| Course | MHA FPX 5016 Introduction to Health Information Systems |
|---|---|
| Assessment | Assessment 2 |
| Paper type | System evaluation |
| Length | About 1,080 words, 5 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Capella University |
| Program | Master of Health Administration (MHA) |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for MHA FPX 5016 Assessment 2
Evaluating a Barcode Medication Administration System: Workflow Criteria, Workarounds as Evidence, and a Verdict With a Basis
Student Name
Capella University
MHA FPX 5016: Introduction to Health Information Systems
Instructor Name
Month Day, Year
Introduction
A composite 280-bed regional hospital, here called Lakeview Regional, installed barcode medication administration five years ago. Before each dose, the nurse scans the barcode on the patient's identification band and then the barcode on the medication package, and the system checks the medication against the active order. The chief nursing officer has asked whether the system is working as intended and whether it should be kept, reconfigured, or replaced during the hospital's upcoming electronic record upgrade. This paper evaluates the system.
Criteria From the Workflow
The criteria come from the steps of medication administration the system is meant to support, rather than from the vendor's feature list. The system should confirm the right patient, confirm the right medication, dose, route, and time, record the administration accurately and immediately, and warn the nurse before an error reaches the patient, while adding as little time and disruption to the nurse's work as possible. Each criterion is measured with data the hospital already collects: scanning rates from the system's reports, alerts and overrides, medication error reports, and direct observation.
Findings Against the Criteria
| Criterion | Measure | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Right patient | Patient wristband scan rate | 91% |
| Right medication | Medication scan rate | 87% |
| Accurate, immediate record | Administrations documented within 10 minutes | 84% |
| Warning before error | Alerts overridden | 38% of alerts |
| Minimal disruption | Added time per administration, observed | About 25 seconds |
Scanning rates are below the 95% level that many hospitals set as a target, and more than a third of alerts are overridden.
Workarounds Read as Evidence
A workaround is a way of completing work that bypasses the intended process. Koppel et al. (2008), in a study of barcode systems in several hospitals, identified 15 types of workarounds and 31 types of causes, and found that many workarounds arose because the technology did not fit the way nurses worked. Debono et al. (2013), in a scoping review of nurses' workarounds, found that workarounds are common and are often responses to real problems in workflow, and that they can have both positive and negative effects on care. Observation on six units at Lakeview found several workarounds. Nurses scanned spare wristbands kept at the nurses' station rather than the patient's own wristband, most often at night to avoid waking patients. Nurses scanned medications after giving them, when the scanner was not working or when a patient needed pain medication urgently. Barcodes that would not scan, on some unit-dose packages and on medications repackaged by pharmacy, were entered manually. Each workaround points to a specific problem in the system or its setup, which makes workarounds the most useful evidence in the evaluation.
Non-Use Treated as Data
Scanning rates were not the same across the hospital. They were above 95% on the medical and surgical units but only 71% in the emergency department and 64% in the post-anesthesia care unit. In those areas, many medications are given in response to verbal orders during urgent care, before an order is entered, so the system has nothing to match the scan against. Scanners in the emergency department are also shared among several rooms. The low use in these areas is not simply noncompliance; it shows that the system was designed for scheduled medications on inpatient units and does not fit care in fast-moving areas.
Alert Overrides Examined
A sample of 200 overridden alerts found that 61% were warnings that the medication was being given outside its scheduled time window, often by less than 30 minutes, and 22% were about a dose that differed from the ordered dose only because the pharmacy had dispensed a different package size. Only a small share warned of a potentially serious error. When most alerts are not meaningful, nurses learn to override them, including the rare important ones.
Staff Time Counted in the Cost
The system adds about 25 seconds to each administration. Lakeview's nurses give about 3,200 scheduled and as-needed doses a day, so the system adds about 22 hours of nursing time a day, or about 8,000 hours a year, equivalent to about 3.9 full-time nurses and roughly 420,000 dollars in wages and benefits. Troubleshooting failed scans and replacing broken scanners add further time. These costs are justified only if the system prevents errors, which means the design problems that reduce its effectiveness also waste this time.
Evidence of Benefit
Medication error reports suggest the system does prevent errors. In the year before installation, Lakeview recorded 41 reported wrong-patient medication errors reaching patients; in the most recent year, it recorded 9. Reported errors are an incomplete measure, and reporting may have changed, but the direction is consistent with the system's purpose.
A Verdict With a Basis
The system should be kept and reconfigured, not replaced. The basis is threefold. First, the evidence of fewer wrong-patient errors suggests the system provides real protection where it is used. Second, most of its weaknesses come from setup and fit rather than from the core technology: barcodes that do not scan, scanners that are not available, alerts set too sensitively, and workflows in fast-moving areas that the system does not support. Third, replacing it would not solve these problems unless they were addressed directly. A verdict to keep and reconfigure rests on the finding that the problems are in configuration and fit, which can be fixed without replacing the system. The recommended changes are to widen the time window for scheduled-dose alerts from 30 to 60 minutes for most medications, to correct dose-mismatch alerts caused by package sizes, to have pharmacy verify that all repackaged medications scan before release, to add scanners in each emergency department and recovery room, to build a workflow for medications given on verbal orders, and to remove spare wristbands from nursing stations. Scanning rates and overrides should be reviewed in six months, unit by unit, so that improvement in one area does not hide persistent gaps in another.
