MHA FPX 5006 Assessment 3 Cost-Benefit Analysis example

Reviewed by Rupert Danvers, MBA Healthcare Finance and Reimbursement Capella University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This MHA FPX 5006 Assessment 3 sample paper is a cost-benefit analysis of a heart failure transitional care program that asks who pays, who benefits and what the case rests on. It closes Capella MHA FPX 5006, Healthcare Finance and Reimbursement, the MHA course with the catalog code MHA-FPX5006. The analysis reviews the evidence for the program, totals costs including those organizations usually omit, such as space and management time, and states its valuation methods. It reports the result from each perspective, hospital, payer and patient, keeps non-financial benefits honest, tests the assumption the case depends on, names risks beyond the numbers and makes a recommendation.

CourseMHA FPX 5006 Healthcare Finance and Reimbursement
AssessmentAssessment 3
Paper typeCost-benefit analysis
LengthAbout 1,080 words, 5 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolCapella University
ProgramMaster of Health Administration (MHA)
UpdatedSeptember 2026

Free sample paper for MHA FPX 5006 Assessment 3

1

Cost-Benefit Analysis of a Heart Failure Transitional Care Program: Who Pays, Who Benefits, and What the Case Rests On

Student Name

Capella University

MHA FPX 5006: Healthcare Finance and Reimbursement

Instructor Name

Month Day, Year

What this part is doingThe title names the program and the three questions the analysis answers. A cost-benefit analysis is judged on whether its perspective and assumptions are clear, so both are signaled.
2

Introduction

A composite 210-bed community hospital, here called Harborview Hospital, discharges about 900 patients with heart failure each year. About 22% of them are readmitted within 30 days. The hospital's chief nursing officer has proposed a transitional care program in which advanced practice nurses visit patients at home after discharge, reconcile medications, teach symptom management, and coordinate follow-up with physicians. This paper analyzes the program's costs and benefits and recommends whether to proceed.

Who Pays and Who Benefits

The first question in any cost-benefit analysis is whose costs and benefits are counted. Drummond et al. (2015) emphasize that the perspective of an economic evaluation, whether that of a provider, a payer, or society, determines which costs and consequences are included, and that results can differ sharply between perspectives. For Harborview's program, the hospital pays almost all of the costs. The benefits are divided: payers, mainly Medicare, save the cost of avoided readmissions; patients avoid the burden of returning to the hospital; and the hospital gains only indirectly, through lower readmission penalties and freed bed capacity. Under fixed payment per admission, an avoided readmission can also mean lost revenue for the hospital. The program's central difficulty is that the party that pays is not the party that benefits most.

What this part is doingThe analysis names the perspective before counting anything. Scorers reward cost-benefit analyses that show how the answer depends on whose costs and benefits are included.
3

The Evidence for the Program

Transitional care has been tested in randomized trials. Naylor et al. (1999) found that older patients who received comprehensive discharge planning and home follow-up by advanced practice nurses had fewer readmissions over the following six months and lower total costs of care than patients who received usual care. Harborview's program is modeled on that approach but adapted to its staffing and to heart failure patients specifically.

Costs, Including the Omitted Ones

Cost itemAnnual cost (dollars)
Two advanced practice nurses, one registered nurse, half-time social worker480,000
Travel, phones, scales, and supplies60,000
Pharmacist time for medication reconciliation30,000
Physician time for coordination and consultation20,000
Total annual operating cost590,000
One-time training and electronic record build65,000

The first draft of the proposal listed only nursing staff and supplies. Pharmacist and physician time, and the record build, were added because they are real costs even though they fall in other departments' budgets. Leaving them out would have understated the cost by about 15%.

