MHA FPX 5017 Assessment 2 Hypothesis Testing for Differences Between Groups example

Reviewed by Rupert Danvers, MBA Data Analysis for Healthcare Decisions Capella University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This MHA FPX 5017 Assessment 2 sample paper applies hypothesis testing for differences between groups, asking whether two nursing home units differ enough in resident dependency to staff them differently. It belongs to Capella MHA FPX 5017, Data Analysis for Healthcare Decisions, which MHA students take as MHA-FPX5017. The paper states its hypotheses before testing, justifies the test from the data, checks assumptions openly and reports the results with the statistic, degrees of freedom, p-value and effect size. It separates a detectable difference from an important one, avoids claiming causation, notes what the test does not settle and closes with a staffing recommendation.

CourseMHA FPX 5017 Data Analysis for Healthcare Decisions
AssessmentAssessment 2
Paper typeHypothesis testing analysis
LengthAbout 1,140 words, 5 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolCapella University
ProgramMaster of Health Administration (MHA)
UpdatedSeptember 2026

Free sample paper for MHA FPX 5017 Assessment 2

1

Hypothesis Testing for Differences Between Groups: Do Two Nursing Home Units Differ Enough in Resident Dependency to Staff Them Differently?

Student Name

Capella University

MHA FPX 5017: Data Analysis for Healthcare Decisions

Instructor Name

Month Day, Year

What this part is doingThe title poses the management question that the test answers. Hypothesis testing papers are judged on whether the test serves a decision, so the decision is stated.
2

Introduction

The descriptive analysis of residents at a composite nursing home, here called Maplewood Care Center, found that residents on the memory care unit had a mean ADL score of 20.1, compared with 17.3 on the long-stay general unit. The administrator wants to know whether that difference reflects a real difference between the units or could easily have arisen by chance, and whether it is large enough to justify staffing the memory care unit more heavily. This paper tests the difference.

Hypotheses Stated First

The hypotheses were written before the test was run, so that the result could not shape the question. Null hypothesis: the mean ADL score of residents on the memory care unit equals the mean ADL score of residents on the long-stay general unit. Alternative hypothesis: the two means differ. The test is two-tailed, because a difference in either direction would matter for staffing, and the significance level is set at .05. Stating hypotheses before looking at the result protects the analysis from being shaped to fit what the analyst hoped to find.

What this part is doingThe hypotheses and significance level are fixed before testing. Scorers reward hypothesis tests that follow the correct order of steps.
3

The Test Justified by the Data

The data determine the test. The comparison involves two separate groups of residents, 44 on memory care and 42 on the long-stay general unit, and each resident belongs to only one unit, so the groups are independent. The ADL score ranges from 0 to 28 and, as the descriptive analysis showed, is roughly symmetric, so it can reasonably be treated as a continuous measure. These features point to an independent-samples t test. Field (2018) recommends Welch's version of the t test, which does not assume that the two groups have equal variances, as a sensible default when comparing two independent means. Because the ADL score is technically built from ordinal ratings, a Mann-Whitney U test, which compares the groups without assuming a normal distribution, was run as a check.

Assumptions Checked Openly

Three assumptions were checked. Independence is met by design, since no resident appears in both groups. Normality was checked with histograms and the Shapiro-Wilk test for each group; the histograms showed no severe skew, and the tests were not significant (p = .21 for memory care and p = .09 for the long-stay general unit), although the second value is close enough to .05 that the Mann-Whitney check is worthwhile. Equal variance was checked with Levene's test, which was not significant (p = .34), but Welch's test was used regardless, since it performs well whether or not variances are equal. No resident was removed; the one data entry error found in the descriptive analysis had already been corrected.

What this part is doingEach assumption is checked and reported with its result. Open reporting of assumptions lets a reader judge whether the test was appropriate.
4

Results

GroupnMean ADL scoreStandard deviation
Memory care4420.15.2
Long-stay general4217.35.9

The mean difference was 2.8 points. Welch's t test found the difference to be statistically significant, t(81.6) = 2.33, p = .022, with a 95% confidence interval for the difference of 0.4 to 5.2 points. The Mann-Whitney U test gave a consistent result (p = .03). The null hypothesis is therefore rejected: residents on the memory care unit have higher ADL scores, on average, than residents on the long-stay general unit.

Detectable Separated From Important

A statistically significant result means that random variation by itself would rarely produce a difference this large. It does not show that the difference is large enough to matter. Wasserstein and Lazar (2016), writing for the American Statistical Association, caution that a p value says nothing about how large an effect is or whether the finding matters in practice. Sullivan and Feinn (2012) recommend reporting an effect size alongside every p value for this reason. Cohen's d for the comparison is close to 0.50, which the usual rules of thumb would call moderate. In practical terms, a difference of 2.8 points on the 28-point scale is roughly equivalent to one additional activity, such as transferring from bed or eating, on which the average memory care resident needs extensive help rather than limited help. Maplewood's director of nursing estimates that this level of added dependence requires about 15 to 20 more minutes of aide time per resident per day. For 44 residents, that is about 11 to 15 more aide hours a day, or more than one additional aide per day across shifts. Translating the difference into aide hours is what turns a statistical result into a staffing decision. The confidence interval matters as well. It ranges from 0.4 to 5.2 points, so the true difference could be small enough to matter little or large enough to require substantial additional staff. The administrator should treat the 2.8-point estimate as the best available figure while recognizing its uncertainty.

Causation Not Claimed

The analysis shows that the two units differ; it does not show why. Residents are not assigned to units at random. Memory care admits residents with moderate to severe dementia, which itself affects the ability to perform daily activities, and residents may be moved to memory care when their needs increase. The difference in ADL scores therefore reflects who is placed on each unit, not an effect of the unit on residents. It would be wrong to conclude that the memory care unit makes residents more dependent. For staffing, the cause does not change the practical conclusion: whatever the reason, memory care residents currently need more help.

