| Course | MHA FPX 5016 Introduction to Health Information Systems |
|---|---|
| Assessment | Assessment 3 |
| Paper type | Technology direction recommendation |
| Length | About 1,070 words, 5 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Capella University |
| Program | Master of Health Administration (MHA) |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for MHA FPX 5016 Assessment 3
Changing Electronic Health Records in a Multispecialty Group: The Productivity Dip, Consequences by Group, and the Full Cost of Transition
Student Name
Capella University
MHA FPX 5016: Introduction to Health Information Systems
Instructor Name
Month Day, Year
Introduction
A composite multispecialty physician group, here called Brookside Medical Group, has 68 physicians and 14 clinics. Its current electronic health record is a product whose vendor has announced it will end support in 30 months. The group's affiliated hospital uses a different, widely used platform and has offered Brookside access to it. This paper analyzes the transition to the hospital's platform, including what it will cost and who will bear the disruption.
The Productivity Dip Admitted
Every electronic record transition reduces productivity for a period. Physicians must learn new screens, build new order favorites and note templates, and document more slowly until the new routines become habits. Brookside's plan reduces physician schedules to 50% of normal for the first week after go-live, 75% for the next three weeks, and 90% for the following month, returning to full schedules by the end of the second month. Even with reduced schedules, many physicians will spend extra time after clinic finishing documentation. At about 18 visits per physician per day, the reduced schedules remove about 10,100 visit slots across the group over the two months; the plan assumes that added evening sessions recover some of them and that about 6,000 visits are lost. Fleming et al. (2011), studying a network of primary care practices, found substantial first-year implementation costs, including lost productivity and the time spent by staff preparing for and carrying out the change, which supports planning for the dip rather than hoping it will be small. Admitting the productivity dip in the plan, with numbers, is what allows the group to budget for it rather than being surprised by it.
Consequences by Group
The transition affects each group differently. Physicians face the largest learning burden and the most visible productivity loss. Those near retirement may choose to leave rather than learn a new system, and the group should expect some departures. Medical assistants and nurses must learn new workflows for rooming patients, recording vital signs, and managing inboxes. Their training needs are often underestimated. Front desk and scheduling staff move to a new scheduling module and must re-create appointment templates for every physician. Billing staff face a period in which claims are delayed while charge capture and coding workflows are adjusted. Many organizations see accounts receivable rise temporarily after go-live, and Brookside should plan for about 30 to 45 days of slower collections. Patients must enroll in a new patient portal, and some messages and appointment requests may be missed during the switch. Older patients and those with limited internet access will need help.
Interoperability Made Concrete
The main benefit of the hospital's platform is that Brookside's clinics and the hospital would share one record. Interoperability here has concrete meaning. When a Brookside patient is admitted, hospital clinicians will see the clinic's medication list, problem list, and recent notes without faxes. Clinic physicians will see hospital discharge summaries and test results as soon as they are final. Referrals within the group and to the hospital's specialists will move as orders rather than faxes. Data conversion must also be concrete. Brookside plans to convert discrete data for allergies, active medications, problem lists, immunizations, and the last two years of laboratory results, so that these appear as usable data in the new system. Older notes and results will be stored in an archive accessible from the new record but not converted. The new platform also supports standardized application programming interfaces required under the federal rule implementing the 21st Century Cures Act, which allow patients to access their data through apps of their choice (Office of the National Coordinator for Health Information Technology, 2020).
Alternatives Argued Down
Three alternatives were considered. Staying on the current system is not viable, because it will lose vendor support, security updates, and certification. Moving to a different stand-alone product would cost less in license fees but would not connect Brookside to the hospital's record, leaving the fax-based handoffs in place and requiring a second transition if the group later joins the hospital's platform. Delaying the decision for a year would leave too little time before support ends, increasing the risk of a rushed go-live. Arguing each alternative down with a specific reason shows that the recommendation was chosen, not assumed.
Full Cost of Transition
| Cost item | Estimate (dollars) |
|---|---|
| License and hosting, first three years | 2,900,000 |
| Implementation and data conversion services | 850,000 |
| Archive of legacy data | 180,000 |
| Training time for staff and physicians | 610,000 |
| Lost visits during productivity dip (about 6,000 visits) | 960,000 |
| Temporary slowdown in collections, cost of carrying receivables | 90,000 |
| Temporary support staff at go-live | 240,000 |
| Total first three years | 5,830,000 |
Some costs, including lost visits and training time, fall entirely in the first year, while license costs are spread over three. The group's current system would require about 1.1 million dollars a year in license and support until it is retired, so the net added cost over three years is about 2.53 million dollars. Against that cost, the group expects savings from eliminating fax-based work, duplicate testing, and separate interfaces, as well as better coordination with the hospital, though these are harder to measure.
Risks to Manage
The largest risks are a go-live that coincides with a staffing shortage, errors in converted medication and allergy lists, and a longer collections slowdown than planned. Each has a mitigation: go-live is scheduled outside the winter respiratory season, converted clinical data will be checked by a nurse at each patient's first visit after go-live, and billing leaders will review claim backlogs daily for the first 60 days.
Recommendation
Brookside should move to the hospital's platform, with go-live 12 months from now to leave time before its current vendor ends support. The plan should budget openly for the productivity dip and collections slowdown, provide extra training for medical assistants and front desk staff, and offer help to patients enrolling in the new portal.