Valuation Methods Stated

Each benefit is valued using a stated method. The program is expected to reduce 30-day readmissions from 22% to 17%, avoiding about 45 readmissions a year. Payer savings are valued at the average payment for a heart failure readmission at Harborview, about 15,000 dollars, for a total of about 675,000 dollars a year. The hospital's readmission penalty is valued using its current penalty under the Medicare Hospital Readmissions Reduction Program, which can reduce a hospital's base Medicare payments by up to 3% (McIlvennan et al., 2015). Harborview's penalty is 0.8%, about 480,000 dollars a year, and heart failure accounts for about half of its excess readmissions, so the program could reduce the penalty by an estimated 250,000 dollars. Freed beds are valued by contribution margin: Harborview runs above 90% occupancy, so each avoided readmission frees a bed for another patient, with a net gain in contribution of about 6,000 dollars per stay, or about 270,000 dollars a year.

The Result by Perspective

PerspectiveAnnual benefitAnnual costNet
Hospital520,000590,000-70,000
Medicare and other payers675,0000+675,000
Combined1,195,000590,000+605,000

From the hospital's perspective alone, the program loses about 70,000 dollars a year. From a combined perspective, it produces a net benefit of about 605,000 dollars.

Non-Financial Benefits Kept Honest

The program should also improve patients' quality of life, reduce emergency visits, and give families more confidence in managing heart failure at home. These benefits are real but were not assigned dollar values, because Harborview has no reliable data to value them and inventing figures would weaken the analysis. They are listed separately so that decision makers can weigh them without mistaking them for measured savings.

What this part is doingThe nonfinancial benefits are named but not converted into dollars. Keeping them separate protects the credibility of the numbers that were measured.
4

The Load-Bearing Assumption Tested

The analysis rests on the assumption that readmissions fall by 5 percentage points. If the reduction is only 2.5 points, about 22 readmissions are avoided, the hospital's benefit falls to about 260,000 dollars, and its annual loss grows to about 330,000 dollars; the combined net benefit falls to about 7,000 dollars. If the reduction reaches 7 points, about 63 readmissions are avoided, and the hospital gains about 140,000 dollars a year. The program's value to the hospital therefore depends heavily on the size of the readmission reduction, and to a lesser degree on the penalty estimate.

Risks Beyond the Numbers

The program carries risks that the analysis cannot fully value. Advanced practice nurses are in short supply in Harborview's region, and a vacancy of even a few months would reduce the number of patients served while salary costs continue. Home visits in rural parts of the service area take longer than the staffing model assumes. Some patients may decline home visits, which would reduce the number of readmissions avoided. Finally, the readmission penalty program's rules can change, which would alter one of the hospital's main benefits. These risks support starting with a pilot rather than a full launch, so that the hospital can learn how many patients enroll, how long visits take, and how far readmissions actually fall before committing to the full cost.

Recommendation

Harborview should proceed with the program only if it can share in the savings it creates for payers. The finance office should approach the two largest Medicare Advantage plans in the region and the hospital's accountable care organization partner with a proposal for shared savings or a per-patient care management fee. A one-year pilot with 300 patients would provide Harborview's own readmission data before full rollout. The pilot should track 30-day readmissions against a matched group of patients discharged before it began, along with visit completion rates, staff time per patient, and emergency visits, so the full-scale decision rests on local evidence.

Conclusion

The transitional care program creates value overall but not for the hospital alone, because the hospital pays the costs while payers receive most of the savings. The analysis includes omitted costs, states its valuation methods, keeps nonfinancial benefits separate, and shows that the case depends on the size of the readmission reduction.

5

References

Drummond, M. F., Sculpher, M. J., Claxton, K., Stoddart, G. L., & Torrance, G. W. (2015). Methods for the economic evaluation of health care programmes (4th ed.). Oxford University Press.

McIlvennan, C. K., Eapen, Z. J., & Allen, L. A. (2015). Hospital readmissions reduction program. Circulation, 131(20), 1796-1803. https://doi.org/10.1161/circulationaha.114.010270

Naylor, M. D., Brooten, D., Campbell, R., Jacobsen, B. S., Mezey, M. D., Pauly, M. V., & Schwartz, J. S. (1999). Comprehensive discharge planning and home follow-up of hospitalized elders: A randomized clinical trial. JAMA, 281(7), 613-620. https://doi.org/10.1001/jama.281.7.613

MHA FPX 5006 Assessment 3 instructions, in plain terms

The final assessment asks you to conduct a cost-benefit analysis of a proposed health care program or investment. You describe the proposal, identify and total costs, quantify benefits and explain how they were valued, compare them over a stated horizon, consider who bears costs and who receives benefits, test key assumptions and make a recommendation. Evidence on the program's effects supports the benefit estimates. In health care, benefits often go to a payer while costs fall on the provider, so perspective matters. Non-financial benefits should be described honestly rather than forced into dollars. Show all calculations and cite sources for each figure.

