| Course | MHA FPX 5010 Strategic Healthcare Planning |
|---|---|
| Assessment | Assessment 2 |
| Paper type | Strategic options analysis |
| Length | About 1,120 words, 5 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Capella University |
| Program | Master of Health Administration (MHA) |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for MHA FPX 5010 Assessment 2
Strategic Options for a Rural Hospital's Obstetrics Unit: Four Constraints, Three Options, and the Conditions That Would Change the Choice
Student Name
Capella University
MHA FPX 5010: Strategic Healthcare Planning
Instructor Name
Month Day, Year
Introduction
A composite 49-bed rural hospital, here called Pine Ridge Medical Center, provides labor and delivery services for a county of about 38,000 people. Births at the hospital have fallen from about 290 a year a decade ago to about 180 today. The unit loses about 1.1 million dollars a year, and the hospital has struggled to maintain round-the-clock anesthesia coverage. The nearest other hospital with obstetric services is 58 miles away. The board has asked for an analysis of strategic options. Ginter et al. (2018) describe strategic decision making as generating options that are genuinely different, evaluating them against criteria grounded in the organization's mission and situation, and selecting the one that best fits. This paper follows that approach.
Four Constraints That Actually Bite
Many factors affect the decision, but four set its limits. Anesthesia coverage: safe obstetric care requires the ability to perform an emergency cesarean section at any hour. Pine Ridge has two certified registered nurse anesthetists, and covering every hour with two people is unsustainable; one has announced plans to retire within 18 months. Volume and competence: at 180 births a year, the unit averages about one birth every two days. Low volume makes it harder for nurses and physicians to maintain skills in rare emergencies, such as postpartum hemorrhage and shoulder dystocia. Finance: the unit loses about 1.1 million dollars a year, mainly because about 62% of births are covered by Medicaid, whose payments do not cover cost. The hospital's total operating margin is about 1%, so the loss cannot be absorbed indefinitely. Access and distance: if Pine Ridge stopped delivering babies, women in labor would face a drive of more than an hour, and some births would occur on the road or in emergency departments without obstetric staff. Naming the four constraints that bite, rather than listing every factor, gives the board a way to test each option against what actually limits the hospital.
Options Differing in Kind
Three options were developed, each a different kind of strategy rather than a variation of the same one. Option A, sustain through partnership: keep labor and delivery open by forming a clinical partnership with a regional health system 90 miles away, which would share anesthesia staffing through a rotating coverage arrangement, provide obstetric telehealth support, and run joint emergency simulation training. Option B, close deliveries and strengthen prenatal care: stop scheduled deliveries, keep and expand the prenatal and postpartum clinic, prepare the emergency department for unplanned births, and establish transfer agreements and a transport plan with the hospital 58 miles away. Option C, consolidate with a neighbor: combine obstetric services with a similar hospital 40 miles away, which also has falling births, into a single unit at one site, with the other hospital providing prenatal care.
Which Constraint Kills Which Option
The status quo, keeping the unit as it is, is ruled out by the anesthesia constraint: when one anesthetist retires, the hospital cannot cover every hour. Option C is ruled out by distance: the neighboring hospital's board prefers that the combined unit be at its own site, which would leave Pine Ridge's patients farther from care than they are from the existing unit 58 miles away, and Pine Ridge's county is the larger of the two. Option B is limited by access: it would lengthen travel for every birth, and published research has found that loss of hospital-based obstetric services in rural counties is associated with increases in births outside hospitals and in hospitals without obstetric units (Kozhimannil et al., 2018). Option A addresses the anesthesia and competence constraints through shared staffing and training, but it does not solve the financial constraint on its own.
Criteria From Mission and Position
The criteria for choosing among the options come from Pine Ridge's mission, which is to provide safe, local care for the county's residents, and from its position as the county's only hospital. The criteria are safety, local access, financial sustainability, and feasibility within 18 months. Option A scores best on local access and moderately on safety, poorly on finance unless the partner shares costs, and moderately on feasibility. Option B scores well on finance and feasibility but poorly on local access. Given the mission's emphasis on local care, the analysis recommends Option A, with a two-year commitment and a financial target.
Making Option A Work
Option A is recommended on two conditions. First, the regional partner must share part of the anesthesia cost, since the partnership also sends high-risk patients to the partner's hospital. Second, Pine Ridge must pursue added revenue: its state's Medicaid program offers enhanced payments for rural obstetric providers, and the hospital should confirm whether it qualifies. If the unit's loss cannot be reduced to about 600,000 dollars a year within two years, the board should move to Option B.
Community and Staff Considerations
The board should also consider how each option would be received. Residents and local physicians have strong attachment to the unit; when closure was rumored two years ago, a petition gathered several thousand signatures. Nurses on the unit worry about their jobs under any option, and several have said they would leave if deliveries ended. Option A offers the best chance of keeping experienced obstetric nurses, whose skills would be hard to rebuild if the unit closed and later reopened. The board should communicate its reasoning openly, including the conditions under which it would move to Option B, so that the community understands that the decision is tied to safety and sustainability rather than made in secret.
What Would Revive a Rejected Option
Rejected options should be revisited if conditions change. Option C would become viable if the neighboring hospital agreed to locate the combined unit at Pine Ridge. Option B would become the preferred choice if the partnership in Option A failed to secure anesthesia coverage, or if births fell below about 120 a year. The status quo could be revived only if Pine Ridge recruited two additional anesthetists, which the hospital has tried without success for three years. Stating what would revive a rejected option keeps the board's decision open to evidence rather than locking it in.