What the Test Does Not Settle

The test compares averages, but staffing decisions are also shaped by timing. Two units with the same average ADL score can need very different staffing if one unit's residents all need help at the same hour. The test also says nothing about the kind of help needed: memory care residents often need cueing and supervision, which ADL self-performance scores capture only partly. These limits do not weaken the result, but they mean the test is one input to the staffing decision rather than the whole answer.

Recommendation

The results support staffing the memory care unit more heavily than the long-stay general unit, by roughly one additional aide per day spread across the shifts when care needs peak. Because the confidence interval is wide, the administrator should confirm the decision by tracking actual aide time on both units for four weeks and by repeating the analysis after the next quarterly Minimum Data Set assessments.

Conclusion

Stating hypotheses first, justifying the test from the data, and checking assumptions openly showed a statistically significant difference in ADL scores between the two units. Reporting the effect size and translating it into aide hours shows that the difference is also large enough to matter for staffing, while the analysis stops short of claiming that the units cause the difference.

5

References

Field, A. (2018). Discovering statistics using IBM SPSS Statistics (5th ed.). SAGE.

Sullivan, G. M., & Feinn, R. (2012). Using effect size, or why the P value is not enough. Journal of Graduate Medical Education, 4(3), 279-282. https://doi.org/10.4300/jgme-d-12-00156.1

Wasserstein, R. L., & Lazar, N. A. (2016). The ASA statement on p-values: Context, process, and purpose. The American Statistician, 70(2), 129-133.

What the MHA FPX 5017 Assessment 2 instructions ask for

The instructions ask you to test a hypothesis about differences between groups in a health care data set. You state the administrative question, write the null and alternative hypotheses, choose an appropriate test, such as a t test or ANOVA, check its assumptions, run the test, report the results and interpret them for a decision. Effect size should accompany the p-value, since a statistically significant difference can be too small to matter. The data set is usually the one from Assessment 1. Software output should be edited into APA-style reporting. The interpretation should be written for an administrator, stating plainly what the result means for staffing, budgets or policy.

How the MHA-FPX5017 Assessment 2 example is put together

Question, test, assumptions, result, meaning. The opening states the administrative question and turns it into hypotheses in statistical form. A test block names the procedure and justifies it from the variables and the design. An assumptions block checks what the test requires and reports any violation with what was done. A result block gives the statistic, the degrees of freedom and the probability, presented in a readable table. A meaning block translates: what this says about the groups, and whether the size of the difference matters operationally as distinct from being detectable. A limits block covers what the design cannot establish, particularly causation. The closing states what would be worth testing next. Figures are reported to a consistent precision. No result is described in causal language anywhere in the paper.

Where the marks sit in the MHA FPX 5017 Assessment 2 scoring guide

The scoring guide rates the hypotheses, the test selection, the assumption checks, the results and the interpretation. Hypotheses reach Distinguished when stated before the test in both statistical and plain language. Test selection scores higher when justified from the variable types and design. Assumption checks earn credit when reported honestly, including any violation and what was done about it, such as using a Welch correction. Results should include the statistic, degrees of freedom, p-value and effect size. Interpretation earns most when detectable is separated from important and causation is not claimed. The recommendation should follow from the result and its limits. Correct APA reporting of statistics, italics and decimal places included, completes the guide.

MHA FPX 5017 Assessment 2 help: mistakes that cost marks

Students often report a p-value without an effect size, which leaves administrators unable to judge importance. Another common mistake is choosing a test without checking assumptions such as normality or equal variances. Hypotheses are written after the result, which reverses the logic. A significant result is treated as proof that one unit causes higher dependency, when the groups may differ for other reasons. Nonsignificant results are described as proving no difference. Output is pasted without APA reporting. Recommendations ignore the practical size of the difference. Report results in a sentence such as the one in the sample, with every number a reader needs, before interpreting them.

Get a MHA FPX 5017 Assessment 2 example written to your instructions

Send the Assessment 2 instructions and your MHA FPX 5017 scoring guide, along with the data your version supplies. We write a custom example against those criteria and return it in 24 to 48 hours. The first custom sample is free, and separating a detectable difference from an important one is the move that makes this administratively useful. The paper above is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Capella University document.

More MHA FPX 5017 papers and MHA samples

MHA FPX 5017 Assessment 2 questions, answered

How do I choose the right test?

From the design rather than from preference. How many groups, whether the same people were measured twice, and whether the outcome is continuous or categorical will narrow it to one or two options. Stating which of those features drove your choice is what the criteria are reading for.

What if an assumption is violated?

Say so and choose a route. Use a test that does not require it, transform the variable, or proceed and report the limitation. All three are defensible when stated. Running the test anyway without mentioning the violation is the version that costs marks, since it presents a qualified result as an unqualified one.

Is a significant result an important one?

Not necessarily, and saying so is often the most useful sentence in the paper. With enough observations, differences too small to act on become detectable. Report the size of the difference in the facility's own terms and let an administrator judge whether it warrants doing anything.

Where can I find a free MHA FPX 5017 Assessment 2 sample paper?

This page contains the full hypothesis testing paper comparing two nursing home units, with hypotheses, test choice, assumptions, results, effect size and a staffing recommendation. A custom analysis is available free.

How do I choose the right test for MHA FPX 5017 Assessment 2?

Match the test to the data: an independent samples t test for two groups on a continuous measure, ANOVA for three or more groups, chi-square for categorical outcomes. Check the test's assumptions and report them.