Conclusion
The transition to the hospital's platform will reduce productivity for about two months, affect every group of staff and patients differently, and cost about 5.83 million dollars over three years. It is still the best option, because it replaces an unsupported system and creates concrete interoperability with the hospital that the alternatives cannot offer.
References
Fleming, N. S., Culler, S. D., McCorkle, R., Becker, E. R., & Ballard, D. J. (2011). The financial and nonfinancial costs of implementing electronic health records in primary care practices. Health Affairs, 30(3), 481-489. https://doi.org/10.1377/hlthaff.2010.0768
Office of the National Coordinator for Health Information Technology. (2020). 21st Century Cures Act: Interoperability, information blocking, and the ONC Health IT Certification Program. Federal Register, 85(85), 25642-25961. https://doi.org/10.1377/hlthaff.2010.0768
Reading the MHA-FPX5016 Assessment 3 instructions
The course ends by asking for a technology direction, built on your systems map and evaluation. You state the recommendation and its basis, consider alternatives and explain why they were rejected, describe the consequences for each group affected, address interoperability, estimate the full cost of transition, identify risks and plan how to manage them. Technology changes cost more than licenses: training, lost productivity, data conversion and interfaces often exceed the purchase price. Honesty about the temporary drop in productivity builds credibility. Evidence from the literature and industry reports supports the recommendation. The audience is organizational leadership.
How this MHA FPX 5016 Assessment 3 example is built
Direction, alternatives, consequences, transition. The recommendation and its basis open the document, drawing on the evaluation already completed rather than restating it. An alternatives block argues down the routes not taken, since a technology recommendation with nothing rejected reads as a preference. A consequences block states what changes operationally for each affected group. A transition block covers the implementation period honestly, including the productivity dip and how long it typically lasts. A cost block totals license, implementation, training and lost productivity. An interoperability block names the interfaces required and the standards involved. The closing states what would make the recommendation wrong. Claims about capability and about standards carry sources rather than vendor assurances. A short block covers who inside the organization would have to agree before any of it could begin, since health IT decisions rarely rest with one person.
Where the marks sit in the MHA FPX 5016 Assessment 3 scoring guide
Capella's scoring guide rates the recommendation, the alternatives, the consequences, the interoperability analysis, the cost and the risks. The recommendation reaches Distinguished when stated first and based on the earlier evaluation. Alternatives score higher when argued down with reasons, including staying on the current system with upgrades. Consequences earn credit when described for each group, since physicians, nurses, front desk and billing staff experience a new record differently. Interoperability should be concrete, such as connecting to the hospital's record, the state immunization registry and payer portals. Full transition cost includes the productivity loss during the first months. Risks should come with mitigation. Clear writing and APA citations complete the guide.
Common MHA FPX 5016 Assessment 3 mistakes, and how to avoid them
Students often recommend a new system without admitting the productivity dip, which leaders will ask about. Another common mistake is presenting only the chosen option, as if no alternative existed. Consequences are described for the organization as a whole rather than for each group. Interoperability is mentioned in general terms without naming the connections that matter. Cost is limited to licenses and hardware, leaving out training, data conversion and reduced clinic schedules. Risks are listed without mitigation. Clinician involvement in the decision is overlooked, though adoption depends on it. A timeline with the go-live month and the expected recovery point helps leaders plan.
Get a MHA FPX 5016 Assessment 3 example written to your instructions
Send the Assessment 3 instructions and the MHA FPX 5016 scoring guide from your courseroom, with the map and evaluation your earlier assessments produced. We write a custom example against those exact criteria and return it in 24 to 48 hours. The first custom sample is free, and admitting the productivity dip is what makes a health IT proposal credible. The paper above is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Capella University document.
More MHA FPX 5016 papers and MHA samples
- MHA FPX 5016 Assessment 1: Mapping Information Systems by the Work They Support
- MHA FPX 5016 Assessment 2: Evaluating a Barcode Medication Administration System
- MHA FPX 5017 Assessment 3: Regression and Combined Techniques
- MHA FPX 5014 Assessment 3: Risk Control and Compliance Program Proposal
- MHA FPX 5020 Assessment 3: Project Recommendations
- MHA FPX 5012 Assessment 3: Governance Recommendations for a Community Hospital Board
MHA FPX 5016 Assessment 3 questions, answered
Why admit that performance will get worse?
Because it will, and everybody who has lived through an implementation knows it. Denying the dip means the first difficult week reads as failure rather than as the expected path. Naming its likely depth and duration protects the project and demonstrates you have understood what these transitions actually involve.
How specific does interoperability need to be?
Name the interfaces and the standards. Which data has to move, in which direction, under what specification. A commitment to improved integration commits to nothing and cannot be costed. The specifics are also where the real expense in these projects usually hides. Specifics are where the expense hides.
Should clinicians be involved in the recommendation?
Say how they were or would be, because it materially affects whether the change succeeds. Health IT imposed on clinical workflow without clinician input is the standard account of failed implementations, and a recommendation that addresses their involvement concretely reads as written by somebody who knows the sector.
Where can I find a free MHA FPX 5016 Assessment 3 sample paper?
This page contains the full EHR change recommendation for the multispecialty group, with the productivity dip, consequences by group, interoperability, alternatives, cost and risks. A custom recommendation is available free.
Why admit that performance will drop in MHA FPX 5016 Assessment 3?
Because every major system change reduces productivity for a period after go-live. Leaders who are told in advance can plan for it; a recommendation that hides it loses credibility when it happens.