Conclusion
Lakeview's barcode medication administration system prevents errors where it is used but is weakened by poor fit with fast-moving areas, barcodes that do not scan, and alerts that nurses have learned to ignore. The evaluation used criteria drawn from the workflow, treated workarounds and non-use as evidence, counted staff time as a cost, and concluded that the system should be reconfigured rather than replaced.
References
Debono, D. S., Greenfield, D., Travaglia, J. F., Long, J. C., Black, D., Johnson, J., & Braithwaite, J. (2013). Nurses' workarounds in acute healthcare settings: A scoping review. BMC Health Services Research, 13, Article 175. https://doi.org/10.1186/1472-6963-13-175
Koppel, R., Wetterneck, T., Telles, J. L., & Karsh, B.-T. (2008). Workarounds to barcode medication administration systems: Their occurrences, causes, and threats to patient safety. Journal of the American Medical Informatics Association, 15(4), 408-423. https://doi.org/10.1197/jamia.m2616
What the MHA FPX 5016 Assessment 2 instructions ask for
The instructions ask you to evaluate an information system in a health care organization against the needs of the work it supports. You derive evaluation criteria from the workflow, assess the system against each, examine adoption, workarounds and overrides, consider costs including staff time, review evidence of benefit and reach a verdict. Observation, interviews, system reports and published studies are the main sources. Vendor claims should be treated as claims. Many students evaluate a system they use at work, which gives access to real workarounds. The evaluation continues from the systems map in Assessment 1 and sets up the technology recommendation in Assessment 3.
How the MHA-FPX5016 Assessment 2 example is put together
Workflow, criteria, evaluation, adoption. The opening establishes the workflow the system supports, drawn from the map already produced. A criteria block derives what the system must do from that workflow rather than from a feature checklist. An evaluation block scores the system against each, using observation or documented experience rather than vendor claims. An adoption block treats workarounds and non use as evidence about the system, which is where the honest findings usually are. A cost block totals license, support and staff time. A compliance block covers privacy and security obligations where they affect the judgment. The closing states whether the system should be kept, reconfigured or replaced, and what that decision rests on. Sources are named for every capability claim.
MHA FPX 5016 Assessment 2 scoring guide: what Distinguished looks like
The scoring guide rates the criteria, the evaluation, the adoption analysis, the cost and the verdict. Criteria reach Distinguished when derived from workflow rather than a feature list, for example scanning at the bedside within the medication pass time a nurse actually has. Evaluation scores higher when based on observation or documented use. Adoption analysis earns credit when workarounds and overrides are treated as evidence of fit problems, not only as staff failings. Cost should include staff time, such as scanning delays at the bedside and help desk calls. Evidence of benefit should be appraised, since published error reductions come from specific settings. The verdict must follow from the criteria and say what would change it. Writing and APA form are graded.
MHA FPX 5016 Assessment 2 help from the desk
Students often evaluate a system with a vendor checklist, which says little about fit. Another common mistake is blaming staff for workarounds without asking what drives them, such as unreadable wristbands or medications without barcodes. Alert override rates are reported without analysis of which alerts are overridden and why. Staff time is left out of cost. Evidence of benefit is assumed from marketing materials. The verdict is a general opinion rather than a conclusion drawn from criteria. When a workaround protects patients in the short term, say so and explain the risk it also creates. Observation during a real medication pass, with permission, is the best source.
Get a MHA FPX 5016 Assessment 2 example written to your instructions
Send the Assessment 2 instructions and your MHA FPX 5016 scoring guide, along with the systems map your first assessment produced. We write a custom example against those criteria and return it in 24 to 48 hours. The first custom sample is free, and reading workarounds as evidence is the technique worth copying. The paper above is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Capella University document.
More MHA FPX 5016 papers and MHA samples
- MHA FPX 5016 Assessment 1: Mapping Information Systems by the Work They Support
- MHA FPX 5016 Assessment 3: Technology Direction Recommendation
- MHA FPX 5017 Assessment 2: Hypothesis Testing for Differences Between Groups
- MHA FPX 5014 Assessment 2: Regulatory Compliance Assessment
- MHA FPX 5020 Assessment 2: Capstone Evidence and Analysis
- MHA FPX 5012 Assessment 2: Governance Tested Against a Real Event
MHA FPX 5016 Assessment 2 questions, answered
How do I evaluate a system I cannot use myself?
Through the people who do. What takes longest, what they avoid, what they have invented to get around it, what they have to enter twice. Documented observation of that kind is legitimate evidence, and it produces a more useful evaluation than any feature comparison would.
Are workarounds always a criticism of the system?
Usually of the fit rather than the software. A workaround means the system asks people to work in an order that does not suit the task. Sometimes the answer is reconfiguration rather than replacement, and distinguishing those two is exactly the judgment this assessment rewards.
How do I cost staff time?
Estimate the minutes per task, multiply by frequency and by the number of people doing it, and say what you assumed. A system costing each nurse fifteen minutes a shift across a large unit dwarfs its license fee, and putting that figure on the page usually reframes the whole evaluation.
How do I evaluate a system I cannot use myself for MHA FPX 5016 Assessment 2?
Observe users with permission, interview them, review system reports such as scan compliance and override rates, and read published evaluations. Treat vendor claims as claims and say what you could not verify.
Where can I find a free MHA FPX 5016 Assessment 2 sample paper?
This page holds the full BCMA evaluation, with workflow criteria, findings, workarounds, overrides, staff time and a verdict with a basis. A custom evaluation of your system can be written free.