How this MHA FPX 5006 Assessment 3 example is built

Proposal, costs, benefits, distribution. The opening states what is being evaluated and over what horizon. A cost block totals capital and operating costs with their bases, including the ones organizations routinely omit such as space and management time. A benefit block quantifies what can be quantified, and is explicit about the method used for anything converted into money. A distribution block states who bears the costs and who receives the benefits, which in healthcare are frequently different parties. A non financial block describes benefits that resist valuation without inventing figures for them. A sensitivity block tests the assumption the result depends on most. The closing recommends and states what would reverse it. Each figure arrives with its source, or is flagged plainly as an assumption where none exists.

Where the marks sit in the MHA FPX 5006 Assessment 3 scoring guide

The scoring guide rates the costs, the benefits, the valuation methods, the comparison, the distribution of costs and benefits, the sensitivity analysis and the recommendation. Costs reach Distinguished when omitted items such as space, management time and training are included. Benefits score higher when their valuation method is stated. The distribution criterion rewards showing the result from each perspective, since a program can save the payer money while costing the hospital revenue. Sensitivity analysis earns credit when the load-bearing assumption is identified and tested. Non-financial benefits should be kept separate and described in words. The recommendation must follow from the analysis and say what result would change it. Writing and APA accuracy are graded.

MHA FPX 5006 Assessment 3 help: mistakes that cost marks

The most common mistake is counting benefits that accrue to someone else as the organization's savings. Another is leaving out indirect costs, which makes the program look cheaper than it is. Students often convert everything into dollars with doubtful methods. The horizon is not stated, so costs and benefits are compared over different periods. Sensitivity analysis is skipped, even though one assumption, such as readmission reduction, may carry the whole case. Evidence for the program's effect is taken from a different population without adjustment. A summary table of costs and benefits by perspective makes the result clear. Recommendations should say what would change the answer.

Get a MHA FPX 5006 Assessment 3 example written to your instructions

Send the Assessment 3 instructions and the MHA FPX 5006 scoring guide from your courseroom, with the proposal and any figures your version supplies. We write a custom example against those exact criteria and return it in 24 to 48 hours. The first custom sample is free, and attributing costs and benefits to the right parties is what this assessment is really testing. The paper above is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Capella University document.

More MHA FPX 5006 papers and MHA samples

MHA FPX 5006 Assessment 3 questions, answered

How do I value a health outcome in money?

Use a published method and say which. Avoided admissions costed at an average, reduced length of stay at a daily rate, or complication rates at a documented treatment cost are all defensible. What is not defensible is a figure attached to wellbeing with no derivation, since it invites a reader to dismiss the whole analysis.

What if the benefit goes to the payer rather than to us?

Say so, because it is the most important finding you can report. Many quality improvements save money for whoever bears the cost of the complication rather than for the organization preventing it. That misalignment is central to healthcare finance and identifying it demonstrates real command of the subject.

Should I include benefits I cannot quantify?

Yes, described rather than costed. Staff retention, community standing and regulatory position are real and resist valuation. Presenting them separately, clearly labeled as unquantified, lets a decision maker weigh them without the analysis pretending to a precision it does not have. Precision it does not have is the risk.

Where can I find a free MHA FPX 5006 Assessment 3 sample paper?

This page holds the full cost-benefit analysis of the heart failure transitional care program, with costs, valuation, results by perspective and the tested assumption. A custom analysis of your own proposal can be requested free.

How do I value health outcomes in MHA FPX 5006 Assessment 3?

Use stated methods, such as avoided admission costs, reduced penalties or published cost estimates, and cite them. Keep outcomes that cannot be valued credibly, such as quality of life, as non-financial benefits described in words.