan will stage remodels to limit disruption and monitor sales and margins by department.

Conclusion

Harbor Market should differentiate on fresh, local, and prepared food, building on resources competitors cannot easily copy, rather than competing on price or delivery where larger rivals have advantages. The strategy is affordable, fits the firm's customers, and forecloses choices that would dilute its position.

5

References

Barney, J. (1991). Firm resources and sustained competitive advantage. Journal of Management, 17(1), 99-120. https://doi.org/10.1177/014920639101700108

Porter, M. E. (1996). What is strategy? Harvard Business Review, 74(6), 61-78.

Reading the MBA-FPX5006 Assessment 2 instructions

Assessment 2 in MBA FPX 5006 has you recommend a strategic direction for a company. You describe its current position, develop genuinely different options, such as competing on price, specializing in fresh and local products or partnering for delivery, set criteria drawn from the company's own situation, evaluate each option, explain why the rejected ones fall short, recommend one and say what it rules out, then consider its effect on operations and culture and how success will be measured. Strategy research and industry data support the recommendation.

How this MBA FPX 5006 Assessment 2 example is built

The example opens with the chain's position in numbers: store count, sales trend, margin and where it sits between the discounters and the delivery apps. Three options follow, each a different way to compete: match discount prices on staples, specialize in fresh, local and prepared food, or partner with a delivery platform and shrink the store base. The criteria come next and are drawn from the chain's own situation, such as its neighborhood locations, its thin balance sheet and a workforce skilled in fresh departments. Each option is scored against them, and the two rejected options get a paragraph each explaining why they fall short. The recommended strategy is stated in one sentence, followed by what it rules out. The paper closes with operational and cultural changes and a short list of measures.

Where the marks sit in the MBA FPX 5006 Assessment 2 scoring guide

The scoring guide weighs the description of the position, the options, the criteria, the evaluation, the recommendation and the measures. Options reach Distinguished when each represents a different way to compete rather than three versions of discounting. Criteria score higher when drawn from this firm's resources and market, such as its locations and its balance sheet. Evaluation earns credit when each rejected option is reasoned through, not dismissed in a line. The recommendation is judged on whether it states what the strategy forecloses, including customers the chain will stop serving well. Operational and cultural implications should be addressed, since a fresh-food strategy changes hiring and training. Success measures should be specific and dated. Distinguished strategies make a real choice and accept its costs.

Common MBA FPX 5006 Assessment 2 mistakes, and how to avoid them

Strategy recommendations often compare options that are variations of one idea, which is not a real choice and gives the scorer nothing to assess. Another weakness is using generic criteria, like "profitability" and "growth," that fit any company. Rejected options are dismissed in a sentence without reasons. The recommendation tries to do everything at once, avoiding the trade-offs that make strategy meaningful. What the strategy rules out is never stated. Culture and operations are ignored, as if a new direction required no change inside the stores. Measures are vague. Building a comparison table with three distinct options scored against firm-specific criteria makes the choice visible and prepares the implementation plan in Assessment 3.

Get a MBA FPX 5006 Assessment 2 example written to your instructions

Send the Assessment 2 instructions and the scoring guide from your MBA FPX 5006 courseroom, plus the organization your version specifies. We write a custom example against those exact criteria and return it in 24 to 48 hours. The first custom sample is free, and the reasoning behind the rejected options is where this assessment is actually scored. The paper above is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Capella University document.

More MBA FPX 5006 papers and MBA samples

MBA FPX 5006 Assessment 2 questions, answered

What does MBA FPX 5006 Assessment 2 ask for?

A strategy for a real or realistic organization, built on the analysis from Assessment 1, with options evaluated and one recommended. Use your earlier analysis as the foundation.

What does "options that differ in kind" mean?

Options that represent genuinely different strategic choices, such as competing on cost, differentiating, or focusing on a niche, rather than variations of the same idea with different budgets.

Why state what a strategy forecloses?

Because strategy is about choosing what not to do. A recommendation that rules nothing out is not a strategy.

Where can I find a free MBA FPX 5006 Assessment 2 sample paper?

This page contains the full strategy recommendation for the regional grocery chain, with options that differ in kind, criteria from the firm's position, rejected options reasoned and what the strategy forecloses.

What does "options that differ in kind" mean in MBA FPX 5006 Assessment 2?

Options that represent different ways to compete, such as low price versus specialty products, rather than small variations of the same approach.