Conclusion
Pine Ridge's obstetrics unit is limited by anesthesia coverage, low volume, financial losses, and distance to alternatives. Among three options that differ in kind, sustaining the unit through a regional partnership best fits the hospital's mission, provided that costs are shared and revenue improves. The analysis names the conditions under which the board should change course.
References
Ginter, P. M., Duncan, W. J., & Swayne, L. E. (2018). The strategic management of health care organizations (8th ed.). Wiley.
Kozhimannil, K. B., Hung, P., Henning-Smith, C., Casey, M. M., & Prasad, S. (2018). Association between loss of hospital-based obstetric services and birth outcomes in rural counties in the United States. JAMA, 319(12), 1239-1247. https://doi.org/10.1001/jama.2018.1830
Reading the MHA-FPX5010 Assessment 2 instructions
The instructions ask you to develop and evaluate strategic options for an organization, building on the environmental analysis. You generate several options that differ in kind, test each against the organization's capabilities and constraints, such as workforce, capital, regulation and payer coverage, set selection criteria from the mission and market position, choose an option and explain how to make it work. Options should be genuinely different, not variations of one idea. Community and staff effects matter, especially for service closures or changes in rural areas. Evidence and data support the analysis. The chosen option carries into the directional strategies and later assessments.
How the MHA-FPX5010 Assessment 2 example is put together
Options, capability tests, comparison, shortlist. The opening carries the market findings forward compactly. Several directions are then generated that differ in kind: a new service line, a partnership, a geographic move, or consolidating something that already exists. A capability block tests each against workforce, regulatory permission, capital and payer coverage, naming which constraint bites for each. A comparison block weighs the survivors on criteria drawn from the organization's mission and position rather than from general attractiveness. A shortlist block reduces to one or two and says what was given up. A conditions block names what would have to change to revive a rejected option. The closing states what the third assessment will settle. Market and regulatory claims carry current sources.
Reading the MHA FPX 5010 Assessment 2 scoring guide
The scoring guide rates the options, the capability tests, the criteria, the selection and the implementation considerations. Options reach Distinguished when they differ in kind, such as a partnership, a service change and consolidation. Capability tests score higher when the specific constraint that rules out each option is named. Criteria earn credit when drawn from mission and market position. The selection should follow from the tests, so a reader can see why the losing options lost. Implementation considerations, including community and staff effects, show realism. Stating what would revive a rejected option, such as a new family physician who delivers babies joining the medical staff, shows strategic thinking. Writing and APA form are graded.
MHA FPX 5010 Assessment 2 help: mistakes that cost marks
Students often present options that are variations of the same idea, which makes the comparison trivial. Another common mistake is choosing the favored option first and testing it lightly. Constraints are described in general terms instead of tied to specific options. Workforce, especially in rural obstetrics, is often underestimated. Community effects are ignored. Selection criteria appear after the choice. The paper should read as a decision process, not a justification, with each option given a fair hearing before it is ruled out. Financial effects on the hospital, such as lost delivery revenue against staffing costs, belong in the comparison too. Conditions that would change the decision make the strategy more resilient.
Get a MHA FPX 5010 Assessment 2 example written to your instructions
Send the Assessment 2 instructions and the scoring guide from your MHA FPX 5010 courseroom, plus the organization your version specifies. We write a custom example against those exact criteria and return it in 24 to 48 hours. The first custom sample is free, and testing options against workforce and licensure is what makes healthcare strategy realistic. The paper above is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Capella University document.
More MHA FPX 5010 papers and MHA samples
- MHA FPX 5010 Assessment 1: Current Environmental Analysis
- MHA FPX 5010 Assessment 3: Directional Strategies
- MHA FPX 5012 Assessment 2: Governance Tested Against a Real Event
- MHA FPX 5006 Assessment 2: Financial Analysis and Benchmarking
- MHA FPX 5014 Assessment 2: Regulatory Compliance Assessment
- MHA FPX 5001 Assessment 2: Evidence-Based Issue Analysis
MHA FPX 5010 Assessment 2 questions, answered
Why does workforce matter so much here?
Because in most healthcare markets the binding constraint is people rather than money. A service line nobody can staff will not open however attractive the analysis makes it look. Testing each option against whether the clinicians exist, and at what cost, eliminates unrealistic strategies before they consume any more of the paper.
Do I need to address regulatory permission?
Where it applies, yes, and it frequently does. Certificate of need requirements, licensure and accreditation can prevent an option outright or delay it by years. A strategy that ignores them reads as written by somebody outside the sector, which is precisely what this course exists to prevent.
How many options should I develop?
Three or four that differ in kind, so the capability tests have something to discriminate between. Options that are all versions of expanding the same service will pass or fail the same constraints together, which leaves the analysis with nothing to conclude. Discrimination is the point.
Where can I find a free MHA FPX 5010 Assessment 2 sample paper?
This page holds the full strategic options analysis for the rural obstetrics unit, with constraints, options, capability tests, criteria and conditions for revisiting. A custom analysis for your organization is available at no charge.
How many strategic options should MHA FPX 5010 Assessment 2 include?
Usually three or four that differ in kind, such as expanding, partnering, consolidating or changing the service model. Fewer genuinely different options produce a better analysis than many similar ones.