| Course | MBA FPX 5016 Operations Management for Leaders |
|---|---|
| Assessment | Assessment 2 |
| Paper type | Costed improvement case |
| Length | About 1,150 words, 5 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Capella University |
| Program | MBA |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for MBA FPX 5016 Assessment 2
Implementing Quick Changeover on Surface-Mount Lines: A Costed and Sequenced Plan for a Circuit Board Contract Manufacturer
Student Name
Capella University
MBA FPX 5016: Operations Management for Leaders
Instructor Name
Month Day, Year
Introduction
A composite contract manufacturer of printed circuit board assemblies, here called Keystone Circuits, runs three surface-mount technology lines that place components on boards for industrial and medical equipment customers. Each line changes over from one product to another about four times a day, and each changeover takes an average of 95 minutes. The operations director has proposed reducing changeover time to 40 minutes using the single-minute exchange of die method. This paper sets out the implementation plan: how the benefit is converted into dollars, what the disruption costs, who does the work, in what order, and whether the case survives if only half the benefit is achieved.
The Method
Shingo (1985) developed the single-minute exchange of die method by separating changeover tasks into internal tasks, which can only be done while the machine is stopped, and external tasks, which can be done while it is still running. Most of the time savings comes from moving tasks from internal to external and then simplifying what remains. At Keystone, video recordings of 12 changeovers showed that about 60% of the 95 minutes was spent on tasks that could be done while the line runs, such as loading component reels onto feeders, finding stencils, and printing setup sheets.
Benefit Converted Step by Step
A saving in minutes is not a saving in dollars until it is converted carefully. The conversion follows four steps. First, minutes saved: reducing changeovers from 95 to 40 minutes saves 55 minutes per changeover. Second, where the time is worth money: Hopp and Spearman (2008) explain that time saved at a bottleneck increases the output of the whole plant, while time saved at a resource with spare capacity only adds idle time. Line A runs at 94% utilization and Keystone turns away quick-turn orders because it lacks capacity there. Lines B and C run at about 70% and have slack. So the capacity benefit counts only for line A. Third, hours freed on line A: four changeovers a day for 250 days is 1,000 changeovers, which at 55 minutes each frees about 917 hours a year. Fourth, dollars: the sales team estimates that it could fill about 60% of those hours with quick-turn orders, which earn a contribution of about 250 dollars per line hour. That is about 550 hours, or 137,500 dollars a year. On lines B and C, shorter changeovers allow smaller batches, which lowers work-in-process inventory; finance estimates the carrying cost saving at about 40,000 dollars a year. The total annual benefit is about 177,500 dollars. Counting only the bottleneck's freed hours as capacity keeps the benefit from being inflated by time that the plant could not sell.
Disruption Counted as Cost
Implementation will disrupt production. Each line will need about three days of reduced output while teams practice the new changeover procedure, estimated at 50% of normal output. Finance values the lost contribution at about 38,000 dollars across the three lines, mostly on line A. The plan also requires 95,000 dollars in equipment: offline feeder carts that let reels be loaded in advance, a stencil storage rack at each line, and a kitting station. The total implementation cost is therefore about 133,000 dollars.
Effort Attributed to People
The work is assigned by role. The process engineer leads the project and will spend about 40% of their time on it for four months, filming changeovers, separating tasks, and writing the new standard work. Each line lead will spend about four hours a week on the project, running practice changeovers and coaching operators. The 24 operators will each receive 16 hours of training. The materials supervisor will set up the kitting station and adjust material delivery so kits arrive before each changeover. The operations director sponsors the project, approves the equipment purchase, and reviews progress every two weeks.
Sequencing That Reflects Dependency
The tasks are sequenced by what depends on what. Filming and analysis must come first, because the task separation defines the equipment needed. Equipment must be ordered in week 3 and installed before practice begins, since the new procedure depends on offline feeder carts. The pilot will run on line C, which has spare capacity, so that mistakes during learning do not cost bottleneck output. Only after line C reaches a changeover time under 50 minutes will the procedure move to line A, followed by line B.
| Weeks | Task | Depends on |
|---|---|---|
| 1 to 3 | Film and analyze changeovers | None |
| 3 to 8 | Order and install feeder carts and racks | Task analysis |
| 6 to 10 | Pilot on line C | Equipment installed |
| 10 to 14 | Roll out to line A | Pilot under 50 minutes |
| 14 to 16 | Roll out to line B | Line A stable |
Half the Benefit Tested
If Keystone achieves only half the expected saving, about 27 minutes per changeover, the annual benefit falls to about 88,750 dollars, and the 133,000 dollar cost pays back in about 18 months. The project remains worthwhile. It becomes marginal only if the sales team cannot sell the freed hours on line A. Testing the case at half the expected benefit shows the leadership team that the decision does not depend on everything going right.
Risks
The main risks are operator resistance to new routines, delays in equipment delivery, and the sales team's ability to win quick-turn orders. Operator involvement in filming and redesign is intended to address resistance, since operators often identify the best improvements themselves. Equipment delays are managed by ordering the feeder carts in week 3, as soon as the task analysis confirms what is needed, and by allowing a buffer of two weeks before the pilot. The sales risk is the most important one for the financial case, since the line A benefit depends on selling freed hours. The sales director has agreed to track quick-turn inquiries that Keystone currently declines, so that the demand behind the 60% fill estimate can be checked before the rollout reaches line A.
Keeping the Gains
Changeover improvements tend to slip once attention moves elsewhere. To hold the gains, each line will post its changeover times on a board at the line, the process engineer will review the times weekly for three months after rollout, and the standard work will be revised whenever operators find a better method. Changeover time will also be added to the monthly operations report that the operations director presents to the plant's leadership team.
Conclusion
Keystone's changeover reduction project is worth about 177,500 dollars a year at full benefit and remains worthwhile at half. The plan converts the benefit carefully, counts disruption as a cost, assigns the work to named roles, and sequences tasks so that learning happens on a line with spare capacity before the bottleneck is changed.
References
Hopp, W. J., & Spearman, M. L. (2008). Factory physics (3rd ed.). McGraw-Hill/Irwin.
Shingo, S. (1985). A revolution in manufacturing: The SMED system. Productivity Press.
What the MBA FPX 5016 Assessment 2 instructions ask for
Assessment 2 in MBA FPX 5016 has you build the financial case for an operational improvement. You describe the method, such as single-minute exchange of die, convert time saved into capacity and then into revenue or cost savings, count the costs of making the change, including lost production during training and trials, estimate the hours required from each role, sequence the work so dependencies are respected, test whether the case holds if only half the benefit appears, identify risks and plan how the improvement will be sustained. Operations and managerial finance texts support the case.
How this MBA FPX 5016 Assessment 2 example is built
Benefit, cost, sequence, payback. The opening carries forward the finding and its measurement. A benefit block converts the operational improvement into money through stated intermediate steps, so the reader can disagree at whichever step they doubt. A cost block totals implementation, disruption and any ongoing expense, naming who supplies the effort. A sequence block sets out what has to happen in which order and what blocks what. A payback block computes the period with its assumptions listed. A sensitivity block states what happens if the benefit is half what was estimated, which is the question anybody funding it will ask. The closing names what would make the case fail. Every figure carries its origin and no benefit is claimed that the measurement does not support.
Reading the MBA FPX 5016 Assessment 2 scoring guide
Capella's criteria for this case cover how the method is explained, the conversion of benefit into money, the costs, the effort, the sequencing, the stress test and the plan to keep the gains. Benefit conversion reaches Distinguished when each step is shown, from changeover minutes saved to extra board runs per week to margin earned, with the demand for those runs confirmed. Costs score higher when disruption is counted, such as lines stopped for trial changeovers and scrap during learning. Effort earns credit when attributed to roles with hours, like process engineers and line leads. Sequencing is judged on whether it respects dependencies, since standard work cannot be written before the new fixtures arrive. The stress test should show whether the case still pays at half the expected benefit. Keeping the gains should be planned with audits and ownership. Distinguished cases survive a skeptical finance review.
Common MBA FPX 5016 Assessment 2 mistakes, and how to avoid them
Improvement cases often multiply minutes saved by an hourly rate and call it profit, which ignores whether the freed capacity can be sold. Another weakness is leaving out the cost of disruption while the change is made. Effort is described without hours. Steps are listed in any order. The case is tested only at the expected benefit. Gains are assumed to last. Building the benefit in a short chain, minutes to hours to units to margin, and repeating it at half the benefit keeps the case honest and prepares the operations synthesis in Assessment 3.
Get a MBA FPX 5016 Assessment 2 example written to your instructions
Send the Assessment 2 instructions and your MBA FPX 5016 scoring guide, along with the process measurement your first assessment produced. We write a custom example against those criteria and return it in 24 to 48 hours. The first custom sample is free, and converting an operational gain into money step by step is what makes the case fundable. The paper above is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Capella University document.
More MBA FPX 5016 papers and MBA samples
- MBA FPX 5016 Assessment 1: Process Improvement Plan
- MBA FPX 5016 Assessment 3: Operations Synthesis
- MBA FPX 5910 Assessment 2: Integrated Analysis Chapters
- MBA FPX 5014 Assessment 2: Evaluation of Capital Projects
- MBA FPX 5002 Assessment 2: Development Plan Business Case
- MBA FPX 5012 Assessment 2: Positioning and Mix Defense
MBA FPX 5016 Assessment 2 questions, answered
How do I turn saved time into money?
Through stated steps. Time saved becomes capacity, capacity becomes units, units become revenue at a margin you name, or the saving becomes hours no longer paid for. Which route applies depends on whether the constraint was binding, and saying which case yours is prevents the commonest overstatement in these papers.
What costs do people forget?
The hours of staff who already have jobs, the output lost while the change beds in, and anything the improvement makes permanently more expensive to run. Those three account for most cases that looked strong on paper and disappointed afterward, and including them makes the estimate far more credible.
What payback period is acceptable?
It depends on the firm and you should say what you assumed. Many businesses want operational improvements back within a year or two. What matters more to the criteria is that the period is computed from your own figures and that its assumptions are visible rather than folded into a single number.
Where can I find a free MBA FPX 5016 Assessment 2 sample paper?
This page contains the complete quick changeover case, with benefit converted step by step, disruption counted as cost, effort attributed to people, sequencing by dependency and the case tested at half the benefit.
How do I turn saved time into money in MBA FPX 5016 Assessment 2?
Only if the freed time can be used. Convert minutes saved into extra units the line can produce, confirm there is demand for them and multiply by the margin